News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by ackatz on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:07AM (#35763214)
I’ll take the convenience of using FaceID over the possibility of being in a situation where it’s used against me. I don’t think that people should be generally worried about these scenarios.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by hotpotamus on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:19AM (#35763363)
With TouchID I always like to imagine some drug lord telling his minions that they need to cut off the protagonist's thumb to unlock his phone and get the secrets within. The minions respond, "couldn't we just hold the phone up to his thumb?". And the boss says, "maybe, but I'd rather cut if off anyway".
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by ihatepython on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:15AM (#35763304)
> I’ll take the convenience of using FaceID over the possibility of being in a situation where it’s used against me. I don’t think that people should be generally worried about these scenarios.

Speaking as a cop, I am very happy that there are people like you out there.

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by gregd on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:25AM (#35763433)
Why the hell would you be happy to have some mechanism with which to delete video of police interactions with the public? Oh wait a minute...you're a cop.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by kaba0 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:41AM (#35763610)
Ideally the cop also has a running recording they can’t turn off.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by zimpenfish on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:45AM (#35763662)
Assuming it ever got turned on. Or it's pointing in the right direction. Or it doesn't get "lost" afterwards. Or any of the other ways cops avoid accountability.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by Brian_K_White on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:37PM (#35764201)
Why the hell would you believe a cop actually just said that?

They are probably not actually a cop, but even of they are, they are only making a point to expose the bad advice of the parent comment.

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by hotpotamus on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:22AM (#35763389)
I don't understand, I get that we don't have phonebooks anymore but I'm sure you can always find a sock full of oranges or a blanket with soap in it. Or get creative; they pay you for a reason.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by zmgsabst on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:17AM (#35763329)
Why does it excite you that a presumably innocent person doesn’t believe police are abusive?

I’m struggling to understand the gloating — what exactly do you believe that enables?

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by BirAdam on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:23AM (#35763401)
My interpretation is that police aren’t all abusive to the population, and many are acting as if all cops are. As such, the poster was happy that someone felt most cops weren’t horrible people.

Logically, it cannot be that all police are horrible as there are boat loads of police in the USA, and were all of them horrible, every single person would likely have a tale of abuse at the hands of law enforcement to tell. As that isn’t the case, one can assume most cops are just normal people.

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by willis936 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:31AM (#35763496)
"A few bad apples spoil the bunch."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_apples

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by zmgsabst on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:24AM (#35763414)
Yet, neither the person he replied to nor I took it that way.

Maybe fewer people would mistrust police if they didn’t make posts that sound threatening?

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by edgyquant on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:42AM (#35763612)
That poster is obviously just trolling dude, even bad cops don’t believe they are bad
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by Brian_K_White on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:33PM (#35764159)
I didn't assume they were even really a cop.

They said "speaking as a cop" and then said something that can't be reasonably interpreted any other way than outlandish. Even a real cop who really liked that, would know enough not to admit it in public. That means it doesn't actually matter if they are really a cop or not, either way they were only illuminating a point, not litteral.

Maybe the world would be a better place if everyone didn't jump to the worst possible explanation, and then act as if that were the fact. There is no reason to believe that an actual cop actually just admitted to enjoying the freedom to abuse innocents, but you just ran with that and amplified it anyway. That's really all on you.

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by jjj123 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:43AM (#35763629)
No, I think they were just making a joke. It certainly made me laugh.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by berkle4455 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:47AM (#35763672)
> I don’t think that people should be generally worried about these scenarios

That's an interesting way to say "I'm a middle-to-upper-class white male who though I now live in a tech area and pretend to be progressive, I still hold deeply onto my conservative roots from my hometown and believe that police are always right and good people have nothing to fear!"

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by zen_1 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:09PM (#35763913)
Would someone mind explaining to this Arab immigrant (since I think I need to state my racial and ethnic background to get answers) why it's seen as acceptable to make broad generalizations based on race and sex in this way?

For what it's worth I'm sitting with two of my asian friends, who agreed with the quoted sentiment, so it's definitely not just "middle-to-upper-class white males" who hold these views.

I also know I'd think very little of someone who tried to dismiss a viewpoint of mine with something that amounted to "of course you'd think that, you're Arab*

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by ihatepython on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:28PM (#35764112)
> why it's seen as acceptable to make broad generalizations based on race and sex in this way?

In the current climate, it is acceptable to make broad generalizations about white males, however if the same exact generalizations are made about black people, then they will call you racist (Black Lives Matter), or if you make the same exact generalizations about trans or non-binary people, you will also have problems. I don't think they are anti-Arab anymore, they lost interest in the War on Terror because it wasn't working. Instead, it looks like they are moving to demonize the Russians and the Chinese. Obviously, the climate will change at some point.

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by berkle4455 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:22PM (#35764634)
> Instead, it looks like they are moving to demonize the Russians and the Chinese.

Moving to? You've just described the bipartisan position of the US for the past 20 - 40 years.

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by ihatepython on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:55PM (#35765488)
You ain't seen nothing yet. It still hasn't reached its peak.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by eragmus on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:17PM (#35764589)
That user is a woke racist, basically a self-righteous hypocrite.
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by THENATHE on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:54PM (#35765480)
Buddy I live in a random ass town where basically every cop is considerably meaner than anywhere else I’ve lived (anecdotally), and I go to the big city nearby for work OFTEN, usually in the not so great or industrial neighborhoods. I don’t worry about biometrics because, frankly, I’m my photos app is locked, my text messages are all backed up, all of my storage apps require a pin, and I don’t keep passwords on my phone.

They want me to unlock my phone and give it to them, I do it. I then file a claim with apple care and get a new phone because I pay $10 a month for theft protection.

Use common sense, don’t live your life in fear

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by Brian_K_White on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:19PM (#35764022)
Criminals and bad police just love that everyone thinks that.

From your point of view, the logic goes "the chances are low that I'll ever be in one of those situations"

But for the bad cop, you created the condition that wherever they go, whoever they DO happen to interact with, they always get away with whatever they want.

You should generally be worried about your house burning down even if your house has never burned down.

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by rocket_surgeron on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:50PM (#35766497)
This incident does not seem a common-enough occurrence to change my behavior.

That would be like euthanizing every dog on earth because a person might be killed by one.

~30,000 people are killed by dogs every year.

How many times annually do people have their phones unlocked by police without their consent?

Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by xypage on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:28AM (#35769094)
This analogy doesn't work because you're comparing euthanizing dogs to using a secure password instead of face ID, one of which ends a life and the other is a mild inconvenience (we all used to use pins before touch ID was normalized, it takes less than a second to enter a password that you've got down to muscle memory). Yeah, we can't make all our choices in life based on an off chance, but when it's this simple it's easily worthwhile
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by taylodl on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:30AM (#35773267)
You are assuming evidence obtained from the phone in this manner would be permissible in court. I don't know that this has ever been tried in court. Do you?
Re:Runa Sandvik: “Example of why you should not use FaceID t... by Brian_K_White on Monday May 01, 2023 @08:27PM (#35781399)
I am not assuming anything, and no such assumption is necessary.