News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by ano-ther on Friday July 14, 2023 @01:33AM (#36719860)
Honest question: what’s the appeal of a bike that needs an internet connection & app to unlock?
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by gnopgnip on Friday July 14, 2023 @01:36AM (#36719872)
If it’s stolen they will either recover it or replace it. And everyone knows this, so no one will buy a stolen one and they are less likely to be stolen.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by fh973 on Friday July 14, 2023 @01:59AM (#36719995)
If they're still in business.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by TeMPOraL on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:11AM (#36720065)
> And everyone knows this

You mean they know the vendor is an infinite supplier of free bikes to steal, deSaaSify, and sell to a different market?

Either way, the message doesn't spread itself; I wouldn't overestimate how much small-scale semi-pro thiefs know or care about bullshit tech startups.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Rebelgecko on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:33AM (#36720195)
Vanmoof's whole thing is recovering the bikes
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by hef19898 on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:45AM (#36720265)
Was, didn't work out as planned, did it?
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Bootvis on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:48AM (#36720665)
Yes, but not because of the anti theft features. The anti theft feature seems to have been a good idea.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by TeMPOraL on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:59AM (#36720371)
In a fight between a bullshit tech startup whose entire business model shows they're actively hostile to both customers and society at large, and minimally sophisticated thieves with access to a dedicated defeat toolkit that is surely already available to buy somewhere[0], I expect the startup to surrender first.

EDIT: the only real advantage VanMoof could have here is if they're selling shitty bikes and overpricing customers for the brand name. That would indeed deter most thieves successfully - by making stealing those bikes not worth the effort. Well, until the metal prices spike or something, and it's profitable to steal them and sell as raw material...

--

[0] - See e.g. cheaply available conversion kits for Bird scooters; IIRC they were being sold for something like $30. Though those had a plausibly legal use case: converting decommissioned or seized scooters. There were plenty of the latter, as following the example set by Uber, Bird also pretended law and society don't exist.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by j-a-a-p on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:23AM (#36720529)
Ah, now i am beginning to understand why they needed 200 million to develop a bike...
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by onion2k on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:21AM (#36720909)
Not any more, so owners will probably need to be a bit more careful now.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by barefeg on Friday July 14, 2023 @01:44AM (#36719907)
Maybe a clarification: it doesn’t need both the app and internet connection to unlock. There are 2 ways to unlock and one of them uses the app and Bluetooth (no internet).

In terms of the appeals, I see it the other way around. The app is just the means to get the feature set to work; people don’t buy the bike because it has an app. There might be other implementations of the features that don’t require an app.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by jjav on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:10AM (#36720054)
> Honest question: what’s the appeal of a bike that needs an internet connection & app to unlock?

I struggle to understand those who think something like that could be a good idea.

Isn't it obvious that an app will not be around for as long as a bike can last?

I have a bike from the early 90s, that's over 30 years. Does anyone think an app will be around even for 10 years, let alone 30+?

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by seu on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:36AM (#36720215)
> Isn't it obvious that an app will not be around for as long as a bike can last?

That's the softwarization of everything, with its in-built early obsolesce: they clearly expect you to start replacing your bike as frequently as you replace your phone, irrelevant of how long the hardware itself is still functional.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by andromeduck on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:34AM (#36721044)
The limiting factor is theft. You're paying a premium theft resistance.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by benoliver999 on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:21AM (#36720134)
I worry about this with most components of e-bikes. I suppose a mid-drive one is probably always gonna have parts you can replace but custom kit like VanMoof seems ready for landfill.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by bicx on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:27AM (#36720166)
My VanMoof is currently dead, awaiting to be shipped off to the VanMoof shop to supposedly replace a battery that is erroring out. Now I’m concerned that I’ll never be able to use it again, or that I’ll lose the bike completely if I hand it over to them for repairs just as they are being shuttered.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by madeofpalk on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:28AM (#36721524)
Heh. I just shipped my S3 to vanmoof 2 weeks ago and it was just repaired this week for what sounds like the same battery issue. I'm... not sure if I'll get it back either.

The website is telling me there's a charge for the shipping, but no way to pay it.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by bicx on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:07PM (#36727716)
It’s a shame. Basically it’s e-waste without a battery due to the e-shifter. Can’t even use it as a normal bike.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by jskrablin on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:21AM (#36720519)
You should be able to get years of support for established brands. They are all using similar/identical components (Shimano, Yamaha, Bafang mid drive motors, similar battery packs, etc). There's also aftermarket support/custmizations available for them.

Going with a small/exotic brand will always carry a risk of brand disappearing, no aftermarket options, hard to get spare parts, etc... And e-bike business is especially competitive these days so I wouldn't bet on some random hipster brand having any chance to survive in the battle against established brands.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by benoliver999 on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:20AM (#36720896)
Yeah I look at e.g. Bosch and it looks like a standardised size and fit. Bit ugly but removable and replaceable.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by RajT88 on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:01AM (#36720397)
A buddy of mine is a hardcore rider. He goes through a $5k bike every 5 years or so.

