News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by thefounder on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @05:55PM (#36607718)
>> Richmond Voyager, under the Bahamas flag,

Are they using tax haven flags to dodge taxes? just to be saved by a tax paid millitary...

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by mcpackieh on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:05PM (#36607838)
Not just taxes, but regulations (treatment of workers, etc)
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by azinman2 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:09PM (#36607868)
A very astute point. Unfortunately people cry foul when their gas prices go up, so no real political pressure otherwise.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by givemeethekeys on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @05:59PM (#36607762)
A small price to pay for free shipping for Made not in America.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by deanCommie on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:23PM (#36608035)
The US military intervenes in world affairs in the interest of geopolitical stability, which benefits the taxpayers that pay it.

But even if that's not the case, do you believe that if you are a tax dodger (individual or corporate) that you no longer should be:

* Helped by the state department such as being given protection at a consulate on foreign soil if being threatened by a foreign nation?

* protected by the military if your life is in danger in international waters?

* helped by an emergency room if your health is in danger on home soil?

This feels like a position akin to screaming at a police officer trying to give you a ticket that "I'm a tax-paying citizen, you work for ME"

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by synetic on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:29PM (#36608100)
There’s a huge difference between helping out a citizen who has broken the law by dodging taxes and helping out a corporation that purposefully evades U.S. regulations. People rate higher than corporations. At least they should.

Note that the State Department does charge people when they are evacuated from a foreign nation.

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by SllX on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:35PM (#36608160)
If you live in a world where the entirety of a corporation was paperwork and robots, that’s a very astute point.

Unfortunately I live in a world where corporations are made up from the investments and works of people (and paperwork, some robots sometimes), including the people whose bodies were on that boat. Do you want to trade?

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by synetic on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:34PM (#36609320)
If the U.S. has the right to intervene when non U.S. flagged vessels owned by a U.S. company are stopped by a foreign government does, say, North Korea have the right to intervene when North Korean owned ships are stopped by the U.S.?
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by SllX on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:35AM (#36611333)
They can try. We can say whatever we want on the land about what folks at sea do, but the truth is on the sea, the bigger gun wins.

The US Navy polices the worlds oceans. Not should, nor can, nor might, nor has considered doing so, but does and has done so for decades; and Iran already knew this, as does North Korea, and this does sometimes include intervening when a hostile power attacks non-American flagged vessels.

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by synetic on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:23AM (#36615355)
… but the truth is on the sea, the bigger gun wins.

Yes. So why go through the rigmarole of trying to justify the actions when it comes down to we do it because we can and our leaders think it’s in our interests.

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by SllX on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:11PM (#36622099)
Because despite the truth in the moment, as a republic we as people still need to believe that our actions are justified to continue our policies, and you don’t have to be lied to believe it, even if you personally end up on the side that it isn’t justified. We still want the approval of foreign nations, even if we’re comfortable with a less than 100% approval rating. Our interests do include human life, even if they’re sailing under a foreign flag on a civilian ship. We would prefer civilian ships and not have to arm themselves to the teeth ready for an adventurous voyage to get across the water without being harassed by hostile actors. In other words, policing actions are a deterrent to greater hostilities.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by khuey on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:51PM (#36608322)
It does seem logical that if you sail under the flag of the Bahamas perhaps you should be calling the Bahamian Navy to rescue you from these glorified pirates.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by kube-system on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:58PM (#36608378)
Yes, but the US doesn't patrol international waters to protect the people or ships that pass through it. They do it to protect their own economy back home. The fact that someone flying the Bahamian flag just happened to be helped was a side effect.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by masfuerte on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:02PM (#36608422)
A better analogy: you've foresworn your American citizenship and emigrated to a different country. Now there's a problem you still expect American law enforcement to sort it out.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by bpodgursky on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:03PM (#36607822)
Expensive oil is good for several of the world's worst governments, which are mostly propped up by high prices (Russia, Iran, Venezuela).

It's in the interest of the US (and moreso, most of the developing world) to keep oil prices from spiking due to shipping insecurity.

