News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Saturday August 12, 2023 @08:39PM (#37105502)
It's not about working hard. It's about working smart.

> So much opportunity is either created or destroyed by external circumstances that we don't perceive, let alone control

However, doing nothing guarantees failure. Some aspects of working smart:

1. doing the prep work so when opportunity does come your way, you are capable of taking advantage

2. placing yourself in a situation where opportunity can find you

3. learning to recognize opportunity (it often comes disguised as hard work)

4. be willing to take risks

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Saturday August 12, 2023 @08:46PM (#37105538)
I've missed at least 4 opportunities to become a billionaire. I bet a lot of readers here can say the same.
Re:The Carrot Problem by scaredginger on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:47PM (#37105863)
What percentage of readers here would you estimate have missed a chance of becoming a billionaire?
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:02PM (#37105958)
Probably nearly all of them over 30 of sound mind and body, that live in America, avoided the lure of alcohol, drugs, and crime, got themselves educated in a useful skill, and avoided the tar pits of victimhood and grievances.
Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:04AM (#37106580)
By what avenue?! Inventing a unicorn business and developing the connections to sell it to the people who matter? Buying the right lottery ticket?
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:01AM (#37106848)
> By what avenue?!

Leveraging everything you had and bought MSFT when it went public. Or AMZN. Or Bitcoin. Or Apple. As the value of the stock increased, buy more on margin.

Of course, this is risky. Note I mentioned a willingness to take risks.

Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:32AM (#37106980)
Are you suggesting that if 100 times as many people bought those stocks at the right time, we'd have 100 times as many billionaires? What exactly would be generating all that extra wealth?
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:01AM (#37107361)
There are a fixed number of shares. If A buys 100 shares, there are 100 shares fewer available for others to buy.

Until a corporation dilutes the shares by issuing more.

Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:29AM (#37107521)
Yes, that was kind of my point. I'm not really seeing how many more people could have possibly become mega-rich just by having bought more of the shares that happened to make the few people that actually did mega-rich, which seemed to be what you were suggesting - apologies if I misinterpreted.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:14AM (#37106900)
Look at the median incomes throughout the us, then look at the living expenses, and honestly consider whether speculative investing would be even remotely feasible, or even a morally defensible financial strategy with other people relying on you? Not being put into a position where other people rely on you— elderly parents, relative's children, etc— is pretty lucky in most socio-economic sections in our country.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:09AM (#37107416)
11.6% of Americans are below the poverty line, not 50%.

You can start an investment program for $100 at robinhood.com.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:07AM (#37109141)
Do you know how absurdly low the federal poverty level is compared to actual living expenses, anywhere? Do you honestly think $ > FPL = able to speculatively invest? Lots of basic needs assistance programs start tapering once you hit 133% of the regionally-adjusted federal poverty level and many don't disqualify until you until you hit multiples... And we still have a lot of food insecurity, housing insecurity, and lack of access to medical care among people who don't qualify.

https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2023/04/11/58percent-of-americans-a...

58% of Americans are living paycheck to paycheck. Throwing money into some Robinhood investment when you're living paycheck to paycheck, especially if you're responsible for other people, as many people in lower socio-economic brackets are, is completely irresponsible.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:09PM (#37111837)
> 58% of Americans are living paycheck to paycheck

That's one of the most misleading statistics ever. Lots and lots of people live paycheck to paycheck because they see money they spend money. I know people who live in McMansions with new cars, spiffy threads, and expensive furniture who spend every dime. Every time they get a raise, they ramp up the spending. When I worked at Boeing, payday was every other Thursday. People would leave the building and run to their cars. This is because they'd already spent the money and needed to get the paycheck deposited ASAP.

They're not poor people. What they are are fiscally irresponsible.

A corollary is the percentage of people with less than $500 in the bank. Well, I have less than $500 in the bank. It's not because I'm poor, it's because I put every dime to work for me in investments.

BTW, what do you think of those millions of people dressing up like Barbie and going to see Taylor Swift concerts, spending a thousand bucks and more on travel, tickets, costumes, etc.? Me, it shows Americans are not mired in poverty.

Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:40AM (#37109960)
With only $100 you're basically going to have to win the lottery: get the right symbol (most won't be) at an ideal buy time, and sell at an ideal selling point. Be sure not to go bankrupt or homeless while buying those tickets and waiting for that perfect timing.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:12PM (#37111871)
LOL. Every investment program starts with a first step. AMZN opened at $35 a share. Buying 3 shares would be worth what, today? North of $100,000. Not bad, eh?
Re:The Carrot Problem by fullstackchris on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:37AM (#37107005)
"willingness to take risks" and betting the farm on a tech stock _continuosly_ over 20+ years are two very different things
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:00AM (#37107351)
I happen to know a person who did exactly that, and became very wealthy.

Making lots of money is usually proportional to how much risk you're willing to take.

Re:The Carrot Problem by abenga on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:47AM (#37107618)
How many more did the same, but only managed to yield spectacular failure? Such lottery wins are not repeatable, and relying on them is horrible advice.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:24PM (#37111999)
I pointed out upthread the willingness to take risk. Nothing is guaranteed. But you can tilt the odds very much in your favor.

