News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by LikelyABurner on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:30AM (#37061126)
I’m with the artists on this one. Our obsession with converting everything into input for an algorithm that spits out an ill-defined number (what the hell is “vividness”?) needs to stop.

We already tried this with human communication and gave birth to the dystopian nightmare that is social media, why keep repeating our mistakes?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Nullabillity on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:38AM (#37061178)
Honestly, this is the really offensive part of the article. Who cares about whether or not it's legal, the idea that it's, in any way, shape, or form, useful is bafflingly laughable.

Not everything can be meaningfully quantified. Not everything needs to be.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by capableweb on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:42AM (#37061209)
> Not everything can be meaningfully quantified. Not everything needs to be.

Ok, so who decides what's OK to analyze or not? Is there some obvious moral line I fail to see, that everyone would immediately agree on?

It seems the project was about analyzing books, not about producing new books. How is that hurting the authors?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by LikelyABurner on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:51AM (#37061286)
What will hurt artists is, when in 10 years, all publishers are demanding that the vividness score (TM) be at least a 95% “because that’s what drives sales”.

Which is what will happen if the authors don’t proactively stop it from happening. Look at how the music industry has evolved over time.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by croes on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:35AM (#37061713)
How his this different from all the vampire novels that hit the shelf after the success of Twilight? Publishers alway preferred the money makers, just the measure changed.

Nowadays writers can at least publish their books without the need of publishers and I think some like the help of the bad Silicon valley stuff that made writing, publishing and interacting with the readers easier.

I'm on your site if it's about automatic content creation and style copying but text analysis is not the real danger. Especially when the usefulness of such statistics isn't even given.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by nottorp on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:24AM (#37063131)
> publish their books without the need of publishers

Except those are very likely to be metoo vampire novels. And lately LLM generated.

I'd move that on the contrary, the role of the publisher as a curator will only become more important in the future.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by croes on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:30AM (#37063254)
But publishers will have to deal with a lot more content thanks to LLMs.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by runj__ on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:57AM (#37061327)
Or it could help me find terser books I like, people will still have preferences and if the author tries to pander to only the largest market segment I'd argue that's on them.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by jprete on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:15AM (#37061492)
I think it’s much more likely you would get the book equivalent of crap SEO sites spammed out to satisfy numerical measures of quality.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by robertlagrant on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:00AM (#37061356)
How is this different to the current process, other than feedback is slower (if forthcoming at all) and less specific?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:22AM (#37061568)
> How is this different to the current process, other than feedback is slower (if forthcoming at all) and less specific?

Let me rephrase your question: "how is it different to the current process, other than <the fact that it is different>?" :-). I would say that the answer lies in the question.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by robertlagrant on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:50AM (#37061870)
Sounds as though your view of the AI is purely positive, in that case. That's fair enough. The answer for other people may well not lie in the question (e.g. for all the people who don't like this development), but it did for you!
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:05AM (#37062062)
Sorry I did not understand that :-).

My point was that it is different: when humans read a book, they don't train a machine learning model. They can't read as many books as a machine, at the same speed, and they can't remember nearly as much as what a machine can.

Humans and computers are fundamentally different, and it matters. You can't conclude that because it works for one, it will fork for the other.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by robertlagrant on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:01PM (#37064667)
> Sorry I did not understand that :-)

You seemed to be saying that the differences I listed (quicker and more specific feedback) were the only differences. Those are both positive.

I was saying that some people may think there are negative differences as well.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:13PM (#37064854)
Right. Yeah I did not express myself clearly, sorry :). You were saying "how is it different other than X and Y?", and I wanted to say that X and Y are already enough for me to consider them different.

I am actually on the side that LLMs are a big problem for copyright, and I don't want my code and blog posts to be used in their training dataset without my consent. To me, at this scale, it's not fair use. IMO it's a bit like if Facebook said that it is fair use to leverage metadata about their users, because "someone who sees you in a public space talking to a friend knows that you are talking with that person, and it is the same for Facebook on social media". My problem is not that Facebook knows that I sent a message to a friend now, but rather that they know who writes to whom and when, at scale.

Similarly my problem is not that somebody could read my blog post, learn from it, and write another blog post. My problem is that LLMs automatically train on all written material they want on the Internet, at scale, and without acknowledging that all that material has a lot of value (and is copyrighted).

I think fair use should somehow consider the scale.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by em-bee on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:57AM (#37061965)
the difference is that an machine analysis is necessarily limited and can't account for all the factors that make a text interesting. so it is possible that this analysis rejects texts that would not be rejected by a human.

it is objective but potentially biased. and it could even be discriminating if the input for this tool isn't diverse enough. but these are the issues that can go wrong with any use of technology, and we have seen many examples of that happening. however i don't think that is problematic if writers use it to analyse their own texts in comparison. it is however a serious issue if publishers use it to decide what to accept

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Nullabillity on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:56AM (#37061324)
Again, I don't particularly care about whether this is allowed to exist, I'm just here to laugh at the mindset that lead to it being created. But sure, I can see this being used in harmful ways.

