News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by delecti on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:55AM (#36666501)
I'm perplexed at the implication that we "decided" to have the number of time zones that we do, rather than just acknowledging the reality that the US is a fairly big country. It's cheating a bit with Alaska in the picture, but the US spans about twice the degrees of longitude as Europe, and it would still be solidly "wider" even if you limit to the lower 48 states.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by RegnisGnaw on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:04AM (#36666637)
It is "decided" which is correct. With 24 hours a day and 360 degrees of longitude, it should be simply 15 degrees per hour.

The number of time zone that a country has is a political choice, perhaps based on geography somewhat. The size of each time zone is also variable depending on the choice the government makes.

* Look at China for example, one time zone.

* India is the same with one time zone.

* Mountain Time Zone in Canada actually stretches across 4 time zones (-9, -8, -7, -6)

* The Pacific Time Zone in Canada actually stretches across 2 time zones (-8, -9)

* Newfoundland in Canada should be geographically in the -4 time zone, but it choose to do -3.5 instead. If that's the proper value, then I'd argue Maine should be in -4.5 instead of -5.

* France should be in the UTC time zone with a tiny slice in the +1 time zone. In reality it is in the +1 time zone.

* Heck, why does time zones go from UTC-12 to UTC+14? What's with the values above UTC+12?

See: https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-0eb6e2b279845c866f903...

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by shinjitsu on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:24AM (#36666929)
>then I'd argue Maine should be in -4.5 instead of -5. Maine knows it should be in Atlantic, it just doesn't want to be more isolated from the rest of the country than it already is https://www.pressherald.com/2017/04/27/maine-may-switch-to-a...
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by RegnisGnaw on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:27AM (#36666952)
I think it should be either a -4:30 or -4:45 time zones instead :)
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by cvoss on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:11AM (#36666731)
And there's also the decision to use hour-aligned timezones. Why not half hours? Why not two hours? It's very much a conscious decision.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by wpietri on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:33AM (#36667046)
Previous to the rise of the railroad, each place's time was based on solar noon. That is, when the sun was at the highest point. Which worked fine. It only became untenable when you needed to manually maintain and publish a railroad schedule. So time zones became a thing. Initially they were on a per-railroad basis, but eventually they got unified.

But now we have computers to do all the bookkeeping. So if we wanted, we could not only return to the previous approach, but take it further to infinite time zones. Your noon is whenever the sun is overhead for you. Our calendars always include locations for events, so the time difference is compensated for. Google Maps knows that if you're traveling east or west a significant distance to make it to an event, it needs to adjust the time. Etc, etc.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by JamesLeonis on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:55PM (#36669141)
Knowing the longitude between yourself and the event is enough information. A sundial is always locally correct as well. This could be calculated in Airplane Mode using only GPS too. Longitude 0 would be the universal clock for network applications.

Uh oh. I'm starting to think this is a good idea...

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by postmodest on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:49PM (#36671991)
We should discuss this in a zoom call. I've scheduled it for eleven-fleventy χm. Don't be late!

...the need to synchronize global tasks means that either you have easily-offset local times, or you just use UTC everywhere and keep it in your head when local wake / sleep is and refuse synchronized tasks outside those times.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by wpietri on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:56PM (#36672094)
No, that's part of the manual-scheduling paperwork. I get that you're used to it, but we could eliminate it. The dialog would go more like: "I looked at our calendars and put it at a time that seems to work for both of us. Feel free to move it if that's better for you." Which is what I often do anyhow with Google Calendar with shared access (as when we work for the same company) or as with Calendly.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by pseudalopex on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:57PM (#36673513)
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by wpietri on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:20PM (#36702461)
That is a good rant, but I think it's wildly overstated. E.g., The whole notion of a timetable is an early-railroad-era artifact. By modern standards, it's a terrible interface. Them not being viable is great.