BTW, AMZN had far, far better odds than any lottery.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:20AM (#37110808)
"I know a guy" is a useless measure of whether or not something is feasible for most people. There's a lot of useful data out there about this stuff.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:15PM (#37111914)
I don't name names for privacy reasons, not because I'm making things up.

The Seattle Times reported in the 1990s that there were over 10,000 Microsoft millionaires living in the Seattle area, excluding housing. And that was when a million dollars was real money.

Ten thousand.

There's probably a similar figure for Amazon employees.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:08AM (#37106872)
Buying the right lottery ticket is the closest chance to this being accurate. If you look at the percentages in social strata and honestly evaluate the logistical and cultural paths most people would have to access billionaire-level opportunity, it's apparent that American meritocracy at the upper echelons is a fucking joke.
Re:The Carrot Problem by interroboink on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:11PM (#37105674)
(apologies for the small tangential rant; it's a topic I care about :)

I have seen this view towards luck a few times — some variant of "make your own luck" or "put yourself in situations where you're more likely to be lucky", and similar.

I don't object to it by itself, but there's a subtlety that is often missed: it only applies to yourself, not other people. Or perhaps more accurately: it only applies to your choice of action, not evaluating others' results.

The reason I have misgivings is because I have seen it used as a cudgel; someone fails, and a person with this mindset is more prone to rationalize it, saying "oh, they didn't try hard enough" or "it was their own fault, they should be smarter about it."

No.

No matter how hard a person tries, they can still fail, and it may not be their fault at all. At least when it's your own self, you have more information to know if you could have done better. When it's directed at others, it's extremely dicey to make those judgements.

Someone more in tune with the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune might be more inclined to actually help that person, rather than blaming them for things outside of their control.

It's tricky, because the "try harder next time" whip is useful, to be sure, but it also can be an enemy of empathy.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:35PM (#37105803)
> they can still fail

Of course. I never wrote otherwise.

Many successful people I know failed multiple times.

> "it was their own fault, they should be smarter about it."

The successful people I know who failed multiple times and eventually succeeded all blamed themselves for the failures, with "I should have been smarter about it".

The great thing about taking responsibility for one's failures is it is empowering - it means you can succeed by learning why one failed and doing it better next time.

You could consider it like airliners. Crashes are not attributed to "bad luck". The cause is always searched for, and once found, it gets fixed. Over time, this has resulted in incredibly safe airliners.

Do you really expect to successfully ride a bike the first time you swing your leg over the seat? Nope. You fall off, get back on, fall off, get back on, fall off, get back on, hey! I'm riding!

Re:The Carrot Problem by oefnak on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:56PM (#37106256)
What if you're born in a poor country? Just keep trying?
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:57AM (#37106836)
I'm sorry for people who are born in communist/socialist countries. My statements apply to the US. For those in democratic socialist countries, stop voting for socialism.
Re:The Carrot Problem by ahf8Aithaex7Nai on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:37AM (#37107006)
Your worldview is amusing. Everything is simple and consistent. Simple concepts, simple explanations, simple recipes. You have to be a complete idiot or very lazy not to succeed in the world as you see it.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:15AM (#37107443)
If you're convinced you can't succeed in America, you certainly won't.
Re:The Carrot Problem by ahf8Aithaex7Nai on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:30AM (#37107522)
If you don't play the lottery, you can't win. That's obvious. But the vast majority of people in America will not succeed even if they are convinced that success is possible.
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:04AM (#37109118)
The vast majority of people in America has already succeeded: being "poor" there is better than being "average" in most countries on Earth.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:05AM (#37110671)
You're changing the topic. This conversation is not about the quality of life among lower-income people-- It is about the opportunity to become a very successful entrepreneur.

And 'better than most countries' isn't a very high bar for the richest country on earth. The Economist ranked the US 30th in food availability, and 28th in food affordability among 112 countries. Not exactly a slam dunk.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:41PM (#37111552)
And yet we're the fattest country in the world, and throw away 40% of the food we buy.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:17AM (#37106908)
Where you are born is a matter of luck, and not just in governance. You can directly correlate success in the US to the zip code you were born into.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/19/learning/how-much-has-you...

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:13AM (#37107436)
Fortunately, you can move to whatever zip code you like.
Re:The Carrot Problem by Niksko on Sunday August 13, 2023 @06:13AM (#37108448)
Unfortunately, that's not how it works. a) no you can't just decide to go and live in any postcode you want, you need to be able to afford the cost of living there, and b) the study is about where you're born, not just where you end up.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:17PM (#37111294)
> no you can't just decide to go and live in any postcode you want,

Yeah, you can.

> you need to be able to afford the cost of living there

More affluent places hire maids, gardeners, handymen, drivers, etc. The even wealthier ones have places for them to live on the premises. In Seattle, of course, they just pitch a tent on the street or live in their cars.

This thread reminds me of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0q4o58pKwA

Re:The Carrot Problem by acdha on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:30PM (#37112051)
> More affluent places hire maids, gardeners, handymen, drivers, etc. The even wealthier ones have places for them to live on the premises.

