News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by dimitrios1 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:46AM (#36864056)
I have been working full time remote since Sept 2021 (correction, 2020, just before pandemic).

It's not even that I don't value the face-to-face conversations and human interaction, I absolutely do. It just doesn't come close to the immense value I gain by WFH.

A side benefit: I was able to move closer to my church community, so my "human interaction" need is being fulfilled richer than ever now.

(One of the most frustrating things in all the WFH vs RTO discourse is that there is this false dichotomy being presented. It's either extroverted people who are energized by others, or introverts who'd rather be in the dark closet by themselves. I am as extroverted as they come, and I thrived in the office environment. Still wouldn't trade WFH for the world.)

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by wfhBrian on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:50AM (#36864133)
> I was able to move closer to my church community, so my "human interaction" need is being fulfilled richer than ever now.

This is what the "but you need human interaction" return-to-office crowd doesn't understand.

WFH !== Being alone

WFH means surrounding yourself with the people you choose to be around.

Whether that's your church community, fellow hobbyists, intramural sports teams, the local co-working space, etc.

Plus, that can include "my coworkers" for anyone that wants to make work a bigger part of their life, like those working in startups. However, this should be the exception, not the rule like it has been.

It should be your choice...

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by JambalayaJim on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:31PM (#36864953)
This is a fundamental misunderstanding of what the return-to-office crowd, like myself, wants. Work relationships and personal relationships serve entirely different purposes for me.

I don't want to be working longer hours, or make work a larger part of my life. I don't particularly care if I have "real" friendships with my colleagues outside of work. I have plenty of friends and family that I already have trouble juggling.

What I want is the camaraderie, greater trust, mentorship, professional networks, etc. that comes from working with people during the day in a shared space.

I'm not sitting with a church community or sports team during my 9-5. I've had a couple co-working memberships during the last couple years - most people just go there to sit and work quietly. Maybe you make some small talk here and there. Except for the people working with their colleagues who are also in the co-working space.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by biomcgary on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:04PM (#36865582)
Are we in a transition period where the previous methods of developing camaraderie, etc simply have not been widely learned?

I've worked remotely for 7 years and haven't missed anything you've listed as a benefit of in-person work. In fact, compared to prior in-person experiences, I have more personal interaction with colleagues than before (largely because my startup is quite conscious about it).

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by dimitrios1 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:34PM (#36867181)
Agreed. I am very close with my remote teammates, and when we meet for our yearly onsite, it feels like we've all been working side by side in the trenches...just like in an office.

We also miss the fact that you can be traveling to an office for years and not actually know anybody. This is especially true of this big large tech campuses.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by HDThoreaun on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @07:36PM (#36871211)
The previous methods of developing camaraderie all involve being in the same room as other people. Yes you can do it if your company works hard to make it happen, but tons(most?) of companies either can't or won't do that.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by DiggyJohnson on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:12PM (#36867816)
Thank you for writing this out so clearly. I've attempted to make this point in the past, but am too tired to these days.

Of all the animosity in the discussions regarding Remote vs Office, this is the one that genuinely bothers me. Saying that I prefer the human interactions of working in office does not imply that I struggle to find or make friends outside of work. You've put it brilliantly.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by HDThoreaun on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:16PM (#36864672)
I think most of the "but you need human interaction" crowd isn't talking about their social life. It's much harder to collaborate with coworkers when you have no relationship with them. It's not impossible to have a relationship with coworkers when remote, but you have to put a lot more effort in than you would in person. Some companies are facilitating that, but some aren't.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by ravenstine on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:20PM (#36864748)
Plus it's just easier than ever to meet people outside of work. If there's no existing group for your interest, be the change you want to see and create one. I'm not saying a person will suddenly have a ton of friends, but even in the antisocial world of LA, my Meetup group gets at least a small handful to show up most of the time.

