And then I was randomly banned for no reason. A 9-year Reddit account, paid for several years, moderator of some moderately sized communities. I had never posted anything controversial, etc. Never got an explanation. Tried multiple appeals.
A few months ago they randomly UN-banned me, much to my amusement. Still no explanation.
Theoretically I'm willing to pay, but I have no faith that I won't just be randomly banned again so I'm wary of becoming invested (financially or emotionally)
... they do offer exactly that.
So a paid ad-free version simply doesn't work for these people.
The dichotomy isn't really "ads" vs "subscription" in most cases; it's "ads + data harvesting (with negative societal externalities)" vs "subscription vs data harvesting (with negative societal externalities)". I am willing to use such a service as a parasite, but not as a paying user.
A paid ad-free version of their site isn't really good enough though. To keep me happy I need to be able to keep using third party apps on mobile, maybe something like 'exempt requests from Premium accounts from API billing'.
(If your answer is yes: well, I think they are dumb for not offering a paid, ad-free version).