I’m trying to tell whether this is a serious argument. Yes, the very wealthiest might allow their most trusted servants to live on their estates but that’s like saying that anyone can go to the moon or win an Olympic gold medal because some humans have done it. Most rich people do not do that and those positions are not widely available: for example, the most common would be live-in nannies which often require things like college degrees and the “right” background. The far more common outcome is that most workers commute to those exclusive places and they often have very strong rules (the last time I drive through an expensive area outside of San Diego, it was noticeable how often the roads were blocked by landscapers’ trucks because they weren’t even allowed to park in the dozen car driveways every estate has). It’s not even uncommon to have things like shuttles so they can park where it’s cheaper and not have to drive all of the way in.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:57AM (#37109057)
Like many people with a libertarian outlook, you don't seem to understand that laws aren't the most limiting factor in most people's lives. Simple economic realities prevent most people from moving to "whatever zip code they want."

Every disadvantage seems trivial if you ignore the actual barriers they impart.

Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:09AM (#37109165)
An unwillingness to do whatever is necessary to improve one's station in life correlates with a lack of success in said life, I am afraid.

Another easy thing to do to improve your "luck" is vote pro-free-market, pro-business and pro-competition policies in your area. Sadly there is a high correlation (at least where I live) between how poor people are and how leftist they vote...

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:39AM (#37109403)
> An unwillingness to do whatever is necessary to improve one's station in life correlates with a lack of success in said life, I am afraid.

An unwillingness to recognize that willpower isn't enough to overcome many, of not most blocks to social mobility in the US correlates with blind support for lazzais fair free market evangelism, I'm afraid.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:40PM (#37111544)
> isn't enough

Yes. I listed upthread what was necessary.

Re:The Carrot Problem by anon4242 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:15AM (#37110226)
This is ignoring the fact that most people commenting here already won big time in the lottery of life: the family you were born into.

If you were born in a family in the wealthiest 10% of the world you have a lot of advantage over the person born in the least wealthy 10%. It's a lot more profound than that you got a game console for X-mas every other year.

For instance, does drowning while crossing the Mediterranean sea on a substandard boat not constitute a willingness to do whatever is necessary to improve one's station in life in your view?

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:38AM (#37110440)
Yes-- and beyond that, to be in the top 10% as of 2019, you needed a HOUSEHOLD income of $154,589. I'll bet many, if not most of the people on HN make or beat that with one household salary. I imagine that it's gotta be at least 200k by now, but a household with the income of a public school teacher and a construction laborer would undoubtedly get you into the top 25%.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:31PM (#37111446)
Yeah, well, my family was lower middle class. The same for many wealthy people I know.

I noted also that my comments were referring to America, which is (still) a free market country that provides a great deal of opportunity. That's why millions of poor people try to get here.

Re:The Carrot Problem by retsibsi on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:38AM (#37110439)
> Another easy thing to do to improve your "luck" is vote pro-free-market, pro-business and pro-competition policies in your area.

Even granting the ideological premise, this is nonsense. Your vote has a minuscule chance of determining who gets elected or what policies they enact.

> Sadly there is a high correlation (at least where I live) between how poor people are and how leftist they vote...

What idiots, preferring the side that at least claims to care about them and is somewhat more likely to help them afford their next meal and their medical bills, rather than the side that blames them for their poverty and offers them 'economic freedom' without the resources that would make it meaningful.

Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:08PM (#37111209)
Actually, this should be expected: an inability to see beyond populist promises and to reason about the world and its immutable laws should often be correlated with staying poor.

The same mentality is pushing people to play the lottery, join pyramidal schemes and vote representatives pretending to solve their problems for them.

Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:27PM (#37112023)
False equivalence. 20 years ago, it was much easier to “get out of poverty” than it is today.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:26PM (#37111391)
America is not full of people who can't afford their next meal. America is full of middle class fat people. Americans throw away what, 40% of the food they buy?

The vast majority of Americans are also healthy and able-bodied, they are not dependent on life sustaining medical help. The bulk of a person's medical bills are heavily skewed towards aged people. And there's Medicare, Medicaid, and Obamacare.

> without the resources

Every American child is offered free K-12 education (with free lunches), and easy loans for college.

Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:26PM (#37112018)
> Every American child is offered free K-12 education (with free lunches)

Spend some time in the south. Parents don’t let kids go to public schools and send them to parochial schools that teach creationism as science, and deride anything that disagrees with God’s word as false. That’s the schooling many kids get in the south.

Go read up a bit on A Beka books and the Bob Jones curriculum.

Those kids didn’t get a choice as to which parents to be born to. It was luck. That’s the point.

> and easy loans for college.

Hahahahahahahahahaha. Yes, “easy loans,” that depending on the job market you graduate into, you may never pay back.

Those students didn’t get the choice as to when they would be born and, thus, when they would graduate school. Entering the job market in 2003 and in 2008 was wildly different, and those that entered in 2008 were stunted not just for one year but many, as those that entered in 2006 or 2007 had more experience, fewer unexplained gaps, etc., all because of when they happened to be born.

