News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by isaacremuant on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:22AM (#36745731)
Personally, the childish "saying motherfucker is shocking/bold" style is a bit of a cop out to make a proper argument.

I don't even say it with the typical puritan TV USA mindset but just the, give me the facts, not the show. Yelling won't make you right, just 14. Specially when it's clearly not a visceral reaction but a thought out post.

It's like comedy that thinks saying fuck or shit is funny when that's basically the lowest bar of humor. Say it, but style matters, the word in itself is not funny (unless you're a kid and afraid of someone telling you off, again: boldness).

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by stavros on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:27AM (#36745772)
I agree, I like a well-placed swearword, but when used as a crutch for humor, it falls a bit flat.
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by alemanek on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:35AM (#36745842)
If you read it in Samuel L Jackson’s voice it makes it a lot better.
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by sigg3 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:51AM (#36745940)
While I appreciate the sentiment, I feel you're missing the point. This is akin to maddox's writing. It aims to strike a nice balance between satire and self-immolation, but might stumble in its attempts.

You're supposed to feel conflicted between the obnoxious tone and the rational message. The writing makes fun of know-it-alls while also making a well reasoned argument.

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by Typhon on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:29AM (#36746224)
It reminds me of the extreme advertising meme.
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by arcanemachiner on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:53AM (#36746455)
I don't think you can just say "Maddox" in 2023 and assume people will know what you're talking about.

maddox.xmission.com

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by logarhythmic on Sunday July 16, 2023 @01:06PM (#36749218)
I find it fairly cringe, personally.
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by isaacremuant on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:41PM (#36761391)
Just read a Maddox (didn't know who they were) post and, boy, is it full of edginess and self confidence to mask that they don't have a good point.

Of course it's easy to rant and monologue. Dozens of TV presenters do it but sometimes it's very easy to find fault in their subjectively humorous generalizations.

http://maddox.xmission.com/c.cgi?u=bob_dylan_is_a_podcaster

https://youtu.be/MMFj8uDubsE

Blowing in the wind, the first song that comes to mind, doesn't fit this at all.

A quick Spotify search through the most popular songs and I can't find any in 10-15 that fits that example soundbite he used, to extrapolate this "emperor's got no clothes" argument on bob Dylan.

I'm not particularly a fan of Dylan except a song here and there I like (looking at the list), but it just shows the style over substance and strength of argument.

To this, someone will call "don't be such a buzzkill, it's just a joke" and that's fine but then you've left the land of making valid points and into the self congratulatory "ironic" content.

I didn't miss the point, it seems, but you did miss mine.

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by mrits on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:27AM (#36746215)
Yelling or cussing doesn't make you 14. I like cussing and think that there should be more of it in technical literature.
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by pdntspa on Sunday July 16, 2023 @10:32AM (#36747431)
Agreed. The idea that words can bring curses or displease some fictional deity is a dated trope with no place in modern society. Which means the only reason left is that it displeases certain people to hear them... but fuck those folks for trying to impinge on freedom of speech
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by isaacremuant on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:56AM (#36758294)
This is not about freedom of speech. I explicitly stated it was not a puritan thing. Fuck your strawman, if you want. See? That did very little in terms of argumentation.

Now it was about using insults instead of proper arguments and pretending the mere use was funny. Which isn't.

Also, it's funny how you "insult" in generic third person because if you insult me directly you might get banned. Hey, feel free to insult me directly. I won't care. You just won't necessarily have a good argument because of it and you might also get your comment deleted, but let's see if you're as "brave" to argue with the would be censors then.

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by isaacremuant on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:01AM (#36758356)
You may also like writing in 1337speak. That's not an actual argument for it being an effective mechanism to convey an argument, which the website presumably tries to.

Finding an insult funny just because it's an insult is definitely childish, as I've said before and you haven't tried to address, it relates to rebelry against some authority, which just isn't there in this case.

I won't be offended by the insult, but using in the way the website in question does is just superfluous content and can effectively serve as an mechanism to hide less than solid points.

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by mrits on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:20PM (#36761048)
Your response is definitely childish. Not in the immature sense but an underdeveloped sense of historical social transformation.
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by isaacremuant on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @10:57AM (#36773456)
You've said nothing and basically held a mirror that says "no u".

How about you actually try?

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by mrits on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:29PM (#36778655)
It is now apparent that you are an actual child. Have a good one
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by isaacremuant on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:05AM (#36826835)
An actual child that signed up to HN in 2013 when they were 1 or something and has worked on the industry for a while, huh?

Running away with a false accusation and a dishonest "good wish" is just sad.

Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by scarface_74 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:58AM (#36746509)
Re:No CSS Club – because no JavaScript was not hardcore enough by lelanthran on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:04AM (#36746558)
> I don't even say it with the typical puritan TV USA mindset but just the, give me the facts, not the show. Yelling won't make you right, just 14. Specially when it's clearly not a visceral reaction but a thought out post.

Yeah, but if they had done it your way neither you nor anyone else would know about it.

Looks to me like they put a lot of thought into the marketing of that thought out post