News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:43AM (#36240935)
After everything that's happened in this space, the number of "true believers" I'm seeing here is astounding to me.

After a decade of use the tech hasn't found many real world uses beyond gambling, drugs, confidence schemes, money laundering, tax evasion, and other financial criminality. This is 100% the community's fault, as they're the ones burning a lot of real world capital build this stuff but have very little real value to show for it at the end of the day. I believe in creative destruction, this is just destructive destruction of capital.

Meanwhile the rest of the world is rapidly catching up. I have no trouble sending fiat money where I need to at the click of a button, with fraud and clawback protections in place. No chance of accidentally losing my savings, etc.

I don't understand how intelligent people can continue to believe this stuff is the future of finance. All signs point to this being a big nothingburger, crypto utopianism works great in theory but not in practice. The sooner this dream dies the better.

I guess it's something something human nature. I guess it's why we can't have nice things as a species. sigh

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by jc_811 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:58AM (#36241125)
This is a great comment, I’ve always thought that the huge blind spot of true believers is that if something looks good on paper, it does not automatically mean it will transfer into the real world.

Crypto currency would work terrific in a society with fixed rules, unchanging laws & regulations, and constant rule followers. In other words, this would be amazing in a society filled with robots. Humans are not that. Humans are error-prone, emotional, conscious, questioning, moral, and very special creatures.

No matter how strong your passwords are, how “offline” your crypto wallets be, or how hacker proof your crypto holdings are - this doesn’t matter! All someone has to do is break into your house, hold a gun to your head and say “transfer your entire bitcoin holdings right now or we kill you”. Just like that you lose your entire life savings with absolutely no recourse or chance to reverse anything. We are immediately faced with an undeniable human issue. A human is breaking the rules of society. A human is fraudulently taking something that is not theirs. A human is using the threat of physical violence in the real world. Not only is Crypto/blockchain technology not equipped to handle this situation, not being able to do anything about this situation is a fundamental feature of the ecosystem.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:09AM (#36241262)
> Not only is Crypto/blockchain technology not equipped to handle this situation, not being able to do anything about this situation is a fundamental feature of the ecosystem.

Yeah, in it's pure form (no interop with fiat) it's the financial equivalent of anarchy. Rules/laws are impossible to enforce, no police or justice system to stop bad actors. It's lawlessness. This is a feature, not a bug.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:22AM (#36241451)
There are plenty of real world uses.

- https://time.com/5486673/bitcoin-venezuela-authoritarian/

- https://coincodecap.com/danish-reporters-in-ukraine-buy-used...

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33644090

People from first world countries tend to reject the legitimacy of these uses because "my country is stable and could never have these problems", or "if buying food is illegal, you shouldn't buy food, you financial criminal", or "I have no trouble sending fiat money where I need to at the click of a button", but that doesn't mean everyone on the planet is in as fortunate a position as you. It's quite selfish to say a technology is useless unless it benefits you personally. I wish humanity as a species could rise above that level of selfishness. Crypto gets its value from being a system that continues working quietly and reliably in the background when other centralized systems falter or turn against their users. As long as it's still helping people, we should keep building it.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by jacksnipe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:58AM (#36241984)
People tend to reject it because it makes negative economic sense for a country with a powerful currency to allow the replacement of that currency, so they won’t.

Becoming the next Greece cannot save you.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:07AM (#36242112)
Yes, this exactly.

The Greek economy may be better than the Somalian economy, but that doesn't make it The Future of Finance.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:05AM (#36242073)
> As long as it's still helping people, we should keep building it.

What if it's hurting more people than it's helping? Just seems like a handwavy way to ignore the scams, fraud and collateral damage. We're talking billions.

If we want to spend capital to help people in other countries, there are better ways of doing so.

I do not believe for one second that the people from rich countries spending money in this space are doing it to help poor people in other countries. It's great spin though.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:23AM (#36242345)
If it's hurting more than it's helping, then we should probably get rid of it. But you'd need to bring some data proving as much. The attention grabbing headlines that linger in your memory are a biased sub-sample.

For bitcoin specifically, a notable crypto skeptic Igor Makarov determined[1]:

> illegal transactions, scams and gambling together make up less than 3% of volume

To me, 3% is an acceptable level. It's a lower percentage than the black market in many countries even.

The reasons people contribute to crypto projects are as diverse as the reasons people contribute to open source in general. Some people want to get rich overnight, others contribute as part of their day job so they can go home at 5pm, and others are genuinely altruistic, though you may not believe it. It's reductive to paint everyone with the same broad brush.