Speak to people who don’t have money. Listen to what they say. Based on your responses, I can pretty much guarantee you’ve never done that.

Re:The Carrot Problem by retsibsi on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:26AM (#37135156)
I don't think this conversation is just about the US; an earlier comment in the chain said "for those in democratic socialist countries, stop voting for socialism".

But if the parent commenter was talking about America, 'leftist' presumably means Democrat. Medicare, Medicaid, and Obamacare were all introduced by Democrats and signed into law by Democratic presidents.

Until quite recently it was Republican policy to repeal Obamacare, and in 2017 a partial repeal (including big cuts to Medicaid) would have gone through if not for a small number who voted against the party line.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:39PM (#37111528)
> a libertarian outlook

Yes, I am a libertarian. Libertarianism is often derided as "simplistic" and "naive". The irony is it's anything but simplistic and naive. It's difficult to understand how order can arrive from chaos. It's difficult to understand how greed and selfishness produces great prosperity for a population.

Simplistic is the Star Trek world, which is ruled by an all-wise, incorruptible, benign dictator. It's the progressive vision of Utopia. The idea is that with enough laws (backed up by force) and enough propaganda, people will behave selflessly and will cooperate for the common good. Why this fails constantly baffles people, and they just reach for more laws and more force.

Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:41AM (#37110964)
Not if you don’t have the money or time because you’re working three jobs. Or you have kids from a previous divorce and can’t leave the state or you never see them again.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:11PM (#37111234)
> Not if you don’t have the money

The homeless in Seattle are largely not from Seattle. Somehow they managed to get here.

So do the people who come by the millions, walking across the continent to get into the US.

In fact, America was populated by poor people coming from Europe. The Titanic's money maker wasn't the first class section, it was steerage. Maybe check out Ellis Island.

Chicago was populated by poor people looking for work.

The American West was settled with people with no money.

> Or you have kids from a previous divorce and can’t leave the state

That's the result of choices the person made.

I wonder what the schools teach about American history :-/

Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:19PM (#37111952)
I wonder what the schools teach about economics :-/

Please don’t attempt to educate me on the idea that “poor people can move.” My parents were poor immigrants and moved twice, across two continents, with nothing in their pockets, to try and make a better life.

That does not mean they could do that today. The economy has changed. Cost of living has gone up dramatically. There is no more “western frontier” where one can luck out and find gold. It is much much harder to move now than ever before.

And that’s before you get to the fact that my parents were here illegally for almost 30 years, but had SSNs, paid taxes, handled all their debt, did not take government handouts/subsidies, never got in trouble, and so on. They were able to do that because paperwork back then was … paper, and they could find people to make it work. Today they’d be deported.

With all due respect, your point of view is marred by the fact that you’ve had success. Spend some time actually talking to some poor people, before you start to tell them why they are poor.

As for “That's the result of choices the person made,” this is a dumb argument. Condoms break. Abortion is illegal in many states. Divorces happen because of things that are not entirely in someone’s control, even after years of happy marriage (i.e. someone cheats). Full custody is something only courts can grant, not your own choices. If you can’t get it, you can’t leave the state, or you don’t get to see your kid again. That has nothing to do with your choice to get married to the love of your life and have a child with them.

The logical conclusion of your argument is “well you can choose to leave your kid behind” which is nonsense.

Please consider that your perspective may be biased by not having actually spoken to anyone in the situations you purport to know so much about.

Re:The Carrot Problem by l3mure on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:33PM (#37114153)
> The American West was settled with people with no money.

Gee, almost like massive parcels of land were given away to incentivize that. Truly one of the dumbest statements I've ever seen on this website.

Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:29AM (#37106960)
What examples of "democratic socialist" countries do you have in mind that would be likely to achieve significantly greater economic wealth/material standard of living just by voting differently?
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:27AM (#37107210)
Britain, for example. For others, there are the former Soviet bloc countries. The ones that voted for more free markets have done significantly better than the ones that clung to socialism. Chile is another one that prospers and declines based on them vacillating between socialism and free markets.
Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:55AM (#37107329)
Pretty sure Britain's economic woes have not been tied to an excess of socialism on account of its governments, at least in the last few decades. At any rate, both the UK and USA (and arguably most other modern wealthy countries) are essentially social democracies - it's largely a matter of degree (and to what extent it's prevalent at a federal vs state vs local level). But from the perspective of an Australian, the economy of the USA looks for all the world like one I want to avoid ours becoming at all costs. To be clear, I'm very much envious of the opportunities US-based technology workers have, and if there were a way to achieve that level of entrepreneurship and sheer variety of industrial success stories here while still maintaining a cohesive society not beset by destabilizing levels of inequality* I'd be all for it.

(*) on the inequality front, perhaps what puts me off the most is seeing the degree to which relatively few mega-corporations appear to dominate much of the social fabric. Which is a problem in Australia too but to a lesser extreme.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:12AM (#37107430)
If you vote for less inequality, be prepared for a lower standard of living. No country has ever managed to raise the standard of living of its citizens by preventing people from getting rich and/or confiscating their wealth and/or murdering them (see Pol Pot).
Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:32AM (#37107533)
I never said anything about preventing people getting rich. But a slightly lower material standard of living on average seems a reasonable price to pay for avoiding the least desirable outcomes from excessive inequality.
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:19AM (#37109248)
> slightly lower material standard of living

How slightly? Do you have a number? Because in certain places lowering the standard may very well people losing access to healthcare and education.

