News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by simonsarris on Monday March 12, 2012 @04:27PM (#3695312)
If anyone has a similar habit and wants to stop it I will tell how my high school fixed it for almost all of us.

In my (private) high school's health class "like" and "um" and others were referred to as "stop-words" by the teacher because people would say them instead of pausing. It's really obvious once you look for them, for instance here with pg but anywhere really. I remember hearing college tour guides that would literally say "um" after every single sentence, probably unbeknownst to themselves!

Almost every class in the school had projects, and the health class project was for us to remove the stop words from our speech by the end of the semester. We did this by all using recording software (had to submit either by cassette tape or wav/mp3) and answering questions such as "Do you want to live forever and why or why not?" by speaking for at least 5 minutes. These were our homework assignments maybe once a month, with the overarching goal considered as the class project.

We had to very consciously never use any stop words. We could pause the recorder if we had trouble thinking of what to say, but we could never say those words.

I was skeptical of the assignment at first but my class all agreed by the end of the semester that it made us much better speakers, simply learning to consider our pauses instead of filling the silence with "like" and "um".

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by kleiba on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:51PM (#3696085)
Half-OT: Note that words such as "like" and "um" are typically not referred to as stop words in (computational) linguistics. They are called filled pauses, or sometimes floor holders, depending on their function. Liz Shriberg's thesis was - as far as I know - the first extensive treatment of speech disfluencies in the field of computational linguistics.

The term "stop words" is, however, used in information retrieval. Here, it refers to words that appear very frequently in (almost) all documents in a corpus; so frequently in fact that they are taken not to carry any/much information content at all. Examples would be "the", "it", "and" etc. For many tasks in IR, stop words are removed from the document representation because they mostly introduce noise.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by gallamine on Monday March 12, 2012 @04:40PM (#3695385)
As a follow-up to this, my HS English teacher broke me of this by forcing the mantra, "if you are about to say 'um', STOP TALKING'". These works are generally used to fill the speech gap while you are thinking. It seems weird at first to pause, but eventually it becomes natural.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by derefr on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @12:14AM (#3696986)
I would posit that people that say "um" more, came from upbringings where they were more likely to be interrupted the moment they left a gap in conversation. That'd be an interesting study.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by cmod on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @03:09AM (#3697353)
Yes. I find in America if you don't keep filling the space with noise when thinking, you lose the chance to finish your thought.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by ineedtosleep on Monday March 12, 2012 @09:08PM (#3696513)
This is generally not a bad thing, though. From my slight applied linguist background: These fillers are generally used in order to establish that the speaker's turn is not yet done. In a conversational situation, having pauses instead of fillers gives the listeners openings into the conversation to become the speaker.

In presentational speeches, fillers aren't so bad, but long pauses IMO are worse. It's a natural thing to have fillers. If you want to have less, just practice more and be more comfortable with what you're talking about.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by SkyMarshal on Monday March 12, 2012 @08:27PM (#3696386)
My HS English teacher was even more harsh (but effective) - every time someone said um, ah, like, or any other tic/pause word, she'd immediately cut them off. 'STOP.' 'TRY AGAIN.' 'NO.' etc. She was relentless, forced students to stop, calm down, gather their thoughts, and say it directly. Most students were cured in a few days, and the really bad ones a few weeks at most.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by twiceaday on Monday March 12, 2012 @05:32PM (#3695675)
I know girls that talk faster than they can think so every third word is "like". In this case it's not a pause but more of a tick. Sometimes I am in awe of the content density. They can talk for hours and say absolutely nothing.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by philwelch on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:05PM (#3695875)
Believe it or not, you can talk for hours and say absolutely nothing without any disfluencies at all. I don't want to derail this thread into a political argument so I won't mention any specific examples, but I'm sure you can think of some yourself.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by ezl on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @01:36AM (#3697173)
+1. More please.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by kristianc on Monday March 12, 2012 @05:46PM (#3695763)
"Like" is increasingly used to introduce a quotation, particularly in SoCal dialect. It's not necessarily the most elegant use of language, but it's not a pause or a tick.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by munificent on Monday March 12, 2012 @05:56PM (#3695830)
kristianc was like, "It's not necessarily the most elegant use of language, but it's not a pause or a tick.", but that's not, like, the only use of "like" in American vernacular. It's also used to pause, or to, like, distance yourself from what you're saying.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by lkozma on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @06:50AM (#3697822)
Nice going... For sentences like your last example, in the past few years I've been hearing "as in" with increasing frequency. I find it quite annoying and would be very curious to learn about its origins, as in how did it start.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by djloche on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:42PM (#3696044)
As someone who grew up in the suburbs of Southern California, It's been my experience that 'like' it's used to introduce a paraphrase that includes non-verbal communication and/or tones that introduce not-so-subtle comments regarding the paraphrase without directly commenting nor limiting yourself with a direct quotation.