[1]: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3942181

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by greatwave1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:55AM (#36242896)
> illegal transactions, scams and gambling together make up less than 3% of volume

> To me, 3% is an acceptable level. It's a lower percentage than the black market in many countries even.

Yeah, but that's because the vast majority of volume comes from speculation and wash trading lmao.

What do you think the ratio of speculation and illegal activity to legitimate use cases is? I'd be willing to be it's greater than 10:1, maybe even 100:1

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:29AM (#36243534)
You don't have to bet, the data is in the paper linked earlier. It says 75% of bitcoin volume is speculation. Meanwhile in the traditional economy, 95% of global financial activity is speculation (see below).

What level of speculation would you say is high enough to justify throwing away the remaining productive uses of an asset class?

---

In 2019, forex volume was $6.6T per day[1], or $1716T per year. In 2019, global GDP was $87.3T[2]. That's less than 5% economically meaningful activity.

[1]: https://www.financemagnates.com/institutional-forex/executio...

[2]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/268750/global-gross-dome...

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:02PM (#36244122)
I should not have said speculation, the article makes it clear that 70% plus of unregulated exchange trades are wash trades.

Speculation (short selling etc) is a necessary part of a healthy financial system. Wash trades on the other hand are simply market manipulation.

GDP / production is what it's all about. The dollar is powerful in part because of US GDP. The financial sector exists to help put capital to work and extract more P (and to do so more efficiently). The financial sector cannot exist on it's own without meaningful production of value underneath it.

The crypto exchanges are different from forex in that forex facilitates people from other countries doing business with each other helping convert the value of one country's productive output into the value of the other countries productive output. Exchange rates rise and fall relative to GDP from the two countries.

I don't think comparing crypto exchange trading to forex makes sense, as that the crypto currencies don't have a meaningful connection to any nations GDP.

I think the point I'm trying to address here is that there is no P with cryptocurrencies. So the "crypto financial sector" seems more about price manipulation and gambling than it is helping facilitate trade between two economies.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:31PM (#36244609)
Each of my links has accounts of people exchanging goods and services in bitcoin for various reasons. Do you consider that productive economic activity (the "P")?

If you don't: why is it productive when I buy a car using dollars, but not productive when I buy a car using bitcoin?

If you do: why must a currency's worth be tied to one particular country's GDP? Why can't it instead be tied to the global production of everyone on earth, in any country, who has chosen to use that currency? I think actually it's a sign of strength when someone goes out of their way to adopt a global non-politcal currency, instead of succumbing to inertia and using the currency that was foisted on them by the geographical circumstances of their birth.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by greatwave1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:42PM (#36247640)
The paper that you linked doesn't say that 75% of crypto activity is speculation, at least as far as I can tell. Are you referring to the line that says

>Starting from 2015, 75% of the real bitcoin volume has been linked to exchanges or exchange-like entities such as on-line wallets, OTC desks, and large institutional traders.

Because there is certainly plenty of speculation outside of those entities.

And for the traditional financial system, when you said "see below", are you referring to the ratio of forex volume to global GDP? Because those metrics are terrible proxies for "global financial activity" or "speculation"

I would recommend doing some reading on what GDP is, and how it's calculated. It's not the same thing as the total volume of transactions, or even in the same ballpark. The United States alone had more than $128T in just non-cash payments in 2021 (https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/fr-payments-st...)

You should also understand that all forex activity is not speculation. I would think that global trade would fall under the bucket of "economically meaningful activity", no?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:52PM (#36251046)
> Because there is certainly plenty of speculation outside of those entities.

Sure. And there's plenty of non-speculative activity outside of those entities as well. The paper explicitly looks at on-chain activity only.

> Because those metrics are terrible proxies for "global financial activity" or "speculation"

Maybe so. I put forward my sources, but there could be a better way of calculating it. My broader point was that speculation is the majority of activity, and I doubt that's any different whether you're talking about fiat, gold, oil, crypto, or any other widely used asset/asset class.

If you had to calculate that same statistic, what methodology would you use?

> You should also understand that all forex activity is not speculation. I would think that global trade would fall under the bucket of "economically meaningful activity", no?

In one sense it is meaningful, in another sense it's just a middleman market maker taking their cut, due to the inefficiency of humans having multiple currencies. Either way I don't see how the meaningfulness of trade changes once you introduce crypto.