I am afraid that "but inequality!" is today used as an ideological rallying cry used to inflame spirits and create hate against a class of population. It's an old communist tactic, quite effective during the beginning of the Cold War but less now as people have seen the failed societies with their best and brightest massacred under this cry.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:16AM (#37110237)
Geez are you really arguing that the US is somehow a model for access to health care and that it's because of the free-market? How would you explain the dramatically less economically free Cuba? the more economically free (according to the heritage institute) Switzerland? Is that why the US has an avoidable mortality rate closer to poor eastern bloc countries than the rest of Europe?
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:00PM (#37111120)
US health care is not a free market, it's heavily regulated.

As a person living in the Eastern Block right now, I'd invite you to use the medical facilities in my town but I am not that cruel.

Luckily free private health care is becoming increasingly good so soon the state-provided horror show will become a distant memory like the communist era that spawned it.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:07PM (#37111198)
So... about Switzerland.
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:12PM (#37111242)
As a non-resident who has to use the Swiss health-care system for anything less urgent than emergency services I can report that the private health-care in Switzerland is quite well developed and quite expensive.
Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:58PM (#37113003)
I'm purely comparing Australia and the US. As a personal preference if we were given a choice to achieve an average material standard of living equivalent to the US, but the price was its measurably less egalitarian wealth and power distribution I wouldn't take it, even though I'd likely personally financially benefit from it. And yes it's an ideological position, but I don't see why that's a bad thing. If there were persuasive evidence that less equal economies/societies were better functioning and provided more fulfilling life experiences for the population as a whole I'd abandon it.

As it is, statistically the US seems to be somewhat of an outlier in having both a very high GDP per capita and a relatively high GINI coefficient, so there's little reason to suspect Australia would benefit at all from higher inequality.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:44PM (#37111570)
Your post is contradictory.
Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:19PM (#37113291)
Not sure how, but I will say statistically there's little evidence that in general higher inequality leads to greater overall wealth anyway: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gini-coefficient-vs-gdp-p... - if anything that tends to indicate the US is something of an outlier.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:54AM (#37111083)
This is such a bizarrely extreme non-sequitur. From the UK, which is neck-and-neck with the US on the Heritage Institute's economic freedom rankings, to Pol Pot. Good lord.
Re:The Carrot Problem by abenga on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:53AM (#37107644)
Haven't the Tories been in power for more than a decade?
Re:The Carrot Problem by seabass-labrax on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:34PM (#37106446)
I learnt to ride with extra wheels attached to the side of the bicycle, and as a result, I almost never fell during that learning process.

Translating the analogy back, what you describe is the entrepreneurial fail-until-you-win method. The alternative method of progression is that of apprenticeship or gradual promotion, which in my country is associated with traditionally middle-class professions like finance, medicine and law. In such a conventional career, success is almost guaranteed, as the number of people entering the profession is very close to the number retiring out of it, and the assumption is that, because the endeavour has always been profitable, it will be for you too.

Ideally, the profession as a whole gradually improves under this system, but no individual member of it has to engage in any more than an average level of risk to be personally successful.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:02AM (#37106855)
Yeah, well, such safe avenues don't lead to making a billion.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:41AM (#37107032)
And unsafe avenues aren't an option for the majority of people in the US.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:23AM (#37107194)
Not buying that. America is not a nation of poor people.
Re:The Carrot Problem by daverol on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:30AM (#37107847)
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:59AM (#37109072)
Most of "poor people" in USA would be considered above average in other countries and continents.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:25AM (#37109295)
So they're financially secure enough for risky speculative investment?
Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:37AM (#37110928)
Context matters. If they moved to those other countries and continents, which have lower costs of living, they’d be fine. But: moving costs money and time they don’t have (since they’ve gotta work 3 jobs to put food on the table), those other countries and continents have even less opportunity to build a business, and so on.

It doesn’t really matter that you think “poor people” aren’t really that poor. They are, and risk is much harder to stomach when it means becoming actually homeless. Denying that is sticking your head in the sand.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @06:53AM (#37108677)
Well, how about you actually look?
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:01AM (#37109094)
Living paycheck-to-paycheck is quite often a lifestyle choice showing more lack of planning and of financial skills than poverty.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:26AM (#37109309)
Feel free to actually show some empirical evidence to support your assumptions.
Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:34AM (#37110910)
Said someone who has never grown up in poverty. rolls eyes

Been in both situations; grew up impoverished, now doing well.

Living paycheck to paycheck is never a lifestyle choice; there are choices that come out of that because even poor people don’t want to feel poor, but given the option, not a single one in most cases would prefer to be paycheck to paycheck.

Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:54AM (#37111077)
I grew up under the utter misery of communism. Even my illiterate grandmother working the earth knew to always have a valuable or two put aside to bribe the party representatives in case one of us got sick or in trouble.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:06PM (#37111188)
That doesn't give you a useful perspective on the logistics of poverty in the US. This isn't some kind of qualification based on a misery meter.
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:23PM (#37111360)
I also lived in the US. My roommate with half my salary had a car twice as expensive as mine. He had house payments while I was renting. Restaurants and bar outings while I stayed home reading. No wonder he was always broke on salary day...
Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:50PM (#37116923)
The “stop drinking Starbucks” is old and nonsensical. That isn’t why people are poor.
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Monday August 14, 2023 @04:18AM (#37118658)
> That isn’t why people are poor

So for you I guess lazy people don't exist? People who refuse to learn, change and adapt? People who just wanna smoke weed, play xbox, jerk off to pornhub and eat Nachos (not necessarily in that order)? People who'd rather make a quick buck doing some border-line illegal "deals" than have a regular honest job? People who would rather play the popularity game in high school than study? People who would rather slack off around the watercooler at work than do what "the boss" asks? People who prefer to coast although their field is changing under them?

It must be nice to live in a world without such people...

Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Monday August 14, 2023 @04:54AM (#37118864)
Of course they exist. They are a minority, though, and the trope of representing people in poverty as lazy is tired and old, in addition to inaccurate.
Re:The Carrot Problem by nickpp on Monday August 14, 2023 @09:16AM (#37120690)
Different worlds it is then. In mine, they are the great majority.
Re:The Carrot Problem by borski on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:08PM (#37111202)
I’m not sure what any of that has to do with the topic at hand? My parents also fled communism.

It’s not that poor people don’t want to save and invest; it’s that because cost of living in most places has far outpaced salaries, there literally is no money to save.

Most Americans live under mountains of debt. My mother had thousands and thousands of dollars in credit card bills because she had to, in order to survive and support a family of four. And we lived in the projects in Brooklyn.

She never told me about it until I was in my twenties, because she never wanted to worry me with it, and moreover, she never wanted me to know we were poor. Pride is a real thing.

Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:01AM (#37106567)
This assumes one can afford multiple failures. Being born rich buys you a lot of swings of the bat. Otherwise you can't swing big, and opportunities to connect will be fewer--if any.

Rich kids can afford 'responsibility' because they have money to pay for their mistakes. Poor kids don't.

Best way to be prepared for success? Be born to a rich and well connected family.

Re:The Carrot Problem by CMCDragonkai on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:05AM (#37106585)
How did their parents get rich? Was it because the grandparents was rich?
Re:The Carrot Problem by interroboink on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:38AM (#37106730)
I think in many cases when you trace it back, it comes down to ... luck (:

Which is funny, since now the descendants of some lucky people get the opportunity to take lots of chances and say "look how hard work pays off — I made my own luck!"

Though that's a pretty simplistic take; I feel like hard work really does pay off, broadly speaking, but also luck plays a (much) bigger role than most give it credit.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:04AM (#37106857)
Luck will never find the person living in his mom's basement playing video games and griping about inequity.
Re:The Carrot Problem by wizofaus on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:23AM (#37106931)
Given the number of possible alternative realities they could have been born into it, I'd strongly suggest luck has already found such people. It's even possible had they not been born into such an easy existence they might have ultimately done better for themselves ("possible", not likely).
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:19AM (#37106918)
That you cite this as the alternative shows the limits of your perspective.
Re:The Carrot Problem by anon4242 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:02AM (#37110130)
I think you miss the point. I believe the point is if you don't try then luck won't help you. Or in other words you can't win the lottery if you don't buy a ticket.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:50AM (#37110548)
I think you missed my point. All of the trying in the world isn't going to replace the luck that's required for most people to succeed-- be it being born white and in a middle-class or better household in a middle-class-or-better town, not being sidled with familial or health obligations, or even being born with a cognitive profile that has workplace utility. Being comfortable enough to live with a parent and be lazy is already a privilege that a giant chunk of the US population doesn't have. Nobody is arguing that people born into opportune circumstances can succeed without doing anything. They just have the opportunity to make that effort turn into significant results when many others don't.
Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:37AM (#37110929)
Tickets are expensive, most people cannot afford more than one. Many are born into debt they have little hope of escaping, much less buying tickets.

Those born wealthy can often buy so many tickets it's virtually guaranteed they'll stumble into something that works, at least once.

No one is saying people don't have to at least lift a finger to try. Just that birth luck affords so many other opportunities that the advice of outliers and the born comfortable isn't transferable.

Re:The Carrot Problem by CMCDragonkai on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:20PM (#37140621)
I was pointing out the circular logic in these explanations. Saying someone is rich because their parents were rich (ad-infinitum) is like saying someone is lucky because they are lucky. It is not a useful explanation because you can't use this to do anything. In fact if you use this explanation to decide public policy, like say socialism, then the converse is also true, you make everybody poor, then their descendants will be poor. But obviously in our history on average, we've all been getting richer in the long run.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:59AM (#37106842)
"Entrepreneurs come from families with money"

https://fortune.com/2015/07/17/entrepreneurs-family-money/

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:07AM (#37106870)
Basically none of the rich people I know came from more than middle class parents. A couple came to America with nothing but a suitcase.
Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:22AM (#37109791)
Depends on your circle. So probably not a representative sample. If you live in SoCal there's probably some clustering of survivorship bias.

