News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by presidentender on Thursday August 10, 2023 @09:27AM (#37075888)
My mom was a hoarder. She'd buy all the pants at the thrift store that fit my brother and me, because it was hard to find pants the right size. She kept stacks of egg cartons for art projects. She rescued dozens of animals, who peed on the abundant pants.

She bought multiple Saabs when I got my driver's license, because they have good crash survival ratings. She bought damaged vehicles at auction so the neighbors could repair and sell them. So there were just a bunch of busted cars on the property.

Once when I was a kid Dad tried to clean. She begged him not to throw away a small screwdriver, saying "it's my friend."

Nobody was allowed to come over because the state of the house and the property were so disgusting.

I'm not a psychiatrist, but for her it seemed to be a combination of totally absent executive function, emotional attachment to inanimate objects (to which she ascribed feelings of their own), and a desire to have a stockpile from which to provide. Add to that the happy side effect of protecting all of us from visitors and the massive inertia of the hoard that made it impractical to clean up even when she was lucid, and you've got an effectively permanent state of being.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Pet_Ant on Thursday August 10, 2023 @10:55AM (#37076944)
> emotional attachment to inanimate objects (to which she ascribed feelings of their own)

This I have heard is a common element amongst hoarders and observed it in a hoarding family member as well. Throwing things out was like killing a pet in front of them.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by FeteCommuniste on Thursday August 10, 2023 @10:58AM (#37076994)
Not a hoarder but I do feel a little twinge in my heart if I see someone throw away plush toys or other things with faces. :-)
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by vikingerik on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:11AM (#37077167)
I get that feeling in thrift stores, where those items show up sometimes. I always wonder what the history was. Was that some child's favorite plush and how did it end up in a thrift shop, or was it overlooked and unwanted and discarded? Either way it's a twinge of sadness, yeah.

Even as an adult, I still have my few favorite stuffies from childhood. I'd never part with them (it's not hoarding, just one box), but I have no idea what happens to them when I pass on. Can't bear to dispose of them or leave instructions for that, but for anyone else to keep them they'd just take up space forever.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by mc32 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:55AM (#37077805)
It seems that that is appropriate. We ought to have some attachment, but also be able to rationalize and supersede emotions in order to qualify some things and then be able to say, this has little utility for me, it's time to move on. With an absence or suspension of emotion we could just become consumers who consume and dispose like a swarm of locusts.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Roark66 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:28PM (#37078260)
>Not a hoarder but I do feel a little twinge in my heart if I see someone throw away plush toys or other things with faces. :-)

Interesting, I get the same, but for electronics/anything mechanical. Also the longer I have some device the more attached I get to it.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Obscurity4340 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @02:24PM (#37079849)
Ever seen that Ikea commericial with the rejected lamp?
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by caseyohara on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:22PM (#37080561)
I love that ad. It was directed by Spike Jonze, which is very fitting.

"Many of you feel bad for this lamp. That is because you're crazy; it has no feelings! And the new one is much better."

Here's the 2002 original and 2018 redux: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecTUnfHyj8k

More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamp_(advertisement)

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by SamPatt on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:06PM (#37081069)
I have computers from the 90s which I will almost certainly never touch again, but they played such a big role in my young life I can't seem to toss them.

I keep thinking I'll boot them back up one day and show my kids.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by npunt on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:45PM (#37081543)
Same. I think it's pretty normal to want to go back and visit the physical locations of our youth to relive the memories, but if the environments we grew up in were digital we lack a tangible memory to return to, so a substitute is holding onto the systems themselves.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by pavel_lishin on Thursday August 10, 2023 @02:41PM (#37080046)
I'm not a hoarder... I hope... but I definitely feel this. Whenever I have to throw something away, I have to explicitly ignore that little emotional twinge, as well as that voice inside my head that says, "... you can use this for something."

If that emotional twinge were too much stronger, or if that voice was too much louder, I'd be in real trouble.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by kulahan on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:37PM (#37080723)
I know I was close to having a hoarding disorder because I feel this way. I get a new appliance or whatever, and I feel bad that what I'm replacing is going away. It's like losing a member of the team.

Anyways, I forced myself to get used to throwing stuff away because I saw where it was going and got freaked out. Maybe I would've been a really minor case had I not tried to intervene at all, if such cases exist.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by hungryforcodes on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:00AM (#37077034)
I nominate your post for this years Nobel prize in literature. That's a pretty epic description of your mom's situation.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by hungryforcodes on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:12AM (#37077190)
Not sure why the downvotes. It was not sarcastic.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by w0de0 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:27AM (#37077399)
The flavor of Reddit in the humor. “Epic.”
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Solvency on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:41AM (#37077628)
Would it be more HN appropriate had he said "your writing helped me grok your mom's disorder?"
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by burnished on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:00PM (#37077882)
Genuinely, yes, I think that would have been better understood written that way here.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by tifik on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:26AM (#37077385)
It's a tad insensitive, and I just plain disagree.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by gumby on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:15PM (#37078086)
I know you're "not supposed" to comment on downvotes but I found your comment useful -- the comment was fine, and still grey, so I upvoted it.

