News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by afavour on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:01PM (#36610040)
I feel like there’s a chicken and egg problem for Threads: it uses your existing Instagram social graph to populate your Threads account. Of course FB is going to do that otherwise they lose a massive edge against any competitor. But for me at least my Twitter is a very different social space to my Instagram and there’s very little crossover.

So Threads looks like it’ll be text posts with your Instagram friends. Which is fine, I suppose. But not a Twitter replacement.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by 88913527 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:28PM (#36610272)
Text posts with your Meta friends sounds like Facebook from 2010. What is old is new again, I suppose.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by qbasic_forever on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:44PM (#36610410)
Facebook minus all your annoying boomer parents/relatives (who have no idea what Instagram is or how to install an app) and their political posts and screeds sounds amazing.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by dboreham on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:52PM (#36610476)
Also the same thing as Facebook prior to 2010.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by anshumankmr on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:03AM (#36611082)
Facebook was pretty good in the early 2010s also, in my anecdotal experience when the most popular thing on my feed used to funny iPhone chat memes and 9Gag
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by chrisco255 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:23AM (#36611255)
No thanks. I like Instagram because it's mostly mindless photos or videos of people's lives. It also makes it a bit more difficult to reshare things which is part of the appeal imo, of it as an independent platform different from other social networks. If it becomes anything else, I'm out. I have barely logged into Facebook for years but I'll use Insta occasionally. I use Twitter for casual industry connections and focused topics, and I unfollow people that get heavily, emotionally political.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by gsatic on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:51PM (#36610468)
What problem are they solving? No one has any idea. Info keeps exploding instead of shrinking.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by enufstuff on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:19AM (#36611223)
> What problem are they solving?

Twitter.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by jscipione on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:36AM (#36611335)
Twitter is great, there is no problem, I don’t understand.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by BudaDude on Thursday July 06, 2023 @01:17AM (#36611561)
Okay Elon
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by t0bia_s on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:59AM (#36612287)
What, Zuck?
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by rchaud on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:17AM (#36615270)
> What problem are they solving?

Think of it as the match Zuckerberg lit to mask the stench of the Horizon Worlds carcass.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by Apofis on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:39PM (#36610367)
Instagram comments are not very good and rarely create a discussion, if that's what they're extrapolating it's going to the Meta-Graveyard pretty quickly.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by foogazi on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:30PM (#36610285)
> it uses your existing Instagram social graph to populate your Threads account

you can skip this step

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by afavour on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:33PM (#36610304)
So they say. I’ve already gotten my first notification about an Instagram friend posting on Threads for the first time, which is an obvious push to get me to follow them.

Something tells me they’ll keep jamming in stuff like this to keep engagement high.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by FormerBandmate on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:25PM (#36610247)
Even the recommended page is completely different. It’s Twitter when celebrities used it before Donald Trump completely reshaped the platform
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by stuckkeys on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:31PM (#36610291)
Yeah it is a dog shit of a post. Uses your existing instagram account. Hype hype hype. Uninstalled it right after it installed.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by doctoboggan on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:44PM (#36610413)
At least in this case they have confirmed[0] that it will intern with the fediverse, which makes it difference from other social network launches in the past.

[0]: copy/past from threads.net: "Soon, you'll be able to follow and interact with people on other fediverse platforms, like Mastodon. They can also find people on Threads using full usernames, like @[email protected]."

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by necovek on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:58PM (#36626034)
Facebook Messenger and Google Talk started off as full XMPP (Jabber) clients: I remember talking to people using Pidgin and whatever Gnome client was of the day (E-something) over my own self-hosted ejabberd.

As soon as they grow over the need for interoperability, they kill it off.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by NikolaNovak on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:57PM (#36610505)
There's an important point you make.

Google plus failed. But a few of us loved it, because of its interface and ease of managing for the large part, but also because we interacted differently with and with different people than on Facebook instagram etc.

