Unfortunately this combination often leads them to assume things are good purely because they are American. They tend to accept their own familiar values and ideas and readily dismiss alternatives because that would be admitting failure. As a result you get incredibly conservative attitudes in some areas side-by-side with world leading innovation in another.
From a Booklist review of the book:
By demonizing trial attorneys and exaggerating high-profile litigation
awards -- the famous McDonald's hot-coffee case -- campaigns for limiting
damage awards threaten to jeopardize the American right to civil jury
trials guaranteed by the Bill of Rights. Investigative reporter Mencimer
examines the Republican campaigns for tort reform that would protect
large corporations from "frivolous lawsuits." The campaigns carry the
dual benefit of supporting the interests of corporations that are major
Republican campaign contributors and hurting trial lawyers, who are part
of the contribution base of Democrats. Mencimer criticizes the media for
their lack of understanding about civil litigation, willingness to
swallow reports of litigation abuses, and failure to understand that
Republican tort reform will also limit the ability of news organizations
to sue for information. Drawing on national data and scrutiny of
individual cases, Mencimer defends the civil justice system and its
reliance on jurors, average citizens who are the same people who vote.
This is an eye-opening look at an important issue for readers concerned
with the civil justice system.
also, "The Lawyer Myth: A Defense of the American Legal Profession"[2]From the Booklist review:
However disliked lawyers have become, they have played an essential role
in the development of the American democracy, assert legal scholars
Strickland and Read. Taking aim at media critics -- left and right -- who
blame lawyers for a host of social ills, Strickland and Read debunk
several popular myths about lawyers. They begin with the notion that
there are too many lawyers and lawsuits, citing statistics to put things
into perspective, and they point to the benefits that have come from
lawsuits, including increased consumer protection from faulty products.
But they concede the need for reform in a chapter that calls for major
research into alternative legal mechanisms. Finally, Strickland and Read
look toward the next generation of lawyers and outline the
characteristics most essential for the practice of law: competency,
responsiveness, and integrity. They emphasize that it’s not what lawyers
bring to the law but what they give that makes a difference. This book
is not likely to stop lawyer jokes, but it is an insightful look at a
much-maligned profession.
[1] - http://www.amazon.com/Blocking-Courthouse-Door-Republican-Co...[2] - http://www.amazon.com/The-Lawyer-Myth-American-Profession/dp...
The cost to avoid lawsuits adds up with a lot of tests that are not needed. Doctors end up doing whole batteries of tests on everyone to avoid the 1:1000 or higher chance that the person in their office with a headache really had an aneurysm and get the doctor sued for negligence when he sends them home.
Another side effect of all these tests is that many are extremely dangerous. CT scans in particular are ordered way too often and can does people with levels of radiation that lead to problems later in life.
Many tests, drugs and treatments have been applied in the name of defensive medicine.
Wouldn't a calculation of the effect of litigation include the scenario you mentioned? Otherwise it would seem to be a bad calculation. Do you have any studies that show how often a test is ordered simply to avoid a lawsuit?
Citations re: excess testing:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15928282 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10136689
Although our estimates delineate a wide range of potential savings, systemwide savings from aggressive malpractice reform could approach $41 billion over five years.
According to one source [1] the U.S. spent $2.6 trillion in health care in 2010. An $8 - $9 billion dollar savings per year from eliminating defensive medicine hardly adds up to "a lot more than 2%".
[1] http://www.kaiseredu.org/Issue-Modules/US-Health-Care-Costs/...
I don't think there is any assumption at all that our health care system works as it stands today.
It'd be really nice if health care could work like a regular market, but evidence and intuition suggest it simply doesn't. As others have commented, people don't comparison shop even if they could. It's a bit like having no idea how a car works or what could be wrong with it, and then being asked to pick the best mechanic and strategy to fix it. Except of course, that it's not a car but your life or somebody else's depending on the right choice. I think it's unrealistic to expect a working market economy to develop under such circumstances.
One or multiple big entities negotiating prices and dictating treatment comes at the cost of less freedom for the providers and also less freedom for the consumers. Whether it gives better or worse care I wouldn't be too sure - on the one hand, special cases won't get specialised treatment, on the other hand trusting the decision of what needs to be done effectively to the provider sounds like it will cause over-treatment.
The freedom aspect probably drives the USA to the current system, but given the measurable effects, it just seems like bad policy.
The US has these entities too - they are called "insurance companies".
As others have commented, people don't comparison shop even if they could.
This is simply false. People with low deductible insurance don't comparison shop because they have no incentive to do so. I have no insurance (my startup is minimally funded), and I do comparison shop.
It's a bit like having no idea how a car works or what could be wrong with it, and then being asked to pick the best mechanic and strategy to fix it.
Here is what I did a few weeks back. I went to a doctor who ordered an MRI. I called around, discovered the price of MRI's varied from 5-7k (INR, not USD), and then picked the closest one to my home (the price difference was small enough that I didn't care).
