> “Canada is the only country in the world where it is illegal to obtain private health insurance when there are long wait-lists. That surely says something,” said Dr. Brian Day, medical director of Cambie Surgery Centre in Vancouver and past president of the Canadian Medical Association (CMA).
…
> He launched a legal challenge to the B.C. Medicare Protection Act, saying wait times in the public health system are too long and stopping patients from paying for those services outside the public system violates their rights.
> In July, the B.C. Court of Appeal dismissed the Vancouver surgeon’s challenge.
> However, in their ruling, the judges accepted that the act’s provisions “deprived some patients’ right to security of the person by preventing them from accessing private care when the public system had failed to provide timely medical treatment.”
https://globalnews.ca/news/9099696/canada-private-health-car...
There are some doctors that works exclusively public or private.
If there is a queue, the price is too low. Surely a good business optimises price such that there is no queue and maximum revenue?
On the other hand, if we allowed a freer market in medicine (anywhere, no particular target country in mind), seeing doctors make more money treating something should spur on new trainees, thus more doctors in that specialism, and hence price drops and improvements in waiting times and possibly techniques, but that would require that freer market that so many seem against.
I’m not sure that medicine could ever be a poster child for the free market. It’s tightly regulated for good reason. Is there anywhere that has free market medicine? I’d like to read about it, but wouldn’t want to use such a system.
I can. I live in New Zealand. Medical practice here is plenty regulated and complying with these regulations is a meaningful percentage of my day job. Not all of it is worthwhile, lots is.
It doesn't clear up why you think a free market and regulations are opposites.
Take a small market store selling product A and product B. Whichever sells more at a given price wins more profit, great. Free market forces are at work. But then (anything goes, after all) the manufacture for A comes in and says to the store owner: if you sell product B we'll firebomb your market and kill your dog. So then the small market stops selling product B. Now, the small market only sells product A and at a huge markup.
Is product A actually better? Does the consumer win?
Regulations are necessary so the manufacture of A can't do that and make sure that the market is actually free.
You can do it based on social status and wealth (America) or on medical necessity.
Obviously this is HN were people have money so they are upset if they are put on a waiting list. We don't hear much about the people from trailer parks getting million dollar cancer treatments thanks to the public healthcare system.
Partly because other professions, like banking, attract greater remuneration. It's also why you'll notice that many new doctors (in the US) choose the ROAD, for many reasons[1], but this one stands out:
> The amounts of money that can be made in dermatology and plastic surgery are a temptation that many people cannot resist
If you want more doctors, and more doctors in things like primary care, then offer incentives. Money is a good one. You may also ask if plastic surgery is still an expense that only a wealthy elite can access, as it was in the past, or if it's become quite commonplace, and then, since it has, why. Could it be that the usual processes that other capitalist goods follow also work in healthcare?
The other side of that is training enough doctors. I think it would be a good question to ask why so few are trained, and I wouldn't be surprised if one of the reasons is that the guild itself, as all guilds do, limits the number of new entrants. That's speculation on my part.
> Obviously this is HN were people have money so they are upset if they are put on a waiting list.
I thought that everybody gets upset if they're put on a (long) waiting list so I'm not sure what need the ad hominem in your comment serves.
[1] https://medicine.yale.edu/news/yale-medicine-magazine/articl...
Can you cite a source for people dying in "large" numbers waiting for medical care in Canada?
If Canadians are dying in large numbers waiting for care, something pretty grim is going on south of the border to make the stats worse in the US.
The bottom link is to commentary on the Supreme Court’s recent ruling in the case, and the criticism of a more privatised system is interesting.
“The entire premise underlying the Canada Health Act is that people ought to be able to access health-care services based on need, rather than ability to pay…
It's pretty clear that having physician's practice both in and outside of the public system, if anything, results in longer wait times for patients in the public system, not the other way around…
The people most likely to need urgent surgery are often the least able to pay out of pocket.”
Notably, the legal action was brought by someone with very vested interests.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/274513/life-expectancy-i...
https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/health-...
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/analaysis-br...
But would it? Those doing the training (eg surgeons) are benefitting from the high prices.
That's not quite right.
As I understand it, private clinics themselves are fine: the very next sentence of your article explains that the doctor in question runs his own private clinic. Instead, the issue is how you pay for services rendered by those clinics since BC's Medicare Protection Act restricts insurance policies that would cover them.
Googling shows ~2000 Canadians died waiting for surgical care in 2020. Meanwhile in the US:
* Millions of people delay even starting care in the first place due to costs
* In the seven years from 2000 to 2006 an estimated 162,700 Americans died because of lack of health insurance
* Massively worse medical outcomes than Canada in virtually every metric
* Massively higher costs
* Systemic lying about waitlists and patients to cover up how bad they are [1]
[1] https://www.cnn.com/2014/04/23/health/veterans-dying-health-...