> It seems the project was about analyzing books, not about producing new books. How is that hurting the authors?

"Vivid books are really in this year, we're gonna have to ask that you aim for a Vividness(tm) of 85 or above."

"US books have 15% more adjectives, clearly this is proof of our superior detail-oriented work ethic!"

"What does the rise in Emotion(tm) have to say about the decline of society?"

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by capableweb on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:53AM (#37061905)
So if I understand you correctly, you're saying that we should not create "metrics" for anything because said metrics could be misused by clueless people?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by runj__ on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:43AM (#37061216)
Certainly something interesting is bound to come out of quantifying things? "Hm, this three act structure thing seems to work, I wonder why." "Children doesn't seem to understand texts which include these words, I wonder why."

Patterns rarely show themselves before we investigate.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Nullabillity on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:06AM (#37061416)
> Certainly something interesting is bound to come out of quantifying things?

In science they call this trap P-hacking. Even data "scientists" know to be wary of overfitting. We're really good at finding patterns, but few of them actually mean anything.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by davorak on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:48AM (#37061846)
>> Certainly something interesting is bound to come out of quantifying things?

> In science they call this trap P-hacking. Even data "scientists" know to be wary of overfitting. We're really good at finding patterns, but few of them actually mean anything.

Quantifying things is not always p-hacking. When people do experiments on novel materials or structures they quantify the data, make readings and record them, and then look for patterns. For example measuring the electronic properties of a new novel nano structure or molecule.

When I think of p-hacking[1] I think of using the same static data and doing various data analysis over and over again until something potentially interesting is found and ignoring the risks of false positives as you do so.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_dredging

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by dmurray on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:55AM (#37061312)
The analysis is cool. The problematic thing is what would have happened next, if this tool turned out to be any good.

Publishers rejecting manuscripts because "this years trend shows customers are looking for vividness in the 70+ percentile, your book is only at 55". Everything becoming the same style. If you thought Hemingway, Joyce or Nabokov had it bad with rejections, there'd be zero chance for actual innovative writing to break through the walls of The Algorithm.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by fullspectrumdev on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:24PM (#37065885)
Joyce should have had more rejections, but that’s just my personal opinion
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by TheCoreh on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:30AM (#37061650)
> Not everything can be meaningfully quantified.

Sure, but written words _can_ be meaningfully quantified. We have been doing that for thousands of years. Starting with numerology and other mystical/religious beliefs, poem metrics, stylometry, crypto analysis, stroke counting, to name a few.

> Not everything needs to be.

Why not?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by pikahumu on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:41AM (#37061763)
If you don't find it useful, don't use it. But why get outraged about something that others find useful? It's clearly a tool that other writers were positive and excited about. Why not let them have it? If you don't find those quantifications meaningful, so be it. You don't need to use it. Why force your opinion on others?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by r053bud on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:34AM (#37063312)
Simple. Just allow an opt-out for Authors or Publishers. Then only interested parties will comprise of and make use of the service, like you want.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by andybak on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @11:19AM (#37064049)
> Honestly, this is the really offensive part of the article.

I would argue that "Offensive" is either hyperbolic or you've used the wrong word.

> the idea that it's, in any way, shape, or form, useful is bafflingly laughable.

I don't know if it's useful because I never tried it. I might harbour my doubts but I'd like to find out. This is how I approach new things.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by thendrill on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:37AM (#37061175)
Well... We still can not agree if...

Technology has to be protected from dumb people, or is it worth protecting dumb people from technology....

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by jprete on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:42AM (#37061208)
What do you even mean by this comment? Have you considered the possibility that people are smart in ways that you are not considering, rather than just labeling it “dumb”?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by s1mplicissimus on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:50AM (#37061278)
Have you considered ... in ways that you are not considering...?

I am pretty confident they haven't. Sounds like you've set yourself up for a reverse "true scotsman" here ;)

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by jprete on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:17AM (#37061507)
Nice catch, thanks for pointing it out.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by LikelyABurner on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:46AM (#37061241)
If anything, it’s the smart people that need to be protected from technology, because Silicon Valley is obsessed with pulling them down into a Harrison Bergeron nightmare where they’re absorbed into the same modeled probability distribution as the rest of the population to better sell them ads (outliers are bad for profits.)
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:53AM (#37061299)
That's silly. Humans review books all the time, using very similar words. Where's the outrage over that?

This is manufactured, stretched, overhyped objections. I believe it's all as the OP suggests, because the word AI is in there. Not because anything illegal or immoral is going on. In fact it's a terribly useful tool, and once the mob cools off it'll likely return.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by LikelyABurner on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#37061366)
You are exactly modeling the chauvinistic Silicon Valley attitude that is causing the outrage in the general population to begin with.

