News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by a2tech on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:34PM (#36420765)
I don’t understand what game IBM is playing with Red Hat. I was under the impression they were profitable prior to the acquisition so I’m not sure why they’re squeezing so hard and ruining the great brand and good will Red Hat had built up.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Timon3 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:41PM (#36420894)
IBM is stuck in a cycle of constant re-invention, because they somehow manage to always re-invent themselves in ways that are even worse and more complicated for customers, which they try to fix by re-inventing themselves again. Even if they initially planned on leaving Red Hat alone, every re-invention is a chance for some executive to make the decision to squeeze a little tighter on existing customers. So the question shouldn't be "what game is IBM playing with Red Hat", but "how long until nothing usable is left". I'd say maybe 20 more re-inventions, or 1-2 years.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by 5e92cb50239222b on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:43PM (#36420922)
Yet they're still way older than most tech companies. I'd wager they will outlive 99.99% of those unicorn startups yet.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by taeric on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:59PM (#36421170)
How much of that is lingering brand value, though? That and simple ties into existing and old industries.

You are also comparing to startups? Which... yes, most things die. Sometimes, it is the old things that die. Often taking a lot of other younger things with them.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Fordec on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:53PM (#36421072)
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by anyoneamous on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:56PM (#36423516)
Immortality is a curse, not a blessing.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pjmlp on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:47PM (#36420988)
Many startups can only dream of being as long and influential as IBM is.

Also note that IBM contributions to Linux kernel in 2000, was one of the reasons it actually took off.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Timon3 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:48PM (#36421006)
> Many startups can only dream of being as long and influential as IBM is.

Okay? Do you feel attacked because I wrote something negative about IBM? Not sure how that is relevant to my point.

> Also note that IBM contributions to Linux kernel in 2000, was one of the reasons it actually took off.

And that influences the motivations behind their current decisions how exactly?

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pjmlp on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:38PM (#36421750)
Me attacked, not all.

HN loves to hate Oracle, IBM, SAP, Adobe and friends, without getting the point that many startups that go through HN programs never achieve half of what they produce.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Timon3 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:42PM (#36421807)
What do startups have to do with IBMs business direction and processes? How does this relate to my point? Not every startup being successful somehow means that I shouldn't comment on IBMs recent business decisions?
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pjmlp on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:19PM (#36422223)
A matter of perspective into actual influence into the capitalist US society.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by dizhn on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:46PM (#36422622)
We seem to even be hating on RedHat now. (I was bummed about the Centos thing too). People on this thread are acting like Redhat doesn't even release any free software.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by JonChesterfield on Thursday June 22, 2023 @11:23PM (#36442417)
Well, they used to. Now there's software to be had in exchange for money. Mostly written by people outside of IBM. And the source access they used to provide is disappearing one move at a time. Which leaves a void and an opportunity, but also a lot of annoyance at IBM.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by ghaff on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:51PM (#36421032)
I'd argue that IBM's contributions in that timeframe were more about about validating it from a large business perspective than about technical contributions (that tended to focus on large system performance which wasn't actually that important for Linux taking off).
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pjmlp on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:36PM (#36421718)
Well, that is playing what-ifs with IBM, Intel, Compaq and Oracle initial set of contributions in 2000.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by PAPPPmAc on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:21PM (#36422260)
"Large" wasn't a very big standard at the time.

Linux's multiprocessor support was ...lackluster at best... prior to IBM contributing all the Sequent (Dynix) derived multiprocessing stuff. Hyperthreading/Multicore started to get "normal" even in consumer systems only a couple years later, so that injection was pretty critical.

Likewise, a lot of Linux's development inertia and cultural acceptance came from being a cheap and consistent alternative to screwing around with the profusion of expensive and mutually incompatible proprietary Unixes in the Server and (as clusters co-evolved) HPC market.

On the broader issue, the tension here is that IBM thinks the value proposition of RHEL is "Supported" and (I suspect) almost everyone else regards the value proposition of RHEL as "standard base." I think it's more likely that the "standard base" for srs bsns Linux in the markets where RHEL is the standard would rebase than IBM having any success trying to squeeze customers, and if that happens the value of "Owning RHEL" suddenly shrinks dramatically. Honestly, all it would take is the RHEL-likes like Alma and Rocky to agree on a coordination mechanism that isn't matching RHEL - could be through a major public interest like CERN, could be through an existing commercial interest like coordinating with Oracle (ew), could be via one of the several entities that does commercial support for RHEL-likes ... there are options.

Oracle being a gigantic litigious parasite on society is a broader issue, and I understand regarding commercial RHEL-likes as more of a problem, but even they have been funding a lot of backport-to-LTS type work.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by ghaff on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:39PM (#36422545)
>Linux's multiprocessor support was ...lackluster at best... prior to IBM contributing all the Sequent (Dynix) derived multiprocessing stuff. Hyperthreading/Multicore started to get "normal" even in consumer systems only a couple years later, so that injection was pretty critical.

It was certainly needed over time but capabilities from things like RCU out of Sequent weren't that important in the 2000 timeframe. And a lot of IBM's contributions didn't come online until the v4 kernel.

None of this is to minimize IBM's contributions to Linux over but I'd argue pretty strongly that IBM's endorsement of Linux for enterprises in January 2000 is what really moved the needle in the short run.

Here's what one of the people most directly involved told me a few years ago:

By the late 90s, it was clear that Linux was becoming more and more important. And we formed a major task force to see to what extent IBM should embrace Linux and this happened in 1999. And the task force came back and said, we absolutely should embrace Linux, that it was going to be an incredibly important part of computing, that we should embrace Linux across all of IBM's offerings. And that IBM should become a major supporter of Linux.

And I still remember very well in December of ‘99, I called Sam Palmisano, the head of IBM Systems Group. And I said, Sam, the task force recommends that we should embrace Linux. And Sam said, okay, Irving, we will do that. But you have to now come over and run an IBM Linux initiative. And I said to Sam, okay, we were pretty much done with our internet strategy. So I was no longer needed to run the Internet division And I said to Sam, when do you want to announce it? And Sam said, how about now? And I said Sam. It's the Christmas holidays. Maybe we should wait until the new year. And in the second week of January of 2000, we made a major announcement saying that IBM would embrace Linux across all of these offerings. And in fact, later that month in January of 2000, I gave a keynote at LinuxWorld, which was taking place in the Javits Center in New York City, about IBM’s Linux initiative.

At some level, the rest is history.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by PAPPPmAc on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:30PM (#36423201)
I was mixing up where the big multiprocessor changes that went into the 2.5 series in that 2000-2005 era came from.

I was thinking of the the basic kernel preemption stuff and sched_setaffinity syscall + userspace plumbing like taskset that is _extremely_ consequential on little multicore/SMT machines, but the prominent name on a lot of that was Robert Love and he was at MontaVista at the time.

The Dynix parts that arrived via IBM were, as you say, mostly NUMA and RCU stuff based on Paul McKenney's work, which also went in in the same major overhaul during the 2.5 series but weren't quite so immediately consequential to smaller systems.

I hadn't heard that anecdote, but that is a neat tale of IBM using their gravitas at the time to legitimize Linux.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by jabl on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:41PM (#36424108)
SGI also did a lot of scalability work in that time frame, as part of their migration from MIPS+Irix to Itanium+Linux. In the end they got Linux working on IIRC up to 4096 processors.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by jamiesonbecker on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:40PM (#36423314)
And who can forget "peace, love, Linux" ;)

https://www.zdnet.com/article/ibm-gets-100000-fine-for-peace...

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by ghaff on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:36PM (#36424053)
Or the "prodigy" series of TV ads that were pitched for CEOs and Prime Ministers according to the then-head of IBM advertising.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by jamiesonbecker on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:32PM (#36423222)
Yes, certifying DB2 for Linux (back in 1998, https://slashdot.org/index2.pl?fhfilter=db2+linux, scroll to bottom) was an absolutely earth-shattering event that announced that Linux had arrived. I think that event (and of course Oracle and Sybase a few months prior) really sounded the death knell for big-iron UNIX.

But in 1999, IBM ported Linux to run on System 390 (https://slashdot.org/index2.pl?fhfilter=mainframe+linux) and I remember there was a story that some IBM scientist booted more than 30,000 Linux instances on a mainframe on his lunch break. This research led to the big SUSE partnership, as well as open-sourcing other enterprise-y software like JFS and putting a big devteam to make the kernel ready for real SMP (Linux didn't have efficient+mature SMP even into the early aughts, although a few companies had built some massive SMP boxes.)

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by ghaff on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:01PM (#36423570)
>Linux didn't have efficient+mature SMP even into the early aughts, although a few companies had built some massive SMP boxes

Including IBM. (Forget when they did their big stackable X-series server.) A lot of the tech eventually became applicable to even super-mainstream dual-socket servers but I wonder how much money was largely wasted on building and trying to sell larger scale-up boxes.

But, yeah, IBM was one of the big investors in OSDL (and their own Linux Technology Center) which had a lot of scale-up focus which made a lot of the legal claims of another 3-letter company pretty much misaligned with the timeline.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by kermatt on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:53PM (#36421069)
Many startups can only dream of being as long and influential as IBM was.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pjmlp on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:35PM (#36421699)
Champion in patents per year in tech, Red-Hat, 2nd major Java implementation, one of the few vendors in quantum computing.

That alone looks quite alright for a dying company.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by StillBored on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:43PM (#36422593)
Except roll the clock back a bit and your would have been talking about Lotus, Machine Learning, and Unix/PowerPC.

And we see what IBM has done with leadership in those areas, as well as a long line of other areas where they somehow managed to turn themselves into a 3rd rate competitor despite being in the right place at the right time.

So, you have to ask yourself, for example how its possible that people are falling over themselves to build a RISCv ecosystem from the ground up, when openpower has been around for a decade now, and IBMs been looking for partners there since the original AIM alliance.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pjmlp on Thursday June 22, 2023 @01:24AM (#36428283)
Looking at their yearly revenue, doing quite alright.

The RISCv ecosystem is a pipe dream that people will finally get it when they start dealing with major boards relying on extensions, or board designs that aren't as open as the CPU itself.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by jimkoen on Thursday June 22, 2023 @04:09AM (#36429312)
There have yet to evolve practical applications for current quantum computers. No one cares about Java anymore, beyond legacy support. They bought RedHat with their massive reserve of capital from more successful times.

IBM is still in business because they can build on massive reserves from the time where they literally created the market for commercial computing. That was indeed influential. Now they slowly burn those reserves and have a crackhead sales team that knows how to sell mainframes and subsequently suck those customers dry.

The new generation of graduates has no idea what IBM does, let alone what a mainframe is. New talent for maintaining Cobol codebases is so rare to come by, that they pay the Linux foundation to offer free courses on Cobol.

IBM's success is a relict of the past. It will die when the last guy that knows how to maintain Cobol dies. Good riddance.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by josefx on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:51PM (#36421927)
> IBM contributions to Linux kernel in 2000

That was quarter a century ago.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pjmlp on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:20PM (#36422231)
In fact, now they own most relevant projects.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by zitterbewegung on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:57PM (#36421135)
I think you are being very pessimistic. All of their acquisitions are used to fund reinventions but due to their existing mainframe and other support contracts it makes a moat that people have a hard time crossing. I could see Oracle being merged or bought by IBM.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Timon3 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:00PM (#36421174)
I definitely am pessimistic, but that is probably due to my time working for them :) I can't remember any acquisition during my time there that didn't get significantly worse. Red Hat was the one hold-out, but this thread is example enough for me to know that nothing has changed since.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by 0x0000000 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:11PM (#36422961)
> I could see Oracle being merged or bought by IBM.

Their market caps are almost identical, and personally I'd say it'll be a cold day in hell before Oracle merges with, nevermind is acquired by, IBM.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by adql on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:37PM (#36420823)
The same game they play with their main customers, make sure they will have more and more problems leaving.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by kermatt on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:51PM (#36421047)
> I was under the impression they were profitable prior to the acquisition so I’m not sure why they’re squeezing so hard and ruining the great brand and good will Red Hat had built up.

Some growth metric that can't be realized quick enough through innovation (new products or services), so the only recourse is to cut costs or get more revenue from existing products without improving them.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by a_subsystem on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:56PM (#36421108)
IBM is slowly ruining everything they produce. Their systems are incredibly secure because it's extremely difficult to even run them normally as an operator, much less hack in. The byzantine/circular documentation and downloads pages on their site are woefully inadequate in enabling developers. Web searches reveal little information if you have a problem, as not many people run these systems. You generally have to pay stunning amounts to 3rd party professionals to manage your platform for even what should be relatively simple things like patching (PTFs), OS updates, and language upgrades. They will balk if you tell them they have bugs in their systems unless you can produce code yourself pinpointing the problem. They aren't interested in working with schools/universities to train young people to create fresh workers knowledgeable on their systems. Seems like they are milking the company and coasting until it expires.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by godzillabrennus on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:10PM (#36421343)
I heard from a former employee at IBM that management has been offended the media used FAANG to describe big tech, because they are delusional and still think they are relevant enough to be big tech…
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by krylon on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:34PM (#36421683)
The slightly, but not too much, sad part is that if they had played their cards right, IBM could be a lot more relevant today than it is. Some aspects of their tech still are quite impressive and unmatched by offerings in the open systems space.

But the profit margins on their mainframe business are (last I heard anything about it) really juicy, and in today's business world, that appears to incentivize IBM management to go for the low hanging fruit of milking that while effectively cannibalizing their own market in the long run.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by barbariangrunge on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:26PM (#36421571)
When I think of ibm, I think of how my wife had to attend special training on how to get paid at her government job due to how unreliable and chaotic the phoenix payroll system is. How it’s sometimes like a part time job sorting through it, and how they are all given time each month as needed to spend days on the phone trying to get somebody to manually fix issues that come up

> By July 2018, Phoenix has caused pay problems to close to 80 percent of the federal government's 290,000 public servants through underpayments, over-payments, and non-payments.

> Instead of saving $70 million a year as planned, the report said that the cost to taxpayers to fix Phoenix's problems could reach a total of $2.2 billion by 2023

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenix_pay_system

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by a_subsystem on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:18PM (#36422208)
Maybe it's still going through the turning into ashes part.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by mananaysiempre on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:24PM (#36423875)
IBM has known how to play vendor lock-in and death by a thousand related products since before computers could fetch instructions from memory, when most of the world still thought just shipping what their customers need was where it’s at. (Evidently—if unfortunately for my worldview—that doesn’t contradict there being a lot of very good engineers there.) I can believe they are dying a slow death, I don’t know, but just making their stuff worse for business reasons is not by itself a symptom of that—it’s simply part of their normal lifecycle.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by throwaway12245 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:58PM (#36421151)
IBM bought Lotus 1-2-3. Looks like the same playbook.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by jmclnx on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:18PM (#36421444)
Yes.

They bought it for Notes, Notes was good before IBM purchased it, rel 4 was pretty good. New Releases it got worse and worse. They finally dumped it I think two years ago and sold it to another company.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by windexh8er on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:27PM (#36421587)
> I don’t understand what game IBM is playing with Red Hat.

And this is yet another part of the reason why I don't understand the big push for RedHat specific tooling. Podman comes up a lot. But, just like with everything RHEL it seems as though RedHat / IBM wants to be the Apple of Linux. I'm not a fan of that. I also don't believe IBM is a good steward of OSS based on how I've seen them try to sell it in the enterprise.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by anyoneamous on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:01PM (#36423568)
> I don't understand the big push for RedHat specific tooling

I'd wager it is driven by RH simply being "least worst" of the options which can be relied on to stick around long enough for enterprise users.

Canonical are doing their best to screw the pooch with snap and similar nonsense, leaving the only other option being cobbling together a collection of tools from fly-by-night small projects - which might go full unicorn-wannabe and adopt an open-core SaaS model any second.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by mjevans on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @06:15PM (#36425438)
Debian? Maybe SUSE?

Offhand I don't know enterprise level support for any of them, but I expect 'support' solutions are offered for all of them, even if not first party as an outside source.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by anyoneamous on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @06:20PM (#36425474)
SUSE is the other one I thought about mentioning - but I have only really seen it used with SAP.

A big part of the problem is ISVs refusing to test their software on more than just RH - which is not in itself a totally unreasonable position - but it does now give IBM too much clout.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by windexh8er on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @07:34PM (#36426237)
I guess I should have been more clear. What I meant was that there seem to be a lot of die hard RedHat fans that hock the RedHat ecosystem for no apparent gain. I failed to make my point clearly, however. Podman is one of those tools that seem to follow up that narrative. RedHat could invest in the container ecosystem to make things better. Instead they strive to compete and hang their hat on very specific arguments against products that were (and still are in many cases) more complete.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by rodgerd on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:56PM (#36424344)
> I don’t understand what game IBM is playing with Red Hat.

IBM is doing the thing IBM knows how to do, which is have their internal politics, honed over a century or so, dictate the customer experience.