Say I'm subscribed to a Australian musician's patreon. I send her USD, then a middleman sells that USD and gives her AUD. I also support a French musician. I send him BTC. He (or a middleman) sells that BTC for EUR. How can you say either of those situations is more or less economically meaningful?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by greatwave1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:32PM (#36252380)
> the data is in the paper I linked. 75% of bitcoin volume is speculation. > Sure. And there's plenty of non-speculative activity outside of those entities as well. The paper explicitly looks at on-chain activity only.

You claimed that 75% of bitcoin volume was speculation. There is nothing in the paper to support this claim. I'm not arguing that there is 0 non-speculative activity, I'm saying that it is significantly less than 25%, and you're making up bogus statistics that aren't supported by your sources in the way that you say they are.

> Say I'm subscribed to a Australian musician's patreon. I send her USD, then a middleman sells that USD and gives her AUD. I also support a French musician. I send him BTC. He (or a middleman) sells that BTC for EUR. How can you say either of those situations is more or less economically meaningful?

Yes, these are both economically meaningful. This type of transaction is much more common in the fiat world than it is in the crypto world (where speculation and wash trading drive the majority of transactions).

Currency speculators make up a tiny portion of the real-world economy, while they make up the vast majority of the crypto economy.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:19AM (#36253083)
> There is nothing in the paper to support this claim

The paper literally says, "75% of the real bitcoin volume has been linked to exchanges or exchange-like entities"

You may think the source isn't perfect, but at least I'm bringing some objective data to the conversation. If you disagree, please show me some data of your own instead of just repeating your preconceived bias (which I'm aware of already)

I repeat: If you had to calculate that same statistic, what methodology would you use?

> This type of transaction is much more common in the fiat world than it is in the crypto world

Source?

> where speculation and wash trading drive the majority of transactions

Source?

> Currency speculators make up a tiny portion of the real-world economy

Source?

> while they make up the vast majority of the crypto economy.

Source?

Those were some mighty bold claims.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by greatwave1 on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:03AM (#36257957)
> The paper literally says, "75% of the real bitcoin volume has been linked to exchanges or exchange-like entities"

Which is an entirely different metric than the % of bitcoin volume that's speculation. If I link a paper that says "1% of squirrels are albino", and I claim that it says that 1% of bitcoin trading is speculative, then I'm not "bringing objective data to the conversation"... I'm just lying

My original comment was

What do you think the ratio of speculation and illegal activity to legitimate use cases is? I'd be willing to be it's greater than 10:1, maybe even 100:1

You responded by lying and trying to shut down any actual data-driven discussion

> You don't have to bet, the data is in the paper I linked. 75% of bitcoin volume is speculation.

And then you have the audacity to ask for a source on the claim that "currency speculators make up a tiny portion of the real-world economy"? How many people do you know who are participants in the real world economy (should be literally everyone you've ever met), and how many of them are FX speculators?

Now compare that to crypto, where the entire marketing apparatus is built not upon its current value proposition but instead the idea that value will go up.

Why would I spend my time digging up data to quantify things are incredibly obvious from observation, when you're willing to lie and make up facts to support your narrative?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:13PM (#36261773)
> Which is an entirely different metric

Of course not. If you disagree, at least try to present a coherent argument instead of just talking about squirrels. What entities do you think are missing from the list: exchanges or exchange-like entities such as on-line wallets, OTC desks, and large institutional traders

That might be overcounting even, since online wallets have nothing to do with speculation. So I'll correct myself: speculation is at most 75%, definitely a bit less.

> trying to shut down any actual data-driven discussion

I responded with exactly the data you asked for, just read it again :) If you need me to do the math for you:

75% speculation (at most) + 3% crime = 78%. 100% - 78% = 22%. 0.78:0.22 = 3.55:1 (at most)

> And then you have the audacity to ask for a source

Yes I do, since all data presented so far disagrees with your unsourced (though very strongly held) opinion.

Here's one example of how reality may be counterintuitive: High-frequency traders can make thousands of trades per second. How many people do you know who receive thousands of paychecks per second? From that alone it's plausible, obvious even, that forex speculation volume is substantially higher.

What's obvious to you isn't obvious to everyone else. That's why, in order to build a larger society, we need to set aside our biases and look at objective data in order to make informed decisions.

> Now compare that to crypto, where the entire marketing apparatus is built not upon its current value proposition but instead the idea that value will go up.

That doesn't sound too different from all modern investing. The stock market is also fueled by the illusion of the possibility infinite exponential growth. Bogleheads don't care about index funds' current value proposition. The grocery store won't accept your VTSAX as payment for a gallon of milk. You're just hoping that later you can sell your VTSAX to a greater fool.

