(If your answer is yes: well, I think they are dumb for not offering a paid, ad-free version).
And then I was randomly banned for no reason. A 9-year Reddit account, paid for several years, moderator of some moderately sized communities. I had never posted anything controversial, etc. Never got an explanation. Tried multiple appeals.
A few months ago they randomly UN-banned me, much to my amusement. Still no explanation.
Theoretically I'm willing to pay, but I have no faith that I won't just be randomly banned again so I'm wary of becoming invested (financially or emotionally)
... they do offer exactly that.
So a paid ad-free version simply doesn't work for these people.
The dichotomy isn't really "ads" vs "subscription" in most cases; it's "ads + data harvesting (with negative societal externalities)" vs "subscription vs data harvesting (with negative societal externalities)". I am willing to use such a service as a parasite, but not as a paying user.
A paid ad-free version of their site isn't really good enough though. To keep me happy I need to be able to keep using third party apps on mobile, maybe something like 'exempt requests from Premium accounts from API billing'.
The halcyon days were really about 15 years ago before subreddits came in and well before it became just a swamp of children, memes, and trolls.
Nothing wrong with children par se I just don't come to the internet to engage with them.
Then again, Twitter at night is just a bunch of drunk people rambling and I still scroll that.