News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by tech_ken on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:38PM (#36909521)
I don’t think any typical internet user would accept Tor’s latency. User behavior has indicated again and again that convenience and frictionless-ness is the overriding priority for the majority. I appreciate the work done by the Tor community, but I also think we need to be realistic about what the threat model is and what viable solutions are on the table:

* If you’re concerned about the MAANGs of the world hovering data for targeted adverts I think you’d get far more traction with aggressive privacy legislation and brutal oversight, or (and I recognize this is extreme) straight nationalization of some of their products with a mandate to operate them in the public interest like PBS or the Beeb

* If you’re concerned about an authoritarian state actor Tor was pwned years ago. TBH I think trying to win against ex. US TLAs in straight cryptography or protocol supremacy is kind of a fools errand (you’re ultimately going to get clobbered purely on the resource differential) and that the best bet is security through obscurity.

Just my 2c, maybe overly fatalistic so curious about counter views

Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by cma on Friday July 28, 2023 @01:43PM (#36910455)
If everyone used it wouldn't latency go down (more nearby nodes), or is it that for privacy via timing attacks they don't preference nearby nodes and/or they add artificial delays?
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by r3trohack3r on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:00PM (#36910728)
I might misunderstand how Tor works, but unless you are a relay I don’t think you participate in routing. Unlike BitTorrent, clients don’t automatically contribute resources back to the network.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by stavros on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:59PM (#36912475)
~~My (perhaps mistaken) understanding is that all nodes relay, but not all nodes are exit nodes.~~

EDIT: They do not.

Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by georgyo on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:30PM (#36912875)
All nodes to do not relay by default. They definitely have the ability to, but it is not the default.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by stavros on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:32PM (#36912897)
Ah ok, thanks.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by Dylan16807 on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:54PM (#36913878)
That depends on how you define node. I would not call the software you run to connect a "node". And in that framework, I would say that node=relay.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by nektro on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:35PM (#36912941)
this is a fatal flaw of Tor imo, it should be a question front and center to enable all browser installations to be relays
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by LoganDark on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:04PM (#36916439)
But critically not exit nodes. Exit nodes should still only be run by people who know they are running exit nodes.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by matheusmoreira on Saturday July 29, 2023 @04:21AM (#36918100)
I'm not sure exit nodes should exist in the first place. Everything should probably be a tor hidden service instead.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by DropInIn on Saturday July 29, 2023 @01:59AM (#36917368)
https://husovec.eu/2014/07/austrian-court-sentenced-tor-exit...

(Ed corrected link to be the sentencing rather than raid)

This _inevitability_ ensures/d it never could be set up like that.

You don't seed the sites you've visited you serve _any_ site the visitor wants.

Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by tech_ken on Friday July 28, 2023 @01:46PM (#36910500)
That’s a good question, tbh I have no idea. Yeah presumably if the user base increased then the number of nodes would also grow, but definitely unclear to me what level of latency (if any) is required for privacy
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by akira2501 on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:13PM (#36910907)
> If you’re concerned about an authoritarian state actor Tor was pwned years ago.

I mean.. wasn't it created by a department of the US Navy? What did everyone expect? The "white label" slapped on it years ago was that this was meant to help "Iranian dissidents" share information on the web.

The utility of this network to everyday people was never going to exist.

Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by make3 on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:25PM (#36911090)
yes, why do people use Tor if it's well known that it's been hacked by multiple governments for a long time?
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by wolverine876 on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:40PM (#36912189)
It depends on the threat you are trying to mitigate. If it's commercial surveillance, then Tor makes some sense.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by timbit42 on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:49PM (#36913826)
Where is this proof?
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by adr1an on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:08PM (#36914606)
I used it plenty at the University to access research articles (sci hub). There are other use cases that go beyond the usual stuff that government try to monitor by serving exit nodes, or doing correlation attacks. Anyway, even if you were a terrorist, using your would be better than not using it. There are probably other solutions that they implement, sure.
Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by DANmode on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:17PM (#36914695)
Because the protocol isn't the issue.

Lately, it's been surreptitiously fingerprinting or exploiting their Firefox fork, timing attacks (if you can see metadata all of the packets in the country or world, they can take as many hops as you choose, someone and or something can still easily line them up),

or other op-sec screwups (controversial, because what is reporterd as fatal OpSec flaws can just as easily be parallel construction finding something that would look or sound blatantly obvious in retrospect).

Re:Tor’s shadowy reputation will only end if we all use it by gray_charger on Saturday July 29, 2023 @03:57PM (#36923940)
If you're not doing anything that affects national security they won't bother burning that capability on you. They save action only for those they can take action against in a clandestine way (so the fact they can crack Tor is not on public record), or against someone so dangerous they need to act quickly for national security reasons (and a government acting quickly with overwhelming force is hard to keep secret).