Happy to be proven wrong, but I don’t believe TaylorAlexander has ever advocated for such, at least here on this forum, and there’s no reading, that I can imagine, of their comments here that would lead to me think they’ve started doing so.
[1] https://apnews.com/article/climate-change-youth-montana-tria...
To this line which I hear from time to time: "My question for you is, what should we do if those things have been ineffective?"
I say, keep thinking. Specially if your answer is terrorism or para-terrorist activities.
Just say what you mean please. What have I suggested which is terrorism?
If someone says "purple is bad" and you comment a bunch of reasons why purple is not bad, am I that much at fault to think you believe purple is good? If you are for democratic and societal change through legal means then you're with me. I'm sorry if I annoyed you for hinting that you were proposing terrorism, but please re-read the original comment and see how that might've happened, I also got annoyed myself due to the fact that I didn't think people would find offense to an anti-terrorist stance, so perhaps I exaggerated.
My point was not to advocate terrorism but to highlight the folly of your suggested alternatives.
Your intention may have been purely to argue against terrorism but in the process you made other arguments I felt compelled to critique. I was not arguing in favor of terrorism.
I don't think it's great for you to be irritated by a suggestion of change through democratic means, that is how our society works. Maybe some of my other suggestions weren't the ones you'd choose, but I was merely making a list of things that can be done to affect change. Believe me you don't want to live in a system where any group can modify everyone else's life in the whole world in less than several decades. That system would be likely to be corrupted very easily. It takes a while to re-align our priorities as a global society.
Unlike the voices that say "it isn't working", I think it is in fact working because we have more and more green parties in power and there's more and more awareness and change. If you step back from the doom voices you can see that voting does work. Of course the warming metrics will keep going up as we still have work to do and there will be a lagging effect, but voting isn't the only option, there's other things one can do as I mentioned in my comment and more even like some of the ones you mentioned.
https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/how-green-party-success-res...
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S026137942...
https://www.eyes-on-europe.eu/greens-in-europe-an-impressive...
You keep missing the point that the system has been captured and perverted.
Without absorbing that fact, you'll never understand the world you live in.
> I think it is in fact working
There is a LOT to how our system works. It's not just a bunch of people going to their 9-5 for two years, skipping over to the ballot box, and then forgetting about politics for another 24 months. You did not explicitly say that is what we should do and I don't even believe you think that, but when someone says "the solution is to vote for change", to me as someone who believed in voting under Obama and then saw how the change we voted for gave way to the status quo, I learned how limited voting is in affecting real change. It is a component sure, but when the establishment on both sides is in agreement that we should either continue aggressively mining, selling, and burning fossil fuels, or we should continue mining and burning fossil fuels while agreeing to a very slow, scientifically disastrous slow wind down of their use, then obviously voting is not enough. And we have had 20 years to digest and reject the notion that individual changes are where we should focus. I mean sure, I am literally vegan, I believe in some sense of responsibility, but I believe more strongly that activism and agitation for broader social change, which requires MUCH MORE than voting, is necessarily required.
That's why in an earlier comment I linked to the lawsuit in Montana. Young people in that state sued the state government for failing to protect the environment for the future as required by the state constitution. That's not voting or starting a new party! When someone says "the solution is to vote" it strikes me as naive. I have been voting for this for 20+ years. It is painfully clear to me that voting is not sufficient. I watched as Obama attended COP21 and failed to make any meaningful commitments. We must do way more than voting.
- elites aren't a monolithic group
- regular people don't all agree with you, specially in their actions, which is the main problem
- change comes about as fast as it comes about, you don't get to dictate what is "fast enough" through revolution or terrorism without facing opposition
- change is in fact coming as I shared with sources showing more governments turning green with trends predicting even more
- decrying a hijack of democracy is folly, and something anyone who's annoyed that their country doesn't do what they personally want can say at any point without any proof. That's what trump said when people didn't vote for him, that democracy was hijacked.
If anything it was a great discussion, hope you have a nice day even if we don't agree on a bunch I respect your fervor and thoughts on the topic.
But maybe it is not all because of an evil elite, but also the very common people who don't believe or care about climate change, because it would mean bad consciousness or reduced comfort?
And the people who say they care, but still fly around the world for a vacation?
A scientific consensus alone is not enough, it needs a general human consensus that something needs to happen. And slowly slowly it is forming in some ways. In other ways things are going backward (russia for example is thinking out loud that climate change is just caused by earths natural radiactivity).
But I also fail to see how terrorism can help create such a consensus.
> But maybe it is not all because of an evil elite
Our system is elite-driven, and popular attitudes are strongly driven by elite manipulation through the media.
> because it would mean bad consciousness or reduced comfort
It would not mean this, but we have been led to believe it would mean this by an elite that doesn't want to make these changes due to reduced profits.
Flying is bad, right? And not flying reduces comfort. What does this has to do anything with evil elites?
That's a prediction that suing and lobbying won't work, leaving only eco terrorism.
You posit that it will work because "if the majority agrees we'll deal with it".
I consider that either an unfounded article of faith, or a confusion between political majority and population majority. (Under apartheid South African whites were a minority of the population but with the majority of political power.)