I totally get being social with your coworkers as a bonus, but it's a little sad to me that people need to rely on that one source. I can count on one hand the percentage of coworkers whom I've actually kept in contact with after either one left the company. Most coworker relationships are a matter of convenience. If that's what people prefer, then cool, but don't act like there's no such thing as human interaction outside the office.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by jtr1 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:29PM (#36864911)
There’s also a risk management side to this. If my social life is built around my office and then I get laid off, that’s a massive impact on my social life. Decoupling reduces that risk significantly.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by calvinmorrison on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:25PM (#36864836)
Yeah but it's not a choice to work 40ish hours a week talking and communicating for introverts that's pretty taxing. At least in office we had a few laughs and good times and some face to face. Now it's all the soul sucking without any of the benefits like grabbing lunch together or skivving off a meeting and smoking cigarettes behind the dumpster. After 40hr/s having to go out and do even more socializing is hard because i used my socializing juice up at work
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by ryneandal on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:55AM (#36864223)
> One of the most frustrating things in all the WFH vs RTO discourse is that there is this false dichotomy being presented. It's either extroverted people who are energized by others, or introverts who'd rather be in the dark closet by themselves.

Perfectly stated. I can be quite outgoing when I want to be, and in many of my previous jobs I enjoyed many of my colleagues, but now I can devote my energy to the relationships I value most.

I have four kids, time is undoubtedly my most valuable commodity. I don't think I'd be able to foster as many friendships if I was working in an office. I'm sure I'd have friendships with a few colleagues, but WFH enables me to devote myself to friendships as I see fit.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by rjzzleep on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:01PM (#36864355)
I have a question for people here. I absolutely value the time with my daughter and I actually enjoy working for home, I had been for the last couple of years, but it's becoming increasingly unbearable to do that with a nagging and micromanaging partner by my side who's life is COMPLETELY unstructured.

So I find myself longing for office time, not because I like office time, but rather because I feel like it might bring back some sanity to the relationship.

Am I the only one in that situation? What do you do? It's not like I can structure another individual, it would only work if they themselves recognize that they need structure, which they don't.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by ryneandal on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:40PM (#36865142)
My kids and wife know there is a rule during work hours:

When my office door is closed, I am not home (except for emergency, say broken limb or something). It takes some training, but they become accustomed to it.

You need to stress to your partner the importance of focus during work. This took an exceptional amount of effort for us because my wife is bipolar and when things are bad, her contributions become a trickle. Summer is always a trying time, because all the kids are home and she gets overwhelmed easily. Thankfully my employer is incredibly accommodating, so if I need to step away and resolve anything at home, they have faith that I'll see to my obligations.

There's certainly value in having a dedicated work area if possible. Your brain really likes having demarcation lines between work and home, so emulating that can help immensely.

It is important to note that WFH is NOT a silver bullet. It is not a solution for every employer/employee. It works incredibly well in many technological scenarios because of remote access and whatnot, but there are limiting factors. Both in bureaucratic requirements, "culture" fits, and domestic situations. What works for me in the Great Plains due to cheap(er) housing may not work in metro areas where some families are living in small apartments.

Don't feel obligated to make WFH succeed in your situation if you don't want to simply because its en vogue. I have dear friends that tried WFH and _hated_ it. Another option is co-working space or otherwise getting out of the house to focus on work. I find myself going to a local hiking trail area during spring/autumn to work outdoors, and it is refreshing.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by JohnFen on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:05PM (#36864435)
> Am I the only one in that situation? What do you do?

What I did (decades ago) was realize that when I was working from home, I needed to treat it the same as working in an office. What that meant was: I need a room that is exclusively "the office". When I'm in there, I'm working. When I'm not working, I'm not in there. And everyone else in the household has to adhere to one rule -- if my office door is closed, they cannot disturb me for any reason other than an actual emergency, just like if I were in an office outside of out home.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by bcrosby95 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:38PM (#36865111)
My rule is if the door is open or not. If it's open, come on in. If it isn't, only emergencies please!

We have 3 kids (5, 5, 8) and they can actually manage themselves for hours at a time. And I don't mean youtube, TV, or tablets. Just regular playing. My wife works part time so in the summer they don't have constant supervision in the morning.

