Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by babelthuap on Monday June 19, 2023 @08:33PM
(#36398234)
I've never used FB or Meta. I do find Elon's comments on free speech on target. We will find out together where this goes I guess. I personally like free speech and I mean all of it. Hatred, spite, honesty, truth, humility...all of it. Put it all out there and let it rip.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by sashank_1509 on Monday June 19, 2023 @09:03PM
(#36398458)
Amazing how many such cases we see: "Once I looked upto Elon, but now not anymore". This almost always occurs due to a very specific pathology: You've inferred motives based on outcomes. When he was focused on SpaceX, Tesla he was "earnest", "sincere", "cool". When he focuses on right wing politics and twitter, he's a "wannabe", "selfish", "duplicitous", there are many such descriptions I see online. The only conclusion I can come to upon seeing sentences like this is that you live in a comic book reality. When people have good outcomes, they decidedly have noble and good intentions, when people have bad outcomes, they have evil and selfish intentions. The possibility that someone can have objectively horrible outcomes with noble, pure intentions or vice versa does not exist in this world. To someone who does not live in a comic book, Elon has always had pure and earnest motives, in the sense that if he acted duplicitous he was not consciously aware of it. He does believe he is saving free speech, making humans multi-planetary, saving the environment, saving lives with autopilot etc. Now whether his earnest desires are leading to good real world outcomes is probably something you disagree with and that is a judgement you can make, yet it's very weird when you make assumptions on motivations. In the comic book world:
1. Journalists who often lead to good outcomes are earnest and moral in stature while when you actually interact with journalists you would realize they are easily the scum of the earth and the most deceptive group in real life to ever exist. You do not want to be their friend. When journalists are aware of their pathology you get amazing lines like: (from Hamilton Nolan in Gawker):
"
Because journalism, particularly at the highest level, is about raw power. It is about bringing important people to heel, on behalf of the public.
All I know is that there is only one way the press maintains its power in society: by metaphorically putting the heads of powerful people on pikes. If the Post and all the other respectable media outlets lose their ability to do that, powerful people will, by extension, stop caring what the well-informed segment of the public thinks.
"
2. Non Profit's often have very noble intentions and high aspirations Yet, a very large number of Non Profit's are the worst thing to happen to the society they're trying to help. One only needs to look at the drug problem at SF and their enablers, but one can also marvel at the death toll of the Arab Spring.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by codetrotter on Monday June 19, 2023 @09:17PM
(#36398574)
> He does believe he is saving free speech
He calls himself a “free speech absolutist” and then he turns around and bans a bunch a people for speech he doesn’t like. So much for the “absolutist” stance on free speech my dude.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by smt88 on Monday June 19, 2023 @08:53PM
(#36398391)
Elon's behavior never matches his words, and that's never been more true than with regards to free speech.
He personally bans people who criticize him or just disagree with him. Twitter has also stepped up compliance with authoritarian governments around the world.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by babelthuap on Monday June 19, 2023 @09:05PM
(#36398475)
I have no info on what he banned or blocked. All I am saying is if someone wants a KKK platform or a white hate platform then so be it. As long as they are not harming anyone physically or financially it is fair game. We can't have this now for some reason but I grew up in a time when it was allowed. Nothing bad happened unlike today. The more things are banned the more bad thing happen. Maybe stop banning things? Just a suggestion from personal experience.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by babelthuap on Monday June 19, 2023 @11:33PM
(#36399408)
I grew up in a time when David Duke was allowed to speak on campuses. He is still a joke just like he was then. You are deluded being there was no major media platforms back then. Major media platforms didn't exist outside of antenna TV.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by smt88 on Monday June 19, 2023 @11:58PM
(#36399533)
> I grew up in a time when David Duke was allowed to speak on campuses.
College campuses are not major or important platforms.
> Major media platforms didn't exist outside of antenna TV.
Cable news has been huge and important for 40 years. Before that (and today), there are thousands of widely-circulated publications with dissenting opinions that reach millions of people.
There's no reasonable argument that information is censored since it became essentially free to publish on the web in the 90s.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by babelthuap on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @10:17PM
(#36427271)
Almost nobody had cable TV in the early 80's. I grew up during this period but believe what you want. Cable TV was barely off the ground. HBO, Showtime, Cinemax, but outside of that it was nothing. No reach.
Fast forward to the 90's when hate groups were allowed on the internet. No race riots, burning of cities. That only happened when things started getting banned. And the violence was not from the right. It was the left. They were the ones who looted and burned but again, believe what you want to believe. If you believe it then it happened. Right wingers burned and looted Walmarts..meh.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by impulser_ on Monday June 19, 2023 @08:46PM
(#36398331)
I'm all for a replacement for Twitter. The changes made by Elon has made Twitter so unbearable. The pay to win aspect of promoting tweets showing up on For You page and replies is absolute cancer. The For You page is literally unusable if you don't want to rot your brain. Before Elon made changes, I barely had to block people. Now I have to block people all the time just to try to make For You page worth looking at.