Could he refurb the titanium frames for newer parts? Maybe. At some point racing tech moves on and you need a newer frame for the latest and greatest stuff to fit.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by wrboyce on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:10AM (#36720454)
Right, but this is a commuter e-bike.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Foivos on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:02AM (#36720751)
What do you mean "go through"? What does a bike have that gets consumed to the point that you have to replace the whole thing?
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by midoridensha on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:40PM (#36753152)
Nothing gets consumed, he just gets bored with his 5 year old bike and wants something that has all the latest new tech. He probably got a new 12-speed bike in the last year just because it's 1 more speed than the older 11-speed bikes from 5 years ago, for instance.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by prmoustache on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:10AM (#36720809)
Your friend just want a new bike every few years, he doesn't go through it. I have been in that place. That doesn't mean older stuff becomes unrideable and unfixable.

You can find parts for nearly any kind of old/obsolete bike technology ever made in volume, even tires for odd wheel sizes that have been mostly abandonned can still be found.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by cr1895 on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:25AM (#36720953)
>At some point racing tech moves on and you need a newer frame for the latest and greatest stuff to fit.

Sure, but that's utterly irrelevant to daily commuter / city bikes, which Van Moof are.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by blackbeans on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:04AM (#36720763)
While what you are saying is true and the market is moving towards long term solutions because of environmental reasons, at the moment the lifespan of electric components in bikes is usually set at 5 years with 2 years of warranty for the consumer.

Bikes are made of aluminium these days instead of steel, which gives them a lifespan of about 10 years, certainly not 30.

If you buy an ebike, you must be prepared for maintenance and replacement of parts. That's the state of the market right now.

I agree that making an app mandatory for a bike is a bad idea, and I would never buy such a solution. However this is an urban city design bike, aimed at a specific group of customers who do value these kind of innovations.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by lm28469 on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:27AM (#36720981)
> Bikes are made of aluminium these days instead of steel, which gives them a lifespan of about 10 years, certainly not 30.

Absolute bullshit, especially for a city bike.

Stress cycle is an issue but city bikes are over engineered and don't see a lot of stress compared to every other type of bikes.

I've used alu bikes over 30 years old daily and I had no issues whatsoever, that's how I went to school everyday for 3 years, and that was a race bike that actually had been use for racing in the past

Online posts make it sound like alu bikes self destruct at 5 years and a day...

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by midoridensha on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:46AM (#36721143)
Old fashioned steel bike lovers live in an alternate reality where bikes not made of steel are all experiencing catastrophic frame failures left and right.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by blackbeans on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:52AM (#36721191)
My experience as long term employee of a big bicycle manufacturer is different.

Yes, aluminium can survive a long time. But in general steel has a better chance to survive. The category of city bikes are low cost bikes, and the frames are as well. They are not so over engineered as you think as it is a very competitive market. The first generation VanMoof frames for instance, were prone to breaking.

While it is possible for a aluminium frame to reach 30 years lifespan, in practice the lifespan is shorter. This is because steel is more forgiving, it can handle dents and scratches where aluminium is more prone to breaking. Also the frames are usually hand welded and this can too be a weak point as it is hard to perfectly weld aluminum. It doesn't mean you can't ride a 30 year old aluminium bike or that it will auto destruct. It does mean that the bike is unlikely to reach that age.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by aembleton on Friday July 14, 2023 @10:18AM (#36724384)
Is aluminium more brittle then? My aluminium frame has plenty of dents and scratches and its about ten years old. I've another thats 25 years old but isn't ridden as often.

Do you know what the median lifespan is of an aluminium frame? I guess it depends on how often its crashed?

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by lm28469 on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:30AM (#36721003)
> Isn't it obvious that an app will not be around for as long as a bike can last?

People under 25 don't know better, they genuenly haven't experienced anything else than Chinese made self destructing Bluetooth enabled plastic gadgets

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by vultour on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:51AM (#36721181)
This is why I struggle updating my old PHP apps. It sure would be nice to refactor it into something newer, but I really don't want to run it on some VC-funded wet dream that disappears one day with 3 hours of notice.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by madeofpalk on Friday July 14, 2023 @08:05AM (#36722658)
Honest answer - I don't expect the e-bike to last past 10 years. I expect(ed) that by the time the app was unavailable I would have moved on to a different e-bike for whatever reason.

I don't want a non-e-bike. I want a bike with pedal assist.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Daz1 on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:34AM (#36720206)
...You have less to worry about with regard to theft? I don't understand your question.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by walthamstow on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:35AM (#36720209)
I have an older model, the ES2, which can be unlocked by tapping a key code into the button in the handlebars. I don't ever use the app for anything, it's not even downloaded to my current phone.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Rebelgecko on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:41AM (#36720241)
You don't need an internet connection or the app, but that's the most convenient way - you can enter a PIN on the bike itself to unlock it.

