Seems like they probably know where these are coming from. I imagine, like your boat analogy, that we can observe massive natural oceans swells and wouldn't notice the wake of a boat as it moves across the ocean.
from a layman's perspective, this sounds crazy cool that they were able to "see" this in the data. seems like one of those things that would be easy to miss from being scoped in and only discoverable after zooming back out. waaaaay out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMFLcmsjOBg
In the video, they mention that the models we have for FTL (by bending spacetime) wouldn't generate ripples in this way. We could however detect ripples from a really massive ship accelerating really really quickly.
I feel like a quasi-expert on these subjects because of it. lol
It would be like being hit by a tsunami and wondering if a cruise ship caused it.
But on a galactic scale.
The merger of black holes radiate something like 10% of that mass as gravitational waves. Start talking 2+ million solar masses black holes and 500,000 solar mass worth of energy in gravitational waves seems plausible though obviously rare.
A big enough cruise ship, accelerating fast enough, could cause a tsunami but it'd be far beyond anything we could reason about sensibly.
If they control that much energy, maybe it's waves from their equivalent of a microwave oven.
My hunch based on nothing is that we will achieve FTL no earlier than 2250.
I see you too have been forced to give PMs estimates when you don't understand the problem.
Somethings we will do the same way for hundreds of years, like the wheelbarrow will still exist in 500 years as it has for likely the previous 5,000.
Otoh, I doubt we will be going faster than light this millenium.
What's meant by the claim that 'space moves faster than light' is that extremely distant objects are moving away from each other, relative to each other, 'faster than light' -- which is permitted, so long as that distance can never be bridged by light.
The claim amounts to, in other words, that the universe is so large that we can compare objects at distances greater than those light could travel between them, and if we do that, they travel faster than light.
This is an "illusion in measurement" more than anything else. Nothing is travelling faster than light.
I think this simply refers to the metric expansion of the universe [1]. While nothing actually travels FTL, the distance between some objects really expands faster than FTL and is not an illusion.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_of_the_universe
'distances' arent literally 'expanding' -- this metaphor of expansion describes a shift in the matter distribution of the universe over time which seems like an expansion of an underlying substance 'space'.
This is the illusion. The metric is just that matter distribution. And the fact of its changing we call 'expansion'.
This metaphorical, substantival language, creates a lay impression that some physical object moves faster than light.
As antimatter is as powerful as one can get, it not being powerful enough is a good reason to think it's not going to work.
An Alcubierre drive (they're theoretical) would basically constantly compress the time curve of spacetime in front of the craft, allowing the craft to "ride" this compression as it moves forward, which means that the local speed of light of the craft is faster than the speed of light of an external observer. Note that the main issue we have is to find something that can compress space, and then to have it have enough energy for it not to be trivial (because 110% of the speed of light, while technically FTL speed, is still very slow for interstellar travel). And of course, while the existence of something that does this spacetime curve compression fits the math we have, we've yet to find a material or technique that actually does so.
Imagine you are on a rubber ruler. You can move at most 1 mark per second on the ruler. This is true regardless of how much the ruler is stretched or compressed.
So to move from mark 1 to mark 100 will always take the same time at top speed, regardless of any stretching/compression.
To take your ruler example, if you compress it by 1mm, you can traverse its entire length traveling 1mm less than before, thus, from the reference frame of someone who can't see that you've compressed the ruler, you've traveled slightly faster.
Do they require a long list of impossible things to work? Also yes!
There are entirely valid solutions in general relativity which allow for an object in a pocket of spacetime with other spacetime warped around it in such a way that, more or less, space is moving but not the object.
However achieving the arrangement of spacetime to make this happens requires many things which are impossible, aren't known to exist, or require something like all the energy in the Universe to achieve.
Also there are no valid known solutions that transition from normal space to this special spacetime arrangement, so it could only exist if it always existed.
So it comes down to: we're pretty sure such things are not actually possible but we know where to look and what problems to solve if it were. Occasionally we see a paper which removes some of the impossible things from the list.
It's one of those "unlikely but maybe someday" kinds of things.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ztc6QPNUqls
The Higgs mechanism affects electrons, not quarks, and is only responsible for about 1% of matter's mass. Most mass comes from the binding energy between quarks, which creates flux tubes between quark-antiquark pairs. If we add more energy to pull quarks apart, eventually the total energy added exceeds the mass-energy equivalence of another quark-antiquark pair, so a new pair gets created from the vacuum. I believe this is related to the Casimir effect, but IANAP (physicist).
Keep in mind that the mass-energy equivalence also applies to time. So like in the movie Interstellar, when they go down to the water planet, gravity is so high that time passes slower for them than the guy in the orbiting ship. In other words, the ship sees the landing craft move slower and slower as it approaches the surface. This difference in the speed of time near a gravity well is what slows the inner edge of a satellite slightly more than the outer, curving it along the path of the orbit, which from the satellite's perspective feels like a straight line at that velocity, because it's weightless and feels no other acceleration other than tidal force. So if someone could move large amounts of energy into a confined space with some kind of flux capacitor (is this a pun? I don't even know anymore), they could slow time there and create a virtual mass through mass-energy equivalence by E=mc^2. If they did it in front of the satellite, it would begin to increase in velocity towards that mass. So this is sort of a warp drive mechanism, although I don't know how you'd confine it, and the energies involved would be planet-scale to achieve 1 g of acceleration like near the Earth.