Maybe the problem is you take everything the "marketing apparatus" says at face value? If one day you saw a TV advert for a pill that didn't work, would you also decide the entire medical industry is a scam?

> Why would I spend my time digging up data to quantify things are incredibly obvious from observation

Reality can be counterintuitive. It was once incredibly obvious that the earth was the center of the universe. Why should I spend my time digging up data when it's incredibly obvious from observation that the sun revolves around the earth?

HN is a place to engage with our curiosity, rise above anecdata, get out of our limited personal bubbles, and maybe even learn a thing or two along the way! Your immediate personal experience is not the objective reality for everyone on the planet. If you're just here to think with your emotions, ignore data, and rant about how much you hate change, you might feel more at home on Facebook or Twitter.

> when you're willing to lie and make up facts to support your narrative?

Source?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by greatwave1 on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:24PM (#36262812)
I'm sorry, I was under the impression that you at least had a basic understanding of cryptocurrencies and the drivers of transaction volume.

If you don't even understand that speculation can (and does) occur outside of on-exchange transactions, then I don't think this conversation is worth continuing.

I now understand that you probably weren't lying, you were just clueless about what you were talking about and actually thought that exchange volume is the only place where speculation occurs lmao.

In case it still isn't clear to you: on-exchange activity != total speculative activity. It isn't an upper threshold on total speculative activity. It has no concrete relationship with total speculative activity. Both on-exchange and off-exchange transactions can be speculative, or non-speculative. The metric you provided is not "exactly the data I asked for", it's a complete non-sequitur that betrays your ignorance on the underlying topic.

> That doesn't sound too different from all modern investing.

This is a valid comparison, you're on the right track here! Crypto ownership is very similar to modern investing, in that it's a speculative asset class, and not primarily being used for its function as a currency.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:44PM (#36266346)
If you replaced the subject matter with something more mundane, this exchange would be hilarious. It almost reminds me of a Monty Python sketch.

1> Here's a paper that calculates the average lifespan of humans. The average lifespan is 75 years.

2> That's because the vast majority of humans eat junk food lmao. What do you think the lifespan of a human is? I'd be willing to be it's less than 10 years, maybe even 100 years

1> You don't have to bet, the data is in the paper. 75 years.

2> The paper only looks at the Americas, Eurasia, Africa, and mainland Australia. It doesn't even look at Tasmania. You're making up bogus statistics that aren't supported by your sources in the way that you say they are.

1> Maybe so. I put forward my sources, but there could be a better way of calculating it. If you had to calculate that same statistic, what methodology would you use?

2> One time I saw someone die from a heart attack when they were 45 years old, and 45 is way less than 75. Why would I spend my time digging up data to quantify things are incredibly obvious from observation, when you're willing to lie and make up facts to support your narrative?

1> Your personal observations are not universal objective reality. That's why data is important when running a society at scale. Why exactly do you believe the inclusion of data from Tasmania would significantly change the results? Do you have any sources for your wild claims?

2> I'm sorry, I was under the impression that you at least had a basic understanding of geography. If you don't even understand that humans live in Tasmania, then I don't think this conversation is worth continuing. When talking about the lifespan of humans on earth, the lifespan of humans in most countries on earth is a complete non-sequitur.

Anyway, if you don't understand why data is important when discussing policy, there's not much to be gained here. I hope you find truth if you're looking for it, and peace otherwise. Cheers.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by greatwave1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @12:44AM (#36267663)
What a ridiculous analogy. Add statistics to the pile of topics that you're overconfident yet completely naive about.

What you're describing is a scenario where you take a sample, and use its measure of central distribution to make inferences about SAME METRIC in the population. This is perfectly valid!

But the obvious flaw with your argument isn't "this paper says that 75% of X volume is speculation, but it's excluding some data", it's that the paper presents literally no claims or evidence about the % of volume that is speculation lmao.

You have been conflating 2 entirely unrelated metrics this whole time. I said this before, but I guess it needs repeating: the % of volume that happens on-exchange is not a proxy for the % of volume that is speculation. These are completely different things!

If you want an accurate analogy, this would be like if you said "this paper shows that the average human lifespan is 4 years", but what the paper actually said was that the Olympics are held every 4 years. It's a completely unrelated data point, irrelevant to the topic at hand, and you'd have to either be ignorant or intentionally deceitful to pretend that they are the same thing.

