News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by bottlepalm on Thursday May 25, 2023 @05:20PM (#36076376)
You shouldn't tail any car in general. There's a lot more 'real' braking out there than 'phantom' braking.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by buildbot on Thursday May 25, 2023 @05:24PM (#36076430)
Sure, but an unexpected full ABS lock when you can see nothing in front of the tesla is going to be yard for most to react quickly too even at a decent distance. 10 second follow distances are only possible in most metros during very light traffic.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by robertlagrant on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:01PM (#36076858)
You only need 2 seconds to be safe. It's longer than you think.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by andybak on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:16PM (#36077045)
3 is the guidance in the UK at least
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by robertlagrant on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:54PM (#36077498)
> You should ... allow at least a two-second gap between you and the vehicle in front on high-speed roads and in tunnels where visibility is reduced. The gap should be at least doubled on wet roads and up to ten times greater on icy roads

Highway code rule 126[0] says 2?

[0] https://www.gov.uk/guidance/the-highway-code/general-rules-t...

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by andybak on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:24PM (#36077747)
Oh. I stand corrected.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by robertlagrant on Friday May 26, 2023 @04:24AM (#36081503)
I mean, I think 3 is better, especially at high speeds. 2 is just the minimum.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by crazygringo on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:05PM (#36076900)
Then you're driving unsafely, although 10 seconds as a general rule is a straw man.

At any time, a child could run out from a hidden spot and the car in front of you could have to slam on the brakes as hard as possible. Or any of a hundred other realistic scenarios.

These things aren't common, but statistically they will happen to you multiple times during a lifetime of driving, and it's your responsibility to always be at a safe distance behind in order to react as well.

The common rule of thumb is generally 2-3 seconds in perfect conditions, and 4-6 seconds in rain or other normal bad weather. 10 seconds is only in cases of ice/snow where most people wouldn't be driving in the first place (you know, when you're going just 15 mph but it still takes 5 seconds to come to a full stop on the slippery ice). The heaviness/lightness of traffic is irrelevant.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by k8sToGo on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:16PM (#36077038)
Phantom braking is not a full ABS lock type of braking. It’s more like a brake check.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by jjulius on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:33PM (#36077248)
>10 second follow distances are only possible in most metros during very light traffic.

I've usually heard that it's three seconds. Even still, you control your follow distance. Even in heavy traffic, you can give yourself more space between you and the car in front of you than other people do. It's easy to do, and I've been able to do just that even in metro areas with heavy traffic.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by threeseed on Thursday May 25, 2023 @05:30PM (#36076514)
Humans in traffic are relatively easy to predict.

They don’t just randomly brake for no reason.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by metalliqaz on Thursday May 25, 2023 @05:59PM (#36076837)
...usually
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:32PM (#36077238)
I hear people talk about people brake checking all the time (whether they're the brake checkers or the person tailing). A buddy of mine was tailing a (non-Tesla) car a little too closely on his motorcycle and the driver deliberately brake-checked him and he wrecked. And that's just people deliberately driving erratically, never mind the people who are responding to debris, animals, people, etc darting into the road.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by bombolo on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:56AM (#36080528)
Fault of your friend for not keeping a safe distance.

If both drivers only had basic insurance covering damages that aren't your fault, he got nothing and the other driver got paid for having his car damaged by a reckless driver that smashed into his car.

How does your friend even know it was without reason? Maybe a kitten or a squirrel crossed the road.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by throwaway894345 on Friday May 26, 2023 @09:28AM (#36083821)
We’re not debating fault, we’re debating whether other drivers drive predictably. Whether the driver brake checked him or whether there was a squirrel or kitten in the road doesn’t really matter: the point is the human driver braked unpredictably. You don’t have to drive with special caution around a Tesla, you should drive with the same amount of caution that you would drive around any car. I have a Tesla and I use autopilot pretty liberally (but not carelessly—I’m always ready to take over) and phantom braking was really frustrating last year, but it was never unsafe unless perhaps someone was literally a foot or two behind you at high speed. They seem to have fixed that sometime in 2022, and since then I’ve had fewer than 5 phantom braking episodes and they have been almost imperceptible (certainly not dangerous). The Tesla critics in this thread are reacting to some pretty extreme assumptions about autopilot (that phantom braking happens all the time, that it’s less safe than the unpredictable behavior of human drivers, etc). We certainly need more evidence, but I’m going to be biased toward the people who actually have experience driving Teslas rather than the people whose information comes from the rumor mill.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ertian on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:34PM (#36077250)
But sometimes there are legitimate reasons for a car to brake hard, which you'd never know from your position one car-length behind them.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by watwut on Thursday May 25, 2023 @05:26PM (#36076463)
Real braking happens for a reason, to avert accidents. Sane drivers don't do it just randomly in perfectly safe situations. Random braking is major risk for everyone around and if you are source of it, you are in fact danger foe others.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by vosper on Thursday May 25, 2023 @05:40PM (#36076606)
> Sane drivers don't do it just randomly in perfectly safe situations

You can't always assume that you will be able to tell when a situation has turned from safe to unsafe. You just can't exactly see what the driver in front of you (or the driver in front of _them_) is seeing.

And you can't assume that the driver in front of you is sane!

