News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by hexator on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:21AM (#35903461)
Is anyone surprised? It really eye-opening working at a startup making a huge impact and the company is valuated in the hundreds of millions with only a few engineers. And you just make like $150k, a tiny TINY fraction of the value. Even if you make more than most workers, you're still getting robbed of the true value of your labor.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by nateabele on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:32AM (#35903625)
On the other hand, 150k is an astronomical sum for most people on the planet—and no one is being forced into accepting that as a market rate, or even living in a high-rent city, particularly post-COVID.

I still don’t understand this idea that labor supposedly has some sort of intrinsic value. The value is derived from the labor being done in the context of a system created by someone else. As others have said, if you want to reap the full value of your labor, you’re free to go it alone.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by green_man_lives on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:44AM (#35903837)
> The value is derived from the labor being done in the context of a system created by someone else.

When property ownership is indefinite and transferrable between generations, then capital accumulation becomes about whoever did it first. Yes there is occasional disruption, but a guy like Micheal Bloomberg did the labor 40 years ago and has had people working for him ever since.

I think the idea is that we ALL stand on the shoulders of giants, and rather than holding all of the gains ourselves, they should be spread so as to give other people the opportunity to make something of themselves.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by prottog on Thursday May 11, 2023 @12:26PM (#35904496)
> When property ownership is indefinite and transferrable between generations, then capital accumulation becomes about whoever did it first.

If this is true, the richest people in this country should be named Washington or Jefferson, or perhaps more recently, Carnegie or Vanderbilt. Instead, we have the likes of Bezos or Musk, the latter of whom wasn't even born here. Bloomberg was born to a bookkeeper, hardly the stuff of generational wealth. Empirical evidence suggests that it's actually pretty hard to remain at the top of the leaderboard across many generations.

I agree with the idea that we all stand on the shoulders of giants, but I dispute the picture you paint that the wealthy are "holding all of the gains [themselves]". Salaries get paid, taxes get paid, new ecosystems are made upon which future wealth can be built. There is no compelling evidence that makes me believe that more redistribution on top of what we already have (which is already quite a bit, contrary to popular belief that the US is a low-taxes-on-the-rich, low-social-benefit nation) would result in better outcomes for the median person.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by green_man_lives on Thursday May 11, 2023 @12:56PM (#35904899)
> Empirical evidence suggests that it's actually pretty hard to remain at the top of the leaderboard across many generations.

I attempted to address this when I said:

> Yes there is occasional disruption

Also Vanderbilt and Carnegie existed during a time of much higher taxation, and also Carnegie gave away most of his wealth. It's also not hard to find examples of "old money". They don't have nearly as much as a Bezos or a Musk, but still more than the average person could ever hope to earn. Finally, I hate to attribute systemic patterns to the actions of individuals, but I think it's more so that rich kids without the same grit as their hard-scrap capitalist parents end up squandering their wealth. Even after his insane corruption, Trump's returns on his dad's money are paltry compared to buying the S&P 500, or even bonds for that matter. I would attribute the dissipation of familial wealth more to hubris and infighting than the system being hostile to generational wealth transfer.

In addition, our current economic system, "shareholder capitalism" is about 40 years old. Under this paradigm it may be much easier to hold on to power. We don't know for sure, but regardless of the inter-generational aspect, think about how Bill Gates hasn't written a line of code in 40 years.

To try and quantify it, think about Bill Gates' total contribution to MSFT as a percentage. Say time multiplied by talent. When there are 10 employees with the same skill level, he contributes 10% and maybe he owns 1% of the company. Seems pretty generous. At 100 engineers he is now just doing CEO duties, but his total contribution averages out to about 2% and still owns 1%. After 40 years and thousands of employees his ownership is still 1%, while his contributions are like 0.00001% of the total contribution to MSFT. This is what I mean by it being about "whoever did it first". Someone with a higher lifetime contribution to the company can be making less simply because Bill was there first.

This is the nature of property ownership. You can defend it or not, but there is clearly a pattern of inequality that develops because of compounding growth's relationship with time. If that ends up harming your system somehow you need to address it. I don't think that pointing out the nature of it should be controversial. It's literally basic math.

> There is no compelling evidence that makes me believe that more redistribution on top of what we already have

Then you aren't looking hard enough.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by Brian_K_White on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:00PM (#35905828)
This is interesting. What might be some ways to put governers on that? Maybe you get to keep whatever money you make while producing, but do not get to collect a tax on all future earnings of other people?

