News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by thejackgoode on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:04AM (#35639310)
Can someone share any relevant experience with this? Best would be if you did it properly under supervision of clinical professional, or if you are a professional here, by any chance. Doesn’t matter if it’s US or not.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by specproc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:41AM (#35639748)
Only recreational. I've taken MDMA many times in my life and -- presumably like most people who have -- can see why it's got therapeutic potential.

Honestly though, I'm not convinced about it in a clinical setting, unless there's a particularly severe issue that needs addressing.

I reckon most people are best off just buying some, getting together with a couple of very good mates on a nice day, rolling out into the country with some very good speakers, and just working it all out by yourselves. Sure-fire cure for what ails ya.

On a sensible note: don't drink alcohol with it, titrate your dose up to ~150mg, if possible get it from a Tor-enabled marketplace so you can be relatively confident in quality.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by eimrine on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:02AM (#35641192)
What a strange idea is to recommend a dose with respect to neither a weight nor a desired effect
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by specproc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:11AM (#35641343)
OK, fair point. In my head it was a fairly big tilde.

I don't think it's a terrible start, but yes, of course, YMMV and one should never go doing such things without a bit of reading about.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by eimrine on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:22AM (#35641514)
If you are starting from very very low and if you are consuming the crystal then you dont need to read anything more. You can try 5mg in the morning and I promise any newbie will understand it fully before evening.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by bnjms on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:41AM (#35641791)
I disagree about a clinical setting, though I think I mostly agree overall.

Mainly I fear people will read this and mistake it for a defense of MDMA as a drug for going out with your mates. I think this can be helpful for some and very helpful for others but not as helpful as a clinical setting. Where a clinical setting is a therapists office and not a cold clinic room.

The problem is many don’t have a couple good mates or don’t know how to talk things through. Better if people go into it with a vague but not definite agenda like a therapist would have.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by specproc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:17PM (#35642301)
It was a flippant but sincere defence of MDMA as a drug for hanging out with your mates.

Naturally, not applicable in all cases, but I guess my point is you can get a lot of benefit in that context.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by vorpalhex on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:22PM (#35642378)
> getting together with a couple of very good mates

I suspect the clinically depressed/ptsd impacted folks don't have "a couple good mates" who are appropriate trip sitters.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by OkayPhysicist on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:31PM (#35644186)
I do see the logic in its clinical application: It's the combination of two facts:

1) Human recall is imperfect. The act of remembering an event actively modifies the memory for future recall, which can be tinted by other thoughts and experiences someone is having while doing the recollection.

2) It's rather difficult to feel strong negative emotion while on MDMA. While under the effects, the baseline is somewhere between "happy" and "downright euphoric".

Combine those two ideas, and you have a pretty compelling groundwork for how MDMA would help those with traumatic memories, particularly PTSD. Dose them with feel-good drugs, have them recall and talk through their traumatic memories without the usual, extreme negative emotional response, and the new memories are less associated with extreme negative emotion. Rinse, repeat, until someone can remember a traumatic experience without setting off an extreme stress response.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by rexpop on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:23PM (#35644924)
> It's rather difficult to feel strong negative emotion while on MDMA. While under the effects, the baseline is somewhere between "happy" and "downright euphoric".

I am floored by this assertion, as it's completely contrary to my experience. My reaction to MDMA was a nightmare of disorientation, fear, and anxiety. I don't remember the dosage, but the setting was my own home, among friends and acquaintances at my own birthday party.

I don't know if my strongly negative memories of this event constitute "trauma," but they are certainly neither warm nor fuzzy.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by musictubes on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:43PM (#35645229)
Did you have it tested? If you look at Erowid’s test reports, so many things that are labeled “Ecstasy” are not wholly or even partly MDMA. Lots of samples are mostly either MDA, meth, other stimulants, a combination of those or other non related chemicals.

Actual, pure MDMA can only ever make you feel good.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by pcthrowaway on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:43PM (#35645219)
> It's rather difficult to feel strong negative emotion while on MDMA.

This is patently incorrect.

My experience is that MDMA makes one feel emotions much more intensely, with a bias towards positive emotions.