I should note that I'm not seriously proposing it. My point is more to get people thinking. Our current hodgepodge approach is extremely historically contingent. I personally believe that there's no good solution to this, just different bad ones.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by chickenpotpie on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:20AM (#36666866)
1 hour is easy to remember, makes the math easier, and not so far apart that it creates radically different concepts of time for people on the extreme ends.

With one hour time zones: * If someone is 3 time zones ahead, they're 3 hours ahead * There are 24 time zones and 360 degrees neatly divides by 24 * 2 hours between time zones means that within a time zone, the sun rises on one side at 8 am and on the other side at 10 am.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by RegnisGnaw on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:43AM (#36667188)
We have :30 and :45 time zones though, no :15 time zone. So that doesn't quite apply.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by chickenpotpie on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:00AM (#36667450)
Doesn't it?

I was explaining why 1 hour as the standard makes sense instead of 30 minutes or 2 hours. The :45 time zones would still be an issue for 30 minute intervals and :30 and :45 are still an issue for 2 hour intervals

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by RegnisGnaw on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:13AM (#36667615)
But the 1 hour is not a standard, we have many places with :45 and :30 time zones. For example, Newfoundland is -3:30 time zone. Nepal is in a +5:45 time zone.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by chickenpotpie on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:53AM (#36668189)
Again, I never said it was the standard. I was saying why 1 hour offsets make more sense than 15 minutes or two hours. I never said different offsets don't exist, I said why they make less sense
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by Ferret7446 on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:29PM (#36674997)
And those exceptions demonstrate why it's a bad idea to go beyond hour offsets. It's just added hassle.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by throwaway09223 on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:19AM (#36666846)
Why have time zones at all, and not simply recognize that day and night occur at different times in different places?

This part wasn't a conscious decision, because the reference frame of time and orbital mechanics were discovered long after the practice of timekeeping. We may have a similar problem on a galactic scale some day.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by Vvector on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:59AM (#36667426)
The primary issue is when the day changes in the middle of the local day. Assume everyone adopts UTC. Then in California, midnight will happen at 5pm local time.

  * Friday UTC 2300 = local time 4pm PST  - This is Friday
  * Saturday UTC 0100 = local time 6pm PST  - Is this Saturday?
  * Saturday UTC 2300 = local time 4pm PST next day  - This is still Saturday?
When would Saturday afternoon be? We'd have to change our vocabulary, and I don't see that worth it.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by throwaway09223 on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:06PM (#36673646)
We don't have to change any vocabulary. Noon and midnight happen at different times in different places and that would be fine. We know it's fine, because that's how it currently is in China.

Most servers run on UTC under the hood, and a lot of big organizations have experience already in terms of doing all timekeeping calculations in UTC. It may seem weird, but works pretty well in the long run -- and not having to deal with corner cases like DST or geographical ambiguities around time is extremely valuable.

Have you ever thought about what it's like to live near the edge of a timezone? In a city where half the city uses one time and half uses the other?

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by Vvector on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:34AM (#36680098)
"Let's go see a movie Saturday afternoon." "I need this done by Thursday." All these statements are common and completely understandable by everyone. Change to UTC, and the statements are ambiguous. It will confusing for so many people, with no obvious benefit.

China is fine, because the day doesn't change during daylight.

Yeah, computers should use UTC. It's easy for them to convert to/from local time for the user. This is what computers are good at.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by RegnisGnaw on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:20AM (#36666859)
There :30 time zones and :45 time zones. Oddly, no :15 time zones.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by retrac on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:20AM (#36667714)
Probably because we like round numbers.

But there are half-hour aligned time-zones. Newfoundland is -3.5. It's currently 11:20 am here in Toronto and 12:50 pm in St. John's. Then there's the Chatham Islands of New Zealand with a quarter hour offset at UTC +12:45.

