News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by adamgordonbell on Thursday June 22, 2023 @07:19PM (#36440593)
As a kid having to read Shakespeare what was lost on me, because of the language, was the language. Will worked hard to turn a phrase.

    "Cowards die many times before their deaths; The valiant never taste of death but once."

    "Some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them." 
    
    "It is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing." 

    "The very substance of the ambitious is merely the shadow of a dream."
These are catchy lines, even today.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by dbtc on Thursday June 22, 2023 @07:54PM (#36440896)
He wrote for our time too
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by Solvency on Thursday June 22, 2023 @09:45PM (#36441794)
It's almost like basic human behavior transcends time.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by bombcar on Thursday June 22, 2023 @08:55PM (#36441342)
Shakespeare has such influence that’s it’s almost more correct to say he wrote English than that he wrote in English.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by codersfocus on Friday June 23, 2023 @12:41AM (#36442858)
150+ words are said to be coined by him
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by MrJohz on Friday June 23, 2023 @12:59AM (#36442978)
In fairness, I think a lot of that is him writing in a vernacular English that wouldn't have been recorded much in official documents or other writings. So he probably didn't coin it so much as save it for posterity. Otherwise his plays would have been like those fantasy novels whether the author gets slightly too excited about using their made up words for everything.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by bloak on Friday June 23, 2023 @02:27AM (#36443521)
I agree. There are plenty of words for which the earliest surviving example of it being used is in a work attributed to Shakespeare, but there is no reason to believe that Shakespeare was the first to use any of those words. People don't generally use a new word for the first time in a play or a poem, but published plays and poems is all we have by Shakespeare.

The first use of a new word tends to be in conversation (so the first use is not recorded) or in a non-fiction work, where the meaning of the new word can be explained. Or in fantasy novels, as MrJohz points out. (But what's the earliest example of the sort of fantasy novel that has invented words in it?)

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by tialaramex on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:11AM (#36444868)
Some (many?) words attributed to Shakespeare follow the ordinary processes for making new words in certain open categories in English, and so you could argue that anybody might make these words as a competent English user, grasping for this specific meaning, has available the tools to make this word for that meaning. This could happen completely independently, even many times. If you need "invulnerable" or "majestic" for example you don't require the services of some specialist word inventor to come up with them, you can just make those yourself since you're a competent user and there are rules.

But Shakespeare used them in a context which people remembered, so that's why it matters, and in the process Shakespeare gets to choose some parameters for these words which are not set by the rules such as their emotional valence - is this a good thing or a bad thing? The rules usually don't dictate that, but usage does and Shakespeare can set the trend.

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by speed_spread on Friday June 23, 2023 @01:54AM (#36443296)
It's fair to say he got his cromulation game all figured out.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by BellsOnSunday on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:24AM (#36444961)
Most of those words weren't coined by him, his writing was just the earliest source that the dictionary makers could find. He didn't invent the word 'elbow', for instance.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by baud147258 on Friday June 23, 2023 @05:11AM (#36444513)
or maybe the English he wrote was subsenquently imposed as the standard English throughout the UK...
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by geokon on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:19AM (#36444921)
I learned that this is actually a bit of a coincidence. English started to in effect be standardized by the publishing of the first English dictionaries shortly after Shakespeare (esp standardizing spelling - which even in Shakespeare is a bit all over the place)

Not totally sure how much that plays into it. Would be curious to hear from someone that knows more

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by hyperbovine on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:22AM (#36445352)
It really is mind blowing how deeply influential his oeuvre has become. For me, one of the most pleasurable parts of reading Shakespeare as an adult have been the umpteen “oooh, so that’s where that comes from” moments (which are totally lost on you when Hamlet is being rammed down your throat in the 11th grade).
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by Dalewyn on Thursday June 22, 2023 @11:39PM (#36442504)
As a kid I hated reading Shakespeare because he's a playwright: His scripts are supposed to be seen, not read.

Taking certain lines out of context make for great memes, as you just demonstrated, but as a whole I simply didn't enjoy reading them and I promptly forgot it all after my schooling years.

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by hilbert42 on Friday June 23, 2023 @04:23AM (#36444217)
"As a kid having to read Shakespeare what was lost on me,…"

What age was that? I reckon most kids think Shakespeare is difficult at the beginning because of the language, and that brings me back to a point made in the article:

"For me, Richard II is the most dull of the Henriad plays."

I now think so too, but when I was studying the play it was the first one with any real story to it, so it encouraged me to figure out the language so I could follow the plot by myself.

I was introduced to Shakespeare at age 12 and in that year we studied two plays, As You Like It and A Midsummer Night's Dream and I was bored with both. The language wasn't difficult as our teacher explained everything well but I didn't find the stories interesting, they were a bit of a yawn really.

As I said that changed with Richard II and by then I was 14. Being older helped to understand nuances in the script but that was only part of it, the play simply had more substance to it which made it more interesting and worthy of study. Moreover, by then we had to first read the text without the teacher's help which would only come afterwards in class discussions.

Thus Richard II was the first play where Shakespeare actually made sense to me, it too was the first one where the language made sense without the teacher having to 'translate' every paragraph.

Putting Richard II behind me as an enjoyable experience rather than drudgery was important as it made me prepared for the great plays like Lear. That appreciation may not have happened if the order of introduction to the plays had been different.