This is where having more kids can be easier. 1 kid can be lonely, or be unable to get help if they hurt themselves. 2 can be a problem if a fight breaks out. With 3 you have someone who can come get you if there's a problem.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by CoastalCoder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:09PM (#36864524)
I did this as well. It took a little time, and a few rebukes, for my kids to understand it as a hard rule. But after that it's been smooth sailing.

It also helps that I majorly soundproofed my home office. Even well-intentioned kids will won't be silent for the entire work day.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by freedomben on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:24PM (#36864819)
I should try the soundproofing. 10 years in and the kids still don't leave me alone, and the rebukes were taking a real toll on the relationship. I work part time in a coworking space which has helped a bit, but it's a real struggle.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by CoastalCoder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:48PM (#36865289)
Let me know if you want to discuss soundproofing details. I'm happy to share some lessons learned.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by freedomben on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:16PM (#36867876)
Yeah that would be great! Is there much you can do without covering all the walls with foam? Even that might be a possibility, although I don't know if my wife would permit it
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by CoastalCoder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:30PM (#36868072)
Cool, will DM you.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by ryneandal on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:53PM (#36865380)
Aye, just gotta rip off the bandaid and make sure you're firm with the rules. My eldest boy has terrible separation anxiety and acted as though I had died for the first week or so, but adjustments were made and it's been relatively smooth sailing since.

I did acquiesce and allow interruptions when the door is open, for times I'm checking email or other administrative tasks. That same son has high-functioning autism so I do find myself bringing him in to calm him down on occasion.

I've found my wife is the one who refuses to follow these guidelines most often, lol.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by CoastalCoder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:48PM (#36866405)
> I've found my wife is the one who refuses to follow these guidelines most often, lol.

Oh. Solving that one is way beyond the pay grade of all HN users combined, I'm afraid :)

(Just kidding. But it would probably require a discussion with marital-counseling-level candor. So maaaybe not one to have in a public forum.)

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by itsboring on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:21PM (#36864762)
I went a step further and installed a keypad lock on my office door. I mean, I’ll admit that there are simpler ways to keep the kids out, but it looks cool…
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by freedomben on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:28PM (#36864888)
hey now that's an interesting idea ...

I did put a keyed locking door knob on in a previous house but for some reason haven't done it to the new house/office.

Did you have a hard time finding one that would fit an interior door? I had to hunt for awhile to find a keyed lock that would fit since they're all designed for exterior doors.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by itsboring on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:39PM (#36867275)
Checked my order history, the one I got was a “SCHLAGE FE575 PLY 626 ELA Plymouth Keypad Entry”. I don’t remember having any trouble installing this on an interior door (and I’m not very “handy” at all). That said, I don’t know much about doors, so can’t say for sure if it works everywhere. Maybe some interior doors are thinner or something.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by JambalayaJim on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:01PM (#36865535)
It's really frustrating that the discussion is often "just shut yourself in your home office", as if an extra room doesn't rent out for $1000/month in many cities.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by CoastalCoder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:15PM (#36867860)
I'm guessing the conversation is biased by the assumption that (remote only) tends to correlate with (not living in an expensive city).

I'm curious what the actual statistics are though.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by massysett on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:06PM (#36864459)
Try telling your partner to leave you alone?

Also, what’s your workspace? It helps if you work in a separate room with a door. Working in a central open spot like the kitchen table invites more interruption. Of course this is hard to do if you’re in a small apartment.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by freedomben on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:25PM (#36864838)
> Try telling your partner to leave you alone?

Some people who we love deeply, just cannot do this. If we're physically there, a reason to interrupt will always be found. IMHO it's not worth damaging the relationship.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by jtr1 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:35PM (#36865056)
I don’t want to read too deeply into your comments, but it may be worth exploring why expressing this need feels like it would damage your relationship. It could be that you both need to adjust your communication patterns to better express yourselves and hear each other.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by freedomben on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:23PM (#36864784)
I'm in a similiar boat, and I finally got a co-working space. Do it for your mental and relatinship health. If we want to be incredibly over-reductionist, $300 per month is a lot cheaper than a divorce :-D
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by MattPalmer1086 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:09PM (#36864514)
Tough one. Sounds like you need to communicate your needs to each other better, and agree some mutual boundaries.