I've personally felt a number of negative emotions on MDMA as well, primarily loneliness when I've taken it alone, or ended up alone after taking it. This makes sense because it makes one strongly desire physical intimacy and physical touch of various kinds (hugs, shoulder rubs, compliments, deep expressions of love, etc)

Even the negative emotions I've experienced on it have however generally occurred at the same time of very positive physical sensations, and a strong sense of connection with myself.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by projectazorian on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:33PM (#35645069)
I agree and wouldn't want to have it in an antiseptic clinical environment either, but not everyone has access to good mates and a sound system, and they should be able to benefit as well. So I'm fine with clinical treatments being available.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by 52-6F-62 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:16AM (#35639468)
My partners mother was depressed and shut in for years. She had been through every process, medical and otherwise, to try and find an escape hatch, window, anything.

She eventually was accepted into a limited program in Victoria, BC for ketamine treatments. 3 large doses rendering intense trips that lasted the course of hours in a clinic under the supervision of doctors and therapists. After the first session she was fundamentally changed. After the third she looked back wondering how she ever could have felt so low.

It’s not a silver bullet, she required some therapeutic work afterward and may do another session in the future. But it still stands that the person she is today (travelling, seeing friends, seeing family, etc) is radically different and restored compared to just a few years ago. She full heartedly credits those sessions, but also doesn’t feel a strong need to return-just to get on with life while she’s still in possession of her functioning body.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by toomanyrichies on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:36AM (#35639687)
What a great outcome. Glad to hear this and thanks for posting.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by 52-6F-62 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:54AM (#35639948)
Happy to share.

I’ve come to think it’s very important that we re-integrate these plants/practices/visions/what have you into society and we stand to benefit from a deeper level down than just salving creature comforts. Some people never forgot that matter and I’m sure are relieved to see some more “rational” people like myself coming around!

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by coffeebeqn on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:30PM (#35647951)
It’s certainly not a silver bullet but as these psychedelic drugs are low harm and quite potent/novel they’re extremely worth exploring
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by hospitalJail on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:14AM (#35639426)
Back in 2018 had just gotten a surprise extra TV from my friend for Christmas. Now we had a 48in tv and a 42in tv. I wasnt sure what to do with it, I wanted 2 TVs for my 2 monitor setup(PC + Wireless mouse and keyboard). My wife cared about appearance more than anything. This was quite contentious.

We happened to take MDMA for the first time(at home) and we talked about the TV situation. We figured out a way to have both of them in the living room and make it look good.

We were so impressed that we ended up designing our backyard landscaping after that.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by atommclain on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:40AM (#35639733)
That you for sharing, it’s a very sweet story and heartwarming to hear how the two of you were able to come up with a solution where both people were satisfied.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by specproc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:44AM (#35639795)
I think we just don't take enough time to talk properly and you know, get to understand how the other person is feeling. Communication is so important in a relationship.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:24AM (#35639556)
You didn't use it in a medicinal context though. You used it recreationally and thought about a problem then arrived at a solution. There's only x ways you could have fit the TVs in, and I'm sure most people could have figured it out without taking anything, it's hardly a difficult task.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by jonfw on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:35AM (#35639678)
I think that designing the TV layout is not the point, the point is opening yourself to new ideas and empathy, facilitating compromise
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:40AM (#35639727)
This handwaves the problem that two adults cannot reach a compromise without taking a drug. That's a personal problem not being solved, but actually being masked and brushed under the metaphorical rug. Perhaps what they need is relationship counselling?

If you anesthetize me, I will protest less when you do something that would otherwise cause me pain, but you haven't taken away my ability to feel pain in the long-term.

If you get me high, I'll be less anxious in the short-term, but the root cause of my anxiety hasn't been solved.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by Xymist on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:07PM (#35642172)
I disagree with the "masked" framing. _Actually talking to each other_ is fairly difficult for a lot of people and even a lot of relatively happy couples. Managing to do that in a productive fashion may take a very good night's sleep, or a lot of coffee, or a few beers, or some MDMA, or post-coital neurochemical rush, or whatever else. As long as it happens, you've had the conversation. If it went well and you got somewhere and did a thing or mutually understand a problem or whatever, it was a success.

