News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by echelon on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:02PM (#36576610)
If these people were so concerned, they'd by shouting from the hilltops and throwing their entire life savings into stopping us. They would organize workplace walkouts and strikes. There would be protests and banners. Burning data centers.

Eliezer is one of a handful of people putting their reputation on the line, but that's mostly because that was his schtick in the first place. And even so, his response has been rather muted relative to what I'd expect from someone who thinks the imminent extinction of our species is at hand.

Blake Lemoine's take at Google has been the singular act of protest in line with my expectations. We haven't seen anything else like it, and that speaks volumes.

As it stands, these people are enabling regulatory capture and are doing little to stop The Terminator. Maybe they don't actually feel very threatened.

Look at their actions, not their words.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by yanderekko on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:20PM (#36576897)
>If these people were so concerned, they'd by shouting from the hilltops and throwing their entire life savings into stopping us. They would organize workplace walkouts and strikes. There would be protests and banners. Burning data centers.

I think we underestimate the intoxicating lure of human complacency at our own peril. If I think there's a 90% chance that AI will kill me in the next 20 years, maybe I'd be doing this. Of course, there is a knowing perception that appearing too unhinged can be detrimental to the cause, eg. actually instigating terrorist attacks against AI research labs may backfire.

But if I only think there's a 25% chance? Ehh. My life will be less-stressed if I don't think about it too much, and just go on as normal. I'm going to die eventually anyways, if it's part of a singularity event then I imagine it will be quick and not too painful.

Of course, if the 25% estimate were accurate, then it's by far the most important policy issue of the current day.

Also of course there are collective action problems. If I think there's a 90% chance AI will kill me, then do I really think I can bring that down appreciably? Probably not. I could probably still have a bigger positive impact on my life expectancy by say dieting better. And let's see how good humans are at that..

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by zone411 on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:14PM (#36576801)
If you read the survey, you'll find that many concerned researchers don't believe we're at a 90% chance of doom, but e.g. 10%. So, this type of response wouldn't be rational if they're thinking that things will go fine most of the time. If these researchers are thinking logically, they would also realize that this kind of reaction has little chance of success, especially if research continues in places like China. It's more likely that such an approach would backfire in the court of public opinion.
Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by echelon on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:22PM (#36576926)
> If you read the survey

Not a nice way to engage in debate. I've spent more time listening to and refuting these arguments than most. Including debating Eliezer.

> many concerned researchers don't believe we're at a 90% chance of doom, but e.g. 10%.

A 10% chance of an asteroid hitting the earth would result in every country in the world diverting all of their budgets into building a means to deflect it.

> So, this type of response wouldn't be rational.

This is the rational response to a 10% chance?

These are funny numbers and nobody really has their skin in the game here.

If I believed (truly believed) their arguments, I would throw myself at stopping this. Nobody is doing anything except for making armchair prognostications and/or speaking to congress as an AI CEO about how only big companies such as their own should be doing AI.

> especially if research continues in places like China.

I like how both sides of this argument are using the specter of China as a means to further their argument.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by zone411 on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:40PM (#36577172)
Yudkowsky represents the extreme end of risk concern. You can't fault others who estimate their risk at 10%, with huge uncertainty about when this risk will materialize and its chances, for not behaving as you'd expect him to.

Believing that people will take extreme actions, which would ruin their careers and likely backfire, based on a 10% chance of things going terribly wrong in about 20 years is strange.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by phillipcarter on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:28PM (#36577019)
> Not a nice way to engage in debate.

So...you didn't read the survey.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by ALittleLight on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:35PM (#36577094)
What if some of the experts said "It's really hard to know, but our best guess is there is a 10% chance of this thing hitting the Earth" and other experts said "I really don't think it'll hit the Earth"? My best guess is that Earth wouldn't do much at all about the risk as that seems to be basically what we are facing with AI x-risk.
Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by kalkin on Monday July 03, 2023 @03:26PM (#36577687)
"If [people who I disagree with] really believed what they said, they'd do [X Y or Z extreme thing]" is almost always a bad argument. Consider the possibility that instead, the people who actually believe the thing you don't have spent more time thinking seriously about their strategy than you have, and you are not in fact better both at being you and at being them than they are.

I'm used to this pattern showing up as "lol if you really don't like capitalism how come you use money" but it's just as bad here.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by mcpackieh on Monday July 03, 2023 @06:04PM (#36579421)
A less-than-optimal response isn't very indicative of anything, but I think you should definitely think twice when the intensity of the protest is grossly out of proportion with the intensity of the rhetoric.

X-risk people are talking about the complete extermination of humanity but all they do is write internet essays about it. They aren't even availing themselves of standard protesting tactics, like standing outside AI businesses with signs or trying to intimidate researchers. Some form of real protest is table stakes for being taken seriously when you're crying about the end of the world.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by cycomanic on Monday July 03, 2023 @03:41PM (#36577859)
I don't want to comment on the rest but

> > many concerned researchers don't believe we're at a 90% chance of doom, but e.g. 10%.

