News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by Flatcircle on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:07PM (#36222387)
Somehow the temperature of the earth is now a political football so any actual facts are hijacked by people with an agenda. Intellectually, I'm scared to touch this subject because it's such a hot potato. (no pun intended)
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by monero-xmr on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:39PM (#36222555)
That’s what’s so precisely fucked up about climate change. This is one (of many) areas of science that is untouchable to have a different opinion on. Even publishing data that can go against the doomer majority is career suicide. That is not science - that is dogma.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by defrost on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:46PM (#36222584)
> Even publishing data that can go against the doomer majority is career suicide.

Can you provide the best example of this that you know of?

Well gathered and published raw instrumentation data that resulted in career degradation.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by nemo44x on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:54PM (#36222639)
It’s because you only get published and therefore funded if you can make a claim that generates power. Money and influence will and does flow to things that will require change. The more dramatic the better.

No one is going to fund research that concludes things will be ok. That’s a snooze fest. Only things that suggest we “DO SOMETHING”, which means justify power, get the attention from the people that want to continue justifying power.

It’s why everything is a “crisis” today. There’s limited funding and finite seats at the table and you better believe the ideas that are “urgent” are the ones that will get funded. It’s not a coincidence these ideas also generate power.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by defrost on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:05AM (#36222688)
Large scale well curated Ocean tempreture datasets originated from the Cold War days from a desire to be able to pinpoint submarine movements heard via sound travelling along thermoclines.

Atmospheric gas libraries originated from the same era in order to track the changes resulting from atmospheric nuclear tests ( ~800+ IIRC ).

Both these data sets were funding by the military with desire to prove climate change etc. although they did hide under the cover of ocean research | environmental research.

Other datasets come from global mineral and energy exploration geophysics, again these have goals far removed from climate change - you're correct that they are motivated by the desire for 'power' via mapping resources and extracting them.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by nemo44x on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:26AM (#36222816)
I think you’re entering tinfoil hat territory here.

Catastrophic climate doomers will get more clicks/citations/panels than moderates than skeptics.

“The world is ending we must act now” is a whole lot more attractive than “there are concerns but they are manageable” which is more attractive than “climatology isn’t actually science because it isn’t falsifiable and there’s a lot of contradicting models built by equally qualified people and we should avoid only listening to the most dramatic ones and try and do actual science when possible and be wary of dogma.” No one’s funding that for more research!

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by defrost on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:40AM (#36222895)
> I think you’re entering tinfoil hat territory here.

What, specifically, do you regard in my comment as "tinfoil hat" ?

I've worked four decades in exploration geophysics on global scale surveys of entire countries and I've met a number of my predecessors that worked on ocean tempreture data aquisition and atmospheric sampling.

The larger data aquisition surveys are not undertaken at the behest of "Catastrophic climate doomers" - they are funded by deep pockets that can sustain a burn rate of often a million+ USD per day (sub sea seismic modelling, satellite constellations, etc).

The data aquired shows that global climate is changing in a manner consistent with the physics first discussed a century ago.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by defrost on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:30PM (#36236825)
Fat Fingered Errata (my bad)

> Both these data sets were funding by the military with desire to prove climate change etc.

should read:

Both these data sets were funded by the military with NO desire to prove climate change etc.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by smolder on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:02AM (#36222673)
Announcing your theory that fractions don't exist or that pi is 3 would also be career suicide in math. That doesn't mean that mathematicians are overbearing dogmatics. Some ice forming somewhere in Antarctica is a fine observation. It's not a contradiction to global warming. Local ice forming or local temperature drops aren't evidence against it. If climate scientists do dare to contradict the consensus around global warming, they have a high burden of proof. Stirring the pot by contradicting consensus without meeting that burden of proof is really earning the career suicide that you say follows, whether or not they believe what they're claiming. If done with intent to mislead, that would seem to put you with all the scoundrels who have taken a paycheck to lie to the public about lung cancer from cigarettes, and then later took paychecks to lie to the public about AGW.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by monero-xmr on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:07AM (#36222701)
The climate is extremely complicated. Measuring “average” earth temperature is itself open to interpretation. We have evidence that the earth was much cooler in the recent past as well as much hotter. Carbon PPM doesn’t necessarily cause the increased temperatures we are perhaps having.