There are also regions where two bordering time zones change by more than 1 hour. At the Pakistani-Chinese border you gain or lose three hours.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by retrac on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:26AM (#36667813)
China's time zone is interesting, mostly a reflection of the fact that like 80% of the population lives in a north-south strip along the coast, largely within one "natural" time zone. The further you are from the east coast, the weirder it is. It may be 7 am in both Beijing and Urumqi, but everyone in Urumqi is still asleep because the sun won't be up for a couple more hours.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by ianburrell on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:20PM (#36670725)
The far west of China sometimes uses a local time zone, Xinjiang Time that is two hours ahead. That indicates that two hours is too far for one time zone. I get the impression is that usage of local time is on ethnic lines and may have disappeared after crackdown.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by izzydata on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:13AM (#36666753)
I'm more perplexed that China decided it should only have 1 timezone. It also decided that timezone should be from the perspective of the eastern coast. When does the sun rise and fall for the western most people?
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by throwaway09223 on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:21AM (#36666884)
Why shouldn't we have one timezone? Why not have one worldwide timezone?

The sun rises and sets at different times according to both latitude and longitude. Timezones only handle longitudinal daylight adjustments. We already deal with plenty of incongruity around daylight.

Why not embrace the variability and let go of the idea that we can predict daylight based on the hour alone? Let people localize the time to discover where the sun is.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by ooterness on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:36AM (#36667102)
Why even use time that's linked to the rotation of our home-planet? That's as geo-centric as it gets.

Just count the number of seconds since the GPS epoch in a galaxy-centered inertial frame. This post was made at 1,373,034,914.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by shpx on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:56AM (#36668226)
A second is one 86400th of a rotation of our home-planet
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by rpearl on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:22PM (#36668599)
A second is defined to be exactly the duration of 9,192,631,770 periods of the radiation corresponding to the transition between the two hyperfine levels of the ground state of the caesium-133 atom.

I don't see anything referencing any planets?

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by throwaway09223 on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:12PM (#36673730)
Well, a second is more specifically defined as:

"the duration of 9,192,631,770 periods of the radiation corresponding to the transition between the two hyperfine levels of the ground state of the caesium-133 atom taken as an average over 11 samples distributed throughout the earth in order to approximate the earth's inertial frame"

Seconds as used in Coordinated Universal Time are in fact defined based on planets, and earth specifically - because they use earth's inertial frame.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by rpearl on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:05AM (#36690352)
The SI definition of a second, available at https://www.bipm.org/documents/20126/41483022/SI-Brochure-9...., section 2.3.1, does not reference our particular planet, nor any particular means of measurement, nor does it have to.

In principle this frequency can be measured in any inertial frame. Seconds are not defined on Earth specifically.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by leetcrew on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:32AM (#36667036)
timezones don't need to perfectly predict whether the sun is up to be useful. when I set a meeting with a colleague in India, I don't really care whether the sun is up. it will almost surely be down for at least one of us. I am just trying to pick a reasonable time where they don't have to end work too late, and I don't have to start too early.

having everyone roughly align their work day to 9am-5pm in their local time works a lot better than asking every single person in my company for their working hours in UTC.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by laserlight on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:08AM (#36667551)
I don't get how the problem would be harder with a universal timezone. Currently, I have to look up which timezone India is in and find a good time that works for both of us. In a universal timezone, I would have to look up what time noon is in India and find a time that works for both of us.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by leetcrew on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:53AM (#36668194)
so the high level problem here is "how can I infer a locale's working hours without asking every individual?"

the current solution is to set an explicit expectation that people work 9-5ish in their local offset.

is your proposal to do the same thing, but the expectation is that people work noon-4 to noon+4, or something like that? I don't see any major advantages to that, but I do see one major disadvantage: solar noon occurs at a different time every day. of all the arbitrary markers to align schedules with, this seems like a pretty bad one.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by laserlight on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:58PM (#36669193)
> is your proposal to do the same thing, but the expectation is that people work noon-4 to noon+4, or something like that?

