I haven't met many people/anyone who went from dismissing it as a joke to taking it very seriously.
Either way, isn't "people not taking it seriously at first" one of the classic signs of disruptive innovation according to Clayten Christensen?
> I haven't met many people/anyone who went from dismissing it as a joke to taking it very seriously.
frankly, then you very likely weren't a community participant during the early years. I don't think most people understand just how small and universally ridiculed, ignored and unknown Bitcoin was for the first couple of years.
> isn't "people not taking it seriously at first" one of the classic signs of disruptive innovation
I don't know who Clayten Christensen is, but that's a silly quote. Of course every new idea and technology that became successful started small, unnoticed etc, but it's pure survivorship bias to point only to the ones that made it. What about countless things that didn't? Taking seriously things no one else does is a not a particularly wise thing to do, 99.999% of the time there's good reason no one takes something seriously, and there is no real way for anyone to reliably identify the 0.001% of times you have something worthwhile.
I've never been a part of the community, but in my experience those outside the community took it much more seriously than they do today. At least, the non-technical people, who constitute the vast majority of the population. I was in law school taking a mid-career break circa 2009-2011 and students and professors spoke of Bitcoin with all the earnest curiosity and lofty expectations as generative AI today, and I felt I needed to pushback. For example, tell them that, no, Bitcoin isn't a perfect money laundering technology; quite the opposite, at least once governments come up to speed. I also remember the countless discussions about Bitcoin on NPR, and the discourse was annoyingly credulous of extravagant claims for many years. (Arguably they never stopped being annoyingly credulous; rather, Bitcoin just stopped being a topic of discussion. To the extent discussion has turned negative, it's more because of the "tech bro" association, part of the whole backlash against social media and Silicon Valley.)
What community? A sub-reddit? bitcointalk.org? How early is early to you? I found out about bitcoin and ethereum by reading Hacker News, I bought my first bitcoin when it was around $10 and most of my ethereum on the first day of the pre-sale and that's around the time when I started discussing crypto with my friends and family, some of whom are programmers but most of whom are not. I'm not sure what you're going on about regarding community.
> I don't know who Clayten Christensen is, but that's a silly quote.
Do you know what Google Search is though? Or maybe your point is that I spelled his name wrong by one letter? Either way, here you go:
"Improving a product takes time and many iterations. The first of these iterations provide minimal value to the customer but in time the base is created and the value increases exponentially."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma
Since you're on this website maybe you've heard of Paul Graham?
"Don't be discouraged if what you produce initially is something other people dismiss as a toy. In fact, that's a good sign. That's probably why everyone else has been overlooking the idea. The first microcomputers were dismissed as toys. And the first planes, and the first cars. At this point, when someone comes to us with something that users like but that we could envision forum trolls dismissing as a toy, it makes us especially likely to invest."
http://www.paulgraham.com/organic.html
> Of course every new idea and technology that became successful started small, unnoticed etc, but it's pure survivorship bias to point only to the ones that made it. What about countless things that didn't?
You're missing the point. I'm not saying that it's proof positive of it being a good idea, but that dismissing an idea on the basis of what other people think is a terrible idea. And no, every technology doesn't start out small or unnoticed (e.g. fire)
> Taking seriously things no one else does is a not a particularly wise thing to do, 99.999% of the time there's good reason no one takes something seriously, and there is no real way for anyone to reliably identify the 0.001% of times you have something worthwhile.
There's no way of replying without coming off as an asshole so apologies but, frankly, you sound like a boring person who doesn't think for themself and is probably a late adopter to most interesting things.
The Coinbase guy recently wasted half a million US dollars in gas fees on a lobbying project. It’s nuts. He could have funded a school. It’s not a good look for Coinbase.
I still don’t have any interest in eth but I’m very much interested in cryptocurrency now. There’s a bunch of more scalable and cheaper L1 tech and a bunch of more private tech too (I wish they’d hang out more). Not naming names as I don’t want to shill any particular projects but yes. Was not interested in cryptocurrency. Now interested in cryptocurrency.
If your getting criticism, the most likely scenario is it’s because your idea won’t work, not that it’s world-changing.
Sadly I was too much of a socialist and there for the tech and utility. Suffice it to say that people threw money at memecoins way more than they threw up money at us, but we did raise a respectable amount in 2018: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1733567/000173356718...