When it came time to get treatment, I did research on the internet, as well as asking three separate doctors. They all independently had the same recommendation - microlumbar discectomy on L5-S1. This was fairly apparent based also on the pattern of pain I was suffering, and just by looking at the MRI. I ruled out one hospital because it seemed dirty, chose a doctor/hospital to have it done (not the cheapest, but not the priciest), downgraded from a deluxe room to a private one [1], and got myself fixed up.
This doesn't work for emergency medicine, but most medicine is not emergencies.
[1] The default over here is to give white guys the gold-plated options.
Health insurers in the U.S. have a captive audience. Most people before the age of 60 who have insurance get it through their employer. What the employer pays for insurance comes out of money that would be paid in salary. It seems to me that the insurance companies don't have a great incentive to lower cost of healthcare. On the surface the evidence suggests that they haven't since procedures cost so much more here than elsewhere.
Costs here did vary significantly for the surgery - the dirty hospital was 0.9-1.5lac (depending on general ward vs private room, etc), the place where I had it done was about 85k. It was the MRI for which the price differential was minor.
I was actually pretty surprised that the price gap was so big - I wouldn't have expected the city hospital to be almost 2x as much as the private hospital.
It seems to me that the insurance companies don't have a great incentive to lower cost of healthcare.
Insurance companies don't have a great incentive to lower the cost of their biggest expense? Um, ok.
On the surface the evidence suggests that they haven't since procedures cost so much more here than elsewhere.
The relevant counterfactual is what procedures would cost absent insurance company negotiation, not what they would cost if US patients had as few MRI's as French patients and US health care workers were paid as little as their French counterparts.
If true, you are glossing over a pretty substantial difference between the two systems.
I.e., Nitramp is wrong, people are capable of shopping around, all they need is incentive to do so.
They only have such incentive if it increases their profit margins. There are a number of scenarios where this wouldn't be the case. They aren't interested in lowering cost just for the sake of lowering cost. I don't have data either way and so my belief in this is easily shaken.
I'm not aware of any insurance companies that charge on a cost-plus basis, and the insurance companies can't just charge companies as much as they want (or else they'd charge an infinite amount).
Parent was looking for an example to explain a possible situation, not a dynamic that the entire world must obey at all times.
As mentioned in the article, American insurance companies appear not to be very good at negotiating prices, partly because the providers are permitted to negotiate different prices with different companies, and to treat these negotiated prices as trade secrets. This is a highly unusual state of affairs.
If so, then compared to what exactly?
The US has some of the highest costs per treatment of just about anywhere in the world, so if the insurance companies are dramatically lowering prices, then the only conclusion I can draw is that the US healthcare providers must be powering all their equipment by burning money for fuel or something.
In terms of MRIs, you have some odd effects with pricing, particularly when the MRI is seated inside of a massive tertiary care center instead of a standalone facility. If you look at the pricing discrepancies, it is almost always related to getting the MRI done at an academic medical center versus one of the ambulatory care centers. The problem is actually pretty simple: hospitals are terrible at cost accounting and totally game it. Instead of taking the leasing costs over the expected uses of the machine, adding in time for the technician and a bit of a real estate or facility charge, they allocate hospital costs (from all departments/overhead) to services based on their expectations on what they can charge. Michael Porter and his staff at HBS are looking at this right now.
Further complicating MRIs (I'm not sure if this is included in the study's cost estimate) is that radiologists essentially operate in a cartel fashion. They are rarely, if ever, employed by the hospital (like most doctors), but band together and set outrageous prices for reading images. Radiology, despite being non-patient facing and limited liability (they render opinions to other doctors, not patients), is one of the most lucrative medical trades. Eventually, traditional radiology should give way - either through disruption (overseas or computers) or by other doctors simply saying why the heck should a radiologist get money for reading an image I can read myself and will then have to intervene on anyways?
Startups have emerged in price/transparency space (e.g. Castlight Health) and will hopefully start to put pressure on hospitals/physicians to actually compete with one another and bring down costs. Since they have so much local market power, there is only so far an insurer can go without owning an entire market.
It's not that they're terrible at cost accounting. The problem is the hospitals are required to provide care to people who can't pay, particularly in the ER and obstetrics. So costs are shifted from other departments to pay for these services.
That's why people who are trying to hold down costs by zeroing in on this test or that procedure are destined to fail. Somehow the service the hospital is required to provide without reimbursement will have to be paid for, either explicitly or through the sort of sleight-of-hand accounting we see today.
I know there are increased costs due to medical advances, but this only accounts for half the increase in costs according to studies, so the rise from 5% of GDP in the 60's to 16% of GDP today, especially seeing the massive increase in GDP during that period, does not chime at all with the idea that the insurance industry is lowering prices in any meaningful way.
In fact, any rational observer might well assume exactly the opposite.
I am not saying that insurers are the most effective option or advocating for them; I am only saying that without them, prices would be significantly higher.
If you need evidence, simply compare the total price of any health care service (i.e. total cash outlay by all parties) between a person who carries health insurance and a person who does not. Universally, the price of the service is higher for the uninsured as they lack negotiating power.
While I would agree that having buying power should bring down prices, this can be completely outweighed by the middleman trying to maximise profits. If prices are kept high, for instance, then you can make more money per person, so therefore having less administrative overhead per dollar made and so more profit margin.