For example, I could say "kristianc was like, OMG it is NOT a pause or a tic, it is SoCal dialect!" in a sarcastic tone and roll my eyes.

edit: This form of communication doesn't translate well into digital form - email, texting, etc. - unless both people are familiar with each other's body language and the dialect to visualize (at a conscious or subconscious level) the meaning.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by kristianc on Monday March 12, 2012 @08:46PM (#3696442)
All communication is to some extent subject to those limitations. Wittgenstein was so like "language acquires meaning through context, bro" but only in his like, later period.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by ldh on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:00PM (#3695845)
Minor interjection: the word you both want is "tic".
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by syaz1 on Monday March 12, 2012 @08:55PM (#3696475)
Funny relevance: Taylor Mali at Def Poetry Jam http://youtu.be/SCNIBV87wV4
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by cyanbane on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @12:24AM (#3697018)
I am from the south so I think I probably pick up on the socal "like" more than people out west who hear it daily, and I distinctly remember listening to Marissa Mayer and attempting to count the instances in which she said it when I heard her speak about 7 or 8 years ago. The talk was very interesting and she didn't use it as a "thinking pause" however it was used very frequently.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by itmag on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:31PM (#3695997)
I know girls that talk faster than they can think

Heh, I'm the other way around.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by msluyter on Monday March 12, 2012 @07:29PM (#3696203)
Toastmasters is quite helpful for this. I did it for a while and highly recommend it. It's also a great way to practice social skills, generally.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by sliverstorm on Monday March 12, 2012 @05:12PM (#3695575)
There's an even more low-tech way. Teacher starts calling you out on it. A little "ding" from a bell or similar draws your attention to it, when you wouldn't notice otherwise. After a while, your classmates will start policing each other, and even the quiet ones will speak up so they can play the "game" of avoiding filler words.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by nostrademons on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @12:15AM (#3696990)
I had a PM at Google who did debate in high school. In his debate class, everybody would throw a pen at him every time he said "um". He has very precise, articulate diction.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtirDMfcOKE

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by kevinclark on Monday March 12, 2012 @07:02PM (#3696126)
We did a similar thing in debate. When one person says 'um', so does everyone else. Stops the habit fairly quickly.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by ezl on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @01:37AM (#3697178)
our partner in cx would stand behind us and hit us on top of the head every time we said "um" or "like"
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by mopoke on Monday March 12, 2012 @10:17PM (#3696689)
That reminds me very strongly of this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdOomYvnyNI&t=1m13s
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by nnnnni on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @08:18AM (#3698050)
There's also the "Subway Challenge":

Go to a restaurant like Subway where you go along a counter and tell the employee what you want on your food item. The challenge is to get through the whole thing without a single "um", "uh", or similar word. It's VERY easy to say "uhhh.... ummm.... pepper jack cheese!" when asked to make a choice on the spot like that.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by petercooper on Monday March 12, 2012 @08:41PM (#3696428)
I did this and it worked well. Except.. I then started listening back and noticed I was adding filler like "you know what I mean?" instead, which is proving a more insidious problem to stamp out.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by screwt on Monday March 12, 2012 @07:42PM (#3696244)
I tried a similar thing in high school to stop saying 'like' as a filler word. For me, it completely backfired though - I found myself saying 'like' twice whenever I would have said it once!

I guess doing this as a group (as others have suggested) might work better.

Years later, and the habit went away by itself.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by bicknergseng on Monday March 12, 2012 @08:58PM (#3696484)
The best way to stop doing something is to become overly conscious of it. I used the same method to get "this" out of my writing.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by badclient on Monday March 12, 2012 @07:00PM (#3696120)
You've simply replaced one problem with another('umm's with pauses).

(assuming you see this as a problem. I actually think this is an overrated problem IRL.)