My vision was mainstream adoption of crypto for all the right reasons. Every community having their own coin and their own monetary policy. https://intercoin.org/communities.pdf
I already had an open source social platform (https://github.com/Qbix) with people in over 100 countries so it seemed like building a payment platform on top of it made sense. So this is what I did:
Architected all the smart contracts on https://github.com/Intercoin
Bootstrapped with revenues and customers and paid our developers for years
Released all the smart contracts and documentation on our own platform here: https://intercoin.app
Got CertiK audits of our smart contracts: https://skynet.certik.com/projects/intercoin
Launched a show where I interviewed economists, regulators, and people like Noam Chomsky and Patri Friedman (grandson of Milton Friedman) https://youtube.com/intercoin
Made ways to raise money that are actually legal: https://community.intercoin.app/t/how-intercoin-helps-to-rai...
Built technology for people around the world to raise money for refugees: https://community.intercoin.app/t/fund-for-refugees
By the way, if you want to come and hear more about it, you're welcome to, we have demos at the end of every month: https://intercoin.app/event/ITR/Qwwsjokht
And we do it on our own platform, livestreaming through peer to peer broadcasting, the works!
Next on our roadmap is to release Intercoin Wallet (completely web-based wallet will try to fix major security flaws in the current Web3 ecosystem) and Intercloud (decentralized layer 1 solution that is NOT a blockchain)
But on HN we get lumped in with the rest of the Web3 bullshit and scam artists, so what can I say. This will probably be downvoted by people who never click a single link in the comment :-P
Any community is typically judged by their worst members. Much like a parent is judged by their worst child.
Don't feel too bad about it, its just the natural course of things.
I searched on the coingecko link you provided and only see $3.9k in liquidity and a single $65 trade in the last 30 days.
One thing about US regulations… we did not want to get involved with making the secondary markets or whatever. Expect the community to do it. We don’t care about attracting speculators to pump and dump. We believe that once we attract CUSTOMERS then the speculators will turn up to make the market.
I'm used to seeing socialism used at a national scale, was your vision to allow a much more local version of socialism with every town effectively running it's own socialist bubble? If not, how would a larger socialist system tie together all the individual currencies used managed by each town?
Sorry for the tangent, I've just never really thought of a hyperlocal version of socialism before!
Airdrops are a form of UBI, and can be used to put money in the hands of the public. Towns can use software to run their own monetary and fiscal policy without relying on the Banking system as the source and sink of their money supply. Banks do not issue money on the basis of public good, the more people need money the less likely they are to issue it to them in the form of credit. They make the rich richer and it is about generating about profits for their shareholders and depositors. In a UBI scenario, money is issued to everyone equally. Even the game Monopoly (which was originally designed by a socialist to illustrate the perils of capitalism!) has a UBI every time you pass Go, or the game doesn’t work.
A socialist alternative to a bank is a Credit Union. Imagine Intercoin letting anyone create a credit union and connecting all of them together like the Internet did for communication.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarian_socialism
It has been practiced by everyone from prehistoric tribes to today’s Housing cooperatives and worker-owned cooperatives and universities.
One of the oldest sites on the Web is run by an anarchist socialist, serves local communities and and has outcompeted all capitalist attempts to disrupt it and extract rents. You’ve definitely heard of it:
https://www.zdnet.com/article/craigslist-ceo-jim-buckmaster-...
Another of the oldest sites on the Web has quickly outcompeted all capitalist encyclopedias including the most famous ones like Britannica and Encarta, making them mere rounding errors in usage. That of course is Wikipedia. Jimmy Wales is not a socialist, he is a libertarian however.
If each member of my family has their own individual currency and monetary policy it would make economic sense for us to form a higher level structure and just have one currency and monetary policy for our whole family to make trade easier within our family. That process scales up to the level of country.
This idea failed because it doesn't solve anything economically. It actually just creates an economic bug.
Why don’t we have one big network for everyone, and one-size-fits-all policies?
Agree with the specific is it not, we need more projects like this testing unique idea and sharing their lessons. In the crypto space specifically, we have learned very little to nothing from most projects because they just try the same model. I'm happy to see a project thinking differently regardless of how it turns out.
Now with regards to your specific argument, centralization and standardization aren't always the answer. It's a web of hyperlocal currencies the answer? No idea. But does that really mean we should centralize all power and stick with one currency and one monetary policy? Should we do that with other things like communication platforms, social media networks, and move all state powers up to the federal government? Would we all be better off with one global currency and one global back driving monetary policy?
I would like a digital currency, but as long as dufuses are incentivized to hype coins to trick others into making them rich these coins aren’t actually useful.
A deflationary currency disincentivizes spending, which reduces velocity, which aggravates deflation – a death sentence for two of the three properties of money (it's not a medium of exchange if nobody is exchanging it; it's not a unit of accounting if prices fluctuate strongly – and that includes falling prices).