“Our algorithms are pretty much the same as human art criticism, so put down the pitchforks you unenlightened scum” is up there with telling them to eat (a Stable Diffusion generated picture of) cake.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by pikahumu on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:38AM (#37061742)
> You are exactly modeling the chauvinistic Silicon Valley attitude that is causing the outrage in the general population to begin with.

Just like the writers he talked to and got positive feedback? Everybody not agreeing with you represents "chauvinistic SV attitude"?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Riverheart on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:49AM (#37061856)
(Edited)

No, he didn’t say anything about them. People side against their interests all the time, finding a few writers that like this is trivial. Are those people the majority opinion on this or are we just trying to prove how wonderful this technology is?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by pikahumu on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:04AM (#37062048)
I'm assuming you read the article.

Let's recap:

> I launched the prosecraft website in the summer of 2017, and I started showing it off to authors at writers conferences. The response was universally positive, and I incorporated the prosecraft analytic tools into the Shaxpir desktop application [...]

And he goes on mentioning that some authors even reached out to him to get their books added.

Unless you are accusing him of lying or unreasonably overstating the response he got ("universally positive"), for which I really don't see any indication, then a statement like "finding a few writers that like this is trivial" is not a good faith engagement with this topic/conversation.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Riverheart on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:31AM (#37063276)
There’s no way to qualify the sample size of writers based on his claims so within the bubble of his experience I’m sure it’s correct but not useful to base an argument on that writers at large are onboard with this and as for good faith engagement your response to parent…

“Everybody not agreeing with you represents "chauvinistic SV attitude"?”

…wasn’t very good faith either as it’s unclear whether the writers share the same belief as some tech people that AI and humans doing stuff are the same and use that idea to further a pro AI agenda as opposed to them just finding a useful tool to incorporate into their workflow regardless of the underlying technology or politics. Your response assumed the former and paints OP and attacking them with his statement.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Chris2048 on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:15AM (#37061490)
People starved while it was suggested they eat cake. Not sure how that relates - are the rights around art crit not the same as AI crit?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by jhbadger on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:39AM (#37062480)
Of course they never were suggested to eat cake in reality. 1) The actual French quote was to brioche, a type of bread and mistranslated as cake because brioche wasn't common in English-speaking countries 2) Was never an actual suggestion -- the French philosopher Rousseau was making a sarcastic remark suggesting that if the people didn't have bread, they should eat brioche (a fancier kind of bread) instead. But for some reason in pop culture this was falsely transformed into an actual suggestion by Marie Antoinette
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by rockemsockem on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:42PM (#37066146)
Glad to see someone else mention the falsehood of the original quote.

It's actually really fitting to see that (mis-)quote used in the context of this outrage since from reading through the original vitriolic Twitter thread it's clear that many of the most outraged are incorrect about what the product does.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Chris2048 on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:51PM (#37092387)
IT doesn't really matter to the idiom - what is understood by the reference is what it means.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by melagonster on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:52AM (#37061888)
or talking about human "just another matrix", so how dare them don't want to offer their artwork for new models.

this even didn't contain how developers decided to let people lose job. people is angry because they worried about losing job.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by wink on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:56AM (#37061950)
Counting the ratio of nouns to verbs in a novel is an algorithm and I think it's like one of the most basic examples of what the thing in the article does, if I understood it correctly.

But I guess there would also be people up in arms about this.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by avgcorrection on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:11AM (#37062143)
Or AI-generated Soylent.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by mardifoufs on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:16AM (#37062204)
There's no outrage in the general population. Just of a minority that is just as small as silicon valley.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Nasrudith on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:00PM (#37064658)
Do you even know the meaning of chauvinism? Because this is literally the opposite of chauvinism. They aren't stating their view is superior, they just want it to exist.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:13AM (#37061477)
> That's silly. Humans review books all the time, using very similar words. Where's the outrage over that?

Easy: humans are not machines. "X does it all the time, so I should be able to do it" is never a valid conclusion. It depends on the situation.

> In fact it's a terribly useful tool, and once the mob cools off it'll likely return.

Maybe this tool in particular does not "abuse" the books. Maybe this tool in particular is terribly useful. But you can't blame authors and artists for taking a stance against those new algorithms that provably have the potential to automatically "steal" from their work. You can believe that asking ChatGPT to "write a novel in the style of X" is not abusing the copyright, that's fine. And the authors can answer that they fear it has the potential to break their source of revenue to a point where they won't want to publish anything anymore. And they are entitled to it. And maybe someday we come up with licenses that prevent the use as training data (how in the world could one conclude today that "it is most definitely fair use", given that this is a very new way of using IP material?).

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:32AM (#37061671)
That was the accusation, and it was misplaced here. So we agree, this is a smear campaign in this case, not a sensible reaction to a reasonable application of machine algorithms.

The idea that counting adverbs is steal their work to the point they won't want to publish anymore is clearly FUD. As my remark made clear.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:00AM (#37062004)
> The idea that counting adverbs is steal their work to the point they won't want to publish anymore is clearly FUD.

