News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by falcolas on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:08PM (#35810023)
Yeah, I’d complain if I were a Google employee too. 70B in wasted potential for new and improved products, plus a CEO who admitted to overhiring getting a big stock grant (in addition to a bonus, err, stock price bump from buybacks).

It feels like the board has said, “We don’t care about the company or it’s future, just the price of our stock.”

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by edgefield on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:20PM (#35810108)
This is basically every public company —- Prioritize short term stock price gains over long term growth and sustainability. The only exception are founder run companies and perhaps a few public companies with strong culture/mission (e.g., Costco comes to mind). Google is no longer founder led and it threw out its mission several years ago.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by andsoitis on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:32PM (#35810205)
> The only exception are founder run companies

Page and Brin collectively own 51.2% of Google's voting power. They seem to be happy with the company direction and its leadership.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by mikepurvis on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @10:06PM (#35810430)
Owning it and running it are hardly the same though. Their priority is probably also "whatever makes money" at this point, other than occasionally grunting in the direction of AI and other moonshot projects.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by andsoitis on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:49PM (#35810985)
> Owning it and running it are hardly the same though.

While they do not run day to day operations, both are on the board https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35810965

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by LeonB on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:13PM (#35810808)
It’s not founder run though. They have a level of separation from the running of the business.

(And even if they were running it, it’s no guarantee that it would stick to any respectable values… just “more likely”… but in their case… still very unlikely.)

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by AwaAwa on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:30PM (#35810893)
Page and Brin are happy that the stock stays up without having to spend any effort running it.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by PaulWaldman on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:32PM (#35810906)
Maybe they're just apathetic or complacent? Almost like when a hobby feels more like a job or you just get bored with it.

With their voting shares, what stakeholders, maybe besides the government, could really exert leverage over them?

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by hsjqllzlfkf on Thursday May 04, 2023 @07:10AM (#35813678)
That's not how capitalism works. If you don't like something about the company, just don't buy the stock. Simple.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by bushbaba on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:42PM (#35810266)
That’s not entirely true. Long term growth also impacts stock price and could be preferential for investors.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by falcolas on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:26PM (#35810151)
I guess one bonus is that no companies will survive intact to become Cyberpunkesque monopolies with such shortsighted planning.

Instead the stock market and its adherents will be (are now?) our overlord.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by darkwizard42 on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:30PM (#35810179)
I don't know, giving Google/randomBigCo leadership too much credit here on even being able to plan long term enough to do that.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by pitched on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:42PM (#35810268)
The way biology evolves to adapt is also very shortsighted! Even without long-term planning, it can still make spiders!
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by falcolas on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:44PM (#35810287)
Or, more broadly, crabs. Carcinisation for all!
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by zmgsabst on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @10:02PM (#35810408)
Biology does that through a try-and-fail approach.

Something akin to venture capital, where it makes many, many tries most of which fail and the occasional success moves the field forward.

Presumably investors want more reliable returns from mature companies.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by LeonB on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:17PM (#35810828)
The survival of the monopolies, monopsonies, oligopolies, oligopsonists is down to whether or not they can defend, protect and retain their monopolies (etc.)
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by jjtheblunt on Thursday May 04, 2023 @01:45AM (#35811645)
> This is basically every public company —- Prioritize short term stock price gains over long term growth and sustainability.

Berkshire Hathaway invests in public companies exactly not like you describe, generally seeking companies whose priorities are evident in dividends not share price.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by sidcool on Thursday May 04, 2023 @04:54AM (#35812828)
Tesla also prioritises long term
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by eqmvii on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:28PM (#35810160)
> It feels like the board has said, “We don’t care about the company or it’s future, just the price of our stock.”

Well since the board is hired to represent the stockholders...

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by falcolas on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:37PM (#35810233)
It has been upheld in court that one of the duties of a company to its shareholders is ensuring the continuation of the company.

Of course courts have also upheld the duty to increase stock value too, but still…

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by AmericanChopper on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:53PM (#35810333)
You don’t need any court rulings to understand this. The owners of a company decide how it will be run. The shareholders own the company, they elect a board to represent them. The board hires a CEO and defines their compensation package (along with its performance incentives). The decisions of the shareholders and their board may prove to be unwise in retrospect, but this doesn’t change how the governance structure works. The board (and thus the CEO) can only do what the shareholders want them to do.

All of the ruminating over short term thinking is also nonsensical. A company that has no future has very little value. Perhaps the share holders, or the board, or their CEO have a long-term vision that you disagree with. But this isn’t anything close to an objective fact, it’s just your own self-aggrandising opinion that if you were running the 4th largest company in the world, that you’d be doing a better job.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by geodel on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:57PM (#35810364)
> We don’t care about the company or it’s future, just the price of our stock.

Yeah board doesn't care, founders don't care, investors don't care, CEO doesn't care. Who cares then? Google employees because they are taking the biggest risk by being employed there.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by skybrian on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @10:10PM (#35810456)
To be fair, many employees care about the stock price too, for good reason.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by YetAnotherNick on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:36PM (#35810923)
Google always hired more people than needed to run existing services. So overhiring is a standard procedure for them and would likely be repeated if the market becomes good again. In almost all the cases in the past it worked in their favor.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by nashashmi on Thursday May 04, 2023 @01:30AM (#35811572)
He did go through a lot of struggle having to cut so many jobs and actually keep the company remarkably profitable. That's why he deserves a raise. He cut costs instead of being like the previous leaders who frequent burned money. And played with shareholders the entire time.