Just bush league stuff... and as I said earlier, if you can't grasp this concept then I don't know what you're doing on a crypto thread.

I actually do think that you have serious underlying confusion about the nature of what speculation even is, because you keep pretending like it's something which can be objectively measured by using on-chain data. Data is obviously a useful tool when it's available, but making up bullshit statistics to support your argument is malignant.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:12AM (#36243197)
> The attention grabbing headlines that linger in your memory are a biased sub-sample.

Agreed, repeated media narratives lead to bias (myself included) which stands in the way of reasoned argument. Data is good.

> illegal transactions, scams and gambling together make up less than 3% of volume

I've read that over 70% of trade on the unregulated exchanges are wash trades / fake volume. [1] Huge huge red flag to me, may not be technically illegal, but evidence like this runs counter to the "helping the poor and unbanked" narrative. Market manipulation usually hurts more people than it helps.

> It's reductive to paint everyone with the same broad brush.

Fair enough.

I still say there's a lot of smoke here, and a few clear major wildfires.

Today's takeaway for me is that there are a lot more of people here that are heavily invested in crypto space than I guessed. People with money invested that need to see the space succeed. Makes it hard if not impossible to have a reasoned discussion here. It's probably fruitless to continue to talk about crypto here.

[1] https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/wash-trading-centralised-cryp...

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lesuorac on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:51AM (#36242832)
Keep in mind, ransomware predates cryptocurrencies they just used the existing financial system ...
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by omniglottal on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:01AM (#36243006)
You're talking about billions of... dollars. Sounds to me like more scams exist because of fiat. Are you implying that scams don't exist with dollars, and it's the crypto alone which makes for fraud? Or is it that, if it's abused for corrupption and fraud, then it's hurting people so we should do away with it, like fiat?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:30AM (#36243566)
Of course scams exist with dollars. Scams exist wherever people hold things of value that others want.

People want the USD. I'd argue that crypto is mainly a dollar/fiat scam, as getting their hands on fiat seems to be the point of it. "I'll trade you magic beans for those USD" isn't about the beans, its about the USD.

People are free to trade BTC on the blockchain no matter what the US government says. It's anonymously cashing out to dollars that seems to be their main goal, and the source of all the ecosystem's trouble and reputation problems.

It seem clear to me that almost all of the utility in the crypto space revolves around fraud and criminal behavior. There is little intrinsic "value" in a crypto token, it seems to be nothing more than an unit of account for a large extra-governmental online casino. It empowers and amplifies criminals who do more collective damage than the few "unbanked" that are helped.

And so my argument is that because of the above, crypto is not The Future of Finance by a long shot. And my original point was that there are a surprising number of people here that still believe it is in spite of the evidence.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by RestlessMind on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:43PM (#36244796)
> It seem clear to me that almost all of the utility in the crypto space revolves around fraud and criminal behavior.

You are along the right path. Now take it one step further - what if "fraud and criminal behavior" is against despotic regimes like Taliban or Putin or dictators around the world? See my examples here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32406095

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by pessimizer on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:40AM (#36242625)
This is the same use: evading local laws. You just think it's good when it's a government you don't like.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by EscapeFromNY on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:51AM (#36242831)
Sometimes yes, sometimes no. In the second and third links, what laws were being evaded?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by dagaci on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:34AM (#36241626)
(1) The sole reason Bitcoin exists is because all governments decide inflate the money supply by printing, and in doing so, they knowingly devalued the efforts and work of everyone who saved their money or relied on fixed income like a pension.

(2) Just this May the USA decided to add 1.5 trillions of inflation on top of the already high levels of inflation people are already experiencing. And I can guarantee that they will do this again and again, in good years and in bad years, both democrats and republicans equally (look at the record, not what they say).

(3) Bitcoin was explicitly created for these reasons, and it has _way_ over succeeded in its goal _financially_.

(4) The other complaints you have are the fault of the government, they have purposely let the space become lawless in the hope that it would diminish the space, or that it would die by itself, but the problem with this is (1), (2) and (3)

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:16AM (#36242246)
(1) agreed this is why it was created

(2) not sure what you mean by 1.5 trillions of inflation, but your point seems to be that inflation is bad. I disagree. High inflation is for sure bad, but zero inflation is also bad. Capital needs to be put to work, inflation forces people with capital to use it (productively) or lose it.

(3) I don't agree that bitcoin has "way over succeeded", seems like an opinion and not a fact.