I did not mean that, I am genuinely not sure if you rephrased my point to make it sound wrong or if you missed it.

My point was that, IMO, it does not matter to the other whether counting adverbs is stealing their work or not. Probably if you counted them manually they would be fine (and most likely they were fine before generative AI).

What matters to them is that generative AI is trained from their copyrighted material, and they fear it (I would, too).

The day people stop reading my blog because they can just ask ChatGPT and will get something generated (partly) from my material without any kind of attribution, I can promise you I will stop my blog.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by TimPC on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:14AM (#37062180)
If you want to be a pitchfork mob against generative AI at least understand whether AI is generative or not? Seems like a reasonably low bar. This was non-generative AI, it didn't produce content it output metrics and labelled some existing content.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:41AM (#37062508)
What makes you think that I don't understand whether AI is generative or not? What I said was that for artists who are complaining about their copyright being abused, it does not matter. 10 years ago they were not complaining, because AIs looking like ChatGPT (to users who see it as a black box) did not exist (or were not remotely as powerful).

And I understand that. It is not their job to learn how the black box works. What they see is that "machine learning models" (which they probably call "AI" now), which are complete black boxes to them (and that's justified: engineers who train them also don't know exactly what they do, but rather test their model on some dataset and judge it from there). And those black boxes are being trained from their copyrighted work and have the potential to generate a ton of money which they will never see.

You can go and say "you guys should learn how the technology works instead of complaining", but let's be honest: probably you are not an expert in AI yourself, and anyway why would the artists have to care? It is a totally legit question that they have: "Why can engineers take my copyrighted work, run it through an algorithm that does stuff no algorithm has done in history at a scale never seen before, make money out of it, and not even consider that maybe they are abusing my IP?".

Before dismissing the artists, you should try to understand their point of view.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by skjoldr on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:56AM (#37063675)
> It is not their job to learn how the black box works

If you have not learned the basics of how something works, you have no right for your opinion on it to be considered valid. Period.

Invalid opinions do harm to democracy and endanger our way of life.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @11:14AM (#37063954)
> you have no right for your opinion on it to be considered valid. Period.

That is so wrong it is actually dangerous. Do I need to understand how a nuclear bomb works for my opinion on it to be considered valid? Obviously not. I only need to understand the consequences of it. It does not matter at all how it works, if I am against the fact that it will kill a whole lot of people.

> Invalid opinions do harm to democracy and endanger our way of life.

And engineers have done much, much more to endanger most living animals (including humans) than authors and artists: technology is the reason for the mass extinction we are currently living, and the problems that are coming with climate change. Maybe it's important to start thinking about the consequences of what you do, not only the technicalities of how you do it. And maybe it's high time you start listening to people who are able to think about the consequences of what you do (maybe they understand that better than you do, ever thought of that?), even if they don't know how to do it.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by jsnell on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:32PM (#37065146)
You can of course have any opinion you want. But this is not just about the authors having an opinion. It's about them starting a harassment campaign based on just faulty facts and making no attempt at verifying them.

If we work from the nuclear bomb analogy, you certainly don't need to be a nuclear physicist to protest nuclear bombs. You just need to have some a reasonably correct high level understanding of the impact of a nuclear bomb. But that's not what is happening here. This is more like storming the Belgian embassy to stop Belgium from using their nuclear arsenal to trigger a chain reaction in the atmosphere: totally detached from reality in every aspect.

As far as I can tell from your messages on this, you think that the harassment was entirely justified. Is that correct?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @06:21PM (#37069182)
> totally detached from reality in every aspect.

I don't think it is totally detached from reality. I believe that engineers are generally pretty bad at realizing the impact technology will have on society. There are many concerns with generative AI in general: it can potentially "break the Internet" (by finishing breaking search engines which already struggle with SEO), or maybe democracy, who knows? Copyright is one such problem.

> you think that the harassment was entirely justified. Is that correct?

I honestly don't know how far it went. What I saw in the article is a few authors who wrote online that they wanted their book removed from that software. Not sure if it is closer to harassment or to lobbying.

What I see, however, is many comments of engineers who don't see the problem with copyright and who don't seem to understand why non-engineers may be against this technology, or why one would even think about forbidding a technology ("but technology is neutral"). My point is just that those engineers should maybe take a step back and try to reflect on that "technology is neutral" belief.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by rockemsockem on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:49PM (#37066229)
If you literally have no idea what a nuclear bomb does, i.e. don't know that it explodes, releases massive amounts of heat, or can kill many tens of thousands of people at once, then no your opinion should NOT be considered valid.

Understanding the consequences of something is a PART of how it works. Since you understand that it can kill a whole lot of people then I'd say you have passed the incredibly low bar.

In this case most of the authors do not understand the consequences of the tool, they think it will generate convincing sound text that sounds like them or that it is serving pirated copies of their books (sourcing that from the original Twitter thread that I unfortunately read a lot of).

