And doing construction work, he paid for his family's house over the course of about five years. It wasn't a palace, but it was a nice house in a (then) nice neighborhood with a good-sized lawn. Today, people routinely spend twenty or thirty years to buy a decent house. Even dumpy houses in poor locations would likely take well over five years for many people to pay for.
Something seems very wrong.
The price of a house depends on how many people there are to build it (like your grandfather).
These days people build all sorts of other things, so the price of a house goes up. But on the other hand you now have so many other cool things that weren't available back then.
Very much so. It used to be from dawn until dusk.
When hours were first instituted, it was always compared to farm work, since that was understood to be the hardest work possible.
EDIT: I see there's a lot of academicians with opinions. Anyone here grow up on a farm? Would you like to tell us about how easy the work is?
Which has pros and cons: people lived much more on the brink of survival, but a local area was also more self-sufficient. The trade we've made is to take risk of dying from starvation during a bad year where we are not self-sufficient enough for risks related to specialization, meaning we now have the equally uncontrollable risk of being screwed by a NYC financier or a DC bureaucrat.
It's also important to distinguish between different cultures and different time periods. A peasant in 15th century England lived a very different lifestyle than a peasant in 2nd century China.
Edited to clarify.
Probably because they've never worked on a farm.
Or are you arguing that no living historian or anthropologist has ever been a pre-20th century peasant?
Few people here have grown up on a farm. But even if you have, it's not representative of what historians and anthropologists study when they study peasant societies. Agriculture is thoroughly embedded in the market nowadays. You can't compare the experience of a struggling family farmer in Iowa, under siege by corporate interests and the demands of the market, with the experiences of the average pre-industrial peasant. A businessman running a gas station in Dallas has more in common with the Iowa farmer than the pre-industrial peasant does.
There are very few places in the world nowadays that are comparable to even the recent (several centuries) past. There is, however, a lot of evidence about how people lived back in the day. Enough evidence, actually, that tens of thousands of people study it.
I grew up in a very agricultural area, and many of my young friends' families owned farms.
You really can't make any kind of comparison between modern farming versus old-timey farming. For example, you can now ride in an air-conditioned combine harvester where you can't chat with your friends, but you're not out in sweltering heat. You can clear vastly many more acres, but is it more or less 'work'?
Also, the amount of work would seem to vary tremendously based on season.
I think it's more interesting to look at pre-industrialized, non-agrarian life. Like, a shoemaker in a city. According to a historian on a Planet Money podcast, you might go a couple of days without doing any meaningful work. Just sort of hanging around the shop, going to chat with friends, and so on. Then, someone would have a need for boots. So, you measure them up, get to work, and a couple of days later you hand them their custom boots. The guy's claim was that these sorts of jobs involved quite a lot of just waiting around for your next customer/project.
The time spent by hunter-gatherers is the least of all. Agrarian times -- when everybody farmed their own -- were more demanding but not all of the time for sure as the other commenter has pointed out.
During times when people were required to work for an "employer" (e.g. landowner) for rent, and then subsist on the time left, yes, they worked hard, but that is not unlike what we have today (just much more extreme).
As Clay Shirky describes in Here Comes Everybody, and you'll find in many other books as well, many skilled people would choose only to work as much as they had to get by, and spend the rest of their time in leisure or drunk.
Clearly some (most) hunter-gatherers found that organized food production was a better alternative, since they were obviously the ones that became farmers.
Beyond that, it wasn't a one way street--people regularly transitioned from farmer to hunter gatherer. Neither was a particularly hellish existence, except in times of plague, famine, or war (all of which hunter gatherers usually could avoid more easily, through lower population density and less demand on natural resources).
The hard evidence, as far as it exists, suggests that the typical hunter gatherer was, if anything, actually better off than the typical farmer. And for ages it was a constant back and forth. Where farming civilizations massively surpassed hunter gatherers was in the creation of the State and its associated violence-producing and self-perpetuating capabilities. Quantity (of people, of swords, of food) has a quality all its own.
See Jared Diamond's "The Worst Mistake of the Human Race" for an interesting perspective. http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html
Clearly some (most) junk-food-eaters found that eating junk food was a better alternative, since they were obviously the ones who kept eating junk food.
That kind of argument simply doesn't hold water. Humans do things which negatively impact them in the short term and the long term, repeatedly, consistently, and with relish.
It's a pipe dream to believe that the height of human happiness and social justice is everyone sitting down at a 9-5 job five days a week so you can pay down the mortgage on housing you overpaid for because everyone else also bought into the same myth. Which is what mainstream political parties in all countries that I know of seem to buy into, just with variations on the theme.
I like Chesterton's vision and see it as more emancipatory than the industrial-corporate socialism/capitalism that we have, despite me being a left wing crazy.
Will have to check out Belloc.