(4) It's not the fault of the US Government that Bitcoin is lawless. It was designed that way from the get go. The government can't stop people from sending and receiving bitcoin on the blockchain.

Why would anyone want to trade their ideologically pure bitcoin for those filthy fiat dollars they've been so desperate to escape from? Bitcoin maximalists say it's all about the bitcoin, but at the end of the day they want a pathway into the USD system.

I don't see any real arguments here on how this is the future of finance.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by tmn on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:48AM (#36259651)
There is a big difference between bitcoin having a relevant future. And it becoming 'the' future of finance
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by logicchains on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:10AM (#36241276)
>hasn't found many real world uses beyond gambling, drugs, confidence schemes, money laundering, tax evasion, and other financial criminality

Lots of people believe the war on drugs is a stupid, counter-productive endeavour, and indeed empirically there's no evidence of its success. The value on crypto is absolutely in that it gives common people a means to "fight back" against the power of the state and it's never-ending quest to control their private lives.

Most "financial criminality" in practice works out to "anyone doing anything the US government disagrees with", and not everyone believes the US has the right to police how the rest of the world spends its money. Nobody sanctioned the US when it killed hundreds of thousands of civilians in Iraq; do you think that's a fair system?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by gwbas1c on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:34AM (#36241632)
> Lots of people believe the war on drugs is a stupid

Agree 100%. I must emphasize that the war on drugs is a political problem.

> The value on crypto is absolutely in that it gives common people a means to "fight back" against the power of the state and it's never-ending quest to control their private lives.

Cryptocurrency claims to offer a solution to political problems, but the political problems it creates are worse than the problems it claims to solve: Its very hard to conduct commerce when the value of your money fluctuates widely; and (for drugs) there's no regulations guaranteeing the quality of the product.

I voted to legalize pot 8 years ago, and now I can go to a store and I have plenty of safe products to choose from. I wish I could do the same for psychedelics; and I'm rather sure that the opiate epidemic would be easier to contain if recreational opiates were also guarantied quality.

Cryptocurrency (and drug markets hidden on Tor) aren't going to solve what really is a political problem.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by rootusrootus on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:21AM (#36242315)
> The value on crypto is absolutely in that it gives common people a means to "fight back" against the power of the state and it's never-ending quest to control their private lives.

The cost of that bit of freedom being that it funnels all of their meager savings to the top of the pyramid, making a few very wealthy people even more so.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by treestander on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:37AM (#36241680)
SVB just collapsed. Do you blame the fiat dollar for that?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:22AM (#36242333)
No, I blame the executives at a poorly run bank.

SVB execs knew the risks of having too many long term low interest securities. The Fed repeatedly warned SVB about it's problems. SVB ignored internal recommendations until it was too late.

If this was a systemic "fiat dollar" problem then many more banks would be failing.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:38PM (#36247569)
Also, the "fiat dollar" system includes parts like "the justice system" that will attempt to resolve conflicts between independent parties in a fair way, and oversight system that attempts to push the value, use, and attributes of the fiat system in certain directions, which can be influenced by the democratic system, which isn't perfect but definitely exists, and includes the police system which ostensibly is there to protect your rights over any dollars you own, and a government system to offer you perks for taking part in the fiat dollar system (such as roads and other shit taxes pay for) and an economic system that assures you the availability of pretty much anything you want to trade for that fiat.

Cryptocoin enthusiasts seem to look at all that, look at how it all isn't perfect, see how that imperfection allowed a big bad event (2008) to happen, and completely throw the baby out with the bathwater. They ignore how the imperfections in the system were intentional, based on misguided and purposefully inaccurate economic theory, that was broadly popular and pushed by the broad political system because of that popularity (literally democracy), and that it can be fixed.

Instead, they want to replace it with a supposedly deflationary system (because gold bugs are still apparently taken seriously in their philosophies), where there is no such thing as property RIGHTS, because you only "have" what you physically control. This is considered a desirable property in fact. Then, this system is also DESIGNED, intentionally so, to profit a select few who already had significant resources. The system, by design, accrues more benefits to those who already have power or resources.

Then they try to tell you that this system somehow benefits you, the normal person.

It's insanity.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by yieldcrv on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:41PM (#36247624)
so apply that same standard to "crypto". where you blame the executives at a poorly run company instead of the sector or asset class they happen to cater to.

mismanaged companies that make the headlines coexist with organizations that function well and make zero headlines "even" in the crypto space. the quotes because it shouldn't be surprising but its odd that this persistently low signal level of discourse is what's prevalent on this otherwise analytical community.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by naet on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:07PM (#36249071)
All SVB depositors are being made whole by the FDIC. When something like Celcius collapses depositors are out of luck.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:05AM (#36241213)
>I don't understand how...