This doesn't seem like the thread to debate whether technology is a good thing, but I can't help but call this assertion ridiculous. Technology is responsible for almost every single good thing in the world today.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @06:36PM (#37069311)
> In this case most of the authors do not understand the consequences of the tool

Because you do? That's my point: engineers believe that because they have some understanding of how machine learning works (and in my experience, usually it is very limited...), they can conclude that they understand the consequences of it. Simple example: the Facebook "like" function, that was supposed to be positive ("oh nice, I got likes"), and actually increases addiction and is mostly negative ("oh no, why did I not get likes?"). Clearly those who implemented the first likes had not realized what consequences they would have.

> Technology is responsible for almost every single good thing in the world today.

If you have a very limited view of the world, I guess it could be. I like trees, flowers, bees, birds, mountains, snow. Can you tell me which ones come from technology? Let me help you: most of them are threatened to die in this century because of technology. For most living species, every single improvement technology is bad news. To the point where it is now globally becoming bad news for humans, because it's quite likely that we will get into global instability, wars, and famines in the next few decades because of technology. Think about it when we start having billions climate refugees, and think about how you were dismissing opinions contradicting your beliefs based on the fact that you understand some implementation detail.

But let's even ignore the fact that the next few decades will most likely get pretty bad for us. It is true that right now, we live longer, we have more food (and obesity problems), and we can cure many diseases that we could not in the past. Does that mean we are happier? Happier than whom? Vikings? Ancient romans? Ancient greeks? That question seems closer to history and philosophy... why does your opinion count then? Are you historian/philosopher?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by skjoldr on Saturday August 19, 2023 @03:27PM (#37192230)
You cannot know the consequences of something if you do not know how it works. Case in point: nuclear reactors. If you do not know how they work, what are their potential dangers, and how they are mitigated by smart design, you do not have a moral right to protest against them. Simple as. Understanding the risks and consequences equals understanding the system in question. Always. This also applies to nuclear weapons, if you do not understand MAD and how they keep other powers in check, and you never had a true threat brief that would explain what exactly nukes are a deterrent against, you just aren't entitled to an opinion on them. Especially one as simple as "it can kill people so I don't want them". This is an invalid opinion, sorry.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by aaaaarrrrrfffff on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @11:39AM (#37064331)
I would disagree. Just because you don't quite understand something, doesn't mean your concerns are not worth consideration - consider the recent zoom TOS issue. I doubt that many of us have a deep understanding of how that data's being used, or the internal guidelines that zoom follows for its data use, and most people aren't lawyers specializing in IP law to know exactly how the law would treat zoom if they were to accidentally (or "accidentally") leak IP. We just see that they are putting in a clause in their TOS to allow themselves to do so, remember our own heuristics of how LLM have behaved in the past, and understandably start raising questions. For all we know, zoom's AI might be something constrained to a framework which doesn't allow for such data leaks to occur, or it's generative capabilities might be constrained in some other way. They're just demanding legal permission to do so, but that still rubs a lot of us the wrong way. Our concerns are still justified, even if Zoom never actually touches AI. Artists lack as concrete heuristics as the technical crowd. But they still have concerns that need addressing, and those concerns about the effects of AI still should be considered and respected. If the details of the situation don't match their concerns, care should be taken to explain how they don't match to the people in question, in a way that isn't looking down on them (admittedly, trying to be the calm voice is often a waste of time on the internet) That said, if you were to make an informational video which succintly summarizes the technical details that are relevant to artists, it might become sufficiently popular to influence debate.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by aaaaarrrrrfffff on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @11:42AM (#37064378)
(to clarify, this is a response to skjoldr's comment)
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by TimPC on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:19PM (#37064933)
Because fair use allows transformation and the output of their algorithm looks nothing like the input of the copyrighted work? For generative models its more complicated because generative models can actually reproduce large sections of a copyrighted work so transformation is a bit less clear.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @06:43PM (#37069389)
> Because fair use allows transformation and the output of their algorithm looks nothing like the input of the copyrighted work?

I feel like you miss the point of a law. You seem to read the law, and say "well, the law says X, new technology Y is compatible with it, so that's legal, everyone is happy". But that is wrong. The law reflects the society we want. Do we want a society that completely kills creative work because Big Tech found a loophole to launder their IP? I guess we all agree that we don't. It is not clear if LLM is that loophole, I agree. But you seriously have to take a step back and think about that. What if it does? Then we may have to redefine the meaning of "fair use".