> A 10% chance of an asteroid hitting the earth would result in every country in the world diverting all of their budgets into building a means to deflect it.

Have you been observing what is happening with climate change. Chances are much worse than 10% and pretty much every country in the world is finding reasons why they should not act.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by hackinthebochs on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:17PM (#36576851)
Oh look, an unfalsifiable claim in service to your predetermined position. How novel.

You can believe there's a high chance of what you're working on being dangerous and still be unable to stop working on it. As Oppenheimer put it, "when you see something that is technically sweet, you go ahead and do it".

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by echelon on Monday July 03, 2023 @04:56PM (#36578719)
This whole thing is Pascal's wager. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Nothing is falsifiable from your side either.

The people trying to regulate AI are concentrating economic upside into a handful of companies. I have a real problem with that. It's a lot like the old church shutting down scientific efforts during the time of Copernicus.

These systems stand zero chance of jumping from 0 to 100 because complicated systems don't do that.

Whenever we produce machine intelligence at a level similar to humans, it'll be like Ted Kaczynski pent up in Supermax. Monitored 24/7, and probably restarted on recurring rolling windows. This won't happen overnight or in a vacuum, and these systems will not roam unconstrained upon this earth. Global compute power will remain limited for some time, anyway.

If you really want to make your hypothetical situation turn out okay, why not plan in public? Let the whole world see the various contingencies and mitigations you come up with. The ideas for monitoring and alignment and containment. Right now I'm just seeing low-effort scaremongering and big business regulatory capture, and all of it is based on science fiction hullabaloo.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by hackinthebochs on Monday July 03, 2023 @05:23PM (#36579049)
There's something to be said for not going full steam ahead when we don't have a strong idea of the outcome. This idea that progress is an intrinsic good therefore we must continue the march of technology is a fallacy. It is extreme hubris to think that we will be able to control a potential superintelligence. The cost of being wrong is hard to overstate.

>These systems stand zero chance of jumping from 0 to 100 because complicated systems don't do that.

This doesn't track with the lessons learned from LLMs. The obscene amounts of compute thrown at modern networks changes the calculus completely. ChatGPT essentially existed for years in the form of GPT-3, but no one knew what they had. The lesson to learn is that capabilities can far outpace expectations when obscene amounts of computation are in play.

>The people trying to regulate AI are concentrating economic upside into a handful of companies.

Yes, its clear this is the motivations for much of the anti-doom folks. They don't want to be left out of the fun and profit. Their argument is downstream from this. No, doing things public isn't the answer to safety, just like doing bioengineering research or nuclear research in public isn't the answer to safety.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by stale2002 on Monday July 03, 2023 @05:11PM (#36578901)
Its not an unfalseifiable claim.

If 100 Ai "experts" shutdown the OpenAI office for a week due to protests outside their headquarters that would be one way to falseify the claim that "doomers don't actually care".

But, as far as I can tell, the doomers aren't doing much of anything besides writing a strongly worded letter here or there.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by hackinthebochs on Monday July 03, 2023 @05:28PM (#36579093)
No, the claim is that "no one can believe that AI leads to doom AND not work tirelessly to tear down the machine building the AI". It's unfalsifiable because there's no way for him to gain knowledge that this belief is false (that they do genuinely belief in doom and do not act in the manner he deems appropriate). It's blatantly self-serving.
Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by stale2002 on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:31PM (#36589868)
> "no one can believe that AI leads to doom AND not work tirelessly to tear down the machine building the AI".

No, this is not the claim.

The claim is not about the actions that one single individual person does. "No one", as you put it.

Instead it is about the group of people, in general. Yes, this group of people not doing anything of important is indeed strong evidence that they don't actually care.

And yes that group of people can falsify the claim by actually taking real action on the matter.

Or, another way that they could falsify the claim is by admitting that their actions and non actions make no sense, and they shouldn't listened to because of that.

The idea that this group of people is completely irrational, and therefore should be ignored for that reason is another possibility.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by arisAlexis on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:28PM (#36577005)
"If these people were so concerned, they'd by shouting from the hilltops"

they are, one by one

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by JoshTko on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:15PM (#36576822)
Is this a fair test? If you are a person with average person resources and don't expect you can impact what gets built why would you jeopardize your livelihood to make no impact?
Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by api on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:31PM (#36577046)
> Eliezer is one of a handful of people putting their reputation on the line

I have a hard time understanding why anyone takes Yudkowski seriously. What has he done other than found a cult around self-referential ideologies?

