News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by Animats on Thursday April 13, 2023 @05:39PM (#35562446)
That's been commercially available for over five years now.[1] Robots doing that are already widely deployed. If you take the tour of the SF recycling center, you can see some of them.[2]

This works at scale. Here's a 90 ton per hour recycling facility.[3]

This is the difference between feel-good recycling and industrial scale recycling.

[1] https://www.max-ai.com/

[2] https://www.max-ai.com/video-max-ai-autonomous-qc/

[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FpsH_ETT7c

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by dan-robertson on Thursday April 13, 2023 @06:46PM (#35563192)
I think there’s some university-publicity-office dynamics here where the OP ends up making silly claims about real world applications. I think the article is much more ‘here is research we did in controlling a robotic arm with neural networks, in real-time, in the real world’ than ‘we think this is the best way to sort waste’.

I think this is like you read some university press release about some research into a weird graph theory algorithm and explained that social networks have been available for decades and their approach isn’t relevant there.

The waste sorting systems are interesting.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by Animats on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:39PM (#35563677)
Yes, that's a huge problem with university publicity offices. I've made the comment on some battery announcements that it's either Nobel Prize material or total bullshit.

The big insight seems to be that you need some robots, but most of the job can be done by simple machines that use gravity, air jets, screens, and magnets. The robots just pull out stuff that wasn't properly sorted by brute-force means. The robotics enthusiasts wanted to do everything with robots, which is not cost effective, and the heavy-machinery people tried to adapt techniques from ore mining to recycling. It turns out that a combination of those approaches, plus the air-jet optical sorter technology used for fruit and vegetable sorting, can do the whole job in a cost-effective way.

This is what production engineering is all about.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by mgraczyk on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:47PM (#35563728)
This is a completely different piece of technology, solving a different (but related) problem for different people in a different environment.

Those industrial robots don't drive around an office building with people around. They can't be repurposed to solve other problems. These Google robots have already been doing other tasks around the MTV campus (for demonstration and research purposes, not yet practically useful).

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by Alupis on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:14PM (#35563946)
Until the day we stop requiring humans to pre-sort garbage, we cannot actually get serious about recycling.

And no, little robots driving around google's campus is not going to change the world - it's a fun novelty.

We need more of the sorting machines linked above. Everything into a single bin, and let the processing plant determine what best to do with it. Not everything that goes into a recycle bin actually gets recycled, etc. Let the pros handle it.

Recycling/Composting needs to be 100% transparent to your average person for it to actually work.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:38PM (#35564128)
I think this is taking things too far.

A system where humans split garbage from recycling, and then potential split recycling into e.g. corrugated cardboard, glass and everything else can work just fine.

How do I know this? It's the system we have where I live, and as far as I can tell, it works better than most others.

Contamination remains an issue, but that's likely to be even more true if humans do no separation at all.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by Alupis on Thursday April 13, 2023 @09:00PM (#35564296)
> A system where humans split garbage from recycling, and then potential split recycling into e.g. corrugated cardboard, glass and everything else can work just fine.

If it's done perfectly every single time - sure. But these are humans we're discussing...

It's silly to even have to think about if something can be recycled or not. Gotta look for that recycle number on the package first - ah, this seemingly regular plastic bottle cannot be recycled after all! Pizza box with a small amount of oil stain? Nope, can't recycle that either.

Sorting machines are clearly the only reliable way to manage waste. Everything else is a distraction meant to make you feel good about doing your part, even though the reality is you probably did some of it wrong and half of the stuff won't be recycled anyway.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday April 13, 2023 @11:23PM (#35565174)
You really do not want to mix garbage and (potential) recycling.

Fine, throw anything remotely potentially recyclable together (and have it post-sorted), but not cooking fat, diapers, dog shit, and more.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by traverseda on Friday April 14, 2023 @12:05PM (#35571097)
So dry and wet garbage?
Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by TylerE on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:17PM (#35573537)
The problem is 90% of proper will think that a grease stained pizza box is dry.
Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by ryandrake on Friday April 14, 2023 @12:18AM (#35565463)
I agree. Any system that requires cooperative, collective action from un-incentivized humans is doomed. All you need are a significant number of uncooperative and/or antagonistic people, and the system will fail. A lot of people are just apathetic and will toss their junk into whatever bin is closest, regardless of what's supposed to be in it. Also, there are a fair number of people who will go out of their way to put things in the wrong bin. I knew someone who proudly admitted he would dump old rotten eggs, motor oil, and poo into his recycling bin because "Recycling is authoritarian government overreach by the liberals." You just can't have nice things, because of people.

Look at how every country's COVID strategy depended on cooperative, altruistic, collective action from ordinary people. This strategy failed everywhere it was tried.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by Alupis on Friday April 14, 2023 @04:06AM (#35566798)
Majority of the stuff you place in the recycling bin cannot be recycled, or will not be recycled - despite good intentions and attitude.

Humans are fallible, and make mistakes. Humans also have more important things to worry about than what can or cannot be recycled (the reality shocks most people).

