News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by williamcotton on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:16AM (#35860728)
To the Austrians out there: you can theorize and even model scenarios where this is not only a bad but a terrible idea but I would like to point out some empirically successful government institutions of managed resources in free parts of the world:

Fannie and Freddie, TVA, Statoil, just to name a few. These effectively manage limited resources, are profitable, and the windfall does not end up in private hands.

Yea, the commies accidentally created famines, but the root cause was their refusal to engage with anything other than their theories and model… which, should sound like the former issue raised with their economic counterparts…

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by analog31 on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:26AM (#35860795)
Moreover, it seems to me that with the amount of oversight needed to prevent the mines from laying waste to their surroundings and abusing their workers, and the anticipated bail-out when it goes bankrupt, the government might as well just run it.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by cmrdporcupine on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:23AM (#35860770)
> Yea, the commies accidentally created famines

I'd actually argue the stalinists created famines not by accident but at least partially by intent. Their economic modelling and planning were terrible, yes -- in part because of ideological blindness you mention. But the existence of the NEP for a short period of time in the 20s shows that at least some of the Bolsheviks were able to demonstrate more flexible thinking.

But they were also legitimately terrible, damaged, malevolent people who were the products of a nasty civil war. Starving their perceived enemies and brutalizing whole populations to do so was part of their MO.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by muro on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:35AM (#35860861)
I would say they were also a cause, not just a product of a nasty civil war.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by cmrdporcupine on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:45AM (#35860962)
Not the Tsarist monsters who sent waves of young men to be butchered in WWI?
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by muro on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:10AM (#35861171)
Every country in WWI did that, no?

Anf while didn't say they were the only cause, they certainly didn't try to minimise casualties.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by cmrdporcupine on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:18AM (#35861243)
My point is that the first act the Bolsheviks did was to end Russian involvement in WWI and end that slaughter. (At the cost of massive loss of territory and reprisal from western powers.)

It ain't black and white.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by muro on Monday May 08, 2023 @11:26AM (#35862653)
That's a good point. I thought the Russian civil war was already happening at that time, so it enabled everyone in Russia to focus on that one alone. Is that incorrect?
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by cmrdporcupine on Monday May 08, 2023 @11:33AM (#35862748)
Civil war happened a bit later, but I guess it's blurry because it was also mixed up with the foreign invasion / punishments that came out of the Soviet withdrawal from the war and Brest-Litovsk. The allies were enraged by the withdrawal from the war, but of course also extremely interested in destroying the new Bolshevik regime. So right away after 1918 they were thrown into a conflict setting.

I'd have to defer to an actual historian here for the full details, but my understanding of the history is that the "whites" that the Bolsheviks fought in the civil war were funded and aided by foreign powers (Britain, etc.), and that that funding and intervention began the moment Brest-Litovsk was signed, but then later transitioned into the full civil war scenario.

Of course it all depends on how you draw definitional lines around civil war vs revolution, etc.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by williamcotton on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:29AM (#35860806)
Good points all around! The same general problem of recovering from a brutal civil war seems core to Maoists as well!

Ideology and gunpowder make for a terrible brew.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by cmrdporcupine on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:55AM (#35861043)
The first half of the 20th century was a cruel time and engineered cruel people, of all ideological stripes. 50 years of living with the consequences of WWI.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by bitL on Monday May 08, 2023 @10:42AM (#35862049)
Stalinists were trying to create economies of scale by centralizing agriculture to large conglomerates but weren't smart enough to avoid supply disruption that together with dry years, optimistic communication/lies and foreign export led to massive famines throughout the whole USSR.

One can see the same pattern in large corps where the front falls suddenly off.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by cmrdporcupine on Monday May 08, 2023 @11:34AM (#35862763)
But it was also bound up with ideological and ethnic campaigns against e.g. Ukrainian nationalists and the Ukrainian peasantry generally. Stalin was a big fan of collective punishment, repopulation, depopulation, etc. Sociopath. Resistance of aspects of the peasantry to collectivization, etc. became an excuse for brutal policies, independent of any theoretical "socialist" policy.

Remember Marx (and even Lenin) wrote nothing about e.g. agricultural policy or even what socialization of industry would look like in practice. So these people (Stalin and his apparatus) were making it up as they went along, and they were awful people.

e.g. Stalin came to power against Trotsky and the Left Opposition by insisting on maintaining the NEP and taking a more gradual and pragmatic approach and then turned around, exterminated his opponents, and did the precisely the opposite and forced mass collectivization (leading to mass starvation.)

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by hackeraccount on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:31AM (#35860826)
I wouldn't hold up Fannie and Freddie as a model for anything.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by williamcotton on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:34AM (#35860855)
Why not? They’ve created an insane amount of private wealth in the US and are profitable. FHA loans have caused more good than harm.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by Kiro on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:43AM (#35860928)
For someone outside the US those names are only associated with the financial crisis. I don't even know what they are and honestly thought they were another Lehman brothers that didn't exist anymore, so your comment read like a joke.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by JauntTrooper on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:16AM (#35861217)
Fannie Mae (FNMA) and Freddie Mac (FHLMC) are companies that the US federal government set up and sponsors in order to support the mortgage industry and provide liquidity to banks and other financial institutions that provide mortgages to Americans.