Maybe this particular software was not a danger for those authors. But they don't know that. And given that most engineers talking about LLMs don't seem to remotely understand how one could be worried about it, I understand that they start speaking up wherever they can't. Because clearly it does not seem like those who build those systems give a damn about copyright holders.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by TimPC on Thursday August 10, 2023 @01:41PM (#37079226)
I think the actual issue is nuanced and complicated. I think it's fairly clear the tool in question that was non-generative AI is the kind of thing we want to allow under fair use. Whether we want to allow generative AI is more complex, I'd lean towards requiring a license because of non-deterministic duplication. Fair use is an important part of copyright law and we should be very cautious about eroding it. For example, I like Green Day's transformation of the scream icon and think it was substantially different enough that it should be allowed. The courts agreed under current transformation laws but if we weaken protection against transformation we likely reverse the ruling of cases like that as well.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by ineedasername on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:54PM (#37066281)
This project was not generative AI. Comments are saying this project, which is not at all similar to generative ai, seemed to be okay. But you keep replying to say essentially “but if it was generative ai then authors have a legitimate reason to be angry”.

There is no need to shoehorn that debate into this particular situation, and I see no merit in defending authors that had a knee jerk reaction to this project on the grounds that they have reasonable fears about other types of projects.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @06:52PM (#37069457)
I think it is not completely off topic. Here is how I see it:

Engineers tend to globally think that LLMs are not really a problem for copyright holders. At least those who develop LLMs pretty clearly don't give a damn. And on top of that, it is in their interest to not be constrained by copyrights.

If this is my feeling (that engineers globally don't care about copyright holders), then it seems reasonable to me that non-engineers could feel the same. That sounds fair, doesn't it?

So those people start speaking up when they see a situation where they feel like "it is happening". And because they don't really know the technology, it is hard for them to know if this particular case is a problem or not. And they can't really trust engineers to tell them, because engineers built LLMs in the first place, and really it does not seem like they care about copyright holders.

Finally, engineers see this reaction from authors, and instead of trying to understand where they come from, they dismiss their opinion. Which probably will reinforce the feeling that engineers don't remotely understand the concerns of those people, and keep building their AI-powered laundering machines. Again, engineers working on those technologies in big companies have absolutely no interest in even considering that it is a problem. Because they get a big salary to help their big company get more profitable, even if it kills many jobs and is a net loss for society (because they benefit from that).

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by ineedasername on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:51PM (#37070440)
To rephrase in my own understanding of what you wrote:

1) Some engineers (or more broadly, software developers) do not respect copyright

2) Therefore you reasonably are skeptical of projects related to material under copyright.

3) It is not always obvious if a project is respectful of copyright.

Now, applying these #1,#2,#3 you believe they justify the outrage for this particular project.

I disagree, because outrage combined with a lack of understanding (#3) is pretty much my definition of a knee-jerk reaction and vastly counterproductive to the interests of copyright holders because it will make the dismissiveness you predict a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by palata on Thursday August 10, 2023 @09:54AM (#37076196)
> you believe they justify the outrage for this particular project.

No, I believe it explains it.

> it will make the dismissiveness you predict a self-fulfilling prophecy.

That's the thing: both parties need to listen to each other. The problem here is not this particular project, but the fact that we are not addressing the bigger concern which is LLMs.

IMHO, it is completely useless to try to solve this particular case, because it will happen over and over again. We need to address the LLM issue.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Nullabillity on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#37061374)
They… quantify the number of adverbs and voices? I'm sorry, but have you ever read either a book or a review of one?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:30AM (#37061658)
Yes, and they have 1000 times the spoilers and quotations and judgemental attitude of ... a summary of adverbs and voices.

So yes, I understand what a review is, thanks for the put-down, that certainly added something to the conversation.

I think we are in agreement - doing statistical analysis on written works is entirely a lesser thing than simple review, and is harmless.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by soco on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:55AM (#37061316)
For this very particular project I agree the reaction seems exaggerated, even though it does walk the thin line of copyright infringement. But as it happens, it rides the wave of all other AI project which started small then headed we know where. Because once your book is in the database of company X you can bet safe money they will take it and continue their "analysis" as much further as they like because hey you did not complain - and I believe you must defend yourself in order to keep the copyright.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Robotbeat on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:49AM (#37061855)
The response to this undermines my ability to take the “backlash” against AI as anything other than innumerate, mob idiocy. It’s hard to prevent myself from being negatively polarized against the backlash when people in the backlash defend outrage against obviously innocuous things like this.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by golemotron on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:05AM (#37061408)
> I’m with the artists on this one. Our obsession with converting everything into input for an algorithm that spits out an ill-defined number (what the hell is “vividness”?) needs to stop.

Anyone who is with the artists should pass a law. Moral outrage is not law.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by Nasrudith on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:04PM (#37064723)
And promptly smack face first into the First Amendment. There is a reason they are going with moral outrage. Because they know they don't have the right.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by vouaobrasil on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:17AM (#37061505)
We repeat the mistakes because in the short term, someone finds it profitable, hence a prisoner's dilemma type situation.

If an AI tool was killed, I consider it a victory. That's because even if there are some small useful applications of AI, AI on the whole will certainly put most creatives out of business.

Instead, I propose the following: anyone who is interested in preventing AI from taking over their craft should join me in a coalition of ban AI from their own business. By placing a notice that your work is "100% AI FREE", you are doing something akin to the fair-trade/sustainably sourced sticker on chocolate or other food products: you are letting consumers know that your work was made by a human, so that they can support you.