Yes. Rather than using solar noon at one day, we can look up an average solar noon time. It should give a better idea how people would plan their day. I understand that schedules will be different at different locations, but then 9 to 5 also has that much variation from location to location.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by makingstuffs on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:37PM (#36669886)
Your solution is the same regardless of the number of time zones in existence. Either way you need to ‘look up what time noon is in India’.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by chickenpotpie on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:24AM (#36666915)
Won't people just end up coming up with their own pseudo time zones anyways? If I'm in New York and I'm calling someone in Seattle, aren't I gonna have to just mentally subtract 3 or so hours anyways?
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by loudmax on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:53AM (#36667342)
Yes. There's no getting around the fact that the sun rises and sets around the world at different times. What we do instead is get rid of the assumption that everybody works 9am to 5pm local time.

It does require a different way of thinking about time zones. It sounds complicated because it's unfamiliar, but if we ever make the transition, the system would be simpler, less ambiguous, and easier to reason about.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by ethbr0 on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:28AM (#36666977)
> Why shouldn't we have one timezone? Why not have one worldwide timezone?

Your watch hands read '20230710T142847Z', don't they?

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by adolph on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:14AM (#36667625)
No. For one, I use the ordinal date option in ISO 8601 because the whole month and day thing is stupid. Today is 2023-191. Also my watch only reads 14:28 since the date and TZ are typically implied in watches.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_8601

One thing for which I would advocate is removing zero based numbering from hours and minutes. Clocks reading 12:15 for 00:15 is tremendously confusing. Most human oriented counting systems are not zero indexed. One indexed series align cardinal and ordinal numbering which reflects the passage of time rather than each hour being nominally disconnected from a sequence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-based_numbering

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by Timon3 on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:50PM (#36672767)
> No. For one, I use the ordinal date option in ISO 8601 because the whole month and day thing is stupid.

Apart from this being very funny and an interesting idea I have a question: how do you deal with leap years? Many important dates throughout the year (e.g. holidays, birthdays, business quarters etc.) are bound to specific days of months, do you just have to remember that all such days after February are one off sometimes in an ordinal date system?

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by adolph on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @01:22PM (#36684181)
I appreciate your questions. I will honor them with the same dry humor by responding as if actually using ordinal dates were something many people did.

Leap years: A sidereal year adjustment may occur on any day, there is not a requirement for it to occur on a specific day. Leap years merely have an additional day identifier in the series before returning to 001.

Anniversary events: Again, there is no requirement that the memorialization of a person or event occur on a specific month and day. Many occurrences such as Mardi Gras and Eid using a lunar calendar or the USA's Thanksgiving using the day of week.

If one wishes to commemorate an annual event at the same orbital position as when it occurred, then ordinal dates are more effective since the Gregorian calendar's fourth-year 02/29 throws off any anniversary after the first 1/6th of the year.

NB: ISO 8601 "leap week" instances occur at a different rate than leap years (a more parallel construction would be "leap week" and "leap day"). "[The] 53 week years occur on all years that have Thursday as the 1st of January and on leap years that start on Wednesday the 1st."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leap_year

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_week_date

A higher order number than ordinal and cardinal is ratio. We can also express the current day as how far through the year we are. Since today is 192, it represents 52% of a year, the ratio of current day to days in the current year. Below is an example in bash.

  $ date '+%j'
  192
  $ echo "scale=2; $(date '+%j') / $(date '+%j' -d $(date '+%Y')'-12-31')" | bc
  .52
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by petesergeant on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:29AM (#36666984)
> Why not have one worldwide timezone ... we already deal with plenty of incongruity around daylight ... why not embrace the variability and let go of the idea that we can predict daylight based on the hour alone?

