News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by rorrr on Monday February 13, 2012 @12:54AM (#3584393)
As much as I love libraries, they are extremely inefficient considering their purpose.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by bpodgursky on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:19AM (#3584470)
It depends on whether you consider the purpose as technically enabling the spreading of information/books, or actually encouraging people to go and read and study. Sure people are able to go and buy or download each of the books in there, but IMO kids still gain a ton from wandering around the stacks until they find something interesting. It's also a good way to impress upon kids the huge amount of gathered knowledge out there, and how important it is to make use of it...
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by rorrr on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:32AM (#3584496)
I think modern kids are online already, and are exposed to all kinds of information. No library in the world can even come close to Wikipedia + Google image search.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by yardie on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:42AM (#3584765)
Wikipedia relies on primary sources. So at some point, whether it was academic, national, or local, a library was used to acquire some of those sources.

Anyway, wikipedia relies on sourced research, which requires people that know how to do research. And this was taught...at the library (You'll have a hard time finding Basic Research Methods 101 in any university catalog).

When someone says that wikipedia can replace libraries I immediately want to shake somebody violently. Please understand that wikipedia isn't a primary source. Jimmy never intended it to replace them. They'll give you a topical understanding and a list of ISBN numbers at the bottom of the page. Now you can go to the library and using your freshly acquired ISBN numbers check out the books you actually need.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by krschultz on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:16AM (#3585421)
You can only come to that opinion if you don't read books. I aim to read a (non-fiction) book a week, but usually end up finishing them in roughly 10 days. My split is about 50% library 50% Amazon.com purchases. Without the library my reading habit would be massively more expensive.

Right now I'm reading a book by Bain about the transcontinental railroads that I picked up at my local library (after reserving it online, picking it up at the front counter without even having to look for it, and walking out the door in <60 seconds using the automated checkout machine) and a book on startups I got off of Amazon.

I've read the wikipedia entry on the transcontinental railroad, it's good. But it's not as detailed as book. And there are about 50,000 blog posts on startups, but none are as detailed as the book I'm reading.

Wikipedia and blog posts are all shallow overviews of the subject. If you want nuance, if you want depth, then you need a book. And the internet doesn't even come close.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by asimeqi on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:07AM (#3584567)
My modern kids visit the local library every 2 weeks and in each visit borrow about 10 books. I don't think I could afford to buy all those books and I would have no space to store the books after the kids read them.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by firefoxman1 on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:57AM (#3584545)
It's true that this generation just receives information differently. I was pretty much a non-reader my first 2 years of high school, like most people I knew. Then I received a Kindle for my birthday. Knowing where to find thousands of really great public-domain books and the ease of access gave me so much (free) knowledge I wouldn't have taken the time to discover in a library.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by zecho on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:32AM (#3585930)
Libraries aren't just books, though. That's kind of an old fashioned view of Libraries. Many librarians coming out of schools now have degrees in information services, and they're fairly progressive programs that are a subset of computer science programs. Many of the librarians I know are experts at using the web.

For example, libraries provide services like access to computers and the Internet, for modern kids and adults without access to the Internet.

Many libraries also now provide ebooks available for the Kindle and Nook devices.

And then there's the fact that they're merely an indoor public space, usually with rooms freely or nominally available for the public to simply meet and share ideas.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by bmj on Monday February 13, 2012 @09:45AM (#3585723)
This may be true, but do you ever go to the library? I often spend a few hours a week there while my kids are in a class, and there are TONS of people doing research (and reading) actual books. Yes, people are doing lots of work online, but in many cases, some material just isn't available (freely) there yet.