Whereas Facebook to your point is dominated by my friends and family (but less and less their original content and more and more with copied "memes), Google plus rapidly developed shared circles of interesting people with interesting things to say. Thay we could flow. Pretty quickly my google plus was a rich mine of unbelievably high quality content from fabulous people. Not even HN has quite reached thay zenith for me.

(Twitter by all accounts does that for some. I have not been able to get over / subjugate it's insane formatting and threading limitations and sorting and algorithms and submit them to my will).

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by FormerBandmate on Thursday July 06, 2023 @01:24AM (#36611623)
Threads is definitely going to be dominated by friends and family. It already is, it’s just that and memes. Twitter is much closer to your Google+, and Threads in no way will be anything like that from what I’ve seen of it over the past few hours
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by rchaud on Thursday July 06, 2023 @08:47AM (#36614947)
Friends and Family won't be churning out grist for the mill anywhere near as fast as Facebook needs. Instagram has just as many loudmouth influencers as elsewhere, they just don't get screenshotted like tweets do. This will change that.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by everybodyknows on Thursday July 06, 2023 @01:47AM (#36611794)
> google plus was a rich mine of unbelievably high quality content from fabulous people.

Naive question here from a non-user: With all that goodness, why did the product fail?

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by cvak on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:20AM (#36612031)
Because Google killed it, because it was not for normal people, my circles were mainly developers/researches. Normal people were already on fb and didn't see any value of trying something else.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by 411111111111111 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:19AM (#36612022)
As a general rule of thumb: The general public is not interested in high quality content.

They're much more interested in instant gratification and mindless entertainment, which was sufficiently catered to on the original platforms, so the critical mass of people never switched over.

Another factor surely was that - at the time - reddit was another platform for high quality discussions on specific topics and made it much easier to find like minded people through the subreddit segmentation.

While the circle functionality worked decently in g+, you still had to actually create and join them, which meant it was too exclusionary and involved to really get going.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by bl4ckm0r3 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:28AM (#36614254)
totally agree with this, quality content is and always will be a niche. a platform that only focuses on that will never be "corporate" good enough and make enough money to justify its existence in companies like google. what twitter and reddit got right (imo) is that they made it easy to filter content based on personal interests.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by elbrian on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:51AM (#36612228)
Lack of mainstream adoption.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by Nexxxeh on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:08AM (#36613219)
I'd argue different to the other replies so far. The reasons were:

First and foremost, it's a Google product. Google's own internal structural failings are predisposed to create and then kill products.

https://killedbygoogle.com

It had a different usage model ("Circles") to the things people already had and understood. Twitter, Facebook etc. And it didn't map clearly to those existing understood structures.

It was more complicated for end users, was unintuitive and badly explained. I didn't "get it" until someone either on HN or Reddit explained how it was supposed to work.

Google tried to use Google+ to replace YouTube comments. Something YouTube users didn't want, something it wasn't good at, and something that was badly communicated and extremely badly received. People actively resented the product as a result.

Google mishandled some big issues. Requiring "real names" went down like a lead balloon, something they had to walk back years later, but not before using it to replace YouTube comments.

It could have been lucrative and sticky glue between Google properties. Instead it was the crappy old spiderweb you accidentally get stuck to your face while cleaning out the shed.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by NikolaNovak on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:05PM (#36618115)
Yeah, I was going to respond with a grouchy "Circles are the most intuitive thing in the world" non-self-aware response :P, but you're right. A lot of people didn't know what to do with them! As is frequently the case, my mind can work differently than other people, and Circles were "YES! THIS IS WHAT I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR!" instant-love for me. Heck, I've been trying to do it with facebook for years and I just can't - it has a "Groups" or something functionality, but it's burried and difficult to use and complete pain to setup.

Whereas for me, circles were amazing to both send and receive. I have a group of friends that are interested in photography, and a group of friends interested in computers, and a group for astronomy and philosophy and bicycling and whatnot. So I can place people and or they can subscribe to what they want to see from me.

Similarly, people would create a circle of say interesting photographers, and you can then share that circle and copy that circle and modify that circle and subscribe to that circle.