That would imply no such thing as owning part of a company. But then a moral equivalent would probably just pop up in it's place. Instead of owning shares, investors become mini lenders collecting interest on their loans.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by green_man_lives on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:12PM (#35905992)
> What might be some ways to put governers on that?

Probably some sort of cooperative ownership. If you could perfectly calculate the weighted contribution of every person, you would just divide ownership up by that number. A contributor who has done 1% of the total work within an organization has 1% ownership and has 1% of the profits. If that employee retires then their contribution diminishes, but this is (theoretically) countered by the growth in profitability of the company. As long as profit growth outpaces the increase in labor (this ratio is productivity) then people should be able to retire and have a growing pension, without also unfairly capitalizing on the labor of new employees.

So let's say they work 20 years and do 1% of the work. In the next 20 years, the number of employees stays the same, but productivity doubles. The original worker has now done 0.5% of all the work done by the company, but if the company has doubled in profitability, they are still making the same amount of profit they were before.

This also assumes no outside investment from people who aren't workers, which makes it really hard to start a business. Maybe there could be some sort of bootstrapping period where investors can make their returns, which are capped at a certain amount. Or have unlimited returns but the company must switch to a cooperative structure past a certain headcount/size. Dealing with investment is certainly tricky in this thought experiment.

That is a totally theoretical solution but it's fun to explore different ways of organizing systems.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by Brian_K_White on Thursday May 11, 2023 @03:41PM (#35907389)
and I was also thinking that "no longer producing" is probably too simple. I may no longer be producing the thing I wrote a few years ago, but the company I used to work for is absolutely still selling it all day every day.

Not trying to cry that that's unfair since that was the deal at the time was salary instead of ownership. Plus what about all the stuff I spent time on that never produced any value? I still got paid and got to keep it.

Just saying as part of the theoretical conversation about other possible deals.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by prottog on Thursday May 11, 2023 @04:13PM (#35907778)
> Also Vanderbilt and Carnegie existed during a time of much higher taxation

Cornelius Vanderbilt lived from 1794 to 1877, when there was no income tax; Andrew Carnegie lived in the US from 1848 to 1919, and he would only have paid income tax in the last six years of his life. Government receipts and expenditures were single-digit percent of GDP back then.

I do wish the wealthy of today were more familiar with the concept of noblesse oblige, and laud Carnegie's devotion to philanthropy, but you couldn't be more wrong with your statement that those people lived in a time of much higher taxation. On the contrary, American government of those times was very, very small, compared to the almost 40% of GDP that it is now.

> think about how Bill Gates hasn't written a line of code in 40 years

> Someone with a higher lifetime contribution to the company can be making less simply because Bill was there first.

Your engineering manager or CTO doesn't write code yet is paid more than you. There's value in directing labor and capital, and putting them together in a prudent way.

If Bill Gates wasn't there to be first, would there be a Microsoft that an employee would be contributing to? Risk and reward go hand in hand, and someone getting paid a handsome salary like clockwork is agreeing to take a small risk for a small slice of the output.

Henry Ford didn't toil away at the assembly line putting cars together; he came up with the whole idea and employed people to execute his vision, without which none of it would have existed to begin with. Seems like implicit to your argument is the idea that the capitalists are neither necessary nor sufficient to these great commercial successes, and it would have spontaneously erupted among the proletariat without them.

> Then you aren't looking hard enough.

OK, let me look harder. It's actually pretty hard, because the US is by most measures one of the richest countries in the world, even for the average person. For median disposable income per person (adjusted for purchasing power), the US tops the list; there is no country where the median person has more money to spend on what they choose to spend it on.

For another measure, look at the GDP (again, PPP) per capita; there are a handful (literally) of countries higher than the US -- Ireland, Luxembourg, Liechtenstein, Singapore, Qatar, Monaco, Macau, UAE, Bermuda, Switzerland, Isle of Man, and Norway. Most of them are some combination of a tiny tax haven or a petro-state, with Ireland, Singapore, and Switzerland being exceptions, all three of which have a lower government expenditure as a fraction of GDP than the US.