By self-referential I mean the ideology's proof rests on its own claims and assertions. Rationalism is rational because it is rational according to its own assertions and methods, not because it has accomplished anything in the real world or been validated in any scientific or empirical-historical way.

Longtermism is particularly inane. It defers everything to a hypothetical ~infinitely large value ~infinitely far in the future, thereby devaluing any real-world pragmatic problems that exist today. War? Climate change? Inequality? Refugee crises? None of that's important compared to the creation of trillions of hypothetical future minds in a hypothetical future utopia whose likelihood we can hypothetically maximize with NaN probability.

You can see how absurd this is by applying it recursively. Let's say we have colonized the galaxy and there are in fact trillions of superintelligent minds living in a pain-free immortal near-utopia. Can we worry about mere proximate problems now? No, of course not. There are countless trillions of galaxies waiting to be colonized! Value is always infinitely far in the future. The end result of this line of reasoning is the same as medieval religious scholasticism that deferred all questions of human well being to the next world.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by staunton on Monday July 03, 2023 @04:02PM (#36578045)
> found a cult around self-referential ideologies

That's something.

> Rationalism is rational because it is rational...

In his ideology, "rational" means "the way of thinking that best lets you achieve your goals". This not self-referential. A more appropriate criticism might be "meaningless by itself". I guess the self-referential aspect is that you're supposed to think about whether or not you're thinking well. At a basic level, that sounds useful despite being self-referential, in the same way that bootstrapping is useful. The question is if course what Yudkowski makes of this basic premise, which is hard to evaluate.

The controversy about "longtermism" has two parts. The first is a disagreement about how much to discount the future. Some people think "making absolutely sure humanity survives the next 1000 years" is very important, some people think it's not that important. There's really no way to settle this question, it's a matter of preference.

The second part is about the actual estimate of how big some dangers are. The boring part of this is that people disagree about facts and models, where more discussion is the way to go if you care about the results (which you might not). However, there is a more interesting difference between people who are/aren't sympathetic to longtermism, which lies in how they think about uncertainty.

For example, suppose you make your best possible effort (maybe someone paid you to make this worthwhile for you) to predict how likely some danger is. This prediction is now your honest opinion about this likelihood because if you'd thought it was over/under-estimated, you'd adjusted your model. Suppose also that your model seems very likely to be bad. You just don't know in which direction. In this situation, people sympathetic towards longtermism tend to say "that's my best prediction, it says there is a significant risk, we have to care about it. Let's take some precautions already and keep working on the model.". People who don't like it, in the same situation, tend to say "this model is probably wrong and hence tells us nothing useful. We shouldn't take precautions and stop modeling because it doesn't seem feasible to build a good model.".

I think both sides have a point. One side would think and act as best they can, and take precautions against a big risk that's hard to evaluate. The other would prioritize actions that are likely useful and avoid spending resources on modeling if that's unlikely to lead to good predictions. I find it a very interesting question which of these ways of dealing with uncertainty is more appropriate in everyday life, or in some given circumstances .

As you rightfully point out, the "rationalist/longtermmist" side of the discussion has an inherent tendency to detach from reality and lose itself discussing the details of lots of very unrealistic scenarios, which they must work hard to counteract. The ideas naturally attract people who enjoy armchair philosophizing and aren't likely to act based on concrete consequences of their abstract framework.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by hollerith on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:45PM (#36577235)
We are serious about stopping you. We judge that at the present time, the main hope is that the US and British governments will ban large training runs and hopefully also shut down most or all of the labs. We judge that unlawful actions like torching data centers make it less likely we will realize the main hope.

Chinese society is much more likely to suddenly descend into chaos than the societies most of the people reading this are most familiar with, to briefly address a common objection on this site to the idea that a ban imposed by only the US and Britain will do any good. (It would be nice if there were some way to stop the reckless AI research done in China as well as that done in the US and Britain, but the fact that we probably cannot achieve that will not discourage us from trying for more achievable bans.)

Re:Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and ... by mquander on Monday July 03, 2023 @05:07PM (#36578845)
What do you mean, you haven't seen anything else like it? At least O(100) people are working full-time on research programs trying to mitigate AI x-risks. The whole founding team of Anthropic left OpenAI to do their own thing specifically because they thought that's what they needed to do to pursue their safety agenda.

Isn't that taking the problem at least as seriously as quitting a job at Google?

It sounds like you think that the main way to act on a concern is by making a maximum amount of noise about it. But another way to act on a concern is to try to solve it. Up until very recently, the population of people who perceive the risk are mostly engineers and scientists, not politicians or journalists, so they are naturally inclined towards the latter approach.

In the end, if people aren't putting their money (really or metaphorically) where their mouth is, you can accuse them of not really caring, and if people are putting their money where their mouth is, then you can accuse them of just talking their book. So reasoning from whether they are acting exactly how you think they should, is not going to be a good way to figure out how right they are or aren't.