News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by readams on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:19PM (#36749373)
I'm curious who has a problem that this solves. You need to have line of sight to something very nearby. So you'd need to wire 10Gb Ethernet to the LiFi points.

But then why not just use wired Ethernet?

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by afavour on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:36PM (#36749564)
> But then why not just use wired Ethernet?

This is a recurring question and one often answered by “people rent houses/apartments and can’t just run cables through the walls”.

I’m not all that sure what I’d use this specific technology for over Wifi but I can understand why people don’t use wired Ethernet.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by mabbo on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:45PM (#36749673)
I own my condo but have this exact issue. There are 1Mb Cat5 cables inside the cement walls and I cannot replace them if they ever break, nor upgrade them.

Already this is a problem as I have 1.5Mbit internet.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by sthuck on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:58PM (#36749799)
if you have coax cables in the walls then MoCA is a pretty good solution. (Powerline is not)

also dear god I hope it's a typo and you meant 1Gb

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by debaserab2 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @02:18PM (#36749983)
Is MoCA reliable? Just bought a new house and wiring Ethernet into some of the rooms will be tricky, but a previous owner already did coaxial in the whole house.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by Klathmon on Sunday July 16, 2023 @02:31PM (#36750094)
Extremely reliable, but it can get expensive to have to buy a moca to Ethernet adapter at each point.

You want to stick with moca 2, and there might be some gotchas with older coax wiring, but I previously ran it for years without issue.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by ryukafalz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:43PM (#36751220)
I think I'm running into some of those gotchas with older wiring. I've got moca adapters set up between a few rooms and have periodic dropouts on one of them, which unfortunately is the room with my wifi AP.

Traced the cables and the only splitter I can find is a moca 2 aware one, and the coax cable that would have been used for cable internet is unplugged so that's not interfering.

Nice when it works, real pain to troubleshoot when it doesn't.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by cj on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:55PM (#36753231)
2 things that solved my problems with moca was buying a moca adapter to filter the signal out from leaving/entering the house (adapter on the primary incoming coax) and then another adapter on the coax plugging into your cable modem.

This fixed some (probably modem specific) problems where internet would randomly drop in the presence of moca.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by ryukafalz on Monday July 17, 2023 @04:29AM (#36755545)
Right, I'm on FiOS so there's no cable modem, and as best I can tell the primary incoming coax line is disconnected.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by rayiner on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:51PM (#36749727)
What is one meg cat5? Isn’t cat5 rated to one gig?
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by ElectricalUnion on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:17PM (#36751015)
CAT5 is in theory only rated for Fast Ethernet (100M) while CAT5e is rated for Gigabit Ethernet. In practice is very hard to actually find a cable that meets only CAT5 and not CAT5e.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by nullc on Sunday July 16, 2023 @02:49PM (#36750235)
There is no such beast as 1Mb cat5. Do you mean 1gb? Assuming the cables are in conduit you may be able to use the existing cables to pull new cables. This usually works.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by mabbo on Sunday July 16, 2023 @02:53PM (#36750273)
Thank you, I had a brain fart and meant Gbit.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by ericbarrett on Sunday July 16, 2023 @06:48PM (#36752190)
> There are 1Gb Cat5 cables inside the cement walls

I believe you when you say you can't replace them, but I'm curious why? Every wire I've ever seen run through concrete was in a conduit that could have replacements pulled through it. Did they just run the wires and pour over them?

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by sclarisse on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:37PM (#36752499)
If you need speed and money is of limited concern, consider fiber. There are some nearly invisible configurations that stick onto the walls, and baseboards or crown molding can be a channel as well. It’s possible you could sneak it under a door, or through a small gap in the frame behind the trim. You might even be able to smuggle it through electrical conduit for short distances, since it’s non conductive (but don’t trust me on the safety or compliance issues of that, I wouldn’t trust myself, though I’ve seen zanier from the previous homeowners here...)

The obvious downside being the extra expense of media conversion.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by Dylan16807 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:28PM (#36752792)
At condo distances you should be able to do 10Gbps over cat5.

