News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @07:55AM (#35974013)
This also seems concerning:

"Under the new law, tenants would be given the legal right to request a pet in their home, which the landlord cannot unreasonably refuse."

We had a tenant once who brought in her two cats who peed everywhere so we had to replace the entire wooden floor and repaint all the walls because the cat piss stench was everywhere. Financial damage done out of our pocket was way higher than the one month worth deposit.

Feels reasonable to have a say in that matter.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by unfunco on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:17AM (#35974206)
Is there a law that states the deposit must be one month? You could adjust the contract so that if a tenant requests pets, they're liable for a larger deposit / cleaning bill when they leave.

I rent and have two cats, they pee in the litter tray so that's not an issue, but they cause all sorts of other damage, mine like sitting on the bannister at the top of the stairs, so there's loads of scratch marks on it because it's too high to jump up to it easily, they're very furry Norwegian forest cats that groom each other a lot, so I wake up frequently to vomited up cat balls on carpets, etcetera.

My deal with the landlord is that I'll just pay for whatever damage is done, even if that's higher than my deposit.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by efaref on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:25AM (#35974282)
The legal limit for the security deposit is five weeks (or six weeks when the annual rent exceeds £50k).

source: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/security-deposit-cap-redu...

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by gpderetta on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @12:33PM (#35977738)
The deposit is max 5 week, but the tenant is still liable for any damage beyond the deposit. Of course the landlord need to take the tenant to court and there is no guarantee they'll ever be able to recover the money.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @02:08PM (#35979066)
>Is there a law that states the deposit must be one month?

No, but the market rate is at one month.

>My deal with the landlord is that I'll just pay for whatever damage is done, even if that's higher than my deposit.

Every tenant claims to your face he's a billionaire and that he will pay for everything, but then bolt it the week before the end of the contract, leaving you with a damaged apartment and unpaid bills. Such claims are difficult to enforce and a bird in the hand is worth more 10 in the bush.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by madeofpalk on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:16AM (#35974203)
Can't any tenant damage a property more than the deposit, regardless of whether they have a pet or not?
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @10:52AM (#35976076)
Can't a car hit you while you're sitting in your house? Of course anything can happen in theory, but as a landlord you're trying to minimize the risk as nobody will cover you if your tenant fucks you and destroys your property, so you optimize by picking the safest and less risky option.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by gpderetta on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @11:11AM (#35976432)
Cars are insured, and ideally landlords should be too. The problem is that if a landlord insurance policy (or mortgage, or long term lease) disallows pets, the landlord is going to prohibit pets. If such prohibition is void then pets are more likely to be allowed.

There were similar issues with social housing tenants where some mortgages or insurances disallowed them until it was made it illegal.

Of course enforcing these laws is hard...

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @12:03PM (#35977295)
>landlords should be too.

There are no insurances where I live that cover against malicious tenants who's pets destroyed your place. Household insurances here only cover you place against accidents (like a pipe bursting flooding the place) or wraths of nature (like a storm breaking your windows) or against burglars breaking in but that's it. So it's up to the landlord to protect himself from bad tenants or they can financially ruin you.

>he problem is that if a landlord insurance policy (or mortgage, or long term lease) disallows pets, the landlord is going to prohibit pets. If such prohibition is void then pets are more likely to be allowed.

And any such insurances against malicious tenants or pets will be expensive and would only be passed on to the tenants in increased rent prices. There is no free lunch here. Landlords aren't gonna take a loss.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by gpderetta on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @12:23PM (#35977586)
Hum. 5 minutes of searching shows that malicious tenant damage cover is available, often as an extra, in the UK.

Of course that's an additional cost. As a landlord you can decide whether to take the risk yourself, pass the cost to the tenant at the risk of being less competitive, or eat the cost.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @02:09PM (#35979087)
>in the UK

Why do people on HN assume I live exactly in the same country as they do? Like I said before, "where I live there's no insurances covering tenant damage". It's great it's a thing in the UK but I don't live there.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:16AM (#35985264)
You're criticising proposed changes in regulations in the UK, though, so the availability of such insurance in the UK is surely relevant.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:20AM (#35974233)
For some reason people are very reluctant to view renting out a property as a business venture with attendant risks and no guarantee of profit. Either you can afford to insure yourself against such eventualities, or the cost of the repairs will be paid off in the long term by future tenants - or your business isn’t really profitable except in fair weather.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by robertlagrant on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:38AM (#35974410)
I keep reading comments like this on HN, as though deliberately introduced legislation that undermines a key industry is somehow a cognitive no-op. Governments can make doing business unreasonably difficult. To mis-name that as "this business has no right to exist" just clouds the issue.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:50AM (#35974531)
Many European countries have far more protections for tenants than the UK and still have rental markets. The idea that these minimal regulations (which really don’t go anywhere near far enough) will somehow make it impossible for people to rent out accommodation is frankly ludicrous.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by robertlagrant on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:52AM (#35974564)
This is another fallacy. We can't compare individual things between countries in such a simple way. If you want to dive into the detail of how the whole of "being a landlord" and "being a tenant" works in those countries, and then figure out the differences and potential improvements holistically, then that's great. But this is so general it's impossible to say why it might or might not work.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @09:08AM (#35974720)
You seem more interested in legislating the terms of the conversation than actually having it.