It's actually fairly simple. They're financially invested, one of the strongest biases of all.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lordfrito on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:20AM (#36241417)
Hadn't considered this. I just figured there are a lot of people here that "believe" in crypto in theory but just don't happen to be playing in this space yet, instead watching from the sideline with interest. I was doing this for a long while (watching since 2011) but never spent a dime until I could be firmly convinced, which never happened.

You're suggesting that most/all of these pro-crypto commenters have real skin in the game. If so, then there are a lot more people here than I guessed with with disappoint in their future.

This is a pretty intelligent crowd, so the blind spot surprises me. Such is human nature.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:24PM (#36247309)
It's not a blind spot, it's very on brand for a VC message board to have a lot of "greed is good" philosophy people who think that making money by mild trickery is perfectly moral, and that there's nothing wrong with getting people to buy into your fancy MLM so you can extract some wealth from the system.

The only value crypto has to the vast majority of people is to exit back into fiat, and doing that is only profitable if the trade value is higher than when you bought in, and that requires new money keep entering the system to be on the other side of your exit trade.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by tomputer on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:27AM (#36241524)
Isn't that almost always the logical consequence once you understand how Bitcoin works and you believe it can actually work as a safe haven investment?

Those who believe it can not work are most probably not invested. Those who believe it can work are most probably invested.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by imtringued on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:54AM (#36242873)
Those who are invested have no reason to understand how it works. They just need to recruit more members.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by yieldcrv on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:17AM (#36243318)
no conflict = no interest
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by misnome on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:05AM (#36241205)
Crypto, Aliens, Science, and Equality are the topics that you really should’t look at discussions for here unless you know what you are getting yourself into, or just want to watch the burning dumpster fire. At least with Crypto it is relatively easy to spot the weird grudges or patently self-interested reasons for continuing to argue for a failed system.

I’m sure when this use case fails there will be another new use case that can be used as the Single Thing that crypto was made and defined for, you always need to find more sources of Greater Fools..

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:40PM (#36247602)
>I’m sure when this use case fails there will be another new use case that can be used as the Single Thing that crypto was made and defined for,

Nah, they just pretend it didn't fail, and blatantly ignore reality.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by olalonde on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:33AM (#36241603)
> After a decade of use the tech hasn't found many real world

The use case was found over a decade ago: "A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System"[0]. For some reason, many HN commenters seem to think we are supposed to come up with other use cases.

[0] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mindslight on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:11PM (#36244278)
To answer your question plainly: because Bitcoin addressed the value question by just letting it float, meaning that its value and the stability of that value are directly tied to its uses that drive demand (as with all currencies). This also led to the ecosystem being dominated by speculation, giving exchanges outsized importance - and simplistically implemented exchanges are a great setup for exit scams.

Contrast with say Hashcash where anybody can make more for a fixed amount of computation, so there would be little point in speculating on Hashcash tokens.

One also has to wonder how much Bitcoin's asymptotically limited supply directly caused the blooming of thousands of shitcoins [0] to satisfy the demand for monetary units. If newcomers could have just straightforwardly minted their own like Hashcash, would there have been as much of an incentive to go create competing currencies?

(I'm not some Hashcash maximalist or something. It's just an example of a system with a different paradigm of monetary creation, regardless of its other flaws)

[0] (not that Bitcoin itself isn't a shitcoin, being non-fungible and all)

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by time_to_smile on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:38AM (#36241691)
> I don't understand how intelligent people can continue to believe this stuff is the future of finance.

My experience is that all of the really intelligent people interested in crypto did leave after the ~2012 wave of excitement. At that time when you saw people give talks on crypto they were almost entirely technical with very little focus (or interest) on becoming rich. That was when the people involved tended to be technical idealists. I didn't buy that crypto was the future then, but I wanted to be wrong.

Fast forward to ~2017 during the next crypto boom and the conversation was around the non-technical people at technical companies getting excited. People did believe crypto was going to become the currency of the world, so there was still some idealism, but it was mainly about getting in to get rich. By this wave a good chunk of the idealists I knew were entirely disillusioned.

