News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by wffurr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:18AM (#36825275)
All the coverage on this memo has missed this point. I guess they can’t imagine a company giving its employees two computers!

You can BYO ChromeOS devices too which make great thin terminals to a remote workstation or cloud VM. I have a whole bunch from dogfooding preproduction Chromebooks.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by danpalmer on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:25AM (#36825316)
I feel like much of the internal coverage missed the point. There were a lot of people arguing in bad faith, ignoring the fact that the whole idea was clearly tied to the rollout of the particular workflow where no internet would be needed on the machines in question. Most devs still aren't working like that yet, and so pushed back hard.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by lokar on Saturday July 22, 2023 @10:46AM (#36826658)
A bunch of people with admin access used a setup like this for a while shortly after the china hack years ago. It’s not that bad.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by jeffbee on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:37AM (#36827124)
By “bunch” you mean the entire SRE org. I felt like it was a good setup, but I also felt that the long-term strategy of reducing the access necessary to operate the infrastructure was a good one. But why not both, as the child in the meme asks?
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by lokar on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:47PM (#36829185)
Far from all, mostly traffic and a few others
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by hinkley on Saturday July 22, 2023 @01:26PM (#36828019)
My first job out of college I ended up with the absolutely slowest box in the office, which definitely pushed me toward optimizing our app (it wasn't even good on fast machines, but it was tragic on slow), but compile times were murder.

We had a Sparcstation somewhere in the office being used as a mail server and nothing else. I don't recall how but I managed to SMB or NFS mount a directory so that I could edit code on my piddly little desktop but compile it on the Sparc. First time Java really worked as advertised for me.

Saved me loads of time and let me iterate on ideas that I don't think I or my boss would have had the patience for otherwise.

I'm not entirely keen on language servers, but those would be another area where distributed computing could come in handy. I think what might be missing though is a multitenant version. Everyone on my team has a duplicate model of our dependencies loaded into Webstorm and it's a pig.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by andrepd on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:58AM (#36833903)
>I ended up with the absolutely slowest box in the office, which definitely pushed me toward optimizing our app

Aside, but I 100% believe most developers of user-facing programs should be forced to use their app on a slow computer/phone with a slow internet connection before being able to ship it.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by wffurr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:12AM (#36826897)
It seems so weird to me to want to use Linux on the desktop. This is not The Year.

I decided at the very start of my career, before Google, to use a laptop at the primary interface and only use workstation / dev environment / etc. remotely. That way I have the same working experience at my desk, at a cafe, on my desk at home. The only thing that changes is the number and size of monitors. It's worked out really well, and during the COVID era it only got better due to investments in the remote workflows.

I wouldn't even notice if my VM lost internet access and root.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by 40yearoldman on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:29AM (#36827046)
I would still want Linux on my laptop.

It has been “the year” for Linux on the desktop for the last 10 years, even more so if you use Emacs as your WM.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by 8n4vidtmkvmk on Saturday July 22, 2023 @12:42PM (#36827675)
I've been using Linux since I started nearly 5 years ago, plus the previous 8 at my last company. I don't have any major issues.

SSH disconnects are still annoying. And mosh/tmux/screen don't do it for me.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by wffurr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:54PM (#36829241)
Mosh and tmux have worked great for me for the last 12 years. Different strokes I guess.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by throwbadubadu on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:21PM (#36828976)
What's wrong with the desktop at Linux, why "classical desktop" at all? I love my tiled wm setup so much since >10 years, and absolutely hate my corp windows desktop so much for everything it does to me. Gf similar regrets her chosing a private Mac Airbook everytime she uses it and swears to never buy one again every time she uses it (but uses it to seldom to consider just installing an Ubuntu, otherwise would do that)... so we are maybe strange people but

> It seems so weird to me to want to use Linux on the desktop. This is not The Year.

It seems so weird to me everybody considering their Windows or Mac as desktop ;)

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by omgmajk on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:23PM (#36828995)
> It seems so weird to me to want to use Linux on the desktop. This is not The Year.

Why? I've used it for many years and still like it very much. I use Windows too, but I do most of my work in Linux. Why would this be weird?

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by Ferret7446 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @08:59PM (#36831560)
I understand that a large proportion of Googlers use Google's slightly customized Linux on laptops (which is also the default/recommended), which is completely compatible with your workflow, so I'm not sure what argument you were trying to make (unless you don't count laptops as "Linux on the desktop"?)

I can only infer that you're suggesting people would only want to use Macbooks? Setting aside the fact that that is wrong, you don't make any argument as to why that would be.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by wffurr on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @10:13AM (#36878058)
Chromebooks are great too.

gLinux laptops are OK I guess? I dunno. Every time I've tried to use Linux as my main interface, it's been crashy and confusing. Maybe it's gotten better since the last time I tried.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by UncleMeat on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:31AM (#36827063)
Yeah this is the unfortunate outcome of the past two years. Memegen is now primed to take anything in the maximally critical way.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by shemnon42 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @02:53PM (#36828746)
Memegen has been toxic for way more than two years. Even before they gave the holiday bonus devices to school children.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by LargeTomato on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:30PM (#36829060)
The days of good faith, logical, respectful arguments is gone. Googlers (the ones on Memegen) have become a bunch of whining and bad faith actors.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by kajecounterhack on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:45PM (#36829743)
Memegen is unbearably whiny now, but doesn't feel like it's because Google hires whiners. It feels more like valid employee feedback, accurately capturing valid worker sentiment toward shitty, randomizing leadership.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by gipp on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:56PM (#36829847)
It can be both.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by kajecounterhack on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:38AM (#36833589)
The cultural shift was basically overnight, after big decisions by leadership. Seems to point to the latter rather than the former.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by LargeTomato on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:29PM (#36829045)
Memegen is toxic and, today, a net negative to the company.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by jeffbee on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:34AM (#36827105)
Is the internal discourse aware of “cleanroom” or has that institutional memory disappeared?
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by Nullabillity on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:03PM (#36829913)
Sounds like fighting against that sort of miserable workflow is part of the point.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by varelse on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:45AM (#36827207)
Sure, they give you two computers. But you better not ask for a GPU!
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by adolph on Saturday July 22, 2023 @01:00PM (#36827818)
Do you get one of those m2 coral to click in there?
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by philjohn on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:55AM (#36827307)
The other option is provisioning dev servers as VMs on big hosts, which some other companies do. That’s where the build and development happens, using an IDE locally on the issued laptop which uses remoting.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by Guvante on Saturday July 22, 2023 @01:00PM (#36827824)
I suspect it is mostly who supports build machines desktop support or network support.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by philjohn on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:35PM (#36838894)
True. In the case of my current gig, that's not an issue as there is a huge organisation supporting that and live services.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by grrdotcloud on Saturday July 22, 2023 @12:48PM (#36827716)
I've been 100% ChromeOS for ten years.

All my dev work, personal, and internet while I work. KVM to swap. External screens.

Strict separation of work and life. No key logging like the work system. No fillers.

Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by dheera on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:39PM (#36829135)
Good for you, my personal life often involves connecting to real hardware in the field and ChromeOS doesn't work for that.
Re:Google tries internet air-gap for some staff PCs by jrockway on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:58PM (#36829864)
I also ran that setup when I worked at Google. I liked it a lot. ChromeOS was a great desktop OS; even when I was in the office, I just ssh'd to my Linux workstation from a Chromebox. Thus, "local" and "remote" had the same experience.