I'm not saying the ceo is right for what he did. I like the previous ceo who kept products alive even when they did not make money. But like IBM, companies do grow up and start acting like adults. This is one of those times.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by thiht on Thursday May 04, 2023 @02:28AM (#35811887)
> He did go through a lot of struggle having to cut so many jobs

Poor Sundar. That’s quite some mental gymnastics here.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by jsnell on Thursday May 04, 2023 @02:49AM (#35812072)
The job cuts had nothing to do with keeping the company profitable. In fact, the company was significantly less profitable in Q1 than it could have been due to not yet realizing any savings but additionally having billions in charges from the layoffs.

It's possible that Google becomes a significantly more profitable company as a result of this, but it seems equally plausible that in three months they'll go on another hiring binge. That's what weak leadership like Sundar's gets you: no vision and no consistency.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by nashashmi on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:05AM (#35815520)
He should have given no severances. That would have kept Q1 up. And he should have just kept it within the senior level to start laying off and let them decide. No sudden movements.
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by lenkite on Thursday May 04, 2023 @05:01AM (#35812878)
> In January, PIchai said he took “full responsibility” for conditions that led to the companywide layoffs.

According to his own words - if he is taking "full responsibility" for layoff conditions, he should be fined or docked his pay right ? Or just resign ?

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by nashashmi on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:01AM (#35815460)
If you want to be the arbiter of justice, go ahead and add your judgement.

It's his problem. He will take the consequences. And it's not for everyone to be aware of.

We need to stop acting like schoolchildren where everyone is eager to know how the bad kid gets punished.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by Arainach on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:24AM (#35815836)
If you're responsible for thousands of employees, your performance report should be (with very limited sensitive redactions) open source. You're getting paid millions and everyone deserves to know what "full responsibility" means. This isn't "acting like schoolchildren", it's part of getting people to buy into the system.

I don't buy into your hero worship. Sundar took a crazily profitable company with tens of billions in raw cash and did a messy disorganized layoff where, unlike Alphabet's biggest competitors such as MS, Meta, and even freaking Amazon, Googlers woke up to no access, no chance to transition or hand off, and no chance to say goodbye. It was a disgrace and not something worthy of praise or pay increase.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by nashashmi on Thursday May 04, 2023 @11:01AM (#35816453)
I hate sundar. Took a great company and made it boring. Like I have less hope for the future now because of the one company that inspired me to break the corporate norms, is itself broken.

But I despite hate more. And there is nothing that says hjs penalty needs to be open. Large organizations like democratic govts need openness. Dictatorships need secrecy. And companies are in a category between the two.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by lenkite on Friday May 05, 2023 @03:45AM (#35826410)
> But I despite hate more.

Lol at your hate statement and that he received any penalty. His annual salary massively jumped up to $242 million as Google fired tens of thousands of employees, many with no notice. He has now >800 times the median employee's pay. Anyone would love to take those penalties. You might want to take a small step back and objectively evaluate your shining bias.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by nashashmi on Friday May 05, 2023 @07:52AM (#35828073)
I'm not going to be judgemental of someone's salary. Or that he was given a raise.

Unfortunately ceo salaries are not based on how happy the employees are. Or how justly they have dealt with them. They are just indicators on how happy investors are.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by Arainach on Friday May 05, 2023 @12:10PM (#35831278)
Google stock is down 10% in the last year while MSFT and META are up 10%. How happy are those investors?
Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by SilverBirch on Thursday May 04, 2023 @03:19AM (#35812322)
I completely disagree. The pure fact is that Google throws off more money than anyone knows what to do with. It's smart to return some of that to share holders.

Google needs to be innovative, build new products and invest in them.

But they basically have a massive money hose and that isn't going to make their products better. It's going to bloat projects, bog them down in too many people with too many ideas, delay the need to find product market fit and remove any financial constraints in the development process. It's very hard to run lean when you've got all that cash. Take a look at what went on at Meta. They took the money they could've returned to investors and lit it on fire. They've got a mediocre product, no product market fit, and now they're pivoting.

You're more likely to see a team of 5-6 people somewhere within Google come up with a great idea and get it to market than you are going to see a team of 500-600 people. And even if the 500-600 person team does ship, the economics mean that they need to have one of the most successful product launches in history for it to be economically viable.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by ashinybrowncoat on Thursday May 04, 2023 @08:18AM (#35814147)
"Google needs to be innovative, build new products and invest in them."

What has Google really built? Seems to me they try, fail ,and then buy something when their attempts fail (when something is available to buy). Nest? Android? Google is not innovative and they never really were, nor are they actually capable of building any viable new products.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by 93po on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:29AM (#35814993)
i laughed out loud browsing https://about.google/intl/en_us/products/ as a result of your comment, and the first random one i clicked on (cloud print) has a big banner at the top saying it was discontinued in 2020.

a second laugh when I went to the "migration options" link and it says

"We recommend that you find another way to meet your printing needs."

never change, google

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by 93po on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:27AM (#35814965)
Your comment has me confused. First you say

> Google needs to be innovative, build new products and invest in them.

and then

> Take a look at what went on at Meta. They took the money they could've returned to investors and lit it on fire.

You're criticizing Zuck for doing exactly what you said Google should do. Granted the price tag was huge, but you can't innovate without building and testing something first.

Re:Google employees complain about CEO's pay raise as cost c... by tennisflyi on Thursday May 04, 2023 @01:32PM (#35819144)
> It feels like the board has said, “We don’t care about the company or it’s future, just the price of our stock.”

Again, why is tech (in this day and age) expected to be different than big tobacco or big pharma? It's about money at the end of the day. Period.