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by jfengel on Friday June 23, 2023 @10:04AM (#36446963)
It's hard to read the comedies. A lot of the humor is hidden in the way Shakespeare encoded his "stage directions" in the text. (The stage directions as we have them are almost never Shakespeare's own writing. They were added by later editors.)

An egregious example: the big gag in the play-within-a-play of Midsummer is that the "hole" in the wall is between the actor's legs. When they kiss, they're kissing his butt and his crotch. The text is really quite clear about it: "I kiss the wall's hole", "Thy stones with lime and hair".

It's not much to read, but in performance, it's incredibly obvious (and juvenile) humor. (So juvenile that a lot of productions do something else, and the whole scene falls flat.) Reading the footnotes is never going to make it funny to a reader.

The histories and tragedies are much more story-focused, and a lot easier to read. They're still better in performance, where the actors and director have done the "translation", and you can connect more viscerally to the moment.

Reading a play is an advanced skill, and I really wish English teachers wouldn't treat it as if it were readily accessible to high school students. You do have to start somewhere, but a complete, unedited comedy is starting at the summit of a mountain.

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by hilbert42 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @02:49AM (#36456229)
"It's hard to read the comedies. A lot of the humor is hidden in the way Shakespeare encoded his "stage directions" in the text."

Agreed, I didn't express what I said well. The comedies make much more sense to me now but are easily lost on 12-year-olds unless carefully introduced and explained well.

At my school it didn't help that anything likely to titillate the minds of 12-year-old boys was expurgated from the text (our school editions were first published in the 1940s/'50s or earlier and had been used by the school for decades so the editing had a sense of prudery about it). Of course that they were censored was never mentioned by the teachers but when I was about 15 I discovered the fact by accident after using one of my father's editions for homework. Not sure of the play now but it wasn't one of the comedies (I think it was Julius C.). This 'naughty' edition was a hit when I took it to school, the kids were rightly annoyed to see large chunks of text missing from their school editions. For example, any part with bastard in it was removed, and that was just for starters.

Had the comedies not been hacked about I'm sure they would have made more sense. Fortunately I don't think that nonsense goes on any longer.

"They're still better in performance, where the actors and director have done the "translation"."

Very true, every once in a while we had a troupe called The Young Shakespeare Players come to the school and perform everything from Lear to Julius Caesar to The Scottish play to the comedies and they performed them in ways that would bring out the best for school kids.

I suppose I'm sensitive to the way Shakespeare is introduced to schools because I'm a techie whose primary interests were technical and science subjects and I was only mediocre at English and languages school, so it would have been easy for me to end up among the group that found Shakespeare a drugery and that was so for some. Their attitude was the words didn't make sense so why bother studying it (the same went for poetry, I recall some kids just giving up on Eliott's The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock and The Waste Land). Fortunately, I caught the Shakespeare bug and I'm very glad I did.

Incidentally, we had a little textbook just called English Essays, it contained works by Addison, Steele, Bacon, Hazlitt, Lamb and so on. I just fell in love with many of these essays such as Old China, A Dissertation Upon Roast Pig, On a Sundial, Sir Roger de Coverley and so on—I remember them as if it were yesterday. The language is so beautiful and eloquent yet they lose nothing for being very short. They were very formative, they brought great writing in small digestible amounts to kids like me who would normally prefer to be reading say Scientific American than novels like Thackeray's Vanity Fair, which I recall I struggled to get through. I cannot understand why these wonderful essays seem to have fallen out of favor with educators.

—

Edit: Re stage directions as we have them are almost never Shakespeare's own writing. I have a reprint collection of the earliest folio editions and they are a little too Spartan for me (they're harder to follow).

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by atchoo on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:29AM (#36445408)
I wonder how many of the classic Shakespeare lines were actually popular idioms of the time rather than novel creations.

I imagine if the works of only one contemporary cliche ridden author survived in 500 years time, they would appear to be a literary genius without the context that shows them to be mediocre.

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by AlecSchueler on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:58AM (#36445631)
If that were the case then we'd expect a similar level of wonderful lines in the works of his contemporaries, but he was very clearly a standout wordsmith even compared with other fine writers such as Marlowe, Middleton, Webster and Jonson etc.

It's not that his are the only works to have survived, they're simply the only ones we still speak of in regular conversation.

Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by dri_ft on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:59AM (#36445638)
There's quite a lot of work on this kind of thing; any edition of Shakespeare with good notes will alert you where a line resembles something 'proverbial'. One thing you notice is that although he often alludes to proverbial sayings, he seldom includes them verbatim - more often, it is a glancing, passing suggestion of them, or he uses them with a twist, or as part of some more complex figure of speech he is developing.
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by klik99 on Friday June 23, 2023 @08:10AM (#36445741)
I recently watch "Upstart Crow" which is full of jokes about this - a running gag is Shakespeare claiming he created all these phrases and another character citing exactly the date and author of an earlier reference. Well - it's funnier in execution than I just made it sound...
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by slim on Saturday June 24, 2023 @05:55PM (#36462993)
meh. he speaks in punchlines. these days many rappers do that all day for hours /s
Re:My ranking of every Shakespeare play by bazoom42 on Sunday June 25, 2023 @08:20AM (#36467436)
Yeah, rap is probably the closest modern popular culture has to Shakespeare. The rythm, rhyming, wordplay, dirty language etc.