Tools are tools. My inability to ram a nail into a wall with my thumb isn't being "masked" by my use of a hammer, and while I might get better at it with practice and better thumb technique that wouldn't be a more valid solution.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by MAGZine on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:24PM (#35642400)
This seems like a bad take. Are you going to tell me ibuprofen is worthless because it doesn't fix the underlying issue?

No, it's a tool. Nobody is saying you should take casual MDMA to discuss every day solutions. But it does highlight the power of allowing people to express things that they might otherwise have difficulty expressing.

And maybe you learn something about your partner in the process.

This is why it's a powerful therapeutic tool. People with PTSD can talk through their most troubled experiences and lift that weight from their shoulders. Something they may be incapable of doing in a sober context.

In that sense, it's not just "anesthetizing" as you so lovingly put it, there is therapeutic value beyond a a momentary high.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by sowbug on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:40PM (#35642624)
An eye-opening experience can still be had while wearing glasses.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by HybridCurve on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:28PM (#35644133)
MDMA was originally named 'Empathy' for a reason. Establishing an empathetic bridge with a spouse or significant other can have lasting effects which can clear a log jam of grievances. And as with all psychoactive medication, therapy is often part of the treatment.

Obviously, self medicating to perpetuate avoidant or maladaptive behavior is generally considered drug abuse and never recommended.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:25PM (#35645793)
it has been the state of humans throughout history that we could not all universally reach a compromise without taking a drug, which makes sense given that we haven't had a lot of time to evolve since then
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by eimrine on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:33AM (#35639657)
how to use mdma in medical way? does it requires obeying to some owner of some kind of medical license?
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:37AM (#35639695)
Medicinally, ergo, if someone has depression, they can use it to overcome it (apparently). Recreationally means that you don't have a medical issue that you are trying to solve and are taking it just to take it.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by eimrine on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:55AM (#35639954)
Thank you for definition. The thing is that I might have a depression and an understanding of what to do with mdma but a lack of trust to every psych* specialist because they are educated by govt who just wants some obey from everybody.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:59AM (#35640036)
I've also struggled with depression. If you're certain there's no rationality behind it (self-esteem, family ill, money problems, war, health etc), it might be worth considering medication of some description, but most depressive episodes can be solved without any kind of medication. Most medications simply mask the problem and don't deal with the root cause.

That's not to say that medications can't be useful in tackling the root cause, they can be, but not uncommonly, the negative side effects outweigh the benefits of taking them versus just resolving the problems in your life. CBT (Cognitive Behavioural Therapy) can be very effective for a lot of problems.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:02PM (#35646285)
it's worth noting that MDMA generally doesn't seem to be one of those drugs that "masks the problem", and can be quite useful in "dealing with the root cause"
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by eimrine on Friday April 21, 2023 @09:04AM (#35653103)
Dealing with the root cause seems more about lsd/dmt. Masks the problem temporarily is about alcohol. Mdma is about mask the problem long term.

But the problem I am having in mind is not war-related PTSR. I don't imagine how to heal from problem when you are a massacre survivor. Especially if you were mobilized against your will.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday April 21, 2023 @09:19AM (#35653313)
MDMA doesn't seem to be one of those that masks the problem, short term or long term, but rather one that helps deal with the root cause: when you're not afraid to discuss a subject due to the pain it causes, you can discuss it
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by eimrine on Friday April 21, 2023 @10:28AM (#35654284)
How it can be possible when a patient wants to talk about traumatic experiense to a specialist, for the sake of getting rid of PTSR, but he afraids to talk about it because of... what may happen?

What kind of pain may block even talking about it? I have built an idea while reading those PTSR-witnessers that mobilization for males is an analog of rape for females and the pain is not from killing and seeing kills but from being enslaved. I have a lot of friends who use to kill Russians in Russo-Ukrainian war, or use to be a medic, and everybody is totally happy to discuss at least some analytical problems (equipment, strategy, caveats, how to avoid being killed in combat, etc). I am just trying not to be jerk and listen more than talk to them and those people even do not claim they heavily suffer from anything like PTSR.