I think the appeal (at least for me, I considered one but never got one) is that it makes the bike harder to steal. Someone can't just ride off on it after they cut your lock. I worry about leaving my $600 bike out in public, so I'd be super paranoid about a $2000+ bike.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by herrherrmann on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:09AM (#36720441)
Similar appeal for me! I have a neighbor with a VanMoof and they are one of the few bikes that can just be parked in a corner with a kickstand and doesn’t need to be locked to a metal bar or other static thing. And this VanMoof has been around in our backyard for quite a few years, so I suppose the “don’t steal me, I’ll be tracked” tactic works. That being said, once I tried riding a (older non-electric) VanMoof, I was shocked how terrible it felt to ride – So, I never considered getting one in the end.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by tjoff on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:19AM (#36720515)
Thought they just throwed them at the back of a van rather than biked away.

Either way you most likely won't recover it.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by mschuster91 on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:33AM (#36720590)
> Thought they just throwed them at the back of a van rather than biked away.

The point of Van Moof was to associate their brand with "don't steal our bikes because they will lead the police to your dump location".

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Rebelgecko on Friday July 14, 2023 @11:48AM (#36725687)
Most of the bike thieves around me are opportunists who live within a mile or two of the bikes they steal. Afterwards, they often just leave the bikes out on the street in semi-organized chop shops. Even for bikes without GPS, people have decent luck just cruising around freeway underpasses until the see their bike.

Regardless, part of the allure was the Van Moof has (had?) a program where if they couldn't recover your bike you'd get a new one for just $100

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by jansan on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:16AM (#36721409)
I once overheard a conversation at a bike shop where a customer complained that he could not switch on the light without using the app. On that day I knew I had made a good decision bying a steel frame non-battery bike.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Gasp0de on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:29AM (#36721540)
How does it prevent the thief from riding away? Does it block the pedals using the motor or something?
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by madeofpalk on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:35AM (#36721603)
Kind of. There's a pin in the rear hub that physically engages when locked, preventing the wheel from turning.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by tiku on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:13AM (#36720478)
The appeal was that the bike signalled that you are not just a normal bike rider. You are one of the few lucky enough to be able to afford one.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by jillesvangurp on Friday July 14, 2023 @03:26AM (#36720545)
The appeal is that thieves need to do the same thing. Which limits the value of the bike for them because it makes it easy to track them down. It's part of the theft protection. Which, if you've ever had your bike stolen is a big selling point for these bikes. Theft is a reason why I've never bothered with premium bikes. Because you can't take them anywhere and expect them to not get stolen. Van Moof changed that. They can be stolen of course but it's a lot of hassle and bike thieves learned pretty quickly that there's very little point in doing so as they'll go through a lot of trouble to track down the bike. Which means it's risky.

Van Moof actually had an insurance policy that you could buy that included a guarantee to either track down your stolen bike or replace it. The so-called bike hunters would attempt to track down the bike. And stealing one involves dealing with a very loud and obnoxious alarm that is motion triggered that can only be disabled by unlocking the bike.

Those were all good things. What's not good is all the proprietary components, the poor quality of those, and the over dependence on the Van Moof servicing. That's what's killing the company. Basically classic VC funded company problem: great idea and product but hopeless execution resulting in a company that has a lot of cost but no profits making that problem worse through rapid growth and inflated investor expectations. The debt bubble burst last year, they are running out of cash now, and game over pretty much.

I actually have a lease bike from a company called Swapfiets here in Berlin. Very nice deal. I pay them per month and the bike is basically ignored by bike thieves and vandals. There are hundreds of thousands of these bikes across Europe. Each bringing in revenue through a subscription. Genius idea.

The bike is decent but nothing special. What they sell is peace of mind. I get to ride a decent bike and not worry about it getting stolen. Very low tech solution; the bikes are just very recognizable which means selling them is not a thing for thieves. If it gets stolen and I can show the key, my risk is 60 euros. I've had one for three years now and I park it all over town in all the hot spots where bikes get stolen, vandalized, etc. without a second thought. Not a single incident.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by ensocode on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:30AM (#36721013)
This. I also would not like my bike to rely on an internet connection. At least in my view this lowers the value of the bike.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by midoridensha on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:40AM (#36721089)
>Theft is a reason why I've never bothered with premium bikes. Because you can't take them anywhere and expect them to not get stolen.