I was also fascinated by Bitcoin in its very early days, from both a technical and an economical/monetary angle – the former fascination remains, but I'm pretty disillusioned on the latter after learning more about the nature of money and inflation (and especially how Bitcoin maximalists use a fringe economical model and definition of inflation to justify the design).
Go look up how much a 400 MHz processor (e.g. Pentium II) cost in 1997 vs. today. Processors get cheaper all the time, but it doesn't seem to harm demand.
Too much inflation ruins the "store of value" aspect; deflation disincentivizes trading it for goods and services, cutting into the "medium of exchange" aspect. Any drastic change of value/purchasing power, i.e. both inflation and deflation, make it useless as a unit of account.
> Processors get cheaper all the time, but it doesn't seem to harm demand.
Processors aren't purported to be money, though.
We used to consider inflation to be the expansion of the money supply, deflation being the opposite. For whatever reason the word inflation was repurposed to describe and increase in *prices*. That metric is effectively useless though as prices are just a side effect of multiple factors including the total money supply, supply and demand of a particular good, technological innovations, etc.
Deflation as we see it today was actually a common thing historically. Prices for a good decrease in time as we become more efficient at producing it and as demand decreases when something better comes out.
I wasn't alive at the time, but the modern definition makes a lot of sense to me: Monetary base is one of several factors impacting inflation, so conflating inflation and (an increase of) the monetary base seems quite confusing.
> Prices for a good decrease in time as we become more efficient at producing it and as demand decreases when something better comes out.
It's totally fine if some prices go down, but the more useful notion here is that of purchasing power.
When people expect the purchasing power of a currency to increase meaningfully, they start deferring purchases and investments (since most/all goods and services are expected to be cheaper tomorrow than they are today), which can cause inefficiencies just like inflation can.
The other interesting aspect is in terms of Robert Shiller's narrative economics. What is most interesting to me is that the narrative economics and contagion were able to morph the currency narrative into something else so that the hording became a feature and not a bug in the narrative.
It is interesting how people can call BTC digital gold but disregard the downsides of gold at the same time in the exact same way deflation/velocity was ignored in the currency narrative. Gold was the "new" anti-central banking currency in the 70s that had its crescendo because of narratives and central bank policy at around a $3,200 all time high inflation adjusted price that we can't touch even 40+ years later. At the same time macro conditions were set up to take out that all time high price but BTC itself grabbed so much of that flow from gold.
Following the narrative dispersion that the all time inflation adjusted high for BTC is already in will be fun for years to come.
Adoption as a payment method has likewise been dominated by regulation and expectation about hype cycles affecting the price.
I can't see why any of that would be different if the narrative differed to not include deflation. As long as it's new tech and a new unit of value to distribute, this is what you get
> First rule of designing anything is what I would call Tucker's Second Law: "if some cunt can make a buck by completely fucking over your system then that cunt will completely fuck over your system because that cunt is a cunt."
This, in essence, is really the problem with crypto. In many ways I think people took the banking crisis of 2008 and learned exactly the wrong lessons (because that, too, was a result of this "law").
Not really disagreeing with you, but maybe Bitcoin wasn't really ever about an alternative currency for buying a few beers, just like gold isn't suited for that purpose. It is certainly possible, if the buyer and seller jump through some hoops to make it happen, as you demonstrated -- but it's slow and expensive for that use case. In the long run, maybe you're the person who really misunderstands what Bitcoin is "actually useful for."
I like the idea of P2P cash but I don't want the casino.I don't wanna invest, I just wanna use it as money. It didn't work out so well for that.
Did the value of bitcoin actually go up, or did the thing you measure it by go down?
I will happily bet on the number of bitcoins in existence by say 2030. Would you bet on the number of dollars in existence by then?
Every project is either an obvious scam and money grab or has fundamental flaw(a) that make it useless for it's original purpose.
I'll stick with using the OG blockchain, git.
Sadly, the "crypto space" was quickly invaded by hordes of people who never really cared about the technology itself, how it works and what it's actually useful for. (and what it's not useful for)
These people, who know nothing about it, and for years had dismissed it as a joke, suddenly began to talk about it very seriously as a very serious "investment" in self-proclaimed "expert" capacity.
You know the type of person I'm talking about! We've all seen them, and most of us can probably count one or two amongst our friends.
The potential for cool applications of blockchains is still there, but so far it seems to me cryptocurrency has mostly just been abused as a vehicle for crazy, baseless manias, and little to no meaningful application.