Ireland is famous for low corporate taxes; the average worker in Switzerland pays a lower tax rate than the average worker here; and Singapore is basically a tax haven, with no capital gains tax and low top tax rates, and a remarkably efficient government at only 15% of GDP (seriously, this is the best in the developed world).

Where is your evidence that higher taxation and more redistribution would lead to a better outcome for the median person in the US?

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by green_man_lives on Thursday May 11, 2023 @05:11PM (#35908452)
> Also Vanderbilt and Carnegie existed during a time of much higher taxation

My bad, I was under the impression that the corporate tax rate was higher in the 1910s->1920s

> Your engineering manager or CTO doesn't write code yet is paid more than you. There's value in directing labor and capital, and putting them together in a prudent way.

I think the main question is how much of this can be measured and what is it worth? Sure it has value but I personally don't think the value is quantitatively different in a way that justifies the huge pay difference between execs and laborers, nor qualitatively different in a way that makes CEO pay be in ownership. I think that these distinctions are more to enforce a class system. If the idea is that a CEO's performance is tied to share price, therefore they should be rewarded in shares, then why doesn't that logic extend to all workers?

> For another measure, look at the GDP (again, PPP) per capita

GDP per capita doesn't really mean much because of averaging, I will address the median though:

> For median disposable income per person (adjusted for purchasing power), the US tops the list

Here are the numbers I found where US is third:

https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/45ae3dae-en/index.html?i....

Disposable income is post-tax. I would like to see normalization where we take things like education, healthcare, housing, and childcare costs that are covered by social democracies and add that to their disposable income, or subtract it from ours. We could even factor in household debt. Even better would be to take that normalized score and divide it by working hours. There's also the question of personal freedoms, how much agency does an individual have in their workplace, in the home the own or rent, wrt healthcare, etc. There is more to qol than just having money to spend.

> Most of them are some combination of a tiny tax haven or a petro-state

I think that the US being the world's reserve currency affords us some sort of status akin to being a tax haven or petro state, no?

> Where is your evidence that higher taxation and more redistribution would lead to a better outcome for the median person in the US?

I think this is a bit of a loaded question. I think the median person is decently well-off in the US barring some medical catastrophe. I think the question should be how to improve the social mobility chances for those below the median. I can't be bothered to look them up now but there are plenty of studies where you can see the effects of social spending on the earning power and life outcomes of people. It's a pretty simple idea that if you give poor people access to the same education and networking opportunities as wealthy people, they will perform better. Anecdotally, I find it a lot easier to take risky career moves now that I have a safety net of savings under me than I did when I was making $12/hr.

Lastly I think you only need to look back as far as the 40s-60s under managerial capitalism to see the effects of higher taxation and more investment in productive sectors of the economy plus housing/schooling. I think most people here would agree that our current economy has been propped up by debt and currency manipulation.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by prottog on Thursday May 11, 2023 @05:33PM (#35908664)
I'm glad we had this productive exchange (and since this is the internet, I will explicitly state that I say this without sarcasm). I think you and I both agree with your point:

> I think the question should be how to improve the social mobility chances for those below the median

but we differ on the "how", as well as having a more (me) or less (you) optimistic view on the current state of things in the country.

Perhaps it's fair to say that you see income and wealth inequality as the proximate cause of what ails us, and an expanded role of government, funded through more progressive/redistributive taxation, as the best way to afford better chances for those most poorly off; whereas I see the worsening of the social fabric seen in the steep rise in single-parent households and increasing permissiveness towards behavior previously deemed sinful (such as drug use) as the proximate cause, and that bigger government will only ultimately hinder the ability of those most poorly off to help themselves.

You may be interested in Thomas Sowell's book, A Conflict of Visions, for a truly elegant analysis of this type of dichotomy.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by brg on Thursday May 11, 2023 @01:09PM (#35905086)
One empirical study of this is the Georgia land lottery of 1832. For the first generation, median wealth increased. But by the 2nd generation wealth reverted to the mean, and by the 3rd there was no measurable affect by lineage.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by green_man_lives on Thursday May 11, 2023 @01:25PM (#35905333)
I have read "The Millionaire Next Door" and I mostly agree with its analysis of entrepreneurship and inter-generational wealth, it's hard to stay a millionaire.

But I think these empirical studies are a bit silly when they describe what happens in a system that accumulates wealth in the hands of a few. Once you pass a certain critical mass, it becomes very difficult to lose power. But if you are just moving up into a slightly higher tax bracket, it's still easier to revert to the mean. By definition most people will return to the mean.