2.5Gbps isn't even going out of spec for cat5 and should go the full 100 meters.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by buildbot on Sunday July 16, 2023 @11:48PM (#36753818)
Not always, one link in my condo can only seem to do 5Gbps, 10 will drop the link. Despite several re-crimpings of the connector
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by wkat4242 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:11PM (#36765982)
Could be that it's snagged somewhere, flattening the twisted pairs?
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by buildbot on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:46AM (#36767898)
Oh no, maybe, but I would have no way to fix it. The run is literally from one side of the condo to the other, probably through the ceiling or floor. Or it's wired wrong, (and I lost my LED blinker somewhere :( ) because it's like 5Gb/s down and 1Gb/s up. Which is odd...
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by withinboredom on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:07AM (#36754376)
With no interference, wifi 2.5ghz can go several km at 100mbits.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by Nullabillity on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:05PM (#36752324)
How do you plan to provide line of sight through those same walls?
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by hulitu on Monday July 17, 2023 @03:37AM (#36755215)
A power drill can do wonders. /s

When everything else fails, ask an RF engineer. Metal is for RF like glass for light.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by Cloudef on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:13PM (#36752363)
I have apt with only 1 ethernet plug, but coax run to every room, so i used moca adapter to have wired internet everywhere, works great
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by cj on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:52PM (#36753219)
Same, realizing it's possible to convert coax cable outlets into ethernet is a game changer.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by supertrope on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:36PM (#36749565)
The same reason people use Bluetooth audio. It's more convenient because there's no cord. (But there's a battery to manage, interference, pairing, and inferior audio quality).
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by NortySpock on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:31PM (#36749512)
Conference halls, open plan offices, LAN parties, maybe data scientist teams sharing large datasets around a room...
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by ugjka on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:23PM (#36749409)
airports would be one case
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by antonvs on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:49PM (#36749708)
Just a vaguely related anecdote, I consulted for a company that had two offices on a river, in old converted houses, separated by a marina. Running a cable proved problematic for various reasons, both bureaucratic and relating to the nature of the site.

To connect the networks between the two buildings, they had a laser connection set up in the widow's walk on the buildings. It worked great except when it was foggy or raining very heavily, or when the marina moved a sailboat so that its mast blocked the beam.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by fy20 on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:22AM (#36754759)
Point to point WiFi links are pretty accessible nowadays. I bought a €60 no-name set from Amazon to link two buildings 250m away that don't even have line-of-sight (other buildings and trees are in the way) and it works good enough for my needs (CCTV).
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by robinduckett on Sunday July 16, 2023 @03:06PM (#36750383)
Two university buildings separated by a privately owned house or two springs immediately to mind. Not sure if they still do but my local university used to have IR links between buildings.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by readams on Sunday July 16, 2023 @03:16PM (#36750480)
They're not talking about point to point links here, but end-user devices.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by blincoln on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:39PM (#36751189)
Once it's widespread in consumer gear, I'm sure it's only a matter of time before people start hacking it to operate over longer distances, similar to what's been done with custom WiFi antennas, parabolic dishes, etc.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by lxgr on Sunday July 16, 2023 @03:25PM (#36750546)
Signals not propagating through doors or walls can be an advantage for many applications, both for capacity and privacy reasons.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by flashback2199 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @03:30PM (#36750586)
I'm imagining offices that put Li-Fi devices on the ceiling and laptops made with Li-Fi in the edge of the screen lid so that you can just open your laptop and it will start using the Li-Fi for faster speeds.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by haswell on Sunday July 16, 2023 @03:31PM (#36750598)
This would be fantastic in my current apartment. My immediate surroundings are completely saturated by WiFi access points across both 2.4 and 5.x GHz making all wireless connections unreliable at best, and the layout of my apartment is such that the only way to have a wired connection in the living room where my desktop sits is to run an ethernet cable across the floor.

So I run an ethernet cable across the floor, and it's not great.

I also think VR/AR use cases may benefit from this eventually.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by wyldfire on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:28PM (#36751105)
I wonder, does this pollute the IR on your apartment so that your TV remote would no longer work? Although with streaming set-top boxes, those are using RF most of the time these days.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by jorvi on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:09PM (#36752346)
It is virtually impossible you’re getting enough distortion from other 5GHz networks to matter, unless your walls are made out of tissue paper. I would recommend analyzing your own devices for faults.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by haswell on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:10PM (#36752687)
5GHz is significantly better than 2.4, but I still get latency spikes that make it unacceptable for gaming.

And my range it atrociously bad.

It’s an old building, and I live on the top floor just below a roof with assorted antennas. I think there’s some microwave gear up there that would explain my issues.

I’ve wanted to do a site survey for awhile to figure out what’s up, but have just lived with the Ethernet cable across the floor.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by jorvi on Monday July 17, 2023 @04:32AM (#36755560)
But that means your distortion issue is not 5GHz networks.

