These aren’t run down hotels. These are both rated 4.2 [0, 1] and while aren’t the greatest in the world are both Hiltons and decent hotels.
The criticism doesn’t change the nature of the original article in that San Francisco is less good as it once was and as a result businesses are defaulting on pretty big things rather than invest in keeping them up.
The inaccurate language seems to have a “everything’s fine here” kind of vibe to me.
[0] Hilton San Francisco Union Square (415) 771-1400 https://maps.app.goo.gl/EPnQC4pbbwRKNjNh9?g_st=ic
[1] Parc 55 San Francisco - a Hilton Hotel (415) 392-8000 https://maps.app.goo.gl/p9SprpPdGZxzbejf8?g_st=ic
I know someone who used to travel to SF for work a lot, like 10-12 times a year. He had a favorite hotel there that was a block and a half away from his office. But every single time, he'd rent a car, just to drive from the underground parking at his hotel to the underground parking at work. It was simply safer than walking.
Having said that, a lot has changed since 2009
I stayed in SF for a few nights, it was pretty shocking to me the amount of homeless people (euphemism creep: temporarily unhoused) and the various tactics they employed to try and get money. One lady was just screaming at people in a fast food restaurant, I guess she was hoping to get paid in order to go away. This was 20 years ago and I hear the situation has only gotten worse since.
California treating homeless people like sacred cows is eventually going to wreck their inner cities for everyone.
SF attracts homeless from all over the US, given its mild weather (great for living outside) and generous social services. It has been like that forever also, you can watch old movies from the 1920s about hobos jumping trains to get to SF (or LA, or Seattle, or Portland, or even Vancouver BC, choose any of the west coast cities, all for similar reasons).
People have freedom of movement in the USA, and they mostly take advantage of it.
> Maybe it’s not capitalism at fault here but a government that is unwilling or unable to supply standard social safety nets like homeless shelters and addiction therapy.
The issue is then how do you prevent one locality from having their resources swamped fixing what is really a national problem. SF can't fix the nations problems, so its voters/tax payers get jaded really quickly.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_Russia
Mentally ill people are a massive part of the homeless population and we basically just yeet them out on to the street.
I stayed in the hilton union square in Feb and yes there are a lot of homeless people and addicts around but none of them even looked at me crossways
I also know that he had a permit to carry a gun, which (at the time) was near impossible to get in California, and that he in fact did so. Nevertheless, he chose to drive the block and a half rather than walk, because the last thing he ever wanted to do was be forced to use his gun.
I personally don't consider that to be an “obvious display of wealth”, but take it for what you will.
This person sounds like they have some mental issues.
And for the record, Mission has almost 4x the crime rate as California, which is already above the national average.[1] So it seems as though their “paranoia” was paying dividends.
[1] - https://www.areavibes.com/san+francisco-ca/mission/crime/
And, for the record, the source you cited shows that crimes where you would be morally or legally justified to use deadly force to defend yourself (e.g. rape, murder, assault), are less frequent in California than the national average and less frequent in San Fransisco than in California's average. Absolutely, if you think using a gun is a valid response to someone breaking your car window you are absolutely not a good judge of threats. Nor are you a responsible gun owner and should be forced to surrender your gun.
That are not run down. My complaint is against writers who are inaccurate. It’s frustrating and wastes my time when writers do this poor quality work with mistakes. And it doesn’t seem like a mistake so much as a deception.
It’s not “may or may not” as these hotels are clearly not run down.
You’re right about then neighborhood, but the point that the article is trying to make is that it’s the hotels that suck, not the neighborhood. But that’s not true
San Francisco progressives got their wish: those evil gentrifying techies are leaving in droves. Unfortunately for the progressives, that also means they are taking their money with them, that was being spent by SF like drunken sailors.
Also, Hilton Union Square SF didn't seem 'run down' to me. I just had a conference there two weeks ago. The area around the hotel seems pretty quiet though...
WSJ article seems fine as these things go.
I'm curious about this part. Is that actually true? That sounds like the contract that the management company has is with the lender to begin with rather than Park Hotels? Or is the contract structured in a way that even if Park Hotels sells, the new owner needs to honor that existing contract?
But not my industry, just seems like it would be reckless from the outside.
Surely they and their counter parties did some modeling and stress tests.
Largely, but not strictly true. When the property changes hands, the old loan is paid down by the original owner / creditor and a new loan is taken out by the new owner / creditor.
Not really.
If I buy a house with a mortgage, I wouldn't say I refinanced the house just because the previous owners also had a mortgage. Refinance is only used when the owner is the same across loans.
[1] https://www.otainsight.com/resources/blog/us-hotel-pricing-t...
Even before COVID, other Bay Area cities have been building up convention space to compete with SF. SF hotels kept raising their prices and wonder where the customers are...
https://wolfstreet.com/2023/06/12/ive-had-it-with-stupid-stu...
> Park Hotels failed to pay off a $725 million interest-only non-recourse mortgage that matured last November. The mortgage was secured by two run-down mega-hotels in San Francisco, the 1,921-room Hilton San Francisco Union Square and the 1,024-room Parc 55 San Francisco.
> Park Hotels only owns the properties. The hotels themselves are operated by other companies, and when Park Hotel defaults on a mortgage and walks away from the property, it means ownership of the property will change. That’s all it means for the hotel. The operating company remains the same.
> Park Hotels has been a catastrophic nightmare for retail investors. The misdeeds that sank Park Hotels’ shares didn’t happen on the streets of San Francisco – as the company ridiculously alleged – but in the C-suite of Park Hotels and on Wall Street. And its investors and now the holders of the CMBS are getting ripped off.