News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by politician on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:51PM (#37141388)
MLS is another example of a system that would be better on a distributed blockchain which would allow multiple companies to offer competing views on the available inventory, and superior search tools.

(N.B. I acknowledge that mentioning the concept above is heavily punished here, but as someone who has interfaced with the existing system, I accept the consequences.)

Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by jsutton on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:11PM (#37141558)
Agreed, this is the kind of use case blockchain excels at. I worked on a project that attempted to do something like a distributed MLS, and we had major industry leaders on board indicating a large degree of belief that blockchain could revolutionize the industry. MLS is, after all, just a legacy federated system running on inertia.

Unfortunately, it's so difficult to get a critical mass of inventory to succeed; it requires either a massive upfront investment, or partnering with RE developers from the beginning.

Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by kjs3 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:18PM (#37141606)
The niche was a poster child for disruption! The incumbent is an incompetent crushed under legacy debt! We had all the buzzwords! All the 'major industry leaders' thought we were awesome!

Nothing came of it!

Sounds like every blockchain proposal I've ever delt with.

Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by jsutton on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:10PM (#37141971)
Everyone said the same thing about ML/AI 5+ years ago. Hard things take time.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by kjs3 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:10AM (#37147280)
The Satoshi paper was 15 years ago. Just keep waiting, one day...one day...
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by jsutton on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:31PM (#37156052)
The first paper on AI and Neural Nets was published in 1945. What's your point? 15 years is not a very long time for deep tech.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by kjs3 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:14PM (#37156341)
You talk about 5 years and things take time. I point out that the subject is 15 years along, and still not there. So now you've gone almost 80 years back...what is your point other than "if I move the goalposts enough...maybe I'll get to be right".
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by symlinkk on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:04PM (#37141494)
I don’t know how anyone could argue with you. The MLS is literally just a database of house listings. In some states you can only access it if you’re a realtor, solely to keep their job secure. Making it decentralized would open up that data for everyone.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by danielvaughn on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:32PM (#37141726)
It's a bit more complicated than that. One issue is that some information should only be shared between professionals. For instance, if a seller has a keypad entry, the listing will often contain the passcode for a buyers agent if they want to tour the house while the seller is away. That kind of information can't be shared publicly, so you need some degree of privacy control.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by symlinkk on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:32PM (#37142205)
Ok so keep that behind a gate and open up the rest. That’s a flimsy excuse. We are software engineers, we know how easy it would be to expose a subset of the data. It’s job security plain and simple. Same reason you can’t buy a car direct from the manufacturer and have to pay thousands in markup to some dealership that adds zero value.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by linsomniac on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:52PM (#37142336)
It's not really so simple as it might seem. For example: In this blockchain, how do you identify a property? Address? Lots of properties are listed that do not have an address. County parcel number? Also not ideal.

But, the real issue is that, as the system currently is, you need to have a license to list a property. Don't like it? You can do FSBO. But, basically nobody does, because the majority of buyers have a Realtor and are showing properties in the MLS.

Realtors should, ideally, provide value in the transaction. When I bought a house, for example, my agent provided tips on how to structure the offer that I'm confident allowed us to get the house we got. On the selling side, the should be providing marketing expertise, as well as negotiating the legal landmines. For example, if you were to list your own house and say "This room would make an ideal man-cave", you are opening yourself up to litigation under the Fair Housing laws (you cannot suggest who should live in your house).

Now, whether this is worth 5-8% of the sale price is another matter for discussion, but let's not forget that Realtors do provide some value.

(Not a Realtor, SysAdmin to an MLS)

Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by jjtheblunt on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:08PM (#37141522)
Does it work only if everyone holds credentials for viewing what's in the (centralized or decentralized) data records?
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by Dalewyn on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:06PM (#37141506)
Please tell us how you're a cryptobro without saying you're a cryptobro.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by LordShredda on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:23PM (#37141638)
He literally told you that he's a cryptobro. At least he mentioned a same use case for block chains
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by Dalewyn on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:04PM (#37141930)
He never said "cryptobro" anywhere in his post, though. Maybe you don't understand what the word "literally" means[1] either.

[1]: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/literally

Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by politician on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:56AM (#37149039)
I'm literally not a cryptobro. I've never owned cryptocurrency, and I've never lost or made any money in speculating on any of it. Rather, I find the data structures and algorithms interesting and relevant to this use case. Promoting cryptocurrencies is not a personal crusade of mine, and I hope shutting down conversations about a data structure is not a personal crusade of anyone on HN.
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by progman32 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @09:55PM (#37141880)
Why is a blockchain better here, vs a normal database?
Re:MLS cyberattack halts entire US real estate market by jsutton on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:48PM (#37142653)
A normal database isn't able to be easily disseminated by the people who need access to this data, which is enormous. Then who gets to host it? Real Estate associations are too many, too fragmented, too entrenched to agree on one or even a handful of companies with the privilege to host this information.

A blockchain (assuming you can get buy-in/critical mass from the agencies) has the ability to align some financial incentives of all interested parties to open up access to real estate listings while still holding ownership and profiting from that access.

Instead of real estate companies protecting their listing data, they could offer access to their listing data in exchange for a fee or revenue share. Instead of out-of-date listings parading as up-to-date, there's a public temporal record of updates. Instead of buyers getting restricted or partial information, they can obtain access to the listing data via alternate sources.