News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @10:04AM (#36906958)
You aren't the average user. Most users can't even afford decent housing or food. Let alone $250/year for apps, and they will never pay. I'm sorry, but I think we just have fundamental disagreements about what software is.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by eropple on Friday July 28, 2023 @10:08AM (#36907017)
We do disagree. But one of us is describing, and one of us is depending, and that skews things a little, doesn't it? Upton Sinclair had a line about this.

What value, in a sane system, does selling advertising that targets people who "can't even afford decent housing or food" actually do? How are the goods you are selling--human attention--actually turning into revenue for the advertiser if the user has no money to act on the advertising? Or is it just one more iteration on a mutual deception that exists to create a predicate for "any of these mobile apps are worth creating in the first place"?

You're building a bigger house of cards with every post.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @10:20AM (#36907182)
Poor people might be better served with targeted ads to help them find lower cost goods to save money, access helpful services they otherwise wouldn't know about, and seek out support groups/clubs/organizations. Not everything in this life is evil ya know.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by mynameisvlad on Friday July 28, 2023 @10:34AM (#36907371)
They might but we both know they won’t be. They’ll be targeted with ads which exploit the fact that they are in an extremely vulnerable state.

In fact, the more desperate, the more willing they’d be to click on an ad, which gives a perverse incentive to advertisers and developers to worsen their financial position.

But please, show me examples of these good targeted ads because while in theory they could exist, something tells me they very much don’t.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @10:51AM (#36907637)
> we both know they won’t be.

Not true, you don't speak for what I know.

> show me examples of these good targeted ads because while in theory they could exist, something tells me they very much don’t.

The non-profits in my area (which is very low income) would very much like to target my local community better/cheaper.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by mynameisvlad on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:02AM (#36907788)
> Not true, you don't speak for what I know.

Just because you refuse to say it publicly does not mean you don't know it.

> The non-profits in my area (which is very low income) would very much like to target my local community better/cheaper.

They certainly would, but have they? I asked for a very simple and specific thing. Examples of targeted ads right now that are specifically targeted towards low-income folks and which are doing it to better their lives.

Please, by all means, show me examples. Not anecdotes. Not opinion. Hard examples.

Until then, it's a pipe dream used to justify your company's desire to further invade people's privacy.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:37AM (#36908471)
> Just because you refuse to say it publicly does not mean you don't know it.

Does that honestly sound fair fair to you? I'm not putting words into your mouth. Please respect my agency and I'll continue to respect yours in kind.

> Please, by all means, show me examples. Not anecdotes. Not opinion. Hard examples.

Aren't examples also anecdotes? https://www.sheerid.com/business/blog/why-and-how-you-should... > Take for example, Headspace, makers of the popular meditation app by the same name. The company created an exclusive discount to help teachers who might not be able to afford the app use it to manage their stress.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by mynameisvlad on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:03PM (#36908904)
So your example is… someone advertising their app so a teacher can spend slightly less money? That’s your choice for targeted ads being used for good? Seriously?

That’s a long way down from those theoretical local non-profits.

And if that’s the best you’ve got, then I don’t know how anyone could say anything but fuck no to invading their privacy for a shiny discount to an app they likely don’t even need.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:46PM (#36909628)
You asked for an example and I gave you one. Where shall the goalpost move next? If it feels like it's an example of low consequence that's because it is: what we're arguing about is pretty trivial to most folks. And that might not make sense, but here's why: most folks aren't on hacker news nor care so deeply about such things.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by mynameisvlad on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:48PM (#36911412)
The goalpost is exactly where it has always been, your example is just a horrible way to try and show that targeted advertising can be used for good. How does it "better their lives"? It's not like Headspace is giving the app away for free; teachers still have to pay for it.

In the single example you did provide, the motivation behind the targeting is still strictly to extract money from people. It may be to extract slightly less money from a specific group, but it's not like Headspace is doing the targeting out of the goodness of their hearts; they are doing it because they think they will get more profits from the higher number of sales even at a discount.

Using the most capitalistic example is certainly a choice you can make, but it's not one that is going to convince most people of your cause. If you want to convince people that targeted ads can be used for good, then actually show that it can be used for good instead of talking about theoretical and hypothetical non-profits and providing the weakest possible example when pushed for reality.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:46PM (#36912278)
https://www.forbes.com/sites/allbusiness/2021/03/06/how-nonp...

https://www.constantcontact.com/blog/facebook-ads-for-nonpro...

Non-profits and for profit companies alike can use targeted ads to mutually benefit those they are targeting. Obviously for profit companies exist to make money. Do you think that true altruism is a real thing? Everybody has a motive and that's the game we call life.

As far as my real-life local non-profit example: my local PP chapter reached out to my local side business IG account to share posts of their social media to widen their audience. Wouldn't it be great if they could better target people in their target demographic more easily / affordably?

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by foobiekr on Saturday July 29, 2023 @12:52PM (#36922081)
There are many nice things we can’t have because they are exploited by bad actors. There is a nearly infinite amount of evidence that targeted ads go hand-in-hand with abusive, anti-social practices.

So I am sorry that you and your innocent nonprofits are being impacted by the massive, exploitative, evil machine that inherently builds around grinding away privacy, but it’s an unfortunate side effect of how many ethicless assholes there are.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Saturday July 29, 2023 @05:13PM (#36924681)
This guy asked for examples for my position and I gave them. All I can do is stand up for my position despite it being unpopular.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by foobiekr on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:52AM (#36908701)
And your business model is to make big money from local non-profits?

Come on. This is just sad.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:50PM (#36909682)
I never said that my business model did, nor that big money was involved. Please don't assume my position and re-read the thread. All I had said was that a non-profit in my area would very much like to target my local community better/cheaper.