What kind of questions were asked to patients and participants of what military group were the patients? If my theory is wrong, then the questions is always about killing and seeing massacre. I really want to know criterions of being chosen to mdma-assisted therapy instead of other antidepressant.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:26PM (#35656135)
in the context of MDMA assisted psychotherapy, people objectively use it to discuss painful topics and memories to deal with root causes

I'm not sure how to answer some of the psychology specific details, and so apologize, but given that MDMA does indeed seem to be one of those drugs that helps people deal with the root causes of their issues, I'm sure the info is out there for someone determined to learn it

I wish you luck with your business idea

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by s1artibartfast on Friday April 21, 2023 @11:28AM (#35655205)
People obviously have different types of problems, and here I divide them into issues with how you relate to yourself or how you relate to others.

I think that the appropriate substance depends on the nature of the problem. If the nature of the problem is a lack of empathy and interpersonal connection, I think MDMA could be a good fit. It can provide biological and experiential practice in dropping the barriers people put up between themselves and others.

Mushrooms, LSD, and hallucinogen seem better suited for addressing motivation and control issues as well as cognitive dissonance within an individual.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by musictubes on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:39PM (#35645164)
If MDMA is approved as a treatment drug it will undoubtedly by a schedule 2 drug only administered at a doctor’s office. The key idea is MDMA assisted therapy.

MDMA is used as therapeutic grease. People with PTSD frequently can’t talk about or otherwise process what happened to them without reliving the event(s) and re-traumatizing them. MDMA tamps down the fear response and makes them more open to communication. It frequently makes people want to connect to someone else which also helps with therapy. MDMA isn’t what relives the PTSD, it is the therapy.

If I recall the MAPS study, patients were given 2-3 doses of MDMA over 8 months of therapy.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by AnthonBerg on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:00AM (#35641140)
The production of a judgement according to criteria defining medicinal is not required for the substance to benefit people. This is a case where a meaningful emotional bond was built on top of a situation which would have been a lingering conflict—or so it seems—and this bond remains and has lasting benefits to the couple involved.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by Glench on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:18AM (#35639487)
My friend has been one of the clinicians on the MAPS trials in Boston. He says it's abundantly clear that people are able to have powerful internal experiences of emotional opening, fear-reduction, release of bodily tension, and self-compassion and new understanding. And amazingly he says that these experiences are somewhat durable — people end up making all sorts of positive changes in their lives after these sessions (like giving up substances of abuse or feeling able to go off medication). And all of this has been backed up by the data. Any specifics you're looking for?
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by thejackgoode on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:37AM (#35639697)
That’s impressive. I was interested in first hand experience with PTSD and persistent depression treatment, but I am happy with any sort of “subjective but clinical” information about this.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by meepmorp on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:52AM (#35639929)
Not MDMA, but LSD. For me, it was unreasonably effective, though some of that might be my quirks. I preferred to use it alone, would frequently do housework while on it, and talked out my problems with myself. It was easier to be kind to myself, and to treat my emotions and thoughts with a degree of distance which was incredibly helpful.

FWIW, I haven't hade the same effect from other psychedelics.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by fallingknife on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:09AM (#35640194)
Have done it recreationally, and I can't imagine doing molly "under the supervision of a clinical professional." Seems like it would be absolutely awful. Don't recommend. I mean I really hope this helps a lot of people, but it's a hard pass from me. Would definitely recommend getting your hands on some and trying it with friends, though.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by musictubes on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:49PM (#35645313)
Therapeutic and recreational doses are very different. As are the goals. Rolling at a festival is very different than trying to open up to a therapist about past trauma.

Therapeutic doses aren’t designed to be fun, they are there to stop you from being afraid and willing to talk to someone. In addition, the subjects are only occasionally using MDMA in context of extended therapy. It’s not like they give you molly and see how you feel afterwards. MDMA is a tool for making therapy better or even possible for people with entrenched issues that couldn’t be solved with conventional treatments.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by game_the0ry on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:29AM (#35640559)
Here are 2 accounts:

Tucker Max wrote at length about mdma therapy. [1]

Vice News had a piece on mdma therapy and ptsd. [2]

[1] https://www.tuckermax.com/what-mdma-therapy-did-for-me/

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAvUDRYg4h4

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by yboris on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:44AM (#35640868)
Highly recommend MDMA as a personal experience. I did not have PTSD or trauma to work through, but I realized how much I could love other people. It's an experience worth having at least once in your life.
Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by cflewis on Thursday April 20, 2023 @01:03PM (#35642943)
Ketamine was huge for me. I have major depression and generalized anxiety disorder. I've been on medicine that I would consider very good for me for four or five years but I wasn't getting to where I wanted to be.