It is true that some earnest comments can innocently be read as sarcastic.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by anon84873628 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:24PM (#37078211)
Comparing a few paragraphs of HN comment to the Nobel prize in literature is just bizarre. I'm not surprised people assumed it must be sarcastic. Or if you put that aside, then it seems to disparage the Nobel prize. It's just such a hyperbolic claim without any rhetorical purpose and doesn't make any sense. I'm happy the commenter was so moved though...
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Qem on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:33PM (#37078328)
The Nobel prize self disparaged when they gave the Peace one to a guy that later went to bomb seven countries: https://theintercept.com/2014/09/23/nobel-peace-prize-fact-d...
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by nick-of-time on Thursday August 10, 2023 @05:02PM (#37081746)
Long, long before that, when they gave it to a guy who intentionally prolonged the Vietnam War and ordered the bombing of civilians in a country not even involved in the war. https://12ft.io/proxy?&q=https%3A%2F%2Ftheintercept.com%2F20...
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by atlantic on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:10AM (#37077150)
Thanks for that. My Mum was almost the exact opposite to yours, but there seems to be no name for her ailment. She would move house once a year, and she would throw away a large part of everything we owned with every move. In the new house, we would often live amongst piles of cardboard boxes that never got around to being unpacked. While my Dad was alive, the books endured, but on his demise they got thrown out too. And obviously, our social circle did not survive frequent relocation.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Solvency on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:21AM (#37077302)
While alive what was your dads role in this annual process? Surely he was involved in the decision/move/lifestyle?
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by rambojohnson on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:13PM (#37078058)
why would anyone want to dive into such a sensitive topic on a public forum? mind your manners.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Solvency on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:18PM (#37078122)
What? Mind my manners? The GP offered their personal anecdote in a thread of vulnerable hoarding stories. I had parents who were equally complicit in their afflictions and I'm genuinely curious about unilateral situations.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by jychang on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:57PM (#37081680)
This is PRECISELY the type of thing that should be discussed in anonymous public forums, with the consent of the person and with neutral questions not for the sake of shaming the person who’s talking.

Growth of issues in society should not be relegated to whispers in back rooms, the way baby boomers do it. That’s how you hamper scientific progress for psychology. How can people investigate an issue if it’s hidden from view? Bringing light to issues for society allows them to be solved as people understand it better.

Shame on you for perpetuating toxic behavior that shames people for looking for insight into our world.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by atlantic on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:18PM (#37078121)
Ok, good question.

He was uncritically supportive, as my mother found fault with each new apartment or neighbourhood, making up reasons to move again. He also accepted her reasons for moving us to yet another school. And he obviously financed this very expensive habit, so there was never much left over for clothes or anything recreational.

The only condition was that his routine would remain undisturbed, and he wouldn't help in any way. So for example, he'd have all his breakfast gear at the ready in the new house, amongst the piles of boxes, from the first morning. And go to work as usual.

Other than that very large elephant in the room, they were great parents, no complaints.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by xur17 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:49PM (#37080855)
> The only condition was that his routine would remain undisturbed, and he wouldn't help in any way. So for example, he'd have all his breakfast gear at the ready in the new house, amongst the piles of boxes, from the first morning. And go to work as usual.

I shouldn't laugh, but I'm just picturing your dad sitting amongst the chaos casually eating his breakfast cereal totally unphased by it all.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by atlantic on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:49PM (#37082710)
If the furniture was still piled up, there'd be a folding table and chair for him, in an open space between the piles of boxes.

He'd have his own milk and pot, coffee and filters, toaster, breadboard, breadknife, butterknife, teaspoon and mug. He was a very generous man, but these objects he didn't share.

The breakfast ritual took several hours, and involved a Swedish exercise routine near an open window, interspersed with reading the news and breakfast itself. The reading was not strictly passive, as it involved marking various articles with a thick red pencil, and then cutting them out, folding the cuttings, and saving a select few into his wallet for later reading.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by clove on Thursday August 10, 2023 @07:51PM (#37083275)
Seems to have had some healthy habits and a positive mindset, so...

What led to his death?

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by jstarfish on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:54PM (#37080929)
Thanks for sharing! Your account is disturbingly relatable. Even:

> The only condition was that his routine would remain undisturbed, and he wouldn't help in any way.

This is totally where I'm at. I can't keep up with the churn and refuse to facilitate it anymore. I started to suspect a disorder of some kind once moving countries altogether became the new goal, but outside of cults moving around to sever family/community ties I've never even heard of this being a thing before. I know I will kill myself if this started up again after going to that much trouble.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by AnimalMuppet on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:00PM (#37080997)
> I know I will kill myself if this started up again after going to that much trouble.

I don't know if this is hyperbole, or an actual assessment of the situation you're in, but... please don't. Get out if you have to, but don't get out that way.

Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by jstarfish on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:21PM (#37081235)
I appreciate your concern, but it's an assessment of a prospective situation I'd be putting myself in. I figure it's best to avoid it rather than test my resilience.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by helsinkiandrew on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:23AM (#37077336)
Not a doctor, but is that a form of Obsessive-compulsive disorder?
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by bell-cot on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:51PM (#37078574)
Reading the first comment, then your reply - my impression is "The left and right tails of yet another bell curve of human behaviors...either tail of which (if less extreme) could be highly adoptive in many situations."
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by Obscurity4340 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @02:22PM (#37079817)
Do you mean adaptive or am I missing something ?
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by ke88y on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:07PM (#37082385)
Yeah, I think he does mean adaptive. The point is that -- although the behaviors are certainly mal-adaptive in resource-rich stable countries -- they might actually be highly adaptive in other situations.
Re:What’s causing the rise of hoarding disorder? by BeFlatXIII on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:58PM (#37080970)
> totally absent executive function, emotional attachment to inanimate objects, and a desire to have a stockpile from which to provide

Fuck me. I have all 3 of those warning signs. At least the emotional attachment isn't strong for most things and can be shaken with a well-placed "Will you realistically ever get around to that?"