Ask Dang: Can we have community guidelines around product launch etiquette?
Over the many years I've been here, I've observed a good number of users being so unnecessarily harsh and critical to users launching new products. The feedback may be valid, but it is often delivered very antagonistically.
This is a community of hackers who build stuff. We should thus be receptive and encouraging of those who are taking the leap to create new products, which is a highly messy process fraught with mistakes, inconsistencies, and low-info decisions.
(
11 comments
| 3 points
| on HN
)
Everyone already politely lies to people trying to do new things, we don't need to encourage it further (see: https://www.momtestbook.com )
[1] I cannot think of a largish site with more polite discussion, perhaps they exist somewhere.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
-Assume the creator's impetus to create is legitimate.
-Give feedback like you would to an excited friend.
-Do not ascribe a product decision to malicious intent.
-Do not predict the ultimate success or failure of a product.
-Do not plug your own competing product.
Why do we need to treat creators like an excited friend? A lot of the ‘excitement’ from founders seems like a self-conscious performance, and they aren’t our friends. They are people starting businesses, not children.
https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html