Of all the people rich today -- or ever -- how many started middle or lower class?

How many came to America with nothing and died, barely survived, went to jail, got deported, peaked at lower middle class, etc.?

If I know a lot of plane crash survivors I still would not recommend getting on an unsafe plane. (I actually only know one crash survivor and would not get on a small plane unless it's a life or death emergency.)

Re:The Carrot Problem by 2devnull on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:18AM (#37110786)
This seems like something that’s changed in recent decades, as would be predicted of course. Most of the older rich people I know were not from upper class homes. Younger rich people (born after 1990) seem to come predominantly from upper middle class and higher. Anecdotal but I’d wager roughly consistent with national trends.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:32AM (#37110895)
Nearly 100% of the rich people I know had family money. Living expenses now take up a very different amount of people's income than they did before. The skills you need to get a leg up now are very different than they used to be, even in recent history. Anecdata is useless.
Re:The Carrot Problem by speleding on Sunday August 13, 2023 @08:04AM (#37109111)
I know several very successful entrepreneurs and I know quite a few people with rich parents. I don't see much of a correlation.

In my perception many of the rich kids lack the drive to work as hard as you need to, to become a successful entrepreneur, instead opting for a safer route. Granted, if you are from a really poor background and live in the US without much of a social safety net, I could see how that could hamper your prospects, but that's hardly a problem where I'm from.

Re:The Carrot Problem by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:30AM (#37109871)
Most people are lazy, rich kids already don't have to work. So if they happen to be driven enough to try they can take on many more risks and start more businesses.

If you're surrounded by entrepreneurs (such as SV) it's not a representative sample. Even being born "middle class" is a narrow slice of humanity today, much less everyone ever born.

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @11:31AM (#37110887)
As of 2019, to be in the financial top 10%, you needed a HOUSEHOLD income of just over 155k. I think that many around here are so utterly out-of-touch with the lives of most people in the US that they can't even reason about the blocks they have to advancement.
Re:The Carrot Problem by interroboink on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:28AM (#37106671)
> they can still fail

>> Of course. I never wrote otherwise.

I did not mean to imply that you did (:

You touched on a general topic, and I was speaking to that, more than your specific words.

> successful people ... blamed themselves for the failures

I'm sure that's true. But I'm trying to draw a thin, wiggly line between awareness of room for improvement (usually more on a rational level), and blame/judgement (usually more on an emotional level). The former is great, the latter not so much.

I'd wager that there are also a whole lot of un-successful people who blamed themselves for their failures, even if they could do no better. People who hate themselves. People who are unhappy. My commentary is more directed at those people and those who would care about them, than the ones you mention.

> taking responsibility ... you can succeed by learning

This definitely straddles the wiggly line (: One one side is "taking responsibility," and on the other is "it's your fault."

Certainly one should internalize the lesson. But hopefully not the shame/blame. Perhaps neither you nor your successful acquaintences suffer from this affliction, but in my experience many do.

I realize that some people are lazy and looking for excuses to escape responsibility, so perhaps you see my viewpoint as somehow enabling or encouraging that bad behavior. I just want to point out that there are downsides in the other direction too, if taken to puritanical extremes. And I daresay the "being lazy is bad" side of the argument gets a whole lot more headspace in our culture than the "it's okay, there's nothing wrong with you" side. Hence my attempt to bring some balance.

> You could consider it like airliners ...

> ride a bike the first time ...

The thing about airlines is that they operate in a very carefully crafted environment. Planes stay away from each other, are generally aware of each other (notwithstanding that friggin' biplane without a radio that cut me off on downwind... grr), have high maintenance standards, etc. etc. Real life can be much more dense/messy/fast-moving/full of unknowns, I find. You do not always get the luxury of knowing the variables involved.

But the problem with both of your examples is that they assume you can learn and try again. And that's not always the case.

What if you're a passenger on one of those airliners that crashes? What should you have done better, personally?

Born in a poor country? Sorry, no re-try.

Born with a damaged brain or body? Sorry, no re-try.

Have abusive parents? Maybe a few can pull themselves out (probably mostly by luck or the help of others), but it will have lifelong effects.

You get the idea. And those examples are extreme; there are myriad other "softer" struggles people have, with varying levels of control. Depression comes to mind.

So, in conclusion, my whole long-winded reply is just trying to say: sometimes people (like you) express the "you have nobody to blame but yourself" attitude, with good intentions, directed at the sort of enabled people you were talking about, but it gets applied to other people, with heart-wrenching effects.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:52AM (#37106805)
> The thing about airlines is that they operate in a very carefully crafted environment.

They do now, as the consequence of many crashes.

> And that's not always the case

I liken this as "humans have two legs" and the riposte is "not all humans have two legs". Notice the requirement to insert a missing word, "all". I hope you'll forgive me, because I am rather testy about this sort of waste of time. If I mean "always" or "all" or "100%" I would use those qualifiers. Those qualifiers exist for a reason.

