On a broader level, could we all just define our acronyms the first time we use them in a thread? Acronyms save very little time, and add a lot of confusion.
edit: I thought about this more, and am now guessing you mean 'private management consultants"; is this correct?
Looks like the NIH is a similar story of corruption.
That is 0.0001% of all the wasted money in COVID spending....
- President Ronald Reagan[1], 1986
Sometimes it is appropriate to invest vast sums of public funds into unproven technologies and ideas. The pandemic seems to be a textbook example of where we can reasonably expect our federal government to act swiftly and decisively, for the greater good.
That does not mean we should simply shrug our shoulders when, in hindsight, it becomes obvious a lot of misfeasance occurred during this unprecedented time. Billions of dollars were thrown around everywhere with very little oversight. It may be decades before we fully understand where all the money went, and most would likely be shocked to discover pandemic-fighting funds were used to prop up pet projects and ideological programs instead. Funds pitched to the public as destined to fight the pandemic were instead used for anything but - and collectively, red or blue, we are all suffering the consequences of those poor, often obfuscated decisions.
We should scrutinize the relationships these farma companies had with the federal government before, during and after the pandemic. They mostly received a blank check for the government to "solve" the pandemic, and it's debatable if that is what really unfolded.
[1] https://www.reaganlibrary.gov/archives/speech/presidents-new...
I, for one would, not be shocked.
On the other hand, I would be shocked if we grew a collective spine and did something about it.
The whole world can thank the Trump administration and Operation Warp Speed [0].
It provided billions of dollars and firm orders for any manufacturer who could get it's vaccine candidate on the market. All paid for by the American tax payer, of course. To fight a disease that most likely originated in a Chinese lab.
Without it it would have been months of additional delay for R&D and production (see the vaccines not selected for Warp Speed or the CanSino program in Canada[1])
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Warp_Speed
[1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/cansino-deal-canada-nrc-fifth...
…like paying for all the vaccines ahead of time, without any guarantee they worked, and the decades of government-sponsored research that made them possible in the first place? The drug companies were not in anyway “heroes,” but net beneficiaries of the enclosure of public research, which, combined with decades of bribing politicians to prevent state manufacturing capacity and enforce bogus IP restrictions, has resulted in wildly inequitable global vaccine access and countless, unnecessary deaths across the world.
https://www.cbc.ca/radio/quirks/jun-12-missions-to-venus-lea...
Some studies really do take longer than 2 years and wait to publish data. As much as people complain about CEO’s focusing on the next quarter’s profits they still seem to want quick results.
That said, most of the money was probably wasted.
Although, that said, I do want to stand up for the anti-government argument here. The NIH isn't going to be as effective as a private market at identifying who is effective. Everyone is affected by COVID, it isn't like they need to force people with money to take an interest in what is happening here. Ironically, although the NIH is effectively throwing people at a problem here to play the odds, we'd probably find that a private organisation is much better at it by similar logic. I'd keep an eye on the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation myself, Gates seemed to be quite busy through COVID. Similar efforts by other wealthy people are also likely to be happening.
[0] Vulcanization is a fun example. Both in fore- and hind- sight the experiment didn't work. Dude just happened to be clumsy.
I'm all for being deliberate and getting things right, but if your procedures are so elaborate that you're not getting anything done, maybe they're flawed.
Most research doesn't result in incremental progress as you pointed out, yet pharma companies still spend a TON of research. They live and breathe by getting to the next "big" drug to make them money and make up for all the failures.
Basically, while the Gates foundation isn't the example I was thinking of, the dangling of a big payoff from the government did spur a LOT of research for COVID (see vaccine and treatment methods for COVID). Private enterprises took some breakthrough concepts (mRNA vaccines) and did a ton of ground work to test and make them viable for humans.
I do strongly agree with your last point, public funded research should be directed at areas with no scalable return since private venture won't go into those areas (but having wealthy non-profits like the Gates foundation working on this is nice!)
The key point here is "return" - in the private markets, it's just a numbers game. Most successful, important scientific research is not going to make a big return. Perhaps it'll lead to money for someone else down the line, but that's besides the point. Private markets are a bad fit for huge swathes of research where success != $$$. Which leaves a couple of areas, e.g. drug development...
> pharma companies still spend a TON of research. They live and breathe by getting to the next "big" drug to make them money and make up for all the failures.
While correct, it's important to remember that pharmaceutical company research spending is highly weighted towards drugs with a large number of patients or where demand is relatively insensitive to price. COVID vaccines are a perfect example because they fit both categories. This usually works out OK, but it isn't a good fit for a poorly-understood condition like long COVID where the size of the target market and the price sensitivity of the customers is very difficult to estimate. You also end up with other undesirable outcomes like the systematic underfunding of research into conditions that predominantly affect minoritized or less well-off communities. Pharmaceutical companies also rely on a huge body of publicly-funded basic research.
It was notable how in the early days of COVID the ... was it the NIH? One of the TLA agencies ... centralised COVID testing under their banner, disrupted the private sector response and shipped out broken testing kits. The private market would have been all over the problem like flies on a grubby sheep. They're much faster at getting research done on health stuff, the financial incentives are absurd. People will pay literally anything for health.
Also a lot of the foundational research of modern society was done based on whatever rich people thought was interesting at the time. That is how a lot of the math was turned up. It is a perfectly fine strategy.
> Markets will instead allocate funding to the least-adventurous surest bets.