The issue is what happens when people are in the long tail of ultra-wealth. How does it affect the health of our society?

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by BobbyJo on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:49AM (#35903924)
I mostly agree with this sentiment, but I think it ignores some of the wealth feedback loops that exist, and the leverage they afford businesses over employees. Our society is filled with information assymetry, and therefore power assymetry. Offsetting that asymmetry with things that aren't necessarily "fair" may be required to make things more fair as a whole.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by falcolas on Thursday May 11, 2023 @12:22PM (#35904428)
> 150k is an astronomical sum for most people on the planet

This assertion (regardless of the dollar value) bugs me, because it never considers the cost of living. Sure, if I lived in Vietnam, $150k would make me a relative millionaire.

But I don't live in (for example) Vietnam. A vast majority of people working a job that pays $150k don't live in a similar place either.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by escapedmoose on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:01PM (#35905844)
You present only the two options to offer labor to 1) an organization in which you’re not compensated in proportion to your output, vs 2) a solo practice where you’re forced to bear the burden of scaling/resource/etc costs on your own. You’re ignoring option 3) where you offer your labor to a collective organization of which you are granted proportional ownership as a condition of employment and can participate in setting the rules of your own compensation and expense burden democratically.

In option 3 the system benefits from every member’s labor contributions, AND every member benefits from the “context of a system created by someone else”

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by BeetleB on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:36AM (#35903699)
> Even if you make more than most workers, you're still getting robbed of the true value of your labor.

I used to think that way too. For years. Until I realized that's never been how labor is valued. Ever. Let's dispense with this fantasy.

There's also a disconnect. Very few people value what they buy in stores this way. We don't care what it cost to manufacture what we buy. We just care what other stores sell it for. If all the other stores are selling it cheaper, then this store is charging more than it's worth.

People pay for product. People pay for services. To first order the pricing model is the same.

And of course as another commenter said: Try starting your own business and earning 150k. I bet 95% of readers here are incapable of it.

Ignore unicorn startups and listen to How I Built This. It's quite common that for several years the founders earn little. All they have is equity they can't liquidate. For years they have to pay employees a lot more than they themselves make and give them employee rights that they themselves don't have.

If you look across all businesses in the US, earning 150k puts you better off than 90% of business owners. The deck is in favor of employees, not business owners.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by groby_b on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:53AM (#35903981)
So close. SO CLOSE.

The deck is in favor of massive inequality. This expresses in different ways. For many employees, it's exploitative workplaces. (These exploitative places are very often large companies - it turns out smaller companies usually have a sense of "together" that makes this harder). For many new businesses, it's an extremely harsh environment with low survival rates. A large part of that is that the environment is controlled by large companies and their owners.

There's a price to massive scale, and it seems we've chosen to pay it as massive inequality.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by BeetleB on Thursday May 11, 2023 @12:32PM (#35904566)
Yes engineers are on the side that's benefiting from the inequality. Virtually all societies with less inequality pay engineers less.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by falcolas on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:59AM (#35904089)
> that's never been how labor is valued

Unless you're a professional sportsball player, C-suite executive, actor, etc...

There's a number of labor jobs who haven't put capital into the business yet who receive compensation in line with the value they bring to the companies.

What we're lacking to receive the same is leverage, because unions have been defanged and discredited in our current times.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by slt2021 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @01:18PM (#35905239)
as a regular worker bee you cannot have benefits of CEO's job without risks & efforts of becoming and working as CEO.

same reason why sports school teacher cannot be paid NFL player's salary, despite both of them engaging in "sports".

high compensation - you have to compete for it, earn it, and prove everyday that you deserve it, you cannot demand handouts with your sole argument being some sort of "fairness"

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by drewcoo on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:32PM (#35906291)
> as a regular worker bee you cannot have benefits of CEO's job without risks & efforts of becoming and working as CEO

I'd love the "risk" of failing up. Do the golden parachute and handcuffs come with that package?

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by slt2021 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:45PM (#35906495)
plenty of regular workers fail up as well, the whole "jump ship every two years" culture of software engineers is essentially failing up, without getting promotion at existing job.

same with rsu packages

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by BeetleB on Thursday May 11, 2023 @04:44PM (#35908112)
Sorry, I'm having trouble connecting your comment to mine.