Maybe where you live. Here in Tokyo, bike theft isn't a big problem, and there's lots of reasonably expensive bikes (and e-bikes) parked on the sidewalk with just a lock through the wheel spokes.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by jillesvangurp on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:04AM (#36721298)
You'd be shocked anywhere in the Netherlands (I'm Dutch) at how common bike theft is. We have actual secured parking garages in many cities to counter the problem. The larger ones in Utrecht and Amsterdam have room for many thousands of bikes and they are used a lto.

Berlin where I currently live isn't much better but they've not yet introduced parking garages for bikes as far as I know.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by midoridensha on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:21AM (#36721451)
Netherlands is a wealthy developed nation; how did it get like that? It sounds like a lack of enforcement, or some kind of problem with an unrecognized socioeconomic underclass. Here in Tokyo, this kind of problem with theft is unheard of. Most bike theft is just joy-riding, and is deterred by using a wheel lock (goes through the wheel spokes, so it can't be easily ridden). Of course, this is also a place where you can put your phone and wallet on a table in a cafe to reserve your seat while you're in the bathroom...
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by tnolet on Friday July 14, 2023 @06:27AM (#36721953)
Everyone in NL has like 2.3 bikes on average. They are many times treated as essentially throw away items. Not for the up upmarket segment, but for the casual bikes.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by avar on Friday July 14, 2023 @10:06AM (#36724219)
(I immigrated to The Netherlands from another developed nation).

It's weird, the main oddity is that it's just not considered theft in the same sense.

Before E-Bikes took off ~10 years ago everyone living in a city had a €50-300 beater bike "omafiets" for commuting, if you went out you were expecting your bike to be stolen on occasion.

So, you'd steal someone else's bike, either personally, or if you were downtown a junkie would ride past every 10 minutes offering a freshly stolen bike for €50 euros, which if you were smart you could easily haggle down to €5-20.

When pressed (especially after a few drinks) almost every city dwelling Dutchie you meet will admit to having stolen a bike, or bought a "second hand" one that's obviously stolen. I'm talking about people who are well off, went to University etc.

So bikes simply weren't personal property in the usual sense, and admitting to stealing one was no big deal, even if admitting in the same company to stealing a car would make you unemployable.

People stole your bike. You stole theirs. It all worked out in the end.

Now, this has really been upset by the E-Bike boom, now people are communiting in the same cities as 10 years ago, but on bikes costing 5-20x as much when adjusted for inflation.

So there's been some adjustment, but not really. The police still don't care about your stolen bike, and realistically you'll face zero consequences if you buy and use a stolen bike.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by jacquesm on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:41AM (#36772014)
> When pressed (especially after a few drinks) almost every city dwelling Dutchie you meet will admit to having stolen a bike, or bought a "second hand" one that's obviously stolen.

Complete bullshit. There are people that steal bikes and there are people that buy bikes they can reasonably assume have been stolen and then there is everybody else, where everybody else is by far the larger fraction.

I've lived in Amsterdam for roughly half of my life and that statement really irks me, especially since you seem to use this as a fig-leaf for your own illegal behavior. The lack of enforcement against bike thieves is vexing, but not as vexing is people that move here and that then engage in criminal acts.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by vr46 on Friday July 14, 2023 @07:13AM (#36722257)
Bike theft is rampant in London, but I never had any worries with the X2, combination of inbuilt-lock and an Almax chain saw to that.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by tgv on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:04AM (#36721292)
Idk the Berlin market, but in The Netherlands, homebase of Swapfiets (literally: swap bike) as you probably know, a decent secondhand bike costs €100-200. Nobody comes to fix your tire, but if it doesn't get stolen, it's a lot cheaper than a Swapfiets. Still quite a few of my (younger!) colleagues have a Swapfiets. I don't really get it.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by Gasp0de on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:26AM (#36721498)
Swapfiets business model are people who are not willing to do even the simplest maintenance tasks and therefore can not use any cheap or expensive bike longer than a few months. Astonishingly, this seems to be working great in the netherlands. In my hometown in germany, where 1/5 of the population are students, they tried but closed down again. My assumption is that this was due to the fact that it is common to repair your own bike here, the uni even has a bike workshop for the students.
Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by ornornor on Sunday July 16, 2023 @05:35AM (#36745117)
> The appeal is that thieves need to do the same thing.

Couldn’t you achieve that with a hardware key though? You don’t really need a server and still have a hardware Bluetooth key that is secure with the bike being useless without it? Then you don’t depend on a company staying afloat and granting you the privilege to keep using your bicycle as they see fit/VC greed dictates.

Re:VanMoof encryption key exporter by madeofpalk on Friday July 14, 2023 @05:26AM (#36721501)
It doesn't need an internet connection & app to unlock.

It needs an internet connection to initially get the bike's encryption keys. After that the app can communicate with the bike over bluetooth without internet access.

And then, you actually don't even need the app to unlock the bike. You can unlock the rear hub by entering a passcode physically on the bike without the app. Occasionally the app/bluetooth conked out and I had to unlock using the code.