Then the 3rd wave which just happened to correlated with a massive injection of money in the market by the Fed. At this point it was just literally get-rich-quick dreamers with more dollars in their hands than sense. Nobody I know who has gotten in during this period even has a coherent vision of what the future looks like, they just have too much money and think crypto is the way to get insanely rich one day. It's also when people completely unrelated to tech started getting involves. People who don't even know how to use a wallet, and rely 100% on 3rd parties to manage all of it.

People are holding on to crypto for the same silly reasons that coworkers of mine keep all their vested stock in companies that have dropped 50%+ in value over the last year. It's because they earnest believe that the era of low interest, free money is the norm. They believe this current macro is just a blip, and if they just hodl a bit longer it everything will go back to "normal".

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by coldpie on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:18AM (#36242283)
> After everything that's happened in this space, the number of "true believers" I'm seeing here is astounding to me.

I think part of that appearance is the rest of us have just kinda moved on from commenting on this space. We've been saying "this crap is dumb" for ten years, it's getting old at this point. Let the true believers play around in their litter box; I got other stuff to do :)

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:22PM (#36247253)
The true believers keep throwing their litter all over my nice clean floor, that's why I don't want them playing in """their""" litter box.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by rootusrootus on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:23AM (#36242349)
> I don't understand how intelligent people can continue to believe this stuff is the future of finance.

I think you're overestimating average intelligence, and/or how well intelligence translates to common sense. Some of the craziest people I've ever met were absolutely brilliant. Still crazy.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by nipponese on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:32AM (#36242495)
Bitcoin is not just a technological play but also a political play.

Try explaining to someone why they are wrong about voting for <idiot you voted against> and the reason becomes obvious.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by progrus on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:32AM (#36242499)
It’s the US empire collapsing, not Bitcoin.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by taeric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:47AM (#36242748)
I mean, this isn't much different than the true believers in the liberating value of cash. And, at large, if you meet someone carrying 100s of thousands in cash with them, you have met a criminal. :D

Just like if you have a small vendor that takes cash only, they are probably tax avoiding. Buying drugs? Heck, even legal drugs for some states require cash.

I'm also still highly amused at just how inappropriate blockchain techs are for crime. It is literally recorded basically forever.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by yieldcrv on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:17AM (#36243304)
> After a decade of use the tech hasn't found

an oft said criticism that ignores a lot.....

standards within the crypto ecosystem follow a proposal and ratification process that takes years, this is a highly active area and highly collaborative

there are people that have the exact same information as you that said "I'll contribute" instead of "I'll find reasons to reinforce my disdain"

those standards get ratified and the crypto ecosystem begins catering to additional industries and additional people

this chronology is very easy to follow

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by boring_twenties on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:13PM (#36244311)
Gambling and drugs represent a ton of value, though.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by RestlessMind on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:40PM (#36244744)
> the number of "true believers" I'm seeing here is astounding to me.

Because maybe when you see crypto, you see scams (SBF, Terra, etc). When we see crypto, we see legit decentralized asset like Bitcoin or massively successful open source project like Ethereum.

> After a decade of use the tech hasn't found many real world uses

Or maybe, there are legit uses but you are ignorant because of your bubble? I compiled some examples here long time back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32406095 (and this has only grown since)

> money laundering, tax evasion, and other financial criminality

That just depends on your pov ("freedom fighter vs terrorist"). If someone is trying to protect their wealth from Venezuela, Putin, Taliban or other despotic regimes, that is still "money laundering" in those regimes' eyes. See my examples above.

> I have no trouble sending fiat money where I need to at the click of a button

My colleague begs to disagree. He can send fiat USD to his native country but official exchange rate is suppressed and he loses a lot of value through fiat channels.

> I don't understand how intelligent people can continue to believe this stuff is the future of finance.

I don't think this will supplant finance as much as augment it. Also, maybe you haven't yet had real conversations with intelligent people who believe in crypto?

> it's something something human nature

Yup. Wanting to escape oppressive regimes with your wealth. Or freedom to protest your government's tyranny (imagine the uproar if Trump had frozen assets of all the BLM protestors in the summer of 2020. Now see what happened when Canadian goverment froze the assets of truckers).

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by vagab0nd on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:44PM (#36245758)
My suggestion: Sometimes you just have to accept that there exists a vastly different perspective that you'll never understand.

If you really want to try, go read all they have to say. There's no shortage of that here.

If your goal is to convince them that they are "wrong", you simply can't.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by asterix_pano on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:54PM (#36245903)
Having internet money that is cross border, instant, efficient and censorship resistant is difficult to build, so it takes time, but it's incredibly valuable as it removes a lot of frictions.