News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by inciampati on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:15PM (#36669453)
> So if gravity is quantized, that means space-time is also quantized. But that doesn’t work,

But... How could space-time not be quantized? That would imply the existence of infinities in the structure of the universe. It is like the ultraviolet catastrophe but in space-time.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by marcosdumay on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:37PM (#36669868)
If space is not quantized, but everything that applies into it is, there is no reason for a catastrophe but the behavior is still different from a quantized space.

Just like the ultraviolet catastrophe was solved by quantizing the photons, not the energy levels.

(What I don't know is if there is some space-space interaction that can't be quantized at the "interaction" level instead of the "space" one.)

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by H8crilA on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:24PM (#36669640)
For the layman, what exactly is going to theoretically "explode" if spacetime is continuous?
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by naasking on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:40PM (#36669956)
The article discusses this question actually, about the apparent incompatibility between classical and quantum systems. Basically, there's a fundamental inconsistency where you can detect a particle's position gravitationally as it passes through a slit in the double slit experiment, which destroys the quantum properties of "passing through both slits" that leads to interference patterns.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by H8crilA on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:05PM (#36670440)
Oh no I get that, but two comments above inciampati was suggesting that we will end up in a situation where some variable will have to have an infinite value. Like, famously, with the ultraviolet crisis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultraviolet_catastrophe

Detecting (something about) the particle through gravity would at best remove the interference, not create an \infty somewhere in the model, implying that the model is self inconsistent.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by naasking on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:20PM (#36671561)
> Oh no I get that, but two comments above inciampati was suggesting that we will end up in a situation where some variable will have to have an infinite value

The black hole information paradox from that article presumably fits. The conclusion from GR is that no information can escape, which is ultimately incompatible with QM, and that conclusion ultimately depends on the infinite density of the singularity.

I think the more charitable reading is that we'll find situations where either no sensible calculation can be done, or the sensible calculations we do churn out nonsense. Divergence in the UV catastrophe was an example of that, and Baez covered more here:

Struggles with the Continuum, https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.01421

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @06:42AM (#36679081)
Problems 1-3 there are caused by point particles, not by space. They mention ultraviolet catastrophe was caused by continuous space, but it was caused by non-quantum radiation, so there's no classical electrodynamics with discreet space, instead there's quantum electrodynamics with continuous space.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by naasking on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @11:54AM (#36682800)
I'm not sure what "problems 1-3" are referring to here, but all of these problems fundamentally trace their roots to issues with the foundational assumption of continuity.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by GoblinSlayer on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:34AM (#36691450)
Per numbered titles:

1 Newtonian gravity

2 Quantum mechanics of charged particles

3 Classical electrodynamics of point particles

They explicitly mention they use point particles. Problem in 1 Newtonian gravity is especially egregious example. They model planets(!) as material points and see how they come infinitely close to each other. The author does mention these problems are pure math unrelated to reality.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:43PM (#36674022)
Zeno would win. And though he is thousands of years dead at this point, I'll be damned if I'm going to let that happen.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by peterfirefly on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:18PM (#36669510)
Wouldn't random noise work instead?
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by omnicognate on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:42PM (#36669994)
But as far as we know there is just such a singularity inside every black hole. (We don't know there really is, but unlike the ultraviolet catastrophe we have no evidence there isn't.)
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by urinotherapist on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:01PM (#36673570)
So, it's like a bubble in a pressured bottle of water.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by CuriouslyC on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:16PM (#36670657)
People talk about how space time can't be quantized as if the universe was made up of tiny little cells like minecraft because there is some evidence against that hypothesis.

An alternate hypothesis, that a particle is "virtual" and its position/momentum "vector" contains a finite amount of information, is actually both extremely plausible and explains odd paradoxes like the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. That would result in "quantized" spacetime for the same reason floating point numbers are imprecise.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by guerrilla on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:50PM (#36671178)
I was told that this is exactly what the Bekenstein bound ultimately means. It seems reasonable to me, but then why is that not conclusive?

Also if anyone who knows wants to explain why the Bekenstein bound is even a thing, I'd love to hear that too.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by consilient on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:37PM (#36671817)
Exceeding the Bekenstein bound would mean having less-than-equilibrium free energy. See https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.07184
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by guerrilla on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @02:55AM (#36677329)
Hmm so that would be a system being out of equilibrium but in a "negative" direction, which is nonsense since any amount of non-equilibrium is a positive amount of free energy.

So, I don't understand any of the math in that paper but is there any easy/intuitive way to explain why a higher information density would require negative free energy?

I guess I need to understand the relationship between information density and free energy first. Hmm.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by consilient on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @11:53AM (#36682778)
> So, I don't understand any of the math in that paper but is there any easy/intuitive way to explain why a higher information density would require negative free energy?

Not really, no. If you don't have the equivalent of a good undergraduate education in physics very little about QFT is going to be accessible to you.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by guerrilla on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @12:56PM (#36683776)
I guess I'll have to wait for the PBS SpaceTime video then...
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by srlowe on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:18PM (#36670683)
Doesn't the plank distance imply quantization of space? At least in relative terms.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by consilient on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:41PM (#36671055)
No, Planck units have no intrinsic physical significance. They're just convenient to work in because they set the numeric values of several different physical constants to 1. The planck distance also happens to be roughly the length scale at which we expect quantum-gravitational effects to become significant, but roughly here means within a few orders of magnitude.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by srlowe on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:17PM (#36671521)
Oh, really? I totally misunderstood then. I thought I knew physics a little better than that! Thanks.

EDIT: Hmm, so doesn't the fact that this particular value makes the math simplified not also imply some kind of meaning?

