News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by shanghaikid on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:50AM (#36664510)
Just be curious why are people still using email client other than web based one? Gmail or outlook 365 is quite good, and I think most people will have one web browser opened always.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by artogahr on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:54AM (#36664558)
Because I like all my email in one place basically. I don't want to hunt for tabs whenever I'm looking for specific mail account, mentally all my mail is behind one icon separate from my browser, and they all look and work the same.

Also maybe not Gmail but aside from that IMHO Thunderbird offers better UX than all other browser mail apps.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by kevincox on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:20AM (#36665290)
Personally I hate GMail.

1. Threads are collapsed into a 1-dimensional list making moderately complex discussions hard to follow.

2. Deleting many messages is very slow. With Thunderbird I can mash <Delete> while scanning subjects and pause for a second to see the actual message body. I get a lot of email that I need to sort through or be aware of so my morning generally consists of quickly (15min) going through up to 100 conversions and getting quick status updates or just deleting uninteresting threads. For whatever reason doing this in GMail is a complete slog. (I'm not sure why, they have the <y> shortcut to archive and have a preview pane but it is just way slower, maybe they need to precache a few messages on either side of the current one?)

3. Threads are based on subject meaning that unrelated messages get grouped together. (Apparently this was changed in 2019 (https://workspaceupdates.googleblog.com/2019/03/threading-ch...) but I've definitely seen this issue for at least a year after that announcement when I stopped using GMail)

I do admit that most of GMail is pretty good. But for me these limitations are enough to really impede my workflow. I've found that Thunderbird is the least-bad option for me. However Thunderbird's performance is quite poor. I do have 350k messages downloaded locally but even opening my empty inbox sometimes causes lockups. IIUC this is because Thunderbird is mostly single-threaded but apparently there is progress slowly being made here. For example composing messages used to frequently lock up for a few seconds but I haven't seen that in a couple years.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by trog on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:00PM (#36675217)
> 1. Threads are collapsed into a 1-dimensional list making moderately complex discussions hard to follow.

You can disable this - it's called "Conversation mode" and you can turn it off. Many of my colleagues have it off as they find it unusable due to their workflow (they often end up with threads with 50-100 emails in them & conversation mode makes it painful).

(Be aware that Conversation mode is required for some tools/plugins/extensions to work though.)

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by diffeomorphism on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:02AM (#36664621)
Because you have more than one email address? Or because you want to work offline (e.g. connectivity on trains is bad)?

I am more curious why people are still using the very limited web based ones and one for each address, when much more capable and universal local clients exist.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by jwells89 on Monday July 10, 2023 @10:09AM (#36666692)
Yes, webmail is a mess if you’re juggling even a few addresses.

Having access to mail offline has saved my bacon a few times, especially while traveling.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by NoboruWataya on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:10AM (#36664706)
They are great for managing multiple email accounts in the one place. Also for me, browsers are kind of ephemeral - I open and close them quite a bit. Whereas I have Thunderbird open constantly in its own separate workspace.

There's also the local backup point that others have mentioned.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by muhehe on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:56AM (#36664581)
Gmail is quite ok-ish for me, outlook is outright terrible. They also take quite a lot of time to load.

Besides, when you have more than one mail with more providers it sucks.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by gog on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:02AM (#36664622)
Multiple reasons:

* not all of my email accounts are hosted by Google/Microsoft

* I want one email client to manage all of my email

* I want offline access and local search

Other then that, I am also not a fan of gmails web interface and the way it handles emails.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by esperent on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:04AM (#36664647)
Outlook.com only loads successfully about one time out of ten for me. Same as MS Teams web app. I've tried all the recommendations around third party cookies, no dice.

Gmail has weird limitations around non Gmail accounts. You can only add up to five, and they get checked randomly - sometimes only once an hour but mostly around 20 minutes. There's no way to force a check. This is a ridiculous limitation - imagine having to wait that long for an email log in code, for example.

If I only used one Gmail account there would be no reason to use Thunderbird. Now I have something like 7 or 8 email addresses across several businesses and a real, reliable email client is vital.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by Sander_Marechal on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:54AM (#36664557)
I don't want my mail managed by either of those two. Many other providers use Roundcube but that's quite "meh". But the killer feature for me for Thunderbird is that I can force everything to be plain text email, both sending and receiving.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by eloisius on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:06AM (#36664669)
My operating system has quite good window management and I hate to have everything collapsed down into a linear row of tabs in one window.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by dizhn on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:12AM (#36664723)
Gmail is good? I am not seeing it. It's a weird 90s gui which is hard to discover. For my use case both round cube and afterlogic webmail lite are better than gmail. I don't use my company account there. (My rspamd based spam protection is better too)
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by tjoff on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:05AM (#36664659)
Gmail and outlook are absolutely atrocious. Gmail can't even search properly, which is what you'd expect from a cloud.

Searching through gigabytes of mail is trivial on a desktop but way too expensive to do on the cloud.

So much quicker, webmail is incredibly slow no matter what hardware and internet you have.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by thiht on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:29AM (#36664877)
I have multiple mailboxes, not all in Gmail, and I want a unified way to read and write my emails.

Also a local copy of the emails is nice to have.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by shanghaikid on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:21AM (#36664804)
By the way, before the internet 2.0, I quite love this client: becky: https://www.rimarts.co.jp/becky.htm, so much faster than thunderbird.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by PurpleRamen on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:20AM (#36664798)
I use Thunderbird for work, for legal reasons (can't move sensitive data to the cloud) and also practical (no mix up of private mails and work). Additionally, Thunderbird has chat, which I use for our internal system.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by palmy on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:54AM (#36664561)
I have accounts with both gmail (personal) and outlook (work), and so using an external email client let's me have all those in one place.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by dgellow on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:59AM (#36664598)
Mostly to keep local archives of my various inboxes.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by mhitza on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:06AM (#36664666)
Local copies of your email, your own mail servers, would be a couple of reasons.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by PinguTS on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:02AM (#36664632)
Because I don't want to have my Emails in the cloud. That is true for many companies.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by rickydroll on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:01AM (#36664614)
most web based email clients let me dictate and edit messages with dragon. desktop clients are frequently anti-accessible.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by indymike on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:58AM (#36664594)
For me, speed.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by Dalewyn on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:59AM (#36664599)
1. Local copy of all emails, which is also very sternly separate and independent because I also use POP3 rather than IMAP.

2. Email in web browser is arse, particularly Gmail.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by rhaway84773 on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:20AM (#36664797)
The interface won’t randomly be changed from under you every couple of years?

On a more serious note, am I using my desktop so very differently? The idea that a web app could even come close to competing with a native app for me simply doesn’t compute.

Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by kyboren on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:39AM (#36681633)
* * *
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by mixmastamyk on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:55AM (#36665079)
If it's free in the cloud, then you're the product. When it is MS, often you pay and are also the product.
Re:What’s New in Thunderbird 115 by LinuxBender on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:50AM (#36666413)
So that my emails are truly mine. I pull them off the server straight away reducing attack exposure should they be compromised. I can then compress and backup my emails. If my provider should falter I can change providers and still have all my emails, even pushing any of them back up to the new server should I have such a need. The same logic applies for my contacts. When a web-only provider goes offline, so do all my emails and contacts which feels too much like corporate capture to me.