News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wage slave? Or slave to the wage? by _delirium on Monday February 27, 2012 @12:54PM (#3639835)
There's considerable variation in estimates, but most historians don't consider dawn-to-dusk to have been typical agrarian working hours, apart from peak weeks at planting and harvest. Data is really spotty, though, and before formalized hourly employment, it's not even really clear that people distinguished systematically between "working hours" and "leisure hours", so reconstructing it is difficult. To take one minor example, is "knitting by the fire while chatting with a neighbor" 100% work, 50% work, or something else? Perhaps it depends on whether it was a relaxed, half-working, half-chatting sort of knitting, or more industrious, but can we plausibly estimate how much of each was done in the 19th century? Even the distribution of how much of their day people typically took off for meals isn't well established (though it probably also varied by season).
Re:Wage slave? Or slave to the wage? by scarmig on Monday February 27, 2012 @01:14PM (#3639924)
Work wasn't considered something apart from social life. Basically, if something needed to be done, you did it. Things weren't nearly as compartmentalized as they are now. Agricultural lifestyles mean that life and work are much more integrated than they are now, because they had to be.

Which has pros and cons: people lived much more on the brink of survival, but a local area was also more self-sufficient. The trade we've made is to take risk of dying from starvation during a bad year where we are not self-sufficient enough for risks related to specialization, meaning we now have the equally uncontrollable risk of being screwed by a NYC financier or a DC bureaucrat.

It's also important to distinguish between different cultures and different time periods. A peasant in 15th century England lived a very different lifestyle than a peasant in 2nd century China.

Edited to clarify.

Re:Wage slave? Or slave to the wage? by true_religion on Monday February 27, 2012 @01:29PM (#3639990)
How is compartmentalizing work from home life related to "uncontrollable risks of being screwed by a NYC financier or a DC bureaucrat"? I'm not following.
Re:Wage slave? Or slave to the wage? by astine on Monday February 27, 2012 @04:18PM (#3640696)
If you're self sufficient, it doesn't matter how the economy is doing.
Re:Wage slave? Or slave to the wage? by jpdoctor on Monday February 27, 2012 @01:48PM (#3640081)
> but most historians don't consider dawn-to-dusk to have been typical agrarian working hours

Probably because they've never worked on a farm.

Re:Wage slave? Or slave to the wage? by _delirium on Monday February 27, 2012 @01:50PM (#3640088)
Ah, I didn't realize we were having an intellectual discussion at that level here. Your counter-argument to historical research is essentially, "fuck them ivory tower mothafuckas, I've got anecdotes"?
Re:Wage slave? Or slave to the wage? by scarmig on Monday February 27, 2012 @02:14PM (#3640190)
How true is this? Are you asserting that no historian or anthropologist has ever worked on a farm?

Or are you arguing that no living historian or anthropologist has ever been a pre-20th century peasant?