Costs here did vary significantly for the surgery - the dirty hospital was 0.9-1.5lac (depending on general ward vs private room, etc), the place where I had it done was about 85k. It was the MRI for which the price differential was minor.
I was actually pretty surprised that the price gap was so big - I wouldn't have expected the city hospital to be almost 2x as much as the private hospital.
It seems to me that the insurance companies don't have a great incentive to lower cost of healthcare.
Insurance companies don't have a great incentive to lower the cost of their biggest expense? Um, ok.
On the surface the evidence suggests that they haven't since procedures cost so much more here than elsewhere.
The relevant counterfactual is what procedures would cost absent insurance company negotiation, not what they would cost if US patients had as few MRI's as French patients and US health care workers were paid as little as their French counterparts.
If true, you are glossing over a pretty substantial difference between the two systems.
I.e., Nitramp is wrong, people are capable of shopping around, all they need is incentive to do so.
They only have such incentive if it increases their profit margins. There are a number of scenarios where this wouldn't be the case. They aren't interested in lowering cost just for the sake of lowering cost. I don't have data either way and so my belief in this is easily shaken.
I'm not aware of any insurance companies that charge on a cost-plus basis, and the insurance companies can't just charge companies as much as they want (or else they'd charge an infinite amount).
Parent was looking for an example to explain a possible situation, not a dynamic that the entire world must obey at all times.
Health insurers in the U.S. have a captive audience. Most people before the age of 60 who have insurance get it through their employer. What the employer pays for insurance comes out of money that would be paid in salary. It seems to me that the insurance companies don't have a great incentive to lower cost of healthcare. On the surface the evidence suggests that they haven't since procedures cost so much more here than elsewhere.