News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by johndhi on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @03:59PM (#37152848)
As someone who makes decisions like the one Google made here at work, sorry, dude, but arguing about it publicly isn't going to change much.

Almost certainly Google has received pressure from these countries on this issue and their business there is more important to google than your single app. Google likely isn't being unreasonable - but the governments of these countries are. Sorry.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by fishtoaster on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:07PM (#37152966)
Historically, it seems like "arguing publicly, getting public outcry, and getting the notice of someone higher up the chain" is pretty much the only way to effectively appeal these sorts of decisions at Google.

I don't know if it'll work in this case, since google's argument ("this contains a slot simulator and some countries don't like that") isn't too egregious, but I can't really fault the dev. When the faceless review process fails, this sort of public appeal has worked before.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by Paul-Craft on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:13PM (#37153066)
> Historically, it seems like "arguing publicly, getting public outcry, and getting the notice of someone higher up the chain" is pretty much the only way to effectively appeal these sorts of decisions at Google.

Not just Google. It seems like a lot of large corporations effectively outsource their customer service to (the platform formerly known as) Twitter and such. Complaining on social media gets results, even after one has been stonewalled by official channels.

And, even if it fails, you can frequently generate a lot of buzz by complaining loudly on social media. How many people reading this do you think had never heard of this game before just now?

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by davely on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:32PM (#37155698)
I’m about to go through the same thing myself due to my Facebook Marketplace account getting banned for… no idea? Some sort of automated moderation kerfuffle.

No matter how many times I click “request a review of this decision” through their customer service portal, my appeal is automatically denied.

When there’s no way to get customer support from a company, it’s the only other thing left to do.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by paulddraper on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:03PM (#37152917)
> arguing about it publicly isn't going to change much

Okay fair enough. What is going to change much?

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by cmdli on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:09PM (#37152990)
Probably changing the laws in those countries, which only the citizens of those countries can really do. Google isn't the cause here, just the middleman.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by TulliusCicero on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:10PM (#37153005)
And in many cases, they can't either, if the country isn't democratic.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by mcpackieh on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:36PM (#37153428)
Even if those countries were democratic, is there any reason to think they would choose to legalize simulated gambling?
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by TulliusCicero on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @05:01PM (#37153773)
I looked at the list more closely and lol, what is South Korea doing on there? Yeah, I could see South Korea legalizing it.

The others...unlikely, to be sure. But you never know, I guess.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by 93po on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @05:18PM (#37153979)
SK has a lot of restrictions on gaming in general and it might be for non-gambling simulation reasons
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by sneak on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:11PM (#37153032)
This, I believe, is called the "just following orders defense". It was attempted most famously in Nürnberg in '46.

It didn't work then, and it shouldn't work now.

See also: Project Dragonfly

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by graypegg on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:18PM (#37153134)
Please remember the context here, we’re talking about a game on the App Store that has a slot machine mechanic.

Many places have similar small variances in obscenity they allow to be published. Your country might forbid nudity on TV, or disallow gambling businesses in public spaces.

I’d say WW2 featured significantly more serious issues.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by sneak on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:21PM (#37153190)
We're talking about mass censorship of artistic output for which there is widespread international consensus (basically all of the global west) around being both harmless and protected. The app in question very clearly does not allow gambling! The fact that the app depicts a slot machine is a red herring.

Such censorship is being carried out against millions of humans, by one of the few organizations on the planet large enough and resourced enough to take principled stands against same.

Google actually left China for this reason specifically. The correct answer by the same organization in question is not without precedent.

This is not a small transgression on Google's part.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by graypegg on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:29PM (#37153325)
Yeah I’m sorry, even as a person living in the western world, I would not want to live in a world with a defined “morally correct” group of decision makers. Countries vary. Cultures vary. It really is OK.

You can make the argument that big tech is already that, but clearly they respect local laws.

You were comparing this to the Nuremberg trials. That’s mostly where my disagreement lies. Beyond over-exaggerated.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by verve_rat on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:22PM (#37153210)
Really? Country X doesn't like simulated gambling mechanics, Google won't release game in country X therefore Google are Nazis committing war crimes?
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by rvnx on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:26PM (#37153272)
Somehow, you made me wonder what phone Hitler would use, if it's Android or iOS. And what social network app he would use.

But one thing for sure, he wouldn't have time to play slots machines.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by graypegg on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:31PM (#37153359)
There’s a sketch idea for the show Horrible Histories maybe, heheheh
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by verve_rat on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:00PM (#37155482)
Surely it would be some sort of Volksmobil? The question is: how would it snitch on you?
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by graypegg on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:07PM (#37152970)
I guess on the other side of the argument: why does a game developer in one country feel obliged to change the content standard set by another country? It’s a pretty minor variance all things considered. Maybe you just can’t “change much” here?

(Also: I don’t agree with the obviously silly content rules.)

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by stronglikedan on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:10PM (#37153006)
The only answer is, likely nothing. There's likely nothing you or anyone else can do to get the governments of those countries to change anything about the way they govern. It's not a tree worth barking up.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by rvnx on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:18PM (#37153133)
Well, there is a solution, but it's unpopular, so it may negatively impact company valuation.

Lobbying government of US, to send them "democracy".

Or hire PMCs (Alphabet has 113B USD in cash).

Or push news and content that is against the local government (but this is half-joke).

So it's possible if you really want.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by tomjen3 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:37PM (#37153437)
Anti trust law suit and PR campaign against Google.

Problem is that it likely cost way more than he can afford.

Anything else effective is illegal.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by tspike on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:00PM (#37152868)
Why is there not even lip service paid to consistent enforcement?
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by janoc on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:08PM (#37152981)
Because they enforce when someone complains. They aren't going to proactively ban stuff unless they really have to (e.g. something that is very obviously illegal/scam/etc.)

So if nobody complained about the other apps, they didn't get banned. It is that easy.

That someone else does something that violates those policies/laws too doesn't mean that you get a free pass, unfortunately.

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by tspike on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:12PM (#37155575)
I'd buy that if the app stores weren't proactively rejecting apps for the same reasons they fail to enforce on others.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by TulliusCicero on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:11PM (#37153015)
Making it consistent across different national laws means ignoring those laws.

Does anyone think Google should just ignore national laws as a general policy?

Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by mrguyorama on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @05:08PM (#37153873)
Only the ones they don't like.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by graypegg on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:21PM (#37153191)
Consistant enforcement means “local laws are consistently applied”. There isn’t one globally recognized list of content moderation standards.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by ceph_ on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:06PM (#37152958)
It's a slot machine game. Seems like it's being enforced properly in this scenario.
Re:Luck be a Landlord is now banned in 13 countries on the G... by Spivak on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:04PM (#37152926)
Because running a global service in multiple sovereign jurisdictions makes it impossible to have consistent enforcement. Would you have it so only the laws of the country of the company's HQ matters?

If you mean why isn't Google bringing the banhammer down on every app that fails to meet the criteria isn't that what you want? Allow as much as possible until a government complains?