If I understand correctly, you believe that England is a special flower and that regulations which would be considered the bare minimum in a great many other countries around the world (including such exotic and remote locales as Scotland) somehow cannot function here.

I’d be happy to point out any fallacies in your argument for that conclusion – if it weren’t for the fact that you’ve presented no argument for it whatsoever.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by robertlagrant on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @09:55AM (#35975250)
> You seem more interested in legislating the terms of the conversation than actually having it.

This is the only conversation-legislating statement in the thread.

> If I understand correctly, you believe that England is a special flower and that regulations which would be considered the bare minimum in a great many other countries around the world (including such exotic and remote locales as Scotland) somehow cannot function here.

I don't think this, no. I certainly haven't said it.

> I’d be happy to point out any fallacies in your argument for that conclusion – if it weren’t for the fact that you’ve presented no argument for it whatsoever.

I don't know the purpose of your entire comment, then.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by psychlops on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:44AM (#35974475)
All the costs will be borne by the tenants. Including the inevitable increase caused by this legislation.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:53AM (#35974577)
If they get passed on to tenants that’s because the UK rental market is still almost entirely unregulated and landlords can charge whatever they want. That’s a symptom of the underlying problem.
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @11:06AM (#35976334)
You can't regulate forcing landlords taking in other people's animals against their will. They'll find other ways to reject tenants with animals if the market is in their flavor from having a high demand from people without animals.

You don't fix a broken real estate market with not enough supply, by adding more regulations on top (try moving in Berlin right now, see how regulations "help" you the tenant trying to rent something), you fix it by building enough supply such that the market becomes in their flavor that most people can afford to buy their own home where they can keep as many animals as they want, turn it into a zoo if they want.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @11:36AM (#35976830)
I'm all in favour of increasing supply.

The issue of pets that you've picked up on seems a minor one, in all honesty. I was thinking more generally about any increased costs for landlords resulting from these reforms.

I rent in London, so Berlin doesn't really work for me as a comparison case. I'm sure it has its issues too, but it's not obviously worse. If someone were to ask me rhetorically "would you like the rental market in London to end up like the rental market in Berlin?" then I'd probably respond "err, yeah, probably".

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @02:10PM (#35979095)
London housing issues: there's supply but it's very expensive

Berlin housing issues: it's not too expensive but there's zero supply because of rent control

So which is best? Or, the least worst.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by psychlops on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @12:23PM (#35977584)
The regulations have nothing to do with it. Landlords need to make enough income to pay for the property. Any increase in expenses will need to be generated through the rent of the property.

I know very little about UK property issues, but would speculate that any housing shortages are caused by regulations.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @12:28PM (#35977663)
>I know very little about UK property issues

Don't let that stop you!

>but would speculate that any housing shortages are caused by regulations.

Which regulations? The UK rental market is almost entirely unregulated. It is less regulated than the rental market in many US states/cities, for example. Landlords can charge whatever rent they like, evict people for no reason, and put up rents without limit when renewing rental contracts.

If any regulations are to blame here, they're likely to be the regulations that prevent building new houses in green belt areas, not regulations on rentals.

>Any increase in expenses will need to be generated through the rent of the property.

You say this as if it's obviously inevitable, but of course one possibility is that landlords will simply make a bit less money on rentals than previously. This is why regulations do have something to do with it: if there are limits on how much landlords can raise rents, then they can't simply defray any increased expenses via arbitrary rent increases. At present, however, there are no such limits.

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by psychlops on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:01AM (#35974068)
"It's my comfort bull."
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by foldr on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:12AM (#35974162)
“Cannot unreasonably refuse.”
Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by snehk on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @08:32AM (#35974349)
> Financial damage done out of our pocket was way higher than the one month worth deposit.

"I lost money doing business"

Re:UK: No-fault evictions to be banned in reform of rental s... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 17, 2023 @10:57AM (#35976169)
We did loose money, but not because we made a business mistake but because our business parter (the tenant) screwed us.

Protecting against such events in the future would mean extra expenses passed on to the other tenants. There is no free lunch here. If the tenants are causing extra damage, then it will cost them more in the end, pushing the market prices up.