For a non-medical example of this, just have a look at Apple, who make tons more money than their competitors, despite shifting less product, by simply ignoring the bottom end of the market.
Of course, even that only applies if increasing government power will even improve healthcare (in the long and/or short run), and if increasing government power won't have ancillary negative effects that counter the improvement in healthcare.
As for waiting times, you may find yourself waiting for years but it's highly unlikely. The median time for surgery in Canada is 4 weeks.
As others have said, it's not illegal to be private in Canada.
Everyone who seeks medical attention at a hospital is sent through triage, you are right. If you don't have a life threatening problem you won't be treated first, but saying "sometimes people wait a years for treatment" is just hilariously misleading.
We have the worst of both systems. We have enough government interference to drive up prices through restriction of competition, bad regulation, bad mandates; and we have government sponsored 'private' entities there to capture the high prices from the stagnant and controlled markets.
All you've identified is that rich nations have good health care regardless of how much regulation they have. This is hardly surprising - the evidence suggests that once health care exceeds a certain minimum level, it has little effect on health outcomes.
Incidentally, the Indian health care system is excellent and less regulated than the US one. I'm very lucky that I blew out my back in over here rather than in the US. I didn't come over here as a medical tourist (my startup is in Pune), but I strongly recommend that more people consider it.
Granted, the vast majority of people here are too poor to use the health care system effectively, but that's not the fault of the system.
"the United States is Cambodia or Burkina Faso or rural India, with access to a doctor available if you can pay the bill out-of-pocket"
Although it dovetails with the well worn narrative on HN, this comparison fails due to the level of care.
Also, from the article comments:
"There are just a couple problems. In 2009, the French Society of Radiology equipment in France was critically undermining care, and the government was refusing to increase capacity, even though people at many emergency rooms couldn't get an MRI even if they needed one because the equipment simply wasn't available. So, yes, the French government has held down the price of MRIs in France...by not purchasing enough MRI machines that one is available at every hospital. If you need an MRI in France, you're rolling the dice that you would be able to get one in a timely fashion.
Second, some of the development of MRI technology happened in Britain. Most was performed in the U.S. Who is paying for the cost of development of this and other new technology and drugs? It's often not the people in places like Canada and France, where government controls hold down prices. Most of the cost of research and development is paid for by Americans. We pay perhaps five times more in the U.S. for some procedures than people in France pay, but the technology might not exist in the first place if we didn't pay this disproportionate share. Once the technology exists, companies keep charging as much as they can in the U.S. to recoup costs and to fund development of the next big thing in medicine, and meanwhile other countries in the world adopt the technology, gaining benefits from it without actually paying the costs. This is Canada, France, and much of Europe. Plenty of medical research goes on in these countries, but American consumers ultimately bear most of the cost. It's an unfair system in many respects, but it's what has kept medical research moving ahead for the last several decades."
The context is purely the model of provision; level of care isn't addressed.
> Second, some of the development of MRI technology happened in Britain. Most was performed in the U.S. Who is paying for the cost of development of this and other new technology and drugs? It's often not the people in places like Canada and France, where government controls hold down prices. Most of the cost of research and development is paid for by Americans. We pay perhaps five times more in the U.S. for some procedures than people in France pay, but the technology might not exist in the first place if we didn't pay this disproportionate share.
This is an interesting point, in that much of the technology is actually developed outside the US, but the very high prices which Americans pay may be funding some of the development. That said, drug companies, for instance, only spend in the region of 12% on research, less than they spend on marketing. This marketing spend is disproportionately targeted at the US, as it's one of the few countries which permits heavy marketing of prescription drugs directly to normal people.
By few, you mean two, soon to be one. The US and New Zealand, and New Zealand has passed legislation to phase it out.
The US will be the only country in the world where you can be advised of your potential need for a prescription drug not by a medical professional, but by an actor on a television screen.
Disclaimer: I live in America.
Exactly. The level of care is not addressed, therefore you can call the US a backwater and hence receive upvotes.
Now, I'm no economist, but that argument does seem to make absolutely no sense whatsoever.
The lack of MRI is a big problem in France anyway. Regardless of the effect on prices (except maybe if they triple or something like that) having 100% more would be a lot better.
For instance, if they all did it by having the government completely run the health care system, with all doctors working for government hospitals and clinics, and being trained in government medical schools, with all costs set by the government, then I could understand the US rejecting that as being too much government intrusion. (Note I didn't say I'd necessarily agree with such rejection--good health care arguably is more important than limited government power--I'm just saying I could understand such rejection).
But looking around, what stands out is how diverse the approaches of other countries are. There are some that do have the government finance and provide health care, much the way the police or military are provided by the government.
There are some that use private insurers paying, with care provided by private hospitals and doctors, but the insurance companies are non-profit and regulated.
There are some that provide care via private hospitals and doctors, but have a government run insurance program to pay for it.
There was a good look at how it is done in 5 capitalist democracies here: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/sickaroundtheworld/c...
See also the link on that page to the explanation of the four basic models used around the world. That page includes a striking way to explain the other systems to Americans: