News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by whimsicalism on Sunday August 06, 2023 @06:05PM (#37027365)
Beautifully written, even if I don’t necessarily agree with every single point made.

Especially towards the end, I feel that she tries to emphasize the nobility and radical nature of this work, taking umbrage at Eric Adam’s use of the word “low-skill” to describe some of these sorts of jobs. But it seems somewhat belied by the fact that, afaict, as soon as she had the means to escape, she did. And the romanticization of sex work as the only job where women get to call the shots and make profit off of men… I am curious the degree to which this is really true for these massage parlors, which are often managed or extorted by male-run organized crime. [0]

But the central message, one that seems like a call for dignity, really resonates with me. It is one of the most beautiful vignettes I have read in a long time.

[0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/02/us/massage-parlors-human-...

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by truculent on Sunday August 06, 2023 @07:36PM (#37028111)
> Especially towards the end, I feel that she tries to emphasize the nobility and radical nature of this work, taking umbrage at Eric Adam’s use of the word “low-skill” to describe some of these sorts of jobs. But it seems somewhat belied by the fact that, afaict, as soon as she had the means to escape, she did.

Just because something is skilful doesn’t make it enjoyable or rewarding. Not to mention a person’s health and safety (both economic and physical) being considered.

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by ses1984 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @08:05PM (#37028322)
The author didn’t assert that sex work is the only job where women get to call the shots. The author suggested that could be a reason why it’s marginalized. Because if it was legitimized, then women would call the shots.
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by whimsicalism on Sunday August 06, 2023 @08:16PM (#37028400)
I did not read it that way and I think that she would have phrased it differently if so.

“an industry where women get to call the shots” she would have said “would get” imo if your interpretation was correct, just as you use ‘would’ in your comment.

I took her to be describing sex work in the present, not some hypothetical future sex work.

Here is the excerpt for those who want to judge for themselves:

‘Unlike sex work, my “good” jobs didn’t threaten to overthrow traditional power structures. Many sex workers, including myself, have long hypothesized that the reason so many people in power work to keep the commercial sex trade marginalized is because they’re threatened by it—by the idea that it’s the only field where women outearn men, that it’s an industry where women get to call the shots, and that women profit off something that men have been told they’re entitled to for free: sex and attention in equal parts. In my experience of the corporate landscape, there was none of this radical power structure, only an upholding of the traditional: men talking and women listening, men in powerful positions getting both credit and profit for the labour of women beneath them’

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by ses1984 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @10:38PM (#37029392)
People in power work to marginalize it because they’re threatened by it. It’s pretty successfully marginalized if a woman can get arrested for it even while sacrificing economic profits to a pimp or massage parlor. Maybe the author could have been more explicit about it but to my reading sex workers can’t be both marginalized and calling the shots.
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by whimsicalism on Sunday August 06, 2023 @11:56PM (#37029894)
> sex workers can’t be both marginalized and calling the shots

Disagree. Calling the shots in the business, not in society. Just like a drug kingpin might be calling the shots in his organization.

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by ses1984 on Monday August 07, 2023 @07:58AM (#37033267)
Comparing a drug kingpin to a prostitute is kind of ridiculous but if that makes sense in your mind then I doubt we would see eye to eye on pretty much anything.
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by whimsicalism on Monday August 07, 2023 @10:11AM (#37034693)
It was a counter-example in the analytic/math sense, I was in no way suggesting that a sex worker is equivalent to a drug kingpin. Merely an example as to why your assertion that [calling the shots is incompatible with overall societal marginalization] is wrong.

Happy to not continue though, I think you struggle with good faith discussion and/or reading comprehension (:

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by barrenko on Monday August 07, 2023 @02:21AM (#37030870)
It's marginalized because it's a shitty job, like every other shitty job (source: I've worked a lot of shitty jobs.)
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by zapataband1 on Monday August 07, 2023 @12:43AM (#37030247)
Women can call more of the shots in places where it is legal like Nevada or other countries. Not saying it's a perfect system but the alterntive so far has been a trade that is controlled by criminals, bad customers, and law enforcement.
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by whimsicalism on Monday August 07, 2023 @12:58AM (#37030332)
Not sure why you assume this would be the case and it also isn’t really all that true [0], nor has it been true historically in societies with legal prostitution nor is it true in other industries with many women frontline workers (like the makeup industry, obviously not that similar but I think is somewhat representative).

[0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Hof

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by yieldcrv on Monday August 07, 2023 @02:59PM (#37039089)
That’s not often true in sex work relying on a venue, and certainly not nevada, and the few women run organizations have the same power dynamics and labor problems as all the others

Should really include sex workers in these discussions

All this conjecture that its exclusively a male run coercive trait exacerbating anything

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by throwaway22044 on Monday August 07, 2023 @01:38AM (#37030563)
> Because if it was legitimized, then women would call the shots.

If prostitution was legitimized, way fewer shots would have to be called in the first place. Apparently nobody wants that

Re:We Are All Animals at Night by flir on Sunday August 06, 2023 @08:16PM (#37028402)
She also doesn't know how many of those office drones also "paid their dues". But that's a nitpick on an excellent piece of first-person journalism.
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by iamnotsure on Sunday August 06, 2023 @10:36PM (#37029379)
It is easy to forget that central bank money is beads and trinkets with an average half-life of 30 years.
Re:We Are All Animals at Night by tsss on Monday August 07, 2023 @05:30AM (#37032223)
She can write, I'll give her that, but contentwise it is exactly the unreflected pseudo-intellectual crap you'd expect from a "journalist". How can you be so naive to sign up to become a propaganda foot soldier for the culture industry and then expect anything else but soulless stab-in-the-back ass-kissing work? This sense of comradery she is missing is the glimmer of class consciousness. It's strangely real, it's people who know they are at the bottom and they're in it together. The corporate world on the other hand is fake. It consists of bosses who want to be treated like a friend or a royal when it suits them. It consists of colleagues who will throw you under the bus for that promotion and you will do the same, but you both act like you don't know it will happen. It is that subconscious shame of betrayal from people like the author, who romance about the precariat on their personal blog and then go back to work to beat down on their former friends with the proverbial cultural stick in service of the man.