It must be automated if it is important enough to do at all. It has nothing to do with cooperation, altruism, collective action or whatever.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by antisthenes on Friday April 14, 2023 @10:02AM (#35569678)
Most recycling facilities already sort everything with better success than 99% of humans can.

And also like you said, most things are not commercially viable to recycle, so a lot of things people put in blue bins ends up in landfills anyway.

Humans should only be used for a very rough split of garbage - e.g. separate yard waste from other trash, and that's it.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by mgraczyk on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:19PM (#35563996)
Sure, but my point is that this research isn't about solving the recycling problem. It's about demonstrating a reinforcement learning solution to a difficult task in a difficult real world "everyday" environment.
Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by mdaniel on Friday April 14, 2023 @12:05PM (#35571099)
> Until the day we stop requiring humans to pre-sort garbage, we cannot actually get serious about recycling.

I wonder if if would be more economical to have robots to pre-sort locally, before it enters the stream? Because if I had a big bucket o' refuse that a local robot would then check the /5\ codes or whatever and sort locally, it would have up to 6 days to do that and thus wouldn't have any hard realtime requirements

Failure scenarios are always present, as is keeping the poor thing clean, but it could still end up being more economical IF the streams really are a source of value, and not -- as I am increasingly starting to believe -- just a sham by the plastics industry to make one think recycling exists

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by karulont on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:47PM (#35563733)
Another existing offer: https://www.terex.com/zenrobotics

At one point they were handing out T-shirts saying 9 out of 10 PHDs

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by choppaface on Thursday April 13, 2023 @07:47PM (#35563736)
But this GoogleAI demo is about having a robotic janitor for your office. It’s also about recruiting and showing how much capital gets invested in R&D. Just one of these robots could have paid to restore the household of the guy who flipped his life to accept Google’s non-job[1].

Really, the point of this demo is not to suggest Google could make a product. It’s to suggest if you keep applying to Google and get accepted on you 3rd / last try, then you will be invited to work on chat app infrastructure for 2 years while other dudes at the company are doing this depicted robot thing and you get to watch. Then after 2 years you might be invited to transfer to their team to clean up their chat app back-end. It’s all about recruiting, see?

[1] https://andgein.ru/blog/all/20-i-worked-at-google-for-10-day...

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by google234123 on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:05PM (#35563863)
> Just one of these robots could have paid to restore the household of the guy who flipped his life to accept Google’s non-job[1].

Instead of writing 100s of comments on HN, you could have done something that would have paid you money and used it to feed 100s of starving kids.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by jiggawatts on Thursday April 13, 2023 @08:15PM (#35563951)
This looks like a tech-demo for the AI company, and not what you would actually want to do for a real recycling centre. Those arms are huge, heavy, and take a lot of energy to move around. The mechanics of industrial-scale sorting of plastics is a solved problem: drop the waste off a ledge, and blast falling items with puffs of air from a row of nozzles. It's sufficient to nudge items just a little bit so that they fall down a different chute.

The #1 problem with recycling is that the cost to manufacture something like an aluminium can is about 5 cents. Recycling it has to be cheaper, otherwise it's a net harm to the environment. For example, if you spend just 10c on energy trucking the waste to a facility, sorting it, remelting it, and making a new can from the molten aluminium, then you've caused 5c more pollution than it would have required to just make a new one!

These energy balance equations are brutal. It's crazy difficult to recycle most packaging materials like plastics or aluminium cans cheaply enough to be beneficial. Currently, it's only truly worth it for more expensive metals like copper and steel, especially if they come in a bulk form. That's why you regularly see headlines like "90% of recycling goes into landfill".

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by midoridensha on Friday April 14, 2023 @12:54AM (#35565655)
The problem with your cost analysis is that you probably aren't properly accounting for the all the environmental costs incurred in the 5c example of making a can from newly-mined aluminum. The costs of mining and other resource extraction are usually externalized (i.e., just dig a big hole in the ground, don't worry about environmental fallout, and let future generations deal with the problems caused). Recycling doesn't get this advantage usually.
Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by lozenge on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:16AM (#35566470)
The cost analysis is done exactly how any corporation would do it. If you want externalised costs to be included then it has to be done by government policy.

And good luck getting re elected if such a policy has a noticeable impact on people's lives.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by jiggawatts on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:25AM (#35566519)
This is precisely why policies such as carbon credits are required, otherwise doing things the "dirty" way is too cheap for the "clean" way to be competitive.

Socialise losses, privatise profits is unfortunately the current norm.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by WeylandYutani on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:34AM (#35567817)
Pollution has a noticeable impact on people's lives which is why the EPA was established in the 1970s.
Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by SanderNL on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:26AM (#35567756)
Can they also open and close drawers and drive around a busy office?

This is so different you might as well say mobility was a solved problem because we had horses.

Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by steveBK123 on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:44AM (#35567883)
who needs offices anymore?
Re:Robotic deep RL at scale: Sorting waste and recyclables w... by SanderNL on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:48AM (#35567910)
Meta?