Re:The Carrot Problem
by WalterBright on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:07AM
(#37106870)
Basically none of the rich people I know came from more than middle class parents. A couple came to America with nothing but a suitcase.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Carrot Problem
by paulryanrogers on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:22AM
(#37109791)
Depends on your circle. So probably not a representative sample. If you live in SoCal there's probably some clustering of survivorship bias.
Of all the people rich today -- or ever -- how many started middle or lower class?
How many came to America with nothing and died, barely survived, went to jail, got deported, peaked at lower middle class, etc.?
If I know a lot of plane crash survivors I still would not recommend getting on an unsafe plane. (I actually only know one crash survivor and would not get on a small plane unless it's a life or death emergency.)
This seems like something that’s changed in recent decades, as would be predicted of course. Most of the older rich people I know were not from upper class homes. Younger rich people (born after 1990) seem to come predominantly from upper middle class and higher. Anecdotal but I’d wager roughly consistent with national trends.
Nearly 100% of the rich people I know had family money. Living expenses now take up a very different amount of people's income than they did before. The skills you need to get a leg up now are very different than they used to be, even in recent history. Anecdata is useless.