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by Spearchucker on Monday March 12, 2012 @07:06PM (#3696141)
Pauses are the opposite of "a problem". They're one of THE MOST effective tools you have as a speaker. Listen to any great speech. Look out for the pauses. Imagine if the impact would've been the same without them.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by psykotic on Monday March 12, 2012 @08:23PM (#3696376)
That is a false equivalence--a rhetorical pause differs from a random pause. Random pauses are certainly preferable to any overt verbal tics.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by Spearchucker on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @03:04AM (#3697338)
I'm not a speech therapist or linguist etc. so wasn't aware of any formal distinction. I can tell you that "random" pauses, as you call them, are as useful as considered pauses. They slow down what's being said, which makes the speaker appear calmer, more considered, and so on.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by psykotic on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @01:40PM (#3699474)
What you say goes against common sense and experience. Pausing randomly in the middle of a train of thought is not on the same level as a carefully considered pause. There was a real-life case study of the difference on the Language Log where the subject was a presidential debate between Bush and Kerry. Kerry spoke at a moderate rate and made careful use of pauses--he had longer pauses before beginning his answers to the moderator's question, and he had shorter, calculated pauses for rhetorical effect. By contrast, Bush launched directly into his answer before hardly taking a breath, spoke hastily, tripping over his own words, pausing frequently and inappropriately during sentences in ways that did not suggest composure but rather confusion and incompetence. Obviously that impression was not helped by his other deficiencies as an speaker, but it was a major flaw in its own right.
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by badclient on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @02:41PM (#3699744)
Bush launched directly into his answer before hardly taking a breath, spoke hastily, tripping over his own words, pausing frequently and inappropriately during sentences in ways that did not suggest composure but rather confusion and incompetence

I pretty much had this speech impediment and had to see a speech language pathologist to get it fixed :) Your description contrasting the two types of pauses nails it.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by Spearchucker on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @05:40PM (#3700539)
What I wrote about pauses is about pauses as opposed to ums and ahs. The unstated assumption is that the rest of the package (message structure, body language and so on, as per PG's speech) is in sync.

While Bush is indeed a really good example of how not to do it, his failing was not pausing. His failing was, as you say, confusion and incompetence.

See my post below.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by badclient on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @06:25PM (#3700662)
His failing was, as you say, confusion and incompetence

The same could be argued about 'umms': that the 'umms' aren't the problem, confusion and incompetence is.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by Spearchucker on Wednesday March 14, 2012 @04:58AM (#3702326)
Lol :-) I didn't say umms are bad. I said cutting them out can be good. If you're looking to improve then that's one something (one of many) you might seek to address.

Another might be how you make a statement. The one you made here is positional. It's positional in that I feel you're trying to push me into telling you you're right.

I may well be wrong, but that's what I feel when I read your comment above.

So another something one might improve, in addition to eliminating umms, is to move from a positional stance to a principled stance. [START Starship Trooper voice] Would you like to know more?[END Starship Trooper voice] :-)

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by lusr on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @04:08AM (#3697470)
I realise that the OP is about a speech, but I think universally dismissing "um"s isn't justified. A speech is not the same thing as a dialogue. Conversational fillers are useful to hold the floor (not that there aren't better ways than "um" but that doesn't mean "um" isn't useful or ineffectual).
Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by Spearchucker on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @06:02AM (#3697710)
I guess that depends on your objective. In either case (communicating a message, or arbitrary conversation) you can choose to be ok, or you can choose to be exceptional.

Ums in either case are a distraction, and to some annoying. The degree obviously varies from person to person. Being a good conversationalist is as counter-intuitive as skiing (where you have to lean forward when facing downhill) in that a good conversationalist is in fact a good listener, and only interjects to elicit more conversation from the other party. So... in a way you're right. Uming a lot when you're really just listening isn't going to affect anything ;-)

Making a speech is about communicting a message. There are many ways to structure that message, for example SCIPAB, but the structure and supporting slides, if any, can be spectacularly annihilated by a mediocre delivery.

To be exceptional you need to work on your delivery. That means slowing way down, not using ums and ahs, maintaining eye contact (I've addressed a 5000-strong crowd, so believe me when I say it's irrespective of the size of the audience), and getting your body language right.

Depends entirely on how good you want to be :-)

If you want to be exceptional you could do worse that start with The Voice Book (http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0571195253/ - Amazon.com is sold out). It's been derided somewhat elsewhere in this thread, but Toastmasters is another hugely useful route.

[Edit - forgot to describe SCIPAB]

(S)ituation

(C)omplication

(I)mplication

(P)osition

(A)ction

(B)enefit

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by badclient on Tuesday March 13, 2012 @10:16AM (#3698508)
There are plenty of smooth talkers who can give a good speech, without any umms, and yet leave the audience unfulfilled. Obviously there are just as many bad speeches full of too many umms.

I think there is a middle ground where 'umms' and general fillers make the communication more authentic and seemingly less rehearsed. Most people don't like listening to a robot, not even a well-rehearsed one.

Re:Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute by rprasad on Monday March 12, 2012 @06:44PM (#3696052)
My high school AP English teacher deducted a full 1% from presentation assignments for every "um" and "like" (except where the use of "like" was contextually appropriate).

Nobody got higher than a D on the first presentation. Nobody got lower than a B after that.