To say any of this publicly as a professor is career suicide. To say it as an employee is to be labeled a corporate stooge. The only solution according to the government is to hand trillions of dollars to ESG whatever the fuck and don’t look too deeply at how it’s spent. Insanity all around.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by smolder on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:34AM (#36222868)
> We have evidence that the earth was much cooler in the recent past as well as much hotter.

Whatever "recent" is to you, there are graphs comprised of plenty of good data which very strongly support the theory that industrialization by humans and the associated, rapid increase of CO2 have lead to increased retention of solar energy and all the effects that come with that.

There's also not really any doubt that raising atmospheric CO2 increases energy retention through reduced emission to space. It's something that can be modeled well.

> To say any of this publicly as a professor is career suicide.

Not true. I happen to know of a community college professor in a rural area who is popular with some people because he is skeptical of global warming... He's unqualified to be in front of a class talking about it, but some people like and encourage that sort of thing.

The fact remains that the oil lobby has paid big bucks to convince people AGI isn't a thing, while at the same time believing it was.

I think most of the skepticism pointed at the fundamental idea of AGI is side effect of that propaganda, or more of the same.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by monero-xmr on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:43AM (#36222915)
One of our best family friends is a PhD in meteorology and her graduate research was on aggregating temperature data collected from global weather stations.

In her own words, the data was shit and full of gaps, she wasn’t a software engineer yet self-taught the necessary python to create horrible kludge scripts that turned it into “something”, and was given a grant from the NIH for her work.

The end result was a single vector trumpeted by her ivy-league school that added “yet more evidence” to the consensus of climate change, and she is now a tenured professor in the UC system. Total garbage end to end.

I love her to death but get her a few cocktails deep and she will freely admit it’s a grift.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by smolder on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:02AM (#36223048)
Interesting anecdote. Can't say I wouldn't be interested to hear the details of her story.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by monero-xmr on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:07AM (#36223075)
I’m not saying climate change is incorrect, but I will say that the “overwhelming consensus” has resulted in a lot of warped incentives and weird results. The climate is really hard to model and in a rush to blame it for the apocalypse we have reduced a lot of critical thinking.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by ajsnigrutin on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:17PM (#36222440)
That's why we need more raw data. Even if people argue, if it's this or that to blame, raw data is always a good thing.

Adding the "good" to turn it into "good raw data" is even better.

Considering the last few years of manipulations with the data about "the plague", sure, there will be arguing, but again, more data is a good thing.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by JamisonM on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:43PM (#36222572)
What more raw data would you like?
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:22AM (#36226473)
Like the article from here.. that the Antarctica gain 600Gt of ice.

Some will say that global warming is a scam because of that, some may say it's just a random increase with a long-term trend of decrease due to global warming... and I just like having the data.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by jfengel on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:38AM (#36228248)
This isn't raw data. The raw data is a gigantic pile of satellite measurements. This is all of that data collapsed down into a single figure via a model (itself derived from yet more data), and the scope of that figure isn't as easy to characterize as "Antarctica did X".

So I'd cautioned you against the belief that you really have any data here. You have a single number, flagged for your attention by somebody who (presumably) believes that they can influence your conclusion in a particular direction. You can't really draw conclusions from data without gathering as much data as possible, and this single number is nowhere near complete. If this data strengthens your confidence that you understand the whole situation, then it is worse than having no data at all.

Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:44AM (#36241776)
So what... give us raw measurements too, still better than someone trying to influence us without data.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by res0nat0r on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:38PM (#36222550)
It's frankly just embarrassing too, since the data is obvious, the majority of (actual qualified scientists) who understand the subject agree that global warming is in fact happening, but a small minority of loud voices backed by big corporations make it appear that this is in fact a debatable issue.
Re:Antarctica gained 600 Gt of ice during '09-'19 vs. a pred... by getwiththeprog on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:00AM (#36222666)
Yes this kind of link seems to be very misleading. It is amazing that just because an idea is presented, that it will have so many people believing it. This is a classic example of disinformation seeding. In reality, a casual pub chat like this is not science, not evidence not anything other than the blind leading the blind.

A really great HN article would present multiple papers and deal with technology and science, as well at ethics. This discussion does not do that.