> Unless you're a professional sportsball player, C-suite executive, actor, etc..

How are these folks valued in a manner different from what my comment states?

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by thsbrown on Thursday May 11, 2023 @12:00PM (#35904109)
Preach! Been a self employed game developer for almost 10 years now. I think a lot of people fail to realize how incredibly hard it is to make a product (even a great one) and make a reasonable profit from it.

It takes a lot of patience, learning and failure. Even after 10 years I still feel like there's so much more to learn to get to where I want to go.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by slt2021 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:26AM (#35903549)
then one can simply create his/her own startup, bear all the risks (99% of startups fail) and reap all the rewards.

market should have found equilibrium, otherwise there is literally free money on the table.

why would engineer work for 150k when he/she can create startup with multi-million valuation?

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by lifeonlars on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:31AM (#35903596)
> then one can simply create his/her own startup, bear all the risks (99% of startups fail) and reap all the rewards.

How does that work? Most of the rewards go to the owners of the capital. That's literally the central idea of socialism.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by slt2021 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:36AM (#35903697)
you don't have to raise capital at unfavorable terms. Plenty of bootstrapped startup founders out there or founders who raised at very favorable terms (like raising 50+ mln with just a powerpoint, not even a POC of a product).

or alternatively - plenty of dual class stock holders (Zuckerberg is prime example), where you still retain control of company, while benefitting from cheap VC and public capital

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by ralusek on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:35AM (#35903675)
The value of your labor is a function of (what you do for them, what they do for you, what you can do without them, and what they can do without you). Why the value of your labor isn't (total profit of company / how much of the labor you think your work represents) is because you're not the only person that could have done that, and there are plenty of people who would do it for less. This exercise is being carried out millions of times per day, and the terminal value of this exercise is $150-$300k for most engineers in the area.

The flip side is true, too. If the value of your labor is truly what you say it is, and all it takes is a few engineers like yourself to produce that high valuation of the total company, what are you doing employed somewhere where your work is so undervalued?

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by Swizec on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:26AM (#35903541)
> you're still getting robbed of the true value of your labor.

But as someone who has tried creating value from scratch (by starting businesses) … my god having a job is so much easier. Making $200k+ as a software engineer is a piece of cake compared to scraping together $50k of fully captured value.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by marknutter on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:23AM (#35903502)
People often forget to factor in the value of risk. The reason engineers who join startups rather than found them make a fraction of what the founders make is because they didn't take on the initial risk of starting the company, which they are of course free to do anytime they like by starting their own company.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by lejoko on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:31AM (#35903606)
There is usually another reason (and I share it) : they don't have enough money to start their own company without it being too big a risk. It is an order of magnitude easier to take risks when you already have enough money so that your family is not at stake...
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by marknutter on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:53AM (#35903975)
You're only proving my point about the value of being able to take on risk.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by lejoko on Thursday May 11, 2023 @01:19PM (#35905262)
I don't see how. You said that engineers can take risks if they want. I say that: 1. a lot can't take any risk at all, even if they'd be willing to, since they have no money. 2. the level of the risk you take depends enormously on your initial wealth. Wealthy founders take a lot less risk than founders who invest their life savings. And when you get to the other side of the investment, when you win, the money you earn does not depend at all on the level of risk you took. But when you lose, it totally depends on it. the risk is not the same for everybody.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by marknutter on Thursday May 11, 2023 @03:48PM (#35907494)
What you're saying effectively boils down to "being rich is better than being poor". Risk is still risk, and it has a market value, whether or not you want to acknowledge it.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by tshaddox on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:37AM (#35903719)
Who do you think is taking on risk with downside that is remotely comparable to an individual engineer losing 2 years of salary?
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by marknutter on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:59AM (#35904090)
If I invest my life savings into founding a startup and it fails, I lose my life savings. The engineer I hired to help build the company loses nothing.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by lejoko on Thursday May 11, 2023 @01:30PM (#35905416)
If I invest pocket money (the same amount as you, or even more) into founding a startup with you and it fails, I lose pocket money. The engineer we hired together to help build the company loses his job and may find himself with serious problems because of that. Risk is in the eye of the beholder...
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by marknutter on Thursday May 11, 2023 @03:47PM (#35907469)
You as the founder also lose your job though..
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by lifeonlars on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:45AM (#35903860)
I don't think you are accurately critiquing the point made above. It is right that founders have a vastly different risk/reward tradeoff to employee engineers. I don't think that is the socialist engineers' argument.