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by consilient on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:47PM (#36671960)
> Hmm, so doesn't the fact that this particular value makes the math simplified not also imply some kind of meaning?

No. There are plenty of other sets of constants you can choose to set to 1, inducing other length scales. Only dimensionless constants have physical meaning in isolation; dimensioned quantities are meaningful only with respect to each other.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by srlowe on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:41PM (#36672643)
Thanks for the explanation. I had to google "dimensionless constant" lol. Maybe it is all just math at the foundation after all!
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by Iwan-Zotow on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:59PM (#36675929)
Fine structure constant, famous alpha ~1/137. It also means that you could multiply or divide what we know as Plank length and it still would be a "valid" unit to be a minimum length entity
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by jacquesm on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:21PM (#36670744)
Planck.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by srlowe on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:16PM (#36671509)
Right, sorry.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by Gordonjcp on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:50PM (#36671176)
But space is quantised, that's what Planck's Constant is.

The oddity we see with things at relativistic energies is simply because - as with all discretised representations of continuous-time systems - things get a bit fucky close to Nyquist, and the maths breaks down.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by fsh on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:05PM (#36671365)
There is zero evidence that space is quantized, and this would contradict the Standard Model, as well as General Relativity. The Planck constant gives the relation between the energy of a photon (or more generally a harmonic oscillator) and its frequency. It has nothing to do with the structure of space.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by Gordonjcp on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:37PM (#36671812)
Whooooooooooooooshhhhhhhhhhhh...

Go and touch grass.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by dang on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @02:37PM (#36685378)
Could you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait? You've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly. It's against what this site is for, so we have to ban accounts that keep doing it, and we've already had to ask you this more than once:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36449159 (June 2023)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34194236 (Dec 2022)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33501516 (Nov 2022)

Nothing Phone (1) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32086641 - July 2022 (97 comments)

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by zerodensity on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:57PM (#36672102)
How exactly does quantized space-time contradict the Standard Model and General Relativity?
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by consilient on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:24PM (#36672434)
It would break Lorentz symmetry, for one.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by edgyquant on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:04PM (#36672177)
You’re thinking of Planck scale which is just a mathematical abstraction not some physical thing we’ve observed.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by jfengel on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:33PM (#36672556)
That's not what Planck's Constant is. Planck's Constant connects energy to length (in space or time). It's just a way of shifting units around.

You're thinking of the Planck Length, which is the result of combining the Planck Constant with the speed of light. It also happens to be the wavelength of a photon so short that its energy makes it a black hole, connecting it to gravity.

It's often presented as if it were the fundamental unit of length, but that's a guess at best. There's no specific reason to believe it, other than the fact that it happens to be a way to connect length, charge, and gravity. That's evocative, but hardly proof. There's neither evidence for it nor a well-supported theory behind it.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by Gordonjcp on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:59PM (#36674768)
I know what Planck's Constant is, probably rather better than about half the folk on HN.

Do you know what a joke is? Maybe it's a bit elaborate for Americans?

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by cornel_io on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:19PM (#36674922)
I think it didn't land because so many people are in the comments seriously arguing almost exactly what you were saying as a joke. Tough environment for parody to thrive in, alas...
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by Gordonjcp on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @03:54AM (#36677781)
I'm currently spending a lot of time in La-La-Laplacian Land, so maybe my sense of humour is currently a bit warped. A bit like my filter responses, really.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by mrguyorama on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @01:49PM (#36684602)
HN as a forum is no better than a pub or bar in a wealthy city. You cannot spout off an extremely common layman misconception and expect people to recognize that as a joke. Most of us are laymen in this area.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by jfengel on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:42AM (#36680850)
I'm afraid I don't get the joke, but that's on me. I apologize.
Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by eigenket on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:01PM (#36672159)
I think this entire comment thread is using the wrong definition of the word "quantized". There are two relevant meanings of this word

1. Something split up into discrete chunks (like integers vs real numbers)

2. Something which acts quantum mechanically (i.e. with superposition and entanglement and all that stuff)

In this context "space-time is also quantized" means space-time is acting like a quantum system.

Whether space-time is discrete or continuous is a wholly seperate question. There is no particular evidence that it is discrete, but if you make the discretization scale small enough it theoretically could be. Most things work more nicely if it is continuous though.

Re:The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy by rovuephysicist on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:15PM (#36672321)
I'll be accused of word salad by random bystanders, but whatever. You can ask ChatGPT to extract what it means if it seems too arcane or dense.

Reality is analog. There are no quantum superstates. The very notions of a quant and a superstate necessarily imply that the former has an evaluator and is traversing a finite decision tree, and that the latter is infinite and is never actually determined.

Consider the following: A train track is laid into a loop. A train enters into the loop. The track leading to the loop is removed. Can the train ever "begin" or "end"? No, because the very notion of beginning and end imply a finiteness that doesn't and cannot exist in an infinite loop. It is a category error.

Quantum mechanics, if anything, supports the assertion that mechanistic digital reasoning machines (of which humans are a type) cannot investigate themselves because it invokes a fundamental race condition of knowing two conditions simultaneously. This limitation implies a single locus of control in the very means that mathematics and physics are understood. Consciousness cannot traverse two trees simultaneously, but only one at a time, thus determining the outcome.

A map cannot be as accurate as the territory it measures without becoming as complex as the territory. Even further, a map that hypothetically is as complex as the territory must also contain itself in all conplexities, which is a logical impossibility resulting in infinite recursion. Reality as analog can handle such events, but philosophy as found downstream of Aristotelian logic and quantum mechanics by definition cannot.