This is just an example/anecdote.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:29AM (#36908344)
We all know that the average mobile ad is for games targeted at whales who will buy loot boxes and gems.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:55AM (#36908755)
If only they could be targeted to be more relevant to you :thinking_face:
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:57AM (#36908799)
Well since I personally refuse to use any apps that I can’t pay to disable ads and I use an ad blocker, that might be kind of difficult…
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:58PM (#36909818)
That's kind of my issue: In journalism it's hard for us to make money because we have a low amount of users who are wiling to pay to disable ads (or remove paywalls for that matter) while at the same time ads don't pay us enough despite high user engagement, so what do we do?
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:23PM (#36911944)
Choose another profession?

The market doesn’t value journalism. I’m not saying that it isn’t important. But the market has spoken.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by bdavbdav on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:46PM (#36913073)
Have you seen the average mobile ad? Targeted ads are driving you to buy that thing you’re thinking about anyway.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by SoftTalker on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:07AM (#36907890)
Yeah I could easily afford that but I haven't spent $250 on phone apps in my entire life. I don't think I've even spent $25. $250 is more like what I'd pay for the phone itself.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by eropple on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:25AM (#36908264)
Totally, but what do you do with mobile devices that needs it? I use iOS with iPads and iPhones, so buying Affinity (which works great on an iPad with a Pencil but also has software for quick edits on a phone) makes a lot of sense to me. They provide value, so I paid for them.

This, not simply "doesn't have money", is the thing about mobile apps that it feels like most people in that most things a user wants to do on a phone don't actually need an app, and if they do it's probably because they're buying something or talking to somebody and neither of those are categories that need more entries with a lower security barrier.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:28AM (#36908314)
Please, iPhone users are paying on average $1000+ for their phone.

The median iPhone user in the US is making $53K a year (https://www.marketingdive.com/news/survey-iphone-owners-spen...).

And most people in the US are neither starving or homeless.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:01PM (#36908866)
Your point is well taken, although I have a hard time grokking how'd I'd fair on that amount of income.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:25PM (#36909265)
Yet the median income in the US is a little less than $40K and the median household income is $67K.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by asow92 on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:51PM (#36909698)
Indeed, they aren't doing well.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:07PM (#36910821)
The average American is not going homeless or hungry.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by ProfessorLayton on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:46PM (#36911379)
Kind of wild that some people are spending ~1.8% of their income on a phone (Even higher if we consider post-tax income).
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:24PM (#36911962)
As much time people spend in their phone and utility that people get out of their phone, why is that crazy?
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by ProfessorLayton on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:26PM (#36912816)
It's just a lot higher than I expected. For someone making a typical developer salary, it's like spending roughly $3,600 on a phone.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by eropple on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:27PM (#36913592)
I paid not-that-much-less for a laptop I use to write code, and spend less time on it than I do deriving value from my phone?
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by ProfessorLayton on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:52PM (#36913860)
That's kind of missing the point? Sure you spent a lot on your laptop, but it isn't (as) a significant portion of your income, presumably.

A typical developer is spending much less on a phone as a % of their income, whereas a typical iPhone buyer is spending much much more — to a surprising degree.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:07PM (#36914005)
The difference is that most professional developers aren’t spending their own money for their work computer.
Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by ProfessorLayton on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:20PM (#36914148)
Agreed, but setting laptops aside, would you spend ~1.8% of your pretax income on a phone? — And not for the best phone either, just the base pro, or an upgraded regular model.

I certainly wouldn't, but a lot of iPhone users are. I'm not judging, I'm genuinely surprised.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by scarface_74 on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:38PM (#36914316)
I only spend 15% of my pretax income on my 15 year mortgage. But I make BigTech money working remotely. So I find that question kind of irrelevant. I definitely don’t expect the average person to only spend 15% of their income on housing.

When I was making $22K a year in 1996, I bought phone for $300, was that too much to spend on a cell phone too?

To a first approximation, no one buys their phone outright in the US and 62% of people replace their phone every 3-4 years (https://www.nevis.net/en/blog/how-often-do-users-change-thei...). So they are only spending .45% of their income on a phone.

Apple released a security update for the iPhone 5s released in 2013 earlier this year. There is no reason to replace your phone every year.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by ProfessorLayton on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:30PM (#36914807)
I wasn't comparing general living expenses, I was comparing iPhone ASP to the income of those buying them. $1k:53k is less affordable than $300:22k accounted for inflation — for tech that is much more mature and commoditized today than it was back then.

Again, it's just surprising and not a value judgement.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by bdavbdav on Sunday July 30, 2023 @04:41AM (#36929161)
Roll back maybe 10-12 years ago. I had a Tomtom in my car, maybe £200. An iPod. Probably the same again. A point and shoot camera. Same again. A 3G WiFi stick and contract for my laptopp. A personal laptop that saw a lot of use. A dedicated Sonos hardware controller. A GPS on my bike, and of course an actual phone (N95).

How many of those devices have been coalesced into one £1200 iPhone. I call that a result.

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by danaris on Saturday July 29, 2023 @02:06PM (#36922869)
You...know most people don't buy a brand-new phone every year, right?

I don't recall exactly what I spent for my iPhone, but it was 4 years ago, so if we assume it was about $1000, then based on that median income, that makes it 0.5%. Does that seem more palatable to you...?

Re:Apple cracking down on 'fingerprinting' with new App Stor... by bdavbdav on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:44PM (#36913052)
You’re gonna need a source on “most users” to fly that one.

“Sensor Tower data reveals that U.S. iPhone users spent an average of $138 on apps in 2020, up 38% from 2019.”