By the time I took Ketamine in a clinical setting (legalized in California), I was spending 80% of my time fighting negative narratives inside my head. "I want to die" (not really, but my engineering brain had decided this was eventually a solution to every problem... Louis CK has a bit that is basically identical to the way my brain was thinking)... "this person hates me so I should hate them"... "all I ever do is fail". I only had 20% of my brain left for interacting with others. I was not a nice person to be around for any period of time. I would be withdrawn a lot because I was in my head.

My therapist asked me once "what would it feel like to wake up and not immediately feel defeated?" and I legitimately had no idea.

After a series of ketamine treatments the narratives calmed down immensely. 80%->10% to some periods in a day of 0%.

I truly despise the actual act of taking ketamine. If you're doing lozenges it tastes like shit, I always felt very nauseous after the trip. I found the trips weird and not therapeutic. Like weird patterns, sometimes seeing things gloopy, sometimes odd experiences that sound fun but just felt strange and disconcerting like flying through hyperspace with Gandalf. But the long-term results have been life-changing.

I would recommend ketamine to anyone who has gone for 2+ years or 2+ psychiatrists and haven't seen the results they had hoped for.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by cascades42 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @01:43PM (#35643499)
My mother-in-law did MDMA and psychedelic mushroom therapy (on separate occasions) with an experienced guide.

This occurred prior to the official training that's occurring now but after the decriminalization of drugs in Oregon. The guide was not a licensed clinician, but she had guided 100s of clients.

My mother-in-law found it incredibly helpful in processing traumas from childhood and in getting "unstuck" in thinking patterns. She described the experience as a seismic shift.

She had been in therapy for her entire life. I suspect that her prior therapy had laid the groundwork for understanding the thinking patterns that weren't serving her.

My wife and I have noticed a subtle personality change. She seems happier and more open to new ideas. This personality change seems to have faded slightly with time. These are of course just our observations, which could be completely off.

Psilocybin mushrooms grow everywhere here in the Pacific Northwest-- I see them all of the time in mulch around our city. I've had many friends take them recreationally, and none of these friends have had such an impactful experience. All of this is anecdotal of course, but it leads me to believe that working with a therapist might be essential for efficacy of the therapy.

I'm a neuroscience researcher, and I'm hopeful that these treatments will be helpful for many people. It is tragic that there haven't been more clinical trials. I'm hesitant to try them myself until there's more data. If I was suffering from intractable depression or anxiety, I'd feel differently.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by coffeebeqn on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:35PM (#35648001)
If you just take them yourself it’s kind of dumb luck if it’ll be helpful. I found a large dose powerful but also kind of random and confusing. I enjoyed my time and still think about it sometimes but it didn’t cure my mental issues. I think with a professional therapist it would be a lot more efficient and directed. Less time spent on trying to figure out if I’m in the correct universe or if time is still a thing or how human food works.

With MDMA I certainly had lovely time talking with friends but again without a therapeutic goal it was just a good time.

Re:US could soon approve MDMA therapy – opening an era of ps... by zealtrace on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:13AM (#35649753)
I’ve undergone this to treat chronic PTSD with a therapist that specializes in it. This was done privately, but I spoke at length with a MAPS certified clinician. My understanding from him is that my months long treatment process was largely the same as what’s done in the trials.

MDMA is very powerful medicine, and likely helped save my life. I have every reason to believe the improvements will be long lasting. However, it’s really important to emphasize what’s being described in these studies is trauma informed psychotherapy first and foremost.

Unfortunately, trauma is a niche and demanding speciality. Given the limited number of experienced therapists, I’m skeptical if this treatment will scale as safely and effectively as shown in the published results. These are very early days and much more education is needed for both therapists and the general public.

Even so, it would be incredible to have another tool available for what can be a disabling condition.