"Sixty-four percent of people believe climate change is a global emergency," says https://www.undp.org/press-releases/worlds-largest-survey-pu... . From the report:
> • Regionally, the proportion of people who said climate change is a global emergency had a high level of support everywhere - in Western Europe and North America (72%), Eastern Europe and Central Asia (65%), Arab States (64%), Latin America and Caribbean (63%), Asia and Pacific (63%), and Sub-Saharan Africa (61%).
> • Of the people that said climate change is a global emergency, 59% said that the world should do everything necessary and urgently in response. Meanwhile 20% said we should act slowly, while 10% percent of people thought the world is already doing enough
Given that a majority of the world's population believes there is a climate emergency, where is the corresponding government response that you say should exist now that a majority agrees?
If the population majority agrees we need urgent and radical change now, but the political majority does not deal with it - what's the next step? What will you do?
> Those are all things that will help without forcing your views on others through force
CO2 and other greenhouse gas emissions are being forced on us, very strongly, backed by the use of police and military power. "Fossil Fuels Received $5.9 Trillion In Subsidies in 2020, Report Finds" - https://e360.yale.edu/digest/fossil-fuels-received-5-9-trill... . Where did that money come from? Our taxes. What if we don't pay taxes? I'll let you finish that.
We may see MLK Jr now as a leader in non-violent protests, but focusing only on his non-violent methods ignores the effect of riots ("A riot is the language of the unheard") and more militant organizations on establishing legal civil rights equality.
Remember, violence can be effective. Violence supported centuries of racial oppression in the US. Violence also ended slavery in Haiti.
> Eco terrorism is just like any other form terrorism.
Especially in that the government gets to define what is and is not terrorism.
Dumping poisonous waste into a waterway, knowing that the fine is cheaper than actual clean up, and knowing that even if it kills plants, animals, and people at most the company will get a fine, is not eco terrorism.
Why not? Because it's not 'violent' (even though it's deadly) and because it's not in support of environmental causes. The government is set up to support large companies over individual people, so fines like this are a simple cost of doing business rather than a death penalty for the company and manslaughter charges against its employees.
The violent attacks on the Dakota Access pipeline protestors were also not eco terrorism, because the attacks are not in support of environmental causes.
Let's call it "biz terrorism", like how coal companies used to hire people to carry out machine gun attacks on strikers. Odd that biz terrorism isn't it's own special category, yes?
Famously, "one person's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter", and Nelson Mandela was on the US terrorist watch list until 2008. Quoting the commentary at https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2012/05/is-one-... :
] "As a descriptor, terrorist is almost never applied rigorously and consistently to describe the tactics a group is using -- rather, it is invoked as a pejorative to vilify the actions only of groups one wishes to discredit. People who agree with the ends of the very same groups often don't think of them as terrorists, the negative connotation of which causes them to focus on what they regard as the noble ends of allies they're more likely to dub freedom fighters."
I take it you, unlike the vast majority of people, don't enjoy sex. With enough sex, there will be children, either through negligence or failure of birth control methods.
Are you sure? How many of your ancestors didn't have kids?
That's not the world we live in, so your argument for terrorism falls apart. This is not a "both sides" issue. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/what-is-the-social-cost-o...
Become a proponent for direct democracy and work to replace the institutions that aren’t serving you how they should.
It's not working extremely well. It's also quite slow which is quite the opposite of what's needed now.
Appenzell Innerrhoden is a tiny half-canton, 67 sq.mi, population ~16,000 or 0.2% of Switzerland (8.8m). Dayton, Tennessee (of Scopes Monkey Trial infamy) has a population of 7,000.
Women in Switzerland obtained the right to vote at federal level in 1971, and at local cantonal level between 1959 and 1972 [0][1], except for Appenzell.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_women%27s_suffrage
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women%27s_suffrage_in_Switzerl...
One I think clearer example is a direct democracy can choose to ignore minorities (of any stripe) more, and have more to spend on visible things that help most people, but also allow smaller groups to fall away (or not allow them in at all). I don't know if that's the case for Switzerland, as with wealth comes the ability to mitigate this, but that is the traditional danger with direct democracy.
None of your concerns have happened in Switzerland, quite the opposite. I don’t know what you mean by minorities, but in Zürich a third of the population aren’t even Swiss citizens. In Switzerland, everything is extremely decentralized.
Additionally, Switzerland is not a homogeneous culture - the differences between Vaud, Zürich, Ticino etc. are massive.
All I know is Switzerland is a wonderful place, and I believe it is because they never really had a king, but ruled their country together.
I don't see the point in changing what I said. I said I think most systems can look good if there's enough money sloshing around.
My point is - e.g. in the US, who also never had a king, most people live in cities. If there were direct democracy then those people could vote for very pro-city policies, and neglect rural. Given there's representational democracy, that's much more difficult, and national rules need to be more balanced.
What if your country is locked in a two party system captured by elite interests with no desire to actually solve the problem? What if what you want is not available by vote?
> form a new party
What if your system is designed to ensure new parties always fail?
> stop having kids
Is our sacrifice really what is needed to stop climate change? Would it even make a difference? Are we doomed to live unhappy lives because of the system we were born in to?
> stop buying things
Shall we just perish then?
> if the majority agrees we'll deal with it
What if the majority agrees but a minority that disagrees controls the political system?