Suppose there are 3 people involved in a startup: the founder, the engineer and the investor. The engineer gets $300,000 for 2 years' work. The founder gets $200,000 for 3 years' very intense work + $10 million if the startup succeeds. The investor puts in capital, does no work, and gets $40 million if the startup succeeds.

It is arguable that the founder and the engineer are getting a comparable amount but with a different risk profile. The socialist argument is that the person who only provides capital is overpaid for doing that. Whether that argument has an economic justification, or just a political or moral justification, and whether you believe that argument, is another matter. But it is clear that, if the investor got less, there would be more to pay both of the people who contribute work.

Perhaps a source of confusion is that successful founders often go on to become investors with the money they have collected, for example Paul Graham or Marc Andreessen. You could also argue that someone like Mark Zuckerberg, while still nominally 'working' as CEO, has gone from being a founder in Facebook the product to being an investor who provides capital for various Facebook the company projects, and that perhaps much of his wealth was accumulated in the second stage.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by marknutter on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:57AM (#35904058)
In the vast majority of cases, the startup will not succeed, and the investor will lose their investment, while the founder will make $100,000 less than the engineer and lose credibility as a founder in the process. The engineer loses nothing other than the potential future income they might have received if the company had succeeded, and they will likely just find another job.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by lifeonlars on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:51PM (#35906592)
Obviously to the investor, only the average case over a large number of investments matters.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by pseudalopex on Thursday May 11, 2023 @07:14PM (#35909614)
Many founders had failed startups before. A significant loss of credibility is not the vast majority of cases in my experience. And paying themselves less than engineers is not universal either.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by slt2021 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @01:15PM (#35905180)
engineer can always negotiate a lower salary + higher equity stake if he joins early + works lot more harder to create early product and reach PMF (especially as a founding engineer / cofounder/ etc)

imo market forces have some equilibrium in current state

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by Brian_K_White on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:13PM (#35906012)
Why are you still talking about the peanuts squabble between the engineer and the founder when they just illustrated that the investor walks away with everything?
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by slt2021 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @02:19PM (#35906100)
And why do founders voluntarily give everything away to investors?

Its not like founders are forced to. They can always be profitable and fund from their own operational cash flow

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by eastbound on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:27AM (#35903560)
As long as engineers are ok with returning 2 years of their pay if their work doesn’t allow the company to double in size, I’m perfectly ok with doubling or decupling the salary of said engineer.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by tshaddox on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:42AM (#35903805)
That doesn’t really make sense though. The people who get most of the profits of a successful startup exit were never in a position where they would lose their only source of money for living expenses for 2 years if that startup had failed.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by jsharf on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:31AM (#35903598)
Do founders return the salary they pay themselves if their company doesn’t double in size?

The answer is no, so I don’t see why software engineers should be held to higher standards.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by parthianshotgun on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:36AM (#35903693)
Founders are simply better and more evolved human beings, the exalted ones, isn't it obvious? /s
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by throwaway585793 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:38AM (#35903728)
Non sequitur.

Sarcasm doesn't make you funny or witty. This isn't reddit.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by parthianshotgun on Friday May 12, 2023 @11:40AM (#35917762)
Irrelevant.

See? I can do it too.

Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by eastbound on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:53AM (#35903971)
Founders do invest savings into creating the company, and can be condemned to prejudices if they fail to manage money properly. And every startup is managed at the edge of bankruptcy all the time, so founders can easily be found guilty of mismanagement.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by Aunche on Thursday May 11, 2023 @11:46AM (#35903872)
A lot of founders have worked for free or have already invested a lot of money in their company. If you want a salary and external investment, you better be prepared to part with much of the stake in your company.
Re:On the Rise of Socialist Engineers by Aunche on Thursday May 11, 2023 @12:03PM (#35904155)
> valuated in the hundreds of millions with only a few engineers. And you just make like $150k

It's telling that you need to compare your salary to a company's valuation rather than their income. That company worth hundreds of millions is probably actively losing tens of millions overall. It's only worth hundreds of millions because capital owners decided that this type of cash is worth burning. Without them, your $150k job simply wouldn't exist.