News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by dekhn on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:35PM (#35876905)
the cost of launching a scope is not the bottleneck.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by pfdietz on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:37PM (#35876929)
High cost of launch prevents economical repair (especially in high orbits), which requires extreme reliability. It also creates incentive for extreme weight reduction. Both these drive up the cost of a satellite. At low launch cost, there's no reason a space telescope should be much more expensive than a terrestrial telescope of the same size.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by dekhn on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:39PM (#35876951)
Do you work in the field of space?
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by spenczar5 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:54PM (#35877144)
No, that goes way too far. Radiation hardening and heat dissipation are really difficult problems that remain for any space telescopes.

(I'm at the University of Washington Department of Astronomy, and work on telescope software).

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by pfdietz on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:26PM (#35878455)
With sufficiently cheap launch, you get radiation hardening with shielding. The goal is to use off the shelf hardware as much as you can. If things break, that's why we have servicing, just like on terrestrial telescopes.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @04:52PM (#35880219)
The cost of rolling a truck to a terrestrial telescope is several orders of magnitude smaller than the cost of servicing a telescope in space. From that difference flows a greater emphasis on reliability for a space-based scope.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by dekhn on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:39PM (#35881774)
Ah. So, I should have said this earlier: there's a whole different world of cubesats that are what you're looking for. We could almost certainly help the astro community by funding and launching large fleets of simple scopes that make observing time available to more researchers.

You don't service cubesats, you just learn from your past mistakes and launch more.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by sebzim4500 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:39PM (#35876955)
No, but the mass and volume constraints are. See how much effort went into making JWST fold up and how hard they had to try to get the mirrors to be light enough.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by pfdietz on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:40PM (#35876963)
That's where in-space assembly comes in.

It's kind of sad that the one real thing the Space Station demonstrated, assembly of large space structures, has been abandoned in the name of feeding the pork pipeline with SLS.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by nordsieck on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:51PM (#35877116)
Why do you say it's been abandoned?

SLS will be delivering segments of Gateway after the first 2 are delivered by Falcon Heavy.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by pfdietz on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:57PM (#35877183)
ISS involved assembling segments that could be lifted on the Shuttle. Continuing that would involve lifting segments that could be lifted on F9 or FH. There would be no need for something as large as SLS.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by sbierwagen on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:48PM (#35883432)
SLS is expending surplus RS-25 shuttle engines. Once they're gone they'll be paying Aerojet Rocketdyne a hundred million each for new ones. The first stage uses four.

Eventually someone with a brain is going to notice, SLS will be canceled, and decades of federal jail time will ensue for the criminals who perpetuated this fraud upon the American people.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by tsimionescu on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:18PM (#35877452)
Given that SLS works and Starship has failed pretty spectacularly so far (engines failing off the gate and in flight, launch site damage, failed to detonate on demand), I think it's about time to stop saying SLS is just pork.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by cubefox on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:34PM (#35877713)
SLS may be further ahead in development (though the version that launched is far from the final one), but it is much worse than Starship in nearly every other aspect. This is consensus in the space community, it has been discussed to death.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by pfdietz on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:57PM (#35878066)
SLS basically has a single purpose: funneling money to particular contractors. There is no objective in space that couldn't be done more cheaply with F9 and FH, given propellant transfer and some in-space assembly.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by GolfPopper on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:42PM (#35878655)
>Given that SLS works

A cost of $27,000,000,000 per launch, and a launch rate of 1 per 132 months is a generous definition of "works". And that's where SLS is right now.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by cubefox on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @04:41PM (#35880110)
I think it is "just" 4 billion per launch, though of course this doesn't include the development costs. Regardless, the costs are staggering compared to Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy, Vulcan, or Starship.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by dylan604 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:19PM (#35877456)
How did China lift their space station?
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by basementcat on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:14PM (#35879071)
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by adgjlsfhk1 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:32PM (#35878538)
Space assembly for a telescope is way harder than the ISS. Telescope mirrors need to be aligned to within a few nanometers of each other, compared to the ISS which just needs airtight seals (so ~1mm + O-ring tolerance).
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by pfdietz on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @02:46PM (#35891640)
The alignment would be actively controlled. That's how they make large terrestrial telescopes work.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by nordsieck on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:45PM (#35877052)
> the cost of launching a scope is not the bottleneck.

Starship isn't just about price, but also fairing volume. And fairing volume is one of the major factors that drives telescope design.

It's even possible that SpaceX would do a limited run hammerhead fairing for the right price.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by cubefox on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:40PM (#35877816)
Not sure a larger fairing would be compatible with the current tower. Though they could use landing legs, then it doesn't have to be caught mid flight.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by nordsieck on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:47PM (#35877924)
> Not sure a larger fairing would be compatible with the current tower.

I'd imagine that a hammerhead fairing would mean an expended 2nd stage. There's just too much custom work that would have to be done (for example with the heat shield) to really make it work.

But if the cost is reasonable (I'm guessing ~$25 million for an upper stage), that isn't a bad price to pay to get access to a 12m fairing.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by cubefox on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:45PM (#35878698)
I think 25 million USD is too optimistic, since the Starship upper stage has six raptor engines, and the Falcon 9 upper stage has only one Merlin engine, but a launch price of around 60 million US dollars.

But NASA would pay much more than that if it means they can launch a telescope with a big mirror that doesn't need to be folded in. The main problem I see is that they would likely also have to pay for the entire development of the new upper stage, which would be much higher than the pure launch cost. Since NASA already has JWST, I'm not sure they have much interest in a big new space telescope currently. Other than that, it's not clear what a super large payload fairing would be required for.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by nordsieck on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:12PM (#35879047)
> The main problem I see is that they would likely also have to pay for the entire development of the new upper stage

I don't see why they'd need to do a full 2nd stage.

I'm sure a limited run fairing (especially a complicated one like a hammerhead) will be expensive - certainly quite a bit more than the $5 million per unit cost of the Falcon fairings. But ultimately a fairing just isn't that complicated, and SpaceX has a lot of experience with them.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by cubefox on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:52PM (#35879545)
Well, the aerodynamics are different and the launch abort system would probably have to be somewhat different too. The structural integrity could also be quite different. Of course it won't be a completely new upper stage, as it is just a modification, but a few test launches are probably required.
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by dylan604 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:55PM (#35878835)
>I'm guessing ~$25 million for an upper stage

that'll be initial cost submitted. once it is approved and work begins, that number will double, triple, or more before it is completed.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by signatoremo on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:00PM (#35883155)
NASA has only awarded SpaceX fixed cost contracts, never cost plus — whether it’s COTS, Crew Dragon or HLS. Same deal with US Air Force.

It’s amazing how wrong facts are asserted with absolute certainty here on HN.

Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by dylan604 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:58PM (#35883487)
SpaceX is just the truck to carry the payload that is built by someone else. It’s the payload that always goes over budget. Facts are facts
Re:James Webb Space Telescope Reveals Fomalhaut's Disk in Un... by signatoremo on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:48AM (#35883746)
> I’m guessing ~$25 million for an upper stage.

That was what you responded to. Since when the upper stage is the payload? Which facts are you asserting?