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by graton on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:00PM (#36608408)
I believe for a ship to be US flagged it must be built in the US, use a US crew, and follow US rules. Which makes things relatively expensive.

https://www.cnbc.com/2015/04/28/us-ship-definition-by-flag-o...

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by jcranmer on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:15PM (#36608570)
> Are they using tax haven flags to dodge taxes?

Not just to dodge taxes, but also to dodge pesky things like worker regulations.

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by renewiltord on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:49PM (#36608910)
The US military enforces sea peace across the globe. e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_Task_Force_151

Pax Americana has yielded the American people great benefits. It is in this nation's interests to preserve global sea trade. When the benefits accrue so much to America, it is in America's interests to intervene on behalf of everyone - even those who won't pay.

Something people often make a mistake with is positive externalities. There are many things that have positive externalities. Others having children is what keeps the country running in your old age when you have none; keeping your country's Western border safe helps you even if your state is miles away in the East; ensuring children are all educated and fed helps even if you will have none; ensuring your population is employed will help even if you don't need to work anymore; ensuring others can take public transit along your route helps even if you must drive; treating people who can't pay in emergency rooms helps you even if you will be forced to pay.

Nations which realize this build a strong collective identity which lets them see assistance of their fellow man as assistance of self, bypassing the innate "why my money spent on him" complaint.

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by jemmyw on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:41PM (#36609381)
It hasn't only benefited the US but everyone except those who specifically reject it. It has hugely befitted China having peaceful and open global trade. Now they want to burn it out from underneath themselves thinking they'll gain some kind of advantage by replacing the American system. "We don't want YOUR peace" so to speak. Not that the USA or American system is perfect, but if it's a choice between that and the others on offer...
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by renewiltord on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:42PM (#36609876)
Yeah, I really enjoyed A Splendid Exchange which talks about this massive good and enjoyed Disunited Nations for one hypothesis of the future.
Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by bobzibub on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:54PM (#36609972)
What the article didn't mention was that the US has pirated (ahem) "commandeered" Iranian oil tankers as well. This is an ongoing dispute between these two countries. Iran violates US sanctions, but technically they are merely US sanctions which have the legal weight of say Togo's sanctions on the high seas. (Togo doesn't enforce their domestic law on the high seas, nor can they.)

The simplest way to get Iran to stop compandeering tankers is for the US to do the same. They don't want our "peace", it is true. "Peace with Piracy" is just not compelling to the Iranians. Can you blame them?

Likewise, China benefits from trade near her borders but the US and allies want the ability to turn off the spigot when they wish to force China into concessions, as has been noted in US geopolitical articles for decades now.

Note the Australian nuclear submarines deal: They don't really want to protect their trade with China...from China, they want the ability to control trade between China and her allies. These subs would do part of the job, with the bulk of it done by the USN. Enjoy a comedy skit on that subject: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sgspkxfkS4k

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by everybodyknows on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:28PM (#36618480)
> China benefits from trade near her borders but the US and allies want the ability to turn off the spigot when they wish to force China into concessions

The word for this is "blockade", generally recognized as an act of war. When exactly did the US threaten to blockade China? And why is it that those nearby trading partners seem to regard China, not the US as a threat? How could they all have it so wrong?

Re:Video: Iranian Navy Warship Fires on Oil Tanker in the St... by bobzibub on Saturday July 08, 2023 @02:49PM (#36647494)
There is concern amongst countries in the area. There are many territorial disagreements. Both that and pressure to host bases etc in exchange for secure access to US markets.

The Biden administration is pursuing a policy of ambiguity with respect to China. A blockade is an act of war, but publically threatening it is also a quick way to lose sway in the court of world opinion. I agree that there is no public threat of a blockade by the adminstration, nor did I claim they did. Similarly, when was the last time the US officially declared war? WWII? Actions are better indicators than words. One cannot "contain" a country like China without assets in place. And they are there. I've read about 400 installations in Asia alone?

China militarily invaded another country in, if I recall, Vietnam in 1971. Most here were not born then. I'm a geezer and I was two. A lot of wars have occurred since then, but we characterize them as an aggressor nation. Their threat to us is not that they will invade their neighbour. It is that their economic force of gravity will pull the entire world into their economic orbit, leaving us as an "also ran".