Add to that interlibrary loan, and you have a wealth of information available.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by tonyedgecombe on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:46AM (#3584522)
In theory you are right, in reality most kids probably don't move off Facebook other than to cheat on their homework.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by learc83 on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:57AM (#3584544)
Just like in reality most kids didn't go to the library unless forced, and spent half their time looking for dirty books.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by Cadsby on Monday February 13, 2012 @04:14AM (#3584844)
I strongly disagree. In New York you can walk into almost any library in the city in the middle of the afternoon, head to the children's/young adult section, and find a ton of kids/teens reading, browsing, engaging in local events, etc. I've found this to be especially true in poorer neighborhoods in the Bronx and Brooklyn, the kind of places where some people assume no one would interested in partaking of these resources. (I have family in these areas so I visit these neighborhoods a lot) Remember also, libraries are much more than storage buildings for lots of dead tree books. They provide important services to their communities - e.g. adult literacy assistance, job/resume services, basic internet access and a whole lot more.

A lot of kids (and adults) get a great deal out of their local library. I still vividly remember the very first book that I picked up by chance while browsing the Sci-Fi section and couldn't put down until I fell asleep with it in my hands at 5am.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by learc83 on Monday February 13, 2012 @04:57AM (#3584943)
>a ton of kids/teens

>A lot of kids

Yes, I was one of those kids, but most of the kids I went to school with weren't readers and never went to the library for fun.

In a densely populated area if 1% of kids regularly vist the library, it will be packed. Still--most kids don't.

I also wasn't implying that libraries are without merit. The OP implied that the internet wasn't beneficial as an educational tool because most kids don't take advantage of it's potential. I merely pointed out that the same was true for libraries.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by Retric on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:18AM (#3585428)
Depends on the library. EX: Library of congress still orders of magnitude ahead of Wikipedia.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by riffic on Monday February 13, 2012 @09:13AM (#3585603)
Having been a Wikipedia editor for a few years, I can assure you that Wikipedia's (and the larger Internet's) content is severely lacking in what you can find in a common library, especially if you consider content older than 20 years.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by kiloaper on Monday February 13, 2012 @06:46AM (#3585221)
You seem to have a very narrow view of what libraries provide. Libraries, at least where I'm from, are far more than book storage facilities. They're essential community centers which promote education, literacy and social interaction. They host events from kids competitions to senior citizens groups. You can't replicate that online.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by pagekalisedown on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:01AM (#3584418)
Most libraries have moved beyond just renting out books a while ago.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by baddox on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:06AM (#3584427)
What do they do now? I know some provide desks, wifi, services like fax and copy machines (which they usually charge for), and public classes (reading clubs, basic computer classes, etc.).
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by firefoxman1 on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:10AM (#3584572)
A new trying-to-be-hip library just opened up in my city. They do a pretty good job of it too. The theme seems to be "How well can we copy Barnes and Noble?" Not only does it include a small coffee shop, but they have a dedicated children's section that looks a lot like Barnes and Noble's (the whole fairy-tail etc. style with elaborate decorations). They even had an opening night where they had the local hit-music radio station came and hosted dance party, complete with neon lights, glow sticks and pounding music (no old lady saying "SHHH" that night).

They rent out conference rooms and have a large auditorium with a theater-sized movie screen. The last time I was there they were showing Kung-Fu Panda which attracted a decent crowd. It's one library that has changed with the times.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by rorrr on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:10AM (#3584445)
Most US libraries have huge collections of videos (VHS, DVDs), most of them are entertainment, like regular crappy action movies, and there's no real good reason for them to be in the library.

Many US libraries have audio (CDs, cassetes). Most of them are just as senseless.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by a_a_r_o_n on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:19AM (#3584469)
Are you saying that libraries should only have sensible holdings? Which ones are those?

I once checked out le Carré's Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy. It was something of an action novel, and it was entertaining. Was that one OK?

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by yummyfajitas on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:32AM (#3584497)
I think the point is that this is the sort of thing people should buy/rent for themselves, rather than demanding other people to rent it for them.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by softbuilder on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:10AM (#3584573)
Exact same argument could be made for books. Why don't we rent books?
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by rdl on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:23AM (#3584715)
There's a reasonable argument that even trashy books have value as reading practice. Most humans have no problem finding enough spoken interaction to practice listening (although I definitely watched mediocre television in foreign language to practice...)

