Not a nice way to engage in debate. I've spent more time listening to and refuting these arguments than most. Including debating Eliezer.
> many concerned researchers don't believe we're at a 90% chance of doom, but e.g. 10%.
A 10% chance of an asteroid hitting the earth would result in every country in the world diverting all of their budgets into building a means to deflect it.
> So, this type of response wouldn't be rational.
This is the rational response to a 10% chance?
These are funny numbers and nobody really has their skin in the game here.
If I believed (truly believed) their arguments, I would throw myself at stopping this. Nobody is doing anything except for making armchair prognostications and/or speaking to congress as an AI CEO about how only big companies such as their own should be doing AI.
> especially if research continues in places like China.
I like how both sides of this argument are using the specter of China as a means to further their argument.
Believing that people will take extreme actions, which would ruin their careers and likely backfire, based on a 10% chance of things going terribly wrong in about 20 years is strange.
So...you didn't read the survey.
I'm used to this pattern showing up as "lol if you really don't like capitalism how come you use money" but it's just as bad here.
X-risk people are talking about the complete extermination of humanity but all they do is write internet essays about it. They aren't even availing themselves of standard protesting tactics, like standing outside AI businesses with signs or trying to intimidate researchers. Some form of real protest is table stakes for being taken seriously when you're crying about the end of the world.
> > many concerned researchers don't believe we're at a 90% chance of doom, but e.g. 10%.
> A 10% chance of an asteroid hitting the earth would result in every country in the world diverting all of their budgets into building a means to deflect it.
Have you been observing what is happening with climate change. Chances are much worse than 10% and pretty much every country in the world is finding reasons why they should not act.