Because it's a useful heuristic in knowing whether someone will be at work or not without having to localize every time.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by watwut on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:45AM (#36667246)
Because this way, when someone tells me "it was 5:00 or 16:00" I know whether it was their morning or evening or around lunch. I do not have to take out map to figure out where they were located to figure out any of that.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by mjswensen on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:18AM (#36667691)
I used to want this too, until I thought about what it would be like to have a date/weekday change during waking hours for most of the world. I suspect that would cause even more problems than the timezone headaches.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by pseudalopex on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:46PM (#36673396)
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by yuck39 on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:20AM (#36666867)
I actually liked the one time zone system in China when I lived there. It made scheduling work across different cities a little more convenient, and I didn't mind that the sunrise/sunset didn't always exactly line up to what I am accustomed to.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by izzydata on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:32AM (#36667025)
I can understand not exactly lining up, but considering how large the country is and how Beijing is so far east it seems like people in the west would have the sun rise at 2:00 or the sunsetting at 14:00. I don't know this for certain I'm just curious how not lined up it can get at the most extremes.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by jlg23 on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:50AM (#36667297)
As long I am not working the same hours as people in the far east of China, I would not really care about what the clock reads at sunset: I'd just get up around sunrise at n o'clock, spend my hours at work and finally go to bed at m o clock. The only difference between n=6, m=22 or n=22,m=14 is habituation. We're used to the former.

But it would definitely screw up cultural references, e.g.: a "5pm tea" then can only be understood with a broader cultural context: "UK, 5pm is late in the 2nd half of the working day for them".

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by ghostpepper on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:31AM (#36667016)
It must lead to some interesting language quirks around times of day. For example in the US/Canada if you say "Nobody wants to get a phone a call at 1AM" that means the same thing to anyone no matter where they're from. "I want you at your desk at 9 o'clock sharp". etc.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by RegnisGnaw on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:02AM (#36667473)
Officially its called China Standard Time in all the international documents. In local media, its called (in Chinese obviously) "Beijing Time". Its all based on the perspective of Beijing.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by zokier on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:06AM (#36666657)
> I'm perplexed at the implication that we "decided" to have the number of time zones that we do, rather than just acknowledging the reality that the US is a fairly big country.

Timezones are still a social construct, and decision made. Mainland China is wider than contiguous US, and yet it runs on single TZ.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by petesergeant on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:31AM (#36667014)
> Mainland China is wider than contiguous US, and yet it runs on single TZ

That's because a vast majority of the country (and certainly all the politically empowered citizens) live in a much smaller span for which the single timezone is pretty accurate. It works in China by not caring about people to the West.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by zokier on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:38AM (#36667121)
* * *
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by acatton on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:49AM (#36667285)
Spain is not UTC+1 purely out of convenience. It's because of history

https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2013/11/30/244995264/...

> So on Oct. 23, 1940, Hitler took a train to the Spanish border to woo Spain's Fascist dictator, Francisco Franco.

> But Spain was in ruins from its own Civil War in the late 1930s, and Franco didn't have much to offer. He stayed neutral, but switched Spain's clocks ahead one hour, to be in line with Nazi Germany.

> Ever since, even though Spain is geographically in line with Britain, Portugal and Morocco — its clocks are on the same time zone as countries as far east as Poland and Hungary.

And the country/politicians are thinking about going back to UTC+0 due to all the problems UTC+1 poses due to geography.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by petesergeant on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:06AM (#36667522)
> to get western europe under single timezone

Western Europe is not under a single timezone, though: the UK, Ireland, and Portugal are not on CET/CEST.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by adolph on Monday July 10, 2023 @11:17AM (#36667678)
Under some circumstances "to get" describes an intent for a result rather than an obtained result.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by justrealist on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:20AM (#36666863)
Think about the concrete thing you're suggesting — making people 4 timezones away wake up early just to be aligned with bureaucrats! Eliminating timezones on its own does not make people wake up before dawn. Consolidating timezones while not forcing people into unnatural wake/sleep cycles accomplishes nothing.

You still would have to figure out when people in SF wake up!