So the NIH is doing what, ignoring sure bets at curing long COVID? That shouldn't be encouraged.
Besides, you are wrong. Ever hear of something called the "Metaverse"? Companies regularly make big risky gambits that don't pay off.
Decades of publicly funded research, then private companies are "spun out" of publicly funded research institutions and then the private companies are given yet more public money as grants.
The disgrace is that the profits are privatised when the novel research is not.
Estimated cost, $1 billion. The only thing slowing them down is legislation - they want to make money by resolving people's medical issues with novel techniques.
Solving Long COVID: NIH $1 billion. Nothing. Probably the biggest problem here is that groups like Pfizer are being banned from doing research by an NIH ethics committee that says trading 1 life to save 1,000 is an unacceptable trade.
Now I'm not against the NIH spending $1 billion on research. Better than feeding it into the military-industrial complex for example. But the evidence here is if you want a research team to fix a known problem, the people who know how work at Pfizer not the NIH. Now Pfizer probably can't do that trick of getting results on demand, but there'll be some company that can - assuming it is possible. There are a lot of companies so there are lots of attempts being made.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pfizer-BioNTech_COVID-19_vacci...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BioNTech tells me BioNTech was founded in 2008 based on research by Uğur Şahin, Özlem Türeci, and Christoph Huber, with a seed investment of €150 million from MIG Capital and AT Impf.
I don't know much about Germany I must admit. Is AT Impf some sort of government body? Because this looks a lot like private actors spotting a good thing well in advance.
I'm sure they took government money at some point because the government is handing out money and why not. It'd be silly to turn it down. But there are obviously millions of dollars here to develop influenza vaccines and we see the payoff was billions of dollars. The Free market could do this with no intervention - the payoffs look pretty good.
> In September 2019, BioNTech received a capital contribution of US$55 million from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, with the option of doubling that investment amount at a later date.
Heh, there they are.
-- 2
> ...US taxpayers would purchase 100 million doses...
Yeah but the 100 million doses purchase would have encouraged them to build infrastructure, which we already know the private sector is better at than the public sector at. Operation Warp speed wouldn't have hurt, but again they technically had the vaccine developed before Operation Warp Speed was a thing.
The only thing stopping people buying the vaccine in mid-2020 was that the government had made it illegal.
Wait until you find out about the DOD.
At least the NIH salaries aren't going to warmongers & building weapons.
It exists.
Sounds like NIH got hijacked by a bunch of people who believed otherwise and required proof of pathobiology first.
Like, why? Can you share any more information? Some reasons on why you're convinced of that statement? Or do you consider yourself so important that you expect your opinions to be taken as real arguments, as facts, as something self-evident?
What I don't believe is that this kind of syndrome is specific to Covid, I suspect it holds for every serious virus you get infected with. The only difference this time is that the medical community is watching.
The fact that Epstein-Barr is causative with MS and HPV is causative with cervical cancer shows that the damage that even fairly mild virii do persists for a very long time.
Any claim that a virus doesn't cause persistent damage simply means you haven't looked very hard.
Of the dozens of people in my extended family that are 50+yo, few of whom were covid cautions, zero of them have reported symptoms resembling long covid. My parents are elderly as are all of the people they know. Zero of their friends have reported long covid, but they did know a couple of folks that died of it.
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/long-term-effects/...
(Actually considering I've known about post-viral ME/CFS since sometime in the early-90s that makes it going on nearly 30 years of knowing about it. And I'm deeply uninterested in wasting my life debating about it with internet strangers.)
press X for doubt
My experience is heavily biased towards people at risk for long covid. I live in TX surrounded by people who weren't too serious about covid. I have friends that got covid 3-4 times. I know people with actual measurable lung damage that have long term consequences in that sense, but I know _zero_ people with anything resembling "long covid". No one I know knows anyone who has long covid. I believe it exists because a wide range of other viruses have occasional mysterious long term effects, but what I don't believe is that it's possible for it to be anywhere close to as common as it's purported to be(figures like 10-30% of those infected were thrown around by news outlets back when I was paying attention). My personal bet is that the majority of peoples' symptoms are psychogenic with a small minority experiencing physiological effects worth studying.
You state that you don't know anyone who has long COVID one way or the other and then state that it must all be "psychogenic".
If it were that common to have fake long COVID you'd think you would know someone who was faking it.
Instead you have no experience with it and you're making sweeping pronouncements about it.
Yes, the studies finding 10-30% rates of long COVID were flawed, but they were usually of people who were hospitalized and they may have included the people you know who actually had lung damage.
And 3 million people can have long COVID and you might not know one of them since that is an incidence of 1-in-100 and even if someone you knew had it, it might not be so totally disabling that they couldn't keep up appearances and hide it from you.
It’s not that NIH didn’t find a cause of “long COVID”…it’s not that they didn’t find any treatments for long COVID if such a thing truly exists…the NIH just did a whole lot of nothing.
The National Institutes of Health hasn’t signed up a single patient to test any potential treatments — despite a clear mandate from Congress to study them. And the few trials it is planning have already drawn a firestorm of criticism, especially one intervention that experts and advocates say may actually make some patients’ long Covid symptoms worse.
Instead, the NIH spent the majority of its money on broader, observational research that won’t directly bring relief to patients. But it still hasn’t published any findings from the patients who joined that study, almost two years after it started.
A really spectacularly expensive whole lot of nothing.