You have to _always_ follow at a safe distance.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by pacetherace on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:04PM (#36076893)
in most commutes, if your tailing distance is too much, someone will else will come in front of you.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by lamontcg on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:29PM (#36077200)
Tell me you're a bad driver without telling me you're a bad driver.

You need to not care about that, and you're actually supposed to let people change lanes into your lane. You're getting into a mental competition with other drivers and sacrificing the safety of yourself and everyone around you.

And if anyone believes that longer following distance causes more traffic, that is also false and the reverse is actually true. It is the poor reaction times of tailgaters that cause traffic slowdowns.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by lagniappe on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:34PM (#36077255)
> Tell me you're a bad driver without telling me you're a bad driver.

> You need to not care about that, and you're actually supposed to let people change lanes into your lane. You're getting into a mental competition with other drivers and sacrificing the safety of yourself and everyone around you.

> And if anyone believes that longer following distance causes more traffic, that is also false and the reverse is actually true. It is the poor reaction times of tailgaters that cause traffic slowdowns.

I think that what they're saying is the flow of cars in front of them keeps that distance between them and the 'next car' to a shorter undesirable distance as more cars fill that gap during traffic.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by tbrownaw on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:45PM (#36077387)
... And then you end up just going slower than the rest of the traffic, and people behind you change to the faster lanes to pass you, and some of the people passing you change lanes back to in front of you. And so trying to keep a longer following distance than the rest of traffic allows just means thtey lots of people are doing things other than just staying safely in one lane.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by lamontcg on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:17PM (#36077691)
you're better off letting people change lanes to the lane they want to be in, and if you're not camping in the left lane then typically you'll find people changing lanes from the left lane to exit, or will change lanes through yours into the left lane.

if you leave lots of space they can do so entirely safely.

trying to prevent other people from changing lanes does not enhance traffic safety.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by lamontcg on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:14PM (#36077664)
then you let off the gas slightly and widen the gap. when people change lanes from in front of you, then you can speed up slightly and close the gap. that isn't a practical problem. it comes out in the wash.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by sushid on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:13PM (#36077006)
That's fine. You lose like .5 seconds of your life when another car comes in front of you.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by manquer on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:01PM (#36077556)
It doesn't stop with one, the problem is not someone cut across, the problem is someone always keeps squeezing in the gap. Every time you open a gap, a new car cuts across. How can you maintain any gap in that context ?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Ingon on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:33PM (#36077245)
As others pointed out - let them. On average all lanes move the same, they might even move away once the lane stops moving. You'll have much worse time rearing a car then letting all those cars in.

I also keep additional distance in traffic to minimize slowdowns/stops, which ultimately actually improves/fixes the flow.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by orpheansodality on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:27PM (#36077181)
if you think about the speeds involved, a single additional car in front of you on the freeway (or even any additional cars) adds pretty miniscule time to the total commute.

Let's compare a few situations. In the baseline you're tailing the car in front of you with a focus on not letting anyone cheat and get in front of you, let's say 50 feet away. Your commute is 30 miles, and in this frictionless sphere of traffic you're going 60mph the whole time. You get to work in 30 minutes flat.

In the second scenario you're following the 3-second rule[0]. This would put you ~285 feet behind the car in front of you. Let's say over the course of your commute 20 cars move in front of you. If the average car length is 15 feet, and they all are 50 feet away from each other, when all 20 cars are in place you're a net -(20 * 65) feet away from the original car, or 1300 feet total. At 60 mph that adds ~15 seconds to your total commute time.

Well worth having an easier time avoiding a potential crash IMO! Also has the benefit of helping prevent traffic to begin with[1]

0: https://driversed.com/trending/what-safe-following-distance.

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iHzzSao6ypE

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by manquer on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:00PM (#36077544)
It is not about efficiency or trying not to be slow. I am not bothered how many people cut in line or "cheat".[1]

Someone will always keep cutting into the space. It is impossible to maintain 3 second to the car ahead. First one car will cut in, you make room for them and add 3 second gap the next car will cut in. Maintaining even a 1 second gap is sometimes very hard close to exits.

[1] Personally my driving pattern changed once I switched to driving a hydrogen fuel cell Mirai, slower is better on the mileage and fuel cell owners are very range conscious.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by orpheansodality on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:16PM (#36077685)
it's anecdata but I drive this this on the regular and don't have any issues! May be some regional differences
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Shocka1 on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:29AM (#36085451)
In the Midwest here and drive the same way, from rural to busy city and back. Never had any issues at all with it minus the car or five I let in front of me. I usually keep about 5 car lengths, so a fairly reasonable gap without being annoying to drivers that happen to be behind me. Also, I have zero panic braking incidents, which seem to be a big cause of crashes and slowdowns in heavy traffic due to the slinky phenomenon that tends to happen.

Not only can I see everything beyond the car in front of me, I tend to "soak" up the braking energy when there is a panic braking incident in front of me. I have no data to back this up, but I'm almost positive I've kept traffic moving much better behind me and prevented rear ending incidents using this tactic. Also, I wouldn't downplay the amount of fuel that is being saved that comes with not having to almost stop, then start over again from the slinky effect.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by andybak on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:15PM (#36077025)
So? Drop back again.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by bombolo on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:54AM (#36080518)
Then another car will do that… and then another… and then another… in the end it becomes way more dangerous.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by olyjohn on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:15PM (#36077029)
So what.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by s3p on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:49PM (#36077437)
That's not what OP was implying.