If enough people get in on this, and pledge to support only those creators who don't use AI, then we can make AI an unprofitable venture and hopefully kill it forever!

I already put a 100% AI FREE badge on my YouTube channel, which means that I will never use AI for writing scripts, editing videos, producing images, etc. Moreover, I also pledge to support other creators who pledge never to use AI, by buying their products over others!

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by kiwih on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:34AM (#37061707)
Without trying to sound flippant - what do you define AI as? Things like autofocus in your video cameras or automatic gain control or noise cancellation in your audio pipeline could also be considered AI. Do you remove those too? What about the AI recommendation algorithm built into YouTube - how do you reconcile being AI free while still using that platform?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by vouaobrasil on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:44AM (#37061804)
Yes, you are right, and I advocate the following: a detailed look at each of these technologies.

However, for practical purposes, a direct definition that encompasses every situation is not necessary, but can evolve. For now, I think we do not need a precise definition and we can start with the following: AI such as ChatGPT, LLMs, image generation tools like DALL-E and ohters, should be restricted.

As for YouTube's algorithm, I agree it is also dangerous. For now, I have restricted the use of direct content generation algorithms, in other words, all content can reasonably said to be human generated in terms of writing, composition, etc.

In other words: AI that makes any creative decision in making content should be banned. Other algorithms should be carefully debated.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by danielbln on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:04AM (#37062052)
Banning automation technology because it could put workers out of business.. isn't that the textbook definition of a luddite? Also, are you saying no creative people are using these technologies? It's not all "enter 1 prompt, get image, call it a day", they are tools that can be and often are part of complex chain. Creatives that don't want to use these tools are probably going to be superseded by creatives who do.

What's your take on generative fill in Photoshop?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by vouaobrasil on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:20AM (#37062252)
I am a luddite. What's wrong with that? I don't believe that all technology is bad, but that AI has reached a stage sufficient so that the order of magnitude of the changes it can affect are too damaging for humanity. I do believe that AI has become advanced enough to pose such a risk to us.

Some creative people are using these technologies, and while it is quite human guided NOW, at some point, the guidance that humans put into it will lessen. That's not to say that AI will ever produce a work like Dostoevsky --- maybe it won't, but it WILL be enough to eliminate most creative jobs, and reduce them to being at most being supervised by people who don't have much of a passion for creative works. And that's a shame, because it will remove the passion of creativity from society.

Generative fill: I don't use it, and that's part of my personal ban. It goes too far. I only use traditionl editing techniques in my photography that works with basically what is there.

Yes, you can say that photography has always been about manipulation, but basically, I have a personal line that I believe I can define sufficiently well, that is far behind the line of AI.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by subroutine on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:49AM (#37061863)
What about the youtube speech to text AI that creates automatic CC transcripts for the hearing impaired? What about the AI that translates transcripts and comments into other languages? (translation certainly makes use of creativity since not every word maps 1:1)
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by vouaobrasil on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:23AM (#37062288)
One can always say that AI has some positive uses like CC transcripts. And of course, I can't prevent the platform from making that. I only mean to say that personally, I will not use it in the basic process of video creation. If YouTube ever forces any sort of editing on my videos through AI, I will quit the platform.

But returning to the topic: even though AI has some benefits, I believe that AI in the long run will have negatives that FAR outweigh the positives, so I believe it still should be restricted.

As for translation, well, the AI transcription/translation sucks. I do attempt to put manual captions in my videos as much as I can though.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by subroutine on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:33AM (#37062414)
So far we have identified like 10 ways you and your audience are currently benefitting from AI, but you haven't mentioned any concrete way AI is harming you.

Also, what do you mean by "forces any sort of editing on my videos through AI". Do you mean like, changing the actual content of your videos?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by planede on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:21AM (#37061550)
I probably agree, but how does this have any relevance to copyright? If the tool is bad but otherwise legal then it should just fail on its lack of merit.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by vidarh on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:24AM (#37061589)
As someone who has published two novels: The outrage over this site was stupid, ignorant and a demonstration of a witch-hunt that will help nobody.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by croes on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:27AM (#37061626)
There is a difference between a statistical analysis of a text to categorize by certain words or word groups and training an AI model to generate texts on the data used for training.

The later creates massive competition to human writers, the former is just an information for potential readers.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by subroutine on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:40AM (#37061759)
Both the former and latter are information for writers. Neither create massive competition for writers (not that there is any law against creating competition), just FUD and better tools for writers.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by croes on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:50AM (#37061871)
Things like GPT already create competition for authors even using their names.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37042561

Pure text statistics won't do the same.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by subroutine on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:47AM (#37062578)
Wrt. your link, the same thing could have happen to this author if these spam books contained complete gibberish (and someone listed it on Amazon/goodreads using the authors name). This isn't legitimate competition (i.e. books written by LLMs that rival the quality and style of the actual author). This is a failure of the selling platform to QC the books they are selling.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by croes on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:32AM (#37063295)
LLMs make the scams better just like they will make spam better.