What ended up happening for me is that after a bit of time, I had a daily feed that was just... way better than any algorithm or AI or ML or privacy-invasive company ever managed to accomplish. Just high quality stuff all around. But also my friends and followers also received better quality stuff from me, as I could tailor who gets to see what.

I also liked the interface at the time, seemed to actually use my wide screen monitor, be clean, and relatively uninvasive (open FB on a 32" monitor and you barely get more useful text than on the 6" phone to this day)

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by jefftk on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:50PM (#36618919)
Circles were so close to what I wanted, but still not quite there. I want to be able to say "these are the people who would probably like to see this post", which Circles let me do, but then it went farther and wouldn't allow others to see the post. There was no way to make the post public but tell the platform that the post was aimed at the Circle.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by troupo on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:01AM (#36615085)
Because no one at Google used it, and no one at Google understood what it means to have a social network.

Instead of developing it further they forced plus logins onto youtube, and after struggling for a year with that, and seeing no meaningful adoption, they rolled everything back, and then sunset Plus.

See also Steve Yegge's platforms rant: https://gist.github.com/chitchcock/1281611 Originally accidentally posted publicly to Google Plus

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by femto113 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:58PM (#36610514)
Fortunately Meta has chickens and eggs. Bootstrapping the graph from Instagram hopefully means that Threads gets enough critical mass that Twitter->Threads tooling (ala Mastodon's Movetodon or Debirdify) will actually work becausethe people you follow on Twitter will already be on Threads when you run them.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by ericmay on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:25PM (#36610735)
The problem with Twitter competitors was/is the very thing you mention - lack of accounts to follow. Threads solves this I think sufficiently.

What will keep me from using it at least as of today is that I can’t tell it to only show content (plus ads I guess) of accounts that I follow. I never ever ever want to see posts from some influencer or something - if they pay to advertise then fine, but otherwise hell no.

So far Twitter has the staying power for me but I’m excited to see what develops here.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by joe_the_user on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:47PM (#36610928)
The only thing I care about on Twitter is the emergency services that use it. I can no longer access their info now that Twitter requires a sign-in and it would be nice to have that access.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by jumpCastle on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:24AM (#36611264)
They no longer require sign-in. Got scared of the reaction.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by joe_the_user on Thursday July 06, 2023 @03:49PM (#36621786)
For the record, the above is not true.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by gexla on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:52PM (#36610975)
It also seems like a problem for anonymity. On Twitter, I can create multiple accounts and I can stay anonymous if I like. I don't know about IG, but FB only allows one account. I don't want my info leaking somehow.

I also have a very different Twitter space from my FB space. Though my IG is also different from my FB.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by jonahhorowitz on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:12AM (#36611163)
Instagram lets you create unrelated "subaccounts" that are tied to your main account. I have one just so I can have a public account that I use to follow F1 drivers. This is great because I don't get spoilers on my main Instagram account and I also can post pictures from F1 events, etc. that my family wouldn't care about.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by graeme on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:35AM (#36611329)
I know you can switch accounts on instagram. How do you make sub accounts? When I searched I only found info on multiple accounts
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by rchaud on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:18AM (#36615282)
You need to provide a phone number to sign up for Twitter these days.
Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by enufstuff on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:20AM (#36611232)
> I feel like there’s a chicken and egg problem for Threads: it uses your existing Instagram social graph to populate your Threads account.

I had a different reaction. "Oh they started with my Insta list which isn't what I want. I'll keep them for now and slowly replace them with stuff I use Twitter for." In other words, not a big deal to me and not something that immediately stood out as being an issue.

Re:Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours by rumblerock on Thursday July 06, 2023 @01:01AM (#36611484)
I noticed this with the base experience after auto-following all my Instagram follows.

But what isn't in the app yet is a "trending" / "recommended" section, which I imagine is ready to go once they bootstrap enough data for it. Any person or entity with PR value or internet clout is likely already gearing up to post across both platforms, so a typhoon of data is about to flow in.

Once that exists then they can move to the next stage of enveloping most of what Twitter has to offer.

My question is, will Elon ban people from posting links to their Threads accounts?