(I'd be fine with no government funding for libraries in general; it seems like something which should be privately or charity funded to keep them safe from censorship and political control.)

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by yummyfajitas on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:50AM (#3584660)
Good question. Here in India this is exactly how it is done. (I'm told a few public libraries do exist, but I've never seen one.)

Given that the private sector does seem fully capable of providing libraries to those who want them, why do we subsidize them?

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by corin_ on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:39AM (#3584761)
The private sector is equally capable of providing hospitals, policemen, firefighters, governments, roads...

The question is rarely as simple as "could the private sector do it?"

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by yummyfajitas on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:12AM (#3585834)
Um, the theory behind the government provisioning of police, firefighters and roads is that they are a public good. I.e., people will refuse to pay for police while enjoying not being murdered.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by corin_ on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:21AM (#3585878)
In the most simplistic explanation possible, "public good" is the reason for everything the government does, including libraries.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by yummyfajitas on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:07PM (#3588134)
No, libraries are rivalrous and excludible, hence a private good.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by corin_ on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @12:07AM (#3588717)
That's just completely irrelevant though.

Healthcare provision is rivalrous and excludible, ask any poor American, doesn't mean it shouldn't be universally provided by the government.

Education is rivalrous and excludible, look at private schools - doesn't mean it's wrong for there to be state schools and laws making children attend them.

The only thing that matters is whether the public benefit outweighs the burden on taxpayers.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by softbuilder on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:33AM (#3584750)
If I'm too poor to rent a book, how do I get it?
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by galadriel on Monday February 13, 2012 @04:57AM (#3584949)
If it is India, you are probably too poor to be literate, or if literate, you have very little time to engage in privilege of reading books. So the answer is I guess, you don't. Pretty much like you don't get (decent) healthcare for poor in US.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by derleth on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:42AM (#3584515)
> Are you saying that libraries should only have sensible holdings? Which ones are those?

You're being facetious, but this is precisely the question libraries have always faced, through thin times and fat, regardless of the social and political winds. They have only so much shelf space and face the simple fact nobody will come to a location that doesn't offer them anything they want.

There's a very old political debate at bottom: Should a government institution give the taxpayers what they want, or should it focus more on giving them what the better-educated types decide they need? Go the first way and you're competing with Wal-Mart and Barnes & Noble; go the second and you have a wonderful temple to Sanctioned Knowledge that, to a first approximation, nobody really cares about.

So, yes, what are 'sensible' holdings? Do you have any answers?

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by a_a_r_o_n on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:37AM (#3584638)
Demand mixed with a librarian's sense of worth/taste is one approach. There are many others. And libraries do have to choose due to shelf space and publisher agreements.

My hackles rise whenever I hear someone tell me what's worthwhile and what's not. But I do recognize practical necessity. I don't believe there's anything magical about the book/text format over electronic/other formats, other than "that's how it's been" up until recently.

I would be pleased to see "Fart Proudly" in any library's holdings, regardless of format.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fart_Proudly

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by softbuilder on Monday February 13, 2012 @02:09AM (#3584571)
Hmm. I'd love to seem some hard stats on that.

Don't forget that libraries host community events, children's books, story time, literacy programs, and give poor people access to computers, printers, and the internet.

Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by beedogs on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:40AM (#3584508)
I agree! Libraries should only stock reference materials. To hell with this "popular culture" BS.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by ww520 on Monday February 13, 2012 @03:22AM (#3584712)
Libraries are extremely valuable for their purposes.
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by Volpe on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:01AM (#3584420)
Which purpose are you ascribing the inefficiency to?
Re:California Cuts All State Funding for Libraries by rorrr on Monday February 13, 2012 @01:06AM (#3584430)
Spreading information.