Also if someone made a closed loop where electron-positron pairs were sent one way, then their energy was used to create quark-antiquark pairs sent the other way, there might be a 1% imbalance in mass due to the Higgs mechanism, which would add momentum to the loop opposite the direction of the heavier stream. Although due to conservation of momentum, I suspect that this wouldn't actually happen, because any momentum above light pressure should get lost to heat/entropy/etc. But it would be a fun experiment to try. The same experiment would also work just sending light energy photons one way and matter-antimatter pairs back the other way, but I've never seen a proof as to why this would or wouldn't beat light pressure. This would be a reactionless rocket, not a warp drive.
If there's a gravity field like a gluon field, just with slightly different rules, then I don't see why it couldn't be modulated. In fact, I think that the dark matter strands connecting galaxies are densities where perhaps something like slowed neutrinos or axions collect and slow time. They could even be places where gravity "flows" along eddies left over from the Big Bang, although this seems strange to us because gravity normally only flows into gravity wells. There's also currently no explanation for the Hubble constant in the expansion of the universe, so perhaps something is creating space over time. So I don't see why space couldn't be created behind a craft to push it forward. We just don't know how.
There are so many unexplored interactions like this, that I don't think any physicist can confidently say that warp drives, reactionless rockets and folding space are impossible. Which means that I give it 50/50 odds that some kind of sci-fi space engine will be invented within the next few decades, probably starting with a reactionless drive like the EmDrive, which (if it works) uses resonance to time the interaction of microwaves with the rebound of atoms in an asymmetric field, similar to the Biefeld-Brown effect explored by Thomas Townsend Brown in the 1920s, which was later found to just be an electrohydrodynamic (EHD) effect:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactionless_drive
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EmDrive
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biefeld–Brown_effect
Unfortunately only physicists are privy to the mental associations which allow thought experiments like this. Textbooks leave us mainly theory and equations, not insights or abstractions. Physics formulas are like trying to understand the behavior of an app from its assembly language. So in a very real way, academic gatekeeping prevented almost everyone from contributing. For every divergent thinker like Einstein, there are 100 convergent thinkers who judge skeptically and crush ideas into oblivion.
I'm just an armchair warrior full of derivative ideas who has never invented anything, who would love to run experiments like these. But just like you the reader, I'll spend the rest of my life making CRUD apps to make rent because billionaires have all the money, instead of getting to be like Dr. Gillian Taylor in Star Trek IV, suddenly able to explore every possibility under the freedom of UBI. That was a joke, but not really.
It effects both. The LHC produces Higgs particles through the annihilation of top-antitop pairs, which works because the top quark couples strongly to the Higgs field.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_mechanism#Simple_explana...
This is a terrible analogy, I apologize in advance because I don't fully understand it yet, but:
We think of empty space as empty because its symmetry isn't broken, so it looks transparent to our matter as we move through it. Similarly to how electrons pair up to form cooper pairs, which act like bosons and pass through the atoms of a superconductor without interacting:
https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/171132/what-is-t...
https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/273894
But the Higgs field permeates space, so if we could pick and choose where to interact with it, we could "grab" it and propel ourselves. This would be analogous to a magnet levitating on a superconducting ring, just like this video but imagine that the track is the superconductor and the puck is the magnet:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AWojYBhvfjM
If we built a puck with two electromagnets, we could power up one of them above the critical field of the superconductor and form a resistive section which the other magnet would be drawn to or repulsed from:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_field
By alternating the strength of the two magnets, the track would stop behaving as empty space, and the puck could accelerate along it like a maglev train. A similar technique should work with the Higgs field.
I don't know how much the Higgs field "weighs", so I don't know how much of a reactive force we would get for the force applied. My guess is that it either wouldn't be higher than light pressure, or that the probability of an interaction would stay beneath what's required to beat light pressure. As in, this may be tied to how often a photon splits into an electron-positron pair, with the remaining energy bleeding off as heat or entropy. But it would be a fun experiment to run.
I just want to add that physics terminology and notation is too big to fit in the human mind, like trying to memorize a 100 digit phone number. The same problem exists in functional programming, where stuff like monads and y combinators just won't stick in a mind trained on imperative programming. So there's a very real limit to what we can understand. No matter how long we study this stuff, we can never connect all of the dots, or see faint relationships between distant concepts. IMHO this problem is getting worse with time, despite the advances in stuff like the Standard Model.
But AI doesn't have that problem. Within 10-20 years, it will infer how to modulate stuff like the weak force and gravity with electromagnetism in a practical way. If the aliens can do it we can do it! Or we can at least build machines to tackle the problem faster than we ever could. And if that's true, then why bother keeping research secret? It's gonna all come out eventually.
Edit: added the Higgs mechanism derivation from superconductivity. Also wanted to add that axions (if they exist) only interact with gravity and electromagnetism, making them a potential bridge between the two:
"I understand how the engines work now. It came to me in a dream. The engines don't move the ship at all. The ship stays where it is and the engines move the universe around it." ―Cubert Farnsworth
------
This is all firmly outside my technical discipline, but aren't there some theories that faster-than-light travel might be achieved by bending spacetime around a spacecraft, as opposed to trying to propel the spacecraft through space?
I really want to emphasize that this is entirely speculation, but is it possible that these gravitational waves could be the "ripples" produced in the wake of such faster-than-light travel, the same way a boat travelling through a body of water leaves ripples in the water behind it?