While returning to the office as an escape may alleviate some symptoms, I would still recommend that you work on your relationship.

Edit: your partner may also have needs too, this isn't just about you getting what you want. It's about communicating better and respecting each others needs.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by jdwithit on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:47PM (#36865282)
Definitely sympathize, you are not alone. I have a wife and two young kids. I love her but for a long time my wife just did not consider me as "at work" when I was working remotely. She had zero qualms about coming into our home office to chat or see if I could change a diaper or whatever. I'm happy to help out if I'm between tasks (hell that's one of the perks of WFH, and everyone takes breaks wherever you're working. I'm taking one to write this post!) but it was all day every day and driving me up the wall. Plus toddlers don't care about work hours, if they want to see daddy they're going to come see daddy. We had plenty of conversations about how disruptive it is to have someone tap you on the shoulder while coding to ask if you can run to the grocery store for milk. But it never went anywhere. To her, if I was physically in the house, I was available to do stuff at any time.

To be honest we never "solved" it. Eventually the younger reached kindergarten age and my wife returned to full time work. I wish I had better advice. The suggestion to have a dedicated office space with a door is a good one, but if your partner does not respect boundaries that won't be enough. If finances allow, you could look at leasing a part time desk in a coworking space or even a dedicated office. I know it feels silly to pay for office space when you can do the job from home, but if it's damaging your relationship, it may be worthwhile. Some employers might even offer a stipend for remote workers to help offset costs. The fact that you refer to your partner as a nagging micromanager tells me something has to change.

I hope this post doesn't make me sound like a dick. I have immense respect for my wife for choosing to pause her career to care for our children. Raising kids is HARD, harder than the work I get paid for to be honest. We're partners in life and parenthood. But my role in the partnership at that time was to hold down a job and that's a lot harder to do when you're being interrupted 10 times a day. Hope you are able to work something out.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by biomcgary on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:13PM (#36865716)
Not possible in places with bad zoning or condos, but I converted a shed into a really nice office. It has a fence and a couple other features that create friction to get to it (even though only a few feet from the house). Helps a lot without being overtly distancing to the relationship.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by ceejayoz on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:48AM (#36864101)
> Sept 2021 (just before pandemic)

Are you in Tonga or something?

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by thebradbain on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:50AM (#36864123)
Do you mean Sept 2020? I believe everything shutdown (in most US states and European countries) in March 2020.

Only wondering because ~3 years versus a little less than 2 years seems like a potentially big difference, so wondering if that feeling of fulfillment has is still going strong that long

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by dimitrios1 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:15PM (#36864649)
Yes! Good catch. The COVID years still all feel like 1 long year..
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by flanbiscuit on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:50PM (#36865341)
Lockdown for me (lived in NYC at the time) started in March of 2020.

Curious what country you live in that Sept 2020 was "pre-pandemic" for you? It was already hitting hard in many countries by then.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by david_shaw on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @05:15PM (#36869696)
> Curious what country you live in that Sept 2020 was "pre-pandemic" for you? It was already hitting hard in many countries by then.

They almost certainly meant September 2019.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by thebradbain on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:09PM (#36881126)
Yup— that’s what I meant. dates and engineers don’t work well together
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by JambalayaJim on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:58PM (#36865480)
>(One of the most frustrating things in all the WFH vs RTO discourse is that there is this false dichotomy being presented. It's either extroverted people who are energized by others, or introverts who'd rather be in the dark closet by themselves. I am as extroverted as they come, and I thrived in the office environment. Still wouldn't trade WFH for the world.)

I believe the extrovert vs. introvert division is a false dichotomy in the first place.

Commute time, environment at home, career seniority - these are the most important factors in this discussion