So if a bank offers a mortgage to a customer and the loan conforms with Fannie and Freddie's underwriting policies, Fannie and Freddie will buy it from them them. They then package some of those loans into a loan portfolio and sell it to fixed income investors.

About 70% of US mortgages are supported by Fannie and Freddie.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by williamcotton on Monday May 08, 2023 @11:34AM (#35862758)
Unfortunately reality isn’t the point of these online exchanges.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mattmaroon on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:52AM (#35861012)
If it makes you feel better, most American home owners have a loan that originated with one of them and still don’t know any more about them than you do.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by everybodyknows on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:16AM (#35861216)
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:33AM (#35860845)
The problem is that the State exists to abuse the rights of the people

I don't understand how or why profits ending up on private hands is bad, you are a private hand and the State robs you all the time

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by andybak on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:44AM (#35860948)
> The problem is that the State exists to abuse the rights of the people

The state exists for a multiplicity of reasons - some of which are harmful and some of which are beneficial.

And if the state doesn't exist then other actors will step in to and will also do a mixture of harm and good.

Any attempt to handwave away the nuance just sounds silly.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:02AM (#35861116)
The existance of the State is an infringement on your rights, any good that comes out of it isn't really an argument. It's akin as saying that killing all poor people would eradicate poverty, so it is harmful in some ways but it has some benefits

Other actors would also be States, we the people should fight against all States, not just the current one

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by fmajid on Monday May 08, 2023 @10:48AM (#35862119)
Because human rights are so well-protected in Afghanistan, Somalia or other such failed states. The alternative to a functioning state is not some techno-anarchist utopia, its warlordism and feudalism. Even the Taliban were seen as preferable to that (they got their initial political capital by rescuing boys kidnapped by warlords to be used as catamites).
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by malermeister on Monday May 08, 2023 @12:38PM (#35863708)
The techno-anarchist utopia is neo-feudalism.

They just hope to be on top this time.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @04:44PM (#35866829)
You should not convince people that your fantasies are mine
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by andybak on Monday May 08, 2023 @10:56AM (#35862240)
> The existance of the State is an infringement on your rights,

Which rights are these and by what authority are they bestowed? Let's assume I'm an athiest for the sake of argument.

You're positing the existence of natural rights without specifying how they came into being and how they are enforced.

Generally "rights" in the normal sense of the word are created by... well... states.

I'm not naive and I'm aware of the history of anarchist thought. But I'm not sure which flavour you're espousing.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @04:43PM (#35866812)
A right is not given to you by an authority. You are free to live your life, as long as you don't control/damage other people.

The State takes away your right to live your life and use your property, and empowers Corporations to make them richer at your cost. In the meantime, the State murders a lot of people.

Your rights must be enforced by yourself until free-market alternatives to the State are created

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by andybak on Monday May 08, 2023 @05:07PM (#35867079)
A "right" is entirely theoretical unless there is a way to ensure it is reflected in reality.

That, sadly, is why any analysis of "rights" is vacuous unless it is accompanied by an analysis of "power".

I wonder if you might be confusing "ought" for "is"?

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by polyamid23 on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:47AM (#35860979)
Please build your own roads then...
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by freedomben on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:27AM (#35861299)
Just fyi, this is one of the biggest running jokes as a low effort, lazy rebuttal. I'm not saying that's you, just in general It's been refuted ad nauseam and there are mountains of answers to this just a duck duck go search away. Most ancaps/Austrians have spent significant time researching and learning, so the tolerance for low effort over confident retorts on forums is minimal. That's likely why you weren't given a serious answer.

Before people reply to this comment arguing with me about roads, it's worth stating that I'm not an ancap myself and do not believe everything including roads are better privatized.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by malermeister on Monday May 08, 2023 @12:41PM (#35863744)
Please don't call market extremists Austrian. We, the people of Austria, want nothing to do with them and their philosophy is seen as crazy fringe theories here.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by freedomben on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:37AM (#35875999)
Point taken, although it's an extremely common/well known term here because it was Austrian economics (such as Mises) that formed the basis of it.

Can you suggest a better term? How would you feel about "Austrian Economics"? I once tried "Mises economics" but that caused a lot of confusion.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by malermeister on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:17PM (#35876600)
Economics in Austria are still strongly influenced by the legacy of Austromarxism [0] (the city of Vienna is the largest landlord in Europe) and, more recently, the Socialists under Bruno Kreisky [1], who built the modern welfare state.

Given this reality of economics in Austria, the term "Austrian Economics" also seems like a misnomer.

Maybe something like "Austrian Marginalism" would be clearer?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austromarxism [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruno_Kreisky

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by polyamid23 on Monday May 08, 2023 @01:11PM (#35864179)
Well this is obviously not a serious answer since the initial statement was: "The problem is that the State exists to abuse the rights of the people"

Which, sure, that's like your opinion man (or you are talking about some North Korea'esque regime). But what can even be argued here?