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by zokier on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:35AM (#36667082)
> Think about the concrete thing you're suggesting

I'm not suggesting anything. I'm just informing that different countries make different decisions on their TZ arrangement based on their priorities, and the arrangement that US has currrently is not just some inevitably from geography.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by Sankozi on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:31AM (#36667013)
Why do you think it accomplishes nothing? Benefits just from communication perspective are enough to consider single timezone.

> You still would have to figure out when people in SF wake up!

Exactly! It is argument against multiple TZs not for it.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by justrealist on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:46AM (#36667248)
Think about this harder! Let's say everyone in the US was on "Eastern Standard Time". You're scheduling a meeting for eastern standard time. You still have to figure out when your San Francisco coworkers wake up, in Eastern Time!

Except without timezones, you just have to remember that SF is 3-ish hours off so people wake up at 11am. If you just had timezones, you wouldn't have to keep this in your head!

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by Sankozi on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:28AM (#36681455)
I don't understand what is your point.

With single TZ: - I need to learn when people at different location work.

With multiple, perfect TZs: - I still need to learn when people at different location work, and additionally I need to translate (or add TZ to) every clock time when communicating with those people.

Learning when people work is similar amount of work in both cases. You always have to keep at least time offsets for every city or even office. If you have multiple TZs you need to keep them and their offsets in your head.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by justrealist on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @11:07AM (#36682079)
> With multiple, perfect TZs: - I still need to learn when people at different location work

That's not true — I can roughly assume that everyone is at work by 9am their time. I just need to know their timezone. If I didn't have a timezone, I'd have to memorize the approximate offset of every city in the US.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by Sankozi on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:43AM (#36691909)
So instead knowing city -> offset mapping, you need to know both city -> TZ and TZ -> offset mapping, and end up with something worse (because TZ will never be perfect, so offset from TZ is usually worse than "human" offset based on the location).

I really see no benefit.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by msla on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:54AM (#36667352)
https://qntm.org/abolish

TL;DR:

People won't wake up at local midnight because the clock says 07:00.

People won't wake up at local sunrise no matter what the clock says.

People will wake up when the people they coordinate with wake up.

If they can't change their clocks to reflect that, the hours they keep will be very unpredictable to outsiders.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by delecti on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:01PM (#36670378)
Independent of how many discrete groups we invent, there is a broader range of times of local solar noon in the lower 48 states than in Europe.

So what I mean is that, because integers are easy to work with, and we've arbitrarily settled on 24 hours in a day, and given time zones exist, the number of them in the lower 48 US states (4 plus Arizona's situation) is pretty far from wild. China's decision is much more of a stretch.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by boomboomsubban on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:07AM (#36666675)
The fact we have two time zones that cover uninhabited regions means it really is a "decision" how many time zones you say America has.

Yes, we're large. That doesn't explain how 4, 9, and 11 are all fairly valid answers to "how many time zones does America have?" Not to mention the confusion of areas that don't follow daylight savings.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by JJMcJ on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:13AM (#36666754)
Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Guam, American Samoa, also.

Hardly cheating. They are part of the United States.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by ceejayoz on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:18AM (#36666837)
This gets complicated. State versus non-state, incorporated versus unincorporated territories, etc. Hawaii's an easy "yes" answer. American Samoa isn't by several possible definitions.
Re:Are the Americans Awake? by JJMcJ on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @04:15PM (#36686642)
I'm not disagreeing with you as I write this, but there are many people who act like Hawaii is some kind of obscure appendage instead of being a state just like the other 49 states.

Puerto Rico is as close to a state as it's possible to be without actually being a state.

Re:Are the Americans Awake? by delecti on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:58AM (#36667404)
Apologies, because I was very unclear with my wording. I didn't mean to imply anything about areas outside the lower 48 being "less American", just that the total population outside the lower 48 is such a small fraction of the total. The US has bases and embassies all around the world which are full of people who are just as American as anyone, but if [1] this article is to be believed, over 99% of Americans are in the lower 48.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contiguous_United_States