Way back when I was still in university, if I would walk out of my room and close the door (which would put a few cm thick wooden door, some plaster wall and about 14m between me and my router) I would already have a significant reduction in connection strength.

Even with the ridiculous walls Americans use for their homes, there is just no way a neighbors 5GHz signal is strong enough to cause significant distortion. And if there somehow is, there is enough room on the spectrum to choose a different band.

Thinking on it, almost all civilian microwaves also only operates at around 2.4GHz. And since you mention sudden spikes, I would check for radar interference and if you are on a band that’s radar-assigned.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by haswell on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:37AM (#36757478)
> Thinking on it, almost all civilian microwaves also only operates at around 2.4GHz.

This has not been my experience. I spent a number of years as a network engineer working with consumer microwave gear, most of which was in the 5.2-5.7 GHz range.

And I’ve seen what a poorly aligned backhaul can do to the wireless networks in the vicinity.

That said, I’m not committed to a specific reason it’s not working well here, it’s just not.

I think it’s a probably combination of factors since I live in a dense city. Radar is certainly a possibility.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by mr_toad on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:26PM (#36752780)
I can get a 5GHz signal in my bedroom through two interior walls. And some appartments do have very thin walls and ceilings .
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by oynqr on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:23AM (#36754441)
Thin dry wall with steel framing is pretty good at blocking wifi signals, as far as I recall.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by rsynnott on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:17PM (#36753046)
You could consider wifi6e; the 6GHz band probably isn't too noisy, for now.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by kccqzy on Sunday July 16, 2023 @10:57PM (#36753568)
In fact in my experience switching to DFS 5GHz channels would already make things much better. Many cheap access points don't support them at all.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by withinboredom on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:00AM (#36754346)
Until you get that radar sweep that cuts off your wifi for 30s.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by kccqzy on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:40AM (#36754550)
Depending on where you are, you might never get that.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by withinboredom on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:55AM (#36758278)
If you're anywhere within ~150km of an airport with radar, you will likely get hits on certain days (due to atmospheric lensing).
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by haswell on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:45AM (#36759630)
I’m in Chicago under an approach path to O’Hare, and Midway airport is within that range as well.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by kccqzy on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:54PM (#36761595)
Not just any airport but only airports with TDWR.

(There are none on the west coast: https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_TDWR.svg)

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by leonidasv on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:15AM (#36754025)
I have the same problem here and I'm considering buying a 6GHz tri-band (2.4 + 5 + 6GHz) Wi-Fi 6E router. Problem is: the only ones I can find are "gamer" routers bloated with features I will never use and priced 5x to 10x a regular Wi-Fi 6 (without the "E") dual band (2.4 + 5GHz) router.

Both my phone and computer supports 6GHz, but it's still hard to find a reasonably priced router.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by withinboredom on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:01AM (#36754351)
You can usually find them lightly used on eBay or Craigslist (or country equivalent). Then just flash it with DD-wrt or openwrt.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by oynqr on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:15AM (#36754400)
I was going to suggest the Banana Pi BPI-R3, but that still doesn't have 6 GHz. The successor to that one is going to have Wifi 7, but might not get supported by mainline OpenWRT.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by shoyer on Monday July 17, 2023 @03:07AM (#36755018)
Not sure if $199 is reasonably priced in your opinion, but the Nest Wifi Pro supports 6E.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by pizzapill on Sunday July 16, 2023 @11:35PM (#36753752)
Have a look at Ethernet over power cables. I had them in my last apartment where WIFI was bad and cable was unacceptable.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by haswell on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:43AM (#36759606)
I’ve actually tried this too! Had great luck at an apartment in the past, but the wiring here is also really old, and I had issues getting reasonable speed.

I need to look into newer generation Ethernet over power to see if it’d work better than the aging pair of plugs I purchased a number of years ago.

Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by pizzapill on Monday July 17, 2023 @04:23PM (#36763525)
My guess is that if the power cables suck the newer generation will have bad speeds too. If you have the option buy a pair with the right to return and try it. I was very happy with this solution.
Re:Infrared may no longer be a punchline, as IEEE approves 9... by themoonisachees on Monday July 17, 2023 @06:04AM (#36756104)
Someone mentionned VR headsets (if they can actually make the speeds advertised work)

Office spaces are going to eat that shit up. They are already running Ethernet everywhere, and they already have many wifi access points. This is probably lower-crosstalk, faster and more localized than wifi.