> Born with a damaged brain or body?

Oh criminy. I shouldn't have to add that if you're mentally deranged none of this applies. In fact, I believe I even wrote somewhere here "of sound mind and body" because I know somebody would pipe up with "not everybody likes ice cream".

Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:21AM (#37106926)
You have no idea how much you have going for you that you didn't have to work for.
Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:52AM (#37107309)
I do not have any advantages the vast bulk of Americans do not also have.
Re:The Carrot Problem by chefandy on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:49AM (#37109009)
"Are Greg and Emily More Employable Than Lakisha And Jamal"

5000 job applications with evenly weighted resumes randomly paired with names more commonly given to white children and names more commonly given to Black children. The "White" applicants were FIFTY PERCENT more likely to get a callback.

https://www.nber.org/papers/w9873

Here's one from Georgetown that follows performance disparity and wealth, with marked differences appearing in kindergarten.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/23780231198317...

Here's an article from the fed discussing a study that shows the average white family has just under 5x more assets than your average Black family, and crucially, that intergenerational wealth doesn't play a big role in that:

https://www.bostonfed.org/news-and-events/news/2023/03/bosto....

There is so much more empirical proof that the US simply is not a meritocracy. You must be deliberately shielding yourself from it or astonishingly naive to think otherwise.

Re:The Carrot Problem by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:59PM (#37111740)
The business I started in the 1980s was mail order and nobody knew my name, color, background, religion, sex, etc.

Today, with the internet, nobody needs to know anything about you for you to run a successful business.

You seem to require that I must be born wealthy. I was born on an Air Force base and spent many years living in base housing. If you're from a military family, you know that ain't wealthy and ain't the path to wealth.

My father grew up in the Depression, and his father apologized profusely to him for asking for a portion of the money my father made collecting scrap so he could buy food. My mother lost everything (and I mean everything) in WW2.

I've posted before about wealthy friends who came to America with a suitcase.

The idea you must be born into wealth in order to be successful in America is simply false. I know too many wealthy people (including Blacks and women) who demonstrate otherwise.

Here's a recipe to move from poverty to the middle class:

1. don't do drugs

2. don't do crimes

3. stay in school

4. learn what the school provides

5. get a loan for college

6. go to college, pick a major that pays well, learn the material rather than cheat

It's a pretty good default strategy. It doesn't take any miracles or unusual effort.

> astonishingly naive to think otherwise

Maybe you should tell that to the millions of poor people attempting to get into the US.

Re:The Carrot Problem by interroboink on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:11AM (#37107150)
I think I am talking past you in some way; sorry about that.

I am not trying to play word games or pull "gotchas" on your phrasing. I think I have a straightforward underlying message; I hope you can hear it through my imprecise miasma of words.

Maybe you already heard it, but are only replying to the remaining small tidbits you object to; I'm unsure.

In truth, I have a similar frustration, where I feel the fragmentary quotations of mine you reply to do not give justice to the larger context in which they were written. But I don't hold it against you; I know that struggle.

Anyway, one more attempt:

You presented some simple advice ("It's not about working hard. It's about working smart."), and as mentioned I don't disagree with it per se.

But in my life, I have seen that advice used "for evil", if you will. (I do not mean to imply that you intend it that way, of course).

And in particular, I do find that people giving and following that advice are often either willfully or ignorantly (more often the latter) blind to the downsides that can go along with it — vis-a-vis empathy towards others, for instance. Of course, I do not mean to imply that you are blind to it. I don't know you.

So, I hoped to give some voice to that other perspective, is all. I find it to be under-represented, in discussions like these. Hugely so.

----

Re: humans having two legs: I truly am not sure if you are messing with me, or if I really failed to deliver my idea so totally. I swear I don't mind if it's the former, though I feel it is the latter (: Help me improve my communications protocol?

I thought our sequence went something like this:

you: work hard and learn from your mistakes

me: agreed. but also, beware of assigning blame for misfortune

you: here are some examples of how learning from mistakes is useful/empowering [airliners, bikes]

me: yes, and here are some examples of misfortune that's not blame-worthy [unlucky birth, etc.]

you: my examples were not meant to be all-encompassing [humans have two legs]

me: ???

Actually, writing it out maybe makes it more clear. Perhaps you feel I was disagreeing with your initial advice, and trying to counter it somehow. But rather, I am trying to add something to it; draw a bigger circle around everything on the Venn diagram, so to speak. Not cross yours out.

Re:The Carrot Problem by kimburgess on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:00AM (#37107678)
A big caveat is #4 should read "be willing and able to take risks". If you're not living in country with a social safety net or have the resources to self-support failure, risk taking is simply not an option.
Re:The Carrot Problem by Niksko on Sunday August 13, 2023 @06:12AM (#37108437)
Not just #4, all of them

It's much easier to do prep work when you have a social safety net to keep you clothed, housed and fed while you're prepping.

It's much easier to place yourself in a situation where the opportunity can find you if you know that if opportunity doesn't find you, you'll be ok.

It's much easier to take a gamble that a bunch of hard work will lead to a fantastic opportunity if the cost of it not leading to an opportunity is very low.