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @04:32PM (#35866692)
Everything the State does robs you of your freedom and gives power to corporations, not in North Korea, in all countries
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:00AM (#35861091)
Oh no, what a nightmare, if you want something done you have to pay for it

There is a lot of material to read on the denationalization of roads, it's not impossible by any means

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by williamcotton on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:46AM (#35861465)
If only those authors had channeled their fantasies into an art form other than economics, perhaps the world would be a more beautiful place.

At least the combination of ideology and internet connection is mainly psychologically destructive. It’s a step up from ideology and gunpowder’s uncanny ability to provide close-up views of friends bleeding to death.

Pragmatism might be defined as anti-ideological or it might be rooted in empiricism or actually it is quite the opposite of pragmatic to even wonder about such things.

We can talk, we can agree, we can use our physical and common senses, and we can do things together that are meaningful and make sense. We don’t really need the modernist requirement of axioms and their extrapolations.

Sure, rocketry benefits from models and empirical results and for a very simple reason: reproducing the results and proving to yourself that your ideas work through direct experience, the foundation of science itself.

The liberal arts are by necessity of a different epistemological foundation for a simple reason: we cannot currently model the entirety of our world in ways that are conducive to falsification. We get hints and generalizations. History is the foundation of these disciplines and trial-and-error across decades of lived experience the laboratory.

This necessarily adds a political dimension as everyone needs to be convinced to be willing participants in near planet-sized experiments.

For the most part people are satisfied with public roads and conservative with their approach to locomotion.

If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. There we go, a workable definition of pragmatism pops out at the end.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @10:28AM (#35861870)
You actually wrote a huge wall of text without addressing anything in my comments, and even managed to insult the intelligence of me and every anarchist in existence in the process, cool

I actually have NEVER heard of someone being satisfied with the roads or strees in their city/county/

The problem is that the State doesn't work, it continually murders tons of people every year, it continually suppresses peoples rights every day, and it continually robs everyone of us of a better world.

The fact that you are currently privileged enough to not feel the oppression, or not understand as oppression and just accept it as a fact of life, is good for you, but it is incredibly abhorrent to just dismiss what I say by saying absolutely nothing

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by smolder on Monday May 08, 2023 @02:39PM (#35865389)
I like my public roads and public transportation. Now you have heard of someone.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by cpursley on Monday May 08, 2023 @08:54AM (#35861039)
Actually (and ironically), Chile has a really interesting experiment in private toll roads. So it can be done.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mypastself on Monday May 08, 2023 @10:01AM (#35861585)
Is there an in-depth article on the topic? I’m interesting in learning about this, but I haven’t had much luck with English language articles on Google.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by boeingUH60 on Monday May 08, 2023 @10:12AM (#35861689)
I'm not an anti-government person or anarcho-capitalist, but in my third-world country (Nigeria), private roads are better built and maintained than government-funded roads. Private companies build their roads to standard because they actually want to please customers, while government-funded roads are given to substandard contractors at a low price and the rest of the funds are stolen...the government maintains a monopoly, so there's no other choice than to drive on the horrible roads they build.

But in this case, this is more a problem of corruption and incompetence than the existence of a government...just saying that "build your own roads" is not the absolute rebuttal you think it is.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by polyamid23 on Monday May 08, 2023 @01:13PM (#35864216)
Yes, this was not a serious answer to this. I replied a stupid statement with an equally stupid statement.
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Monday May 08, 2023 @04:44PM (#35866838)
Sure, you were being stupid only because you though my argument was stupid
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by polyamid23 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:13AM (#35873157)
Kind of... I was being stupid, because there is no argument but a statement without any reasoning behind it. I could say that the state that I live in provides free education, which is not something that necessarily robs my freedom and gives power to corporations. So at least, it's not "everything" the state does, right?
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:44AM (#35873513)
Yes, the education system is hand made to make the students into good employees for the corporations
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by polyamid23 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:59PM (#35878082)
Not sure if you are trolling... Do you have any references or something. Again, this is just a statement without any arguments or am I missing something?
Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by mughinn on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:51PM (#35878770)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_schooling has several sources if you want to read, specifically the first argument, of the school system as government control

But I didn't think I'd need sources, it's almost a meme how everyone thinks school is where your curiosity dies.

Everyone says we need schools, just not the ones we have, or the ones we had, or the ones we will have.

The school system is the monopoly of the government to say what is important for children to learn, mostly to obey authority

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by trompetenaccoun on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:00AM (#35861095)
It's about macroeconomics, it doesn't mean that you can not have the state run anything at all. Austrian economists are not anarchists. For example I can point to successful schemes in Saudi or China and still see that on the grand scheme of things private markets are a lot more efficient. You're pointing to the exception as a criticism of the rule.

If they do it right this step makes a lot of sense for Chile. It doesn't negate the fact that socialist policies have economically ruined South America at large. Venezuela is the best example, it used to be the richest of them all not very long ago.

Re:Chile to Nationalize Lithium Industry by alvarezbjm-hn on Monday May 08, 2023 @09:30AM (#35861320)
Not "socialist policies" Populist dictators have ruined everything.