If it's gibberish you know you got scammed, LLM texts look convincing so you don't know for sure.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by subroutine on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:45AM (#37063494)
I agree LLMs can make better spam. But good spam isn't real competition. It's not like anyone is debating whether they should buy the latest book from their favorite author or the latest book from their favorite author's clone LLM (which is known to have written some solid books). Again, this is an issue that needs to be solved by vendors (it seems like all they need is a system where authors get a copyright to their name, and can curate the list of titles published under their name).
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by croes on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @02:34PM (#37066755)
That's partly true for established authors,but how many readers will get fooled and think those books are real. See these 11 Harry Potter books from China

https://11points.com/11-amazing-fake-harry-potter-books-writ...

It's worse for new authors, they disappear between all the AI authors.

Publishers and readers will have to search a bigger haystack to find the needle.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by macNchz on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:32AM (#37061680)
If you’re an author of books intended for children, your texts are likely already being quantified to produce a reading level difficulty score:

https://metametricsinc.com/parents-and-students/lexile-for-p...

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by dontupvoteme on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:43AM (#37061793)
I'm disappointed he went for "vividness" and not novelty. Judging text based on how uncommon the n-gram is/how much it differs from an LLM could be interesting for sure.

The better an LLM can complete your joke the worse it is, for instance. Important to have a good Letterman-MacDonald quotient.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by torginus on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:15AM (#37062191)
I kind of don't understand the issue - IANAL, so I'm not going to delve on the legality of things, but I think making automated book recommendations better is absolutely fits the bill for 'transformative use' - as in book recommendations are in no way a substitute product for books themselves.

And personally, I think book recommendations are an absolutely underserved market, if I liked a book, having the ability to find more like it would be an absolute godsend for connecting authors with people who would be interested in their works, resulting in much more potential sales for them.

I can't count how many times have I discovered an absolutely great book on Amazon with like 50 reviews accidentally, as well as other, objectively less recommendable books that have nevertheless made an impression on me.

Discovering these books is sort of a hobby of mine, and is the exact kind of activity an LLM would be a great help with.

Going further, if there was an LLM that could be asked for book recommendations for your particular tastes, it could also identify markets for books not yet written, and would give a hint to authors on what sort of books to write to find an audience.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by aredox on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:03AM (#37062822)
Stop with the "this is good, I want more" Skinner-box model of happiness. Try some serendipity instead of being led by a generic algorithm.

I discovered absolutely great books by moving slowly along the shelves of a library or a bookshop.

And you need to read bad books to understand the great ones.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by webnrrd2k on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:37AM (#37063365)
The whole point of this site is for people to express their opinions, and torginus took the time to write a thoughtful comment anout LLMs and how they might help both authors and readers.

As for your point about serendipity, torginus never said that he didn't wander book stores and libraries looking for books he wouldn't have been previously exposed to.

Based on the post, I'm sure they understood the basics of reading a variety of books, both good and bad -- there is no need to get judgemental.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by giantrobot on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:35AM (#37063341)
Are you seriously telling someone else how they should enjoy something?
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by nkjnlknlk on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:57PM (#37066318)
> And personally, I think book recommendations are an absolutely underserved market

I haven't read about the industry in years but isn't it the case that the job of "book recommendations" is essentially the publishers job? They unironically try to sell you more than a book. An algorithm would threaten their worth.

(There are, of course, other useful functions like publishing and the irreplaceable editors, but neither require the capital strength of marketing.)

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:58AM (#37062747)
"It's a mistake." OK, you could be right.

"Needs to stop." OK, you could be right on that one too. I don't think you are, but that's not the point.

Neither of those adds up to "it's currently illegal". (Whether it's actually illegal probably depends on the details of how he did what he did.)

Further, neither of those things adds up to "the howling mob should attack him until he stops". (Even if the "attacks" are purely online.) I am against "attack him with outrage dialed all the way up to 11 without actually understanding what his tool is and does". I am also against giving in to the outrage - it just shows the mob that baseless outrage attacks work.

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by sobellian on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:01AM (#37062796)
I agree that it's probably not that useful, but to actually take offense? The outrage seems to misunderstand the law and the technology. If you think the numbers offer no meaning, then just ignore them. People produce bad tools every day and the world still turns.
Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by jasonlotito on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:26AM (#37063173)
> I’m with the artists on this one. Our obsession with converting everything into input for an algorithm that spits out an ill-defined number (what the hell is “vividness”?) needs to stop.

Usefulness is immaterial here.

Is he allowed to do this? Yes.

What's wrong with presenting a page count and word count, for example?

Re:The Fear of AI Just Killed a Useful Tool by sneak on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:04PM (#37064727)
The guy who wrote code is also an artist, and he is allowed to publish his book reports.