The ads on Twitter are almost always scam products. Some of them even have community notes saying it a scam product yet they are still showing the ads lol.
The old twitter was great once you figured out how to use it, but that all went away once they started promoting only tweets/replies from paid users.
I just want to follow some topics and people and get tweets related to that like you could with the old twitter.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by holler on Monday June 19, 2023 @09:10PM
(#36398521)
Half of me thinks dead on arrival, as this lacks any creative ingenuity, novelty, or innovation. Other half thinks it will work in the same way instagram reels were a success after being copied from Snapchat.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by scrum-treats on Monday June 19, 2023 @09:47PM
(#36398754)
Whatever Zuckerberg rolls out, it'll be spyware for whatever government agency wants to disseminate propaganda, target and manipulate subgroups, and surveil innocent people. Somehow this is allowed. I choose not to use any of Zuckerberg's offerings going forward.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by scrum-treats on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @12:50PM
(#36406864)
Oh, I don't use Twitter. I set up a handful of accounts to look at information spread, for academic research purposes, and that was it. Once I learned nothing can be deleted, it was enough to deter me from the platform.
The real challenge isn’t building a Twitter clone, it’s everything that comes around it- like having a consistent content moderation policy, following relevant privacy laws, growing engagement with a good discovery engine, and most of all getting people to be willing to try your app in the first place.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg goes in for the kill as Elon Musk’s Twitt...
by Zigurd on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:04AM
(#36404155)
This isn't about speech. This is Zuck doing what he is really good at: making a place advertisers want to be on, providing the best tools for advertisers, making money for advertisers and, hence, for Meta.
Twitter, meanwhile, has hired an ad sales head, called her CEO but denied her the tools to make Twitter a good place to advertise, which puts her on the "glass cliff." Elon has someone to blame for failing at ads.
Until of course, the moment where after having bought Twitter he saw to it that they banned people saying things he didn’t like.
Elon Musk is not about free speech. He is about speech that he likes.
I used to look up to the guy when he was focusing on space and electric cars. But he’s just another wannabe, not a real cool person :(
1. Journalists who often lead to good outcomes are earnest and moral in stature while when you actually interact with journalists you would realize they are easily the scum of the earth and the most deceptive group in real life to ever exist. You do not want to be their friend. When journalists are aware of their pathology you get amazing lines like: (from Hamilton Nolan in Gawker): " Because journalism, particularly at the highest level, is about raw power. It is about bringing important people to heel, on behalf of the public. All I know is that there is only one way the press maintains its power in society: by metaphorically putting the heads of powerful people on pikes. If the Post and all the other respectable media outlets lose their ability to do that, powerful people will, by extension, stop caring what the well-informed segment of the public thinks. "
2. Non Profit's often have very noble intentions and high aspirations Yet, a very large number of Non Profit's are the worst thing to happen to the society they're trying to help. One only needs to look at the drug problem at SF and their enablers, but one can also marvel at the death toll of the Arab Spring.
He calls himself a “free speech absolutist” and then he turns around and bans a bunch a people for speech he doesn’t like. So much for the “absolutist” stance on free speech my dude.
He personally bans people who criticize him or just disagree with him. Twitter has also stepped up compliance with authoritarian governments around the world.
College campuses are not major or important platforms.
> Major media platforms didn't exist outside of antenna TV.
Cable news has been huge and important for 40 years. Before that (and today), there are thousands of widely-circulated publications with dissenting opinions that reach millions of people.
There's no reasonable argument that information is censored since it became essentially free to publish on the web in the 90s.
Fast forward to the 90's when hate groups were allowed on the internet. No race riots, burning of cities. That only happened when things started getting banned. And the violence was not from the right. It was the left. They were the ones who looted and burned but again, believe what you want to believe. If you believe it then it happened. Right wingers burned and looted Walmarts..meh.
[1] has 30 race riots in a 5 year period before the internet was invented. [2] has a whole lot more pre-1990s.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghetto_riots_(1964–1969)
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_racial_violence_in_the_Un...
The ads on Twitter are almost always scam products. Some of them even have community notes saying it a scam product yet they are still showing the ads lol.
The old twitter was great once you figured out how to use it, but that all went away once they started promoting only tweets/replies from paid users.
I just want to follow some topics and people and get tweets related to that like you could with the old twitter.
https://english.elpais.com/international/2023-05-24/under-el...
https://web-crunch.com/posts/lets-build-with-ruby-on-rails-7...
The real challenge isn’t building a Twitter clone, it’s everything that comes around it- like having a consistent content moderation policy, following relevant privacy laws, growing engagement with a good discovery engine, and most of all getting people to be willing to try your app in the first place.
Twitter, meanwhile, has hired an ad sales head, called her CEO but denied her the tools to make Twitter a good place